Probate Litigation Costs and Contested Sales, with Attorney Dilair Nafoosi
Probate Weekly · · Guest: Dilair S. Nafoosi, Lionheart Legal
Episode summary
Bill Gross talks with Dilair Nafoosi, a Los Angeles-area attorney whose reputation developed mainly in probate litigation. He explains why no one can say up front what a contested case will cost, and gives his rough estimate at the time of recording: two to five years to trial and $50,000 to $100,000 or more in attorney's fees.
Dilair walks through hourly rates, which he says have risen since he started practicing in 2014, typical retainers at smaller and larger firms, and why most probate cases are not litigated at all.
He explains how to reduce the risk of a trust contest: for an older person amending a trust, get a doctor's letter confirming capacity, and in blended families hire an estate planner who anticipates the foreseeable disputes. He says planning costs are small compared with litigation after death.
Bill and Dilair discuss a conservatorship case where the father signed a contract to sell property while the petition was pending, why court confirmation can invite complaints from heirs, a cashier's check made out to the wrong party at a confirmation hearing, and why title is ultimately what the title company says it is.
Key points
- Contested probate cases can take years and cost tens of thousands of dollars in fees.
- A recent doctor's letter confirming capacity can help protect a late-life trust amendment.
- Blended families need an estate planner who anticipates likely disputes.
- At a court confirmation, the deposit check must be made out correctly; a wrong payee can delay the hearing.
- In practice, title is what the title company will insure, so order a preliminary title report early.
Questions answered in this episode
How much does probate litigation cost?
Dilair Nafoosi says there is no way to know in advance, but at the time of recording his basic estimate for a case that goes to trial was two to five years and roughly $50,000 to $100,000 in attorney's fees, probably more like $75,000. Watch at 4:10
What do probate litigators charge?
Dilair says he works hourly. He recalls rates from about $200 to $600 an hour when he started practicing in 2014, and says rates at the time of recording could reach $1,000 an hour, with retainers up to about $20,000 at smaller firms and much more at large firms. Watch at 8:18
How can an older person reduce the risk of a trust contest?
Dilair says that someone in their 80s or 90s amending a trust should see a doctor and get a letter saying they have full capacity, so there is evidence if a child later contests the amendment. Watch at 22:36
Why do blended families need careful estate planning?
Dilair says that with spouses bringing in children from prior marriages, you want an estate planner who is sensitive to the foreseeable lawsuits, because the cost of doing the plan right is small compared with litigation after death. Watch at 24:43
What can go wrong with the deposit at a court confirmation hearing?
Dilair describes a hearing where the overbidding broker brought a cashier's check for the right amount but made out to his own clients. The judge was gracious, but the parties had to come back in the afternoon. Watch at 45:20
Who decides what the title is on a probate property?
Dilair says he can look at the deeds and form an opinion, but in practice title is what the title company says it is, because it issues the title insurance. A preliminary title report is not expensive. Watch at 51:34
Transcript
Transcript generated from YouTube's automatic captions for this episode and lightly cleaned (filler words and repeated words removed, names and web addresses corrected; phone numbers and email addresses read on air are replaced with a placeholder; [unclear] marks words the captions did not capture). It may still contain transcription errors, and speaker labels are not included. Timestamps link to that point in the video, which is the authoritative record.
0:00 The forms I'm involved with I guess a question can you refer me to an attorney and you know on Tuesday I think it was a week it was a week or Tuesday we had Jack [name unclear] local attorney talked about a real estate attorney the different great degradations and Specialties and how to find the right kind of attorney for a person and I came across recently I met delar on a matter we were working together and I just really liked his approach and style and wanted to talk to somebody about probate Administration versus public litigation and today we have a probate litigator but also he's been congratulated on having his first child you might remember we had his I used this picture a few weeks ago not just to promote him because he's so good looking but I did it because he was going to come on and instead he had his and his wife had their first child so he used to be congratulated for that welcome to permit weekly Dillard thank you for joining us thanks Bill it's good to be here so we started everybody who's watching before we kicked off the call you went to add your name probate litigator now I do know that first off I'll say the name of your firm you go by The Branding is Lionheart legal and that you do estate planning as well as conservatorships and probate and Trust education I find it interesting that of all those you put on your name probate litigator so explain to me why that one is that your focus or that's the one you enjoy the most or why that particular nomenclature well I mean litigation can be enjoyable but the enjoyable moments are few and far between however it is it is kind of a niche and there aren't a ton of probate litigators in Los Angeles County and the ones who primarily practice and probate litigation like myself we kind of all know each other we recognize each other's names we I we used to say we see each other in court all the time but now it's more like we hear each other on the phone in court all the time so it's most of my
2:05 Cases are litigated cases I don't know why it worked out that way but that's just kind of my experience and my reputation developed in kind of the litigation realm more than anything else so you know I'll own it I'll own the title so let's talk about probate litigation first a little bit more when people come to me with a situation that requires litigation the thing I try to explain to them before refer them somebody is there's no way to know what it's going to cost but it's most likely going to cost a lot so when somebody walks to you and says hey I had this public case my brother's stealing this or whatever or I'm gonna probate it my brother's accusing me of stealing it he hired attorney how do you handle and how many crafts and say it all comes down to money but to a lot of people that is a barrier to get over how do you handle kind of upfront expectations of what we should expect from the facing litigation right it's very important I think for an attorney to set a client's expectations ahead of time often I find myself talking people out of bringing a lawsuit because I'm so upfront about these things I like to tell them you know without knowing about any specific situation I tell pretty much anyone who calls me if they're calling me at the outset of litigation meaning there's no case number nothing's been filed yet which is which is the right time to talk to me often people call me after some other attorneys like screwed up their case and I'm like oh great but if they call me at the outset I say you know without a I just in general to people without any specific the details or facts about a particular situation you know you're looking at two to five years if we file this lawsuit it's
4:10 Contested and it goes to trial so you're gonna have to wait two to five years for an outcome in 99 of the time and you're looking at fifty to a hundred thousand dollars in attorney's fees on the way that's the basic estimate I could give people nowadays probably more like seventy five thousand and I think it froze up there just about the good part about the money I think you froze up potential clients are frustrated by that and the reason I can't give a better estimate and I have an explanation for this is that we what how much work I need to do depends on what other people do what the opposing party does the near do well brother in the example you brought what the court does which judge we have some judges or I was just in court this morning and there was a kind of a newer judge in department Five and she's implemented a policy that she made clear to me as well as to people who were appearing in another matter before mine that she requires some form of attempted informal resolution prior to setting a case for trial so every judge handles their Department their own way I think that particular policy is probably a good policy in at least 90 percent of the cases you know but these things all depend if the opposing party was digging their heels in serving sets of Discovery left and right on you I mean it's going to take some time to respond to all of that draft response is thoughtfully and carefully and do these
6:15 Sorts of things and you know there might be motion work required so it's all it's all it's all real specific to each case but what you can guarantee is it's going to be you know tens of thousands of dollars at the low end to take a case to trial now most cases don't get to trial and they end up settling somewhere along the way and I always push for that and I try to get everybody to do to do that but you know when one side's unreasonable or the opposing parties are just so far away that they're unable to negotiate it's inevitable so after I call you up on the phone about my nerdwell brother and you give me that speech it's 50 to 75 000 a hundred thousand dollars is two to five years I pass out I get recitated and I wake up and go okay fine I have money I'm committed to this how much upfront because I do know sometimes a litigation attorneys take on contingency some require certain amount of money up front to cover expenses or out-of-pocket expenses so would it and again I'm not looking for a trade secret so you're welcome to give me a kind of a general rule in the industry what's the general rule that somebody should expect to you know write check for to get the process started my can you hear me sorry yeah oh okay so in terms of like The Upfront costs there are the market and the range that I've seen and I've heard from clients and kind of what I charge is that the retainer is usually the attorney requires a retainer well first let me talk about the contingency cases and stuff like that so there's kind of two fee structures generally there's
8:18 Hourly which is how I operate and how my firm operates and there's an hourly rate I've seen hourly rates you know back in 2014 when I started practicing law I've seen like 200 at the low end and kind of 600 at the high end kind of nowadays it's more like you know it could be up to a thousand an hour and kind of on the lower end I don't know I assume it's still maybe 200 but you know at least 200 in California or in Los Angeles County or Southern California and then there's the contingency is basically you get a the attorney gets paid out of what they recover and it's just a certain percentage by law that percentage is capped at 50 percent I don't do contingency matters and there are certain fields of law such as employment law on the plaintiff side personal injury to law like car accidents almost every attorney in that field in my experience does it on contingency because it makes a lot of sense from a business model perspective in those fields I know one attorney who does trust in estate cases on contingency however the upside for the client that's hiring them has to be seven figures plus and if I encounter situation where that makes sense I can refer to that attorney but if it's like that their upside is 500 grand they're not going to I'm not going to be able to find a contingency attorney for them so and then the and the guys who do continue to see they're usually very good and they're usually very
10:20 Wealthy because it's great if you are good at it and know what you're doing but the hourly guys are kind of more schlubs like you know no in general so in terms of The Upfront costs kind of what I've observed in since 2014 kind of practicing in this field is so the retainer goes into What's called the client trust account the attorney will not hold the funds that are provided as the retainer in their business account or in their you know personal account they deposit into a client trust account the State Bar of California has regulates the client trust account it's a very specific type of account a bank has to make that offering it's called an iolta or I Ulta account interest on lawyer trust account is what those letters stand for and then let's say you give ten thousand dollars as a retainer and the attorney is charging you know 500 an hour spends two hours then they'll Bill the clients for the two hours which is a thousand dollars and they'll either take it out of the 10 000 or the client will pay an additional a thousand on top of the 10 000 and the returning just holds the retainer for all purposes until the representation is terminated that is what's that the type where the retainer is just held in the client trust account it's not used to pay bills that is called an evergreen retainer also the range of retainers I've seen for these types of cases are probably like 5 000 for kind of the sole practitioner or someone who's just like trying to do it
12:22 Is a pretty standard or a smaller firm is a pretty standard retainer amount you know that can go up to maybe 20 000 for smaller firms and then for like the big boys you know I could get 50 or 100 000 as a retainer but generally the clients for them are or you know multi-million dollar cases so it prices you know the vast majority of people who have to go through probate are going to be probably not litigated and probably you know some sort of savings I'd imagine under a hundred grand and a house that's probably the most common asset mix or a very nominal amount of cash and an interest in the house that's probably the vast majority of people who die in past wealth on either without any sort of estate planning or through a trust or through a deceit in a state or probate to see it in a state and probate are interchangeable terms that you're talking about kind of one real property and maybe some sort of life insurance benefits or cash and those can be moved without the use of probate and we can talk about that more but just to answer your question I would say kind of for the general situations the range for a retainer is probably five to twenty thousand and not as you mentioned doesn't go the attorney until they're billing for their Works they don't get all that money at once and additionally there's expenses there's filing fees there's paralegal services perhaps delivery fees service fees publication fees that all go into the mix that come out that money as well I think sometimes people feel like oh I
14:24 Wrote him a check for twenty thousand dollars and he the trade took the check deposit twenty thousand dollars and went for a party that night it doesn't really work that way though I do think the attorneys tend to do a lot of a good chunk work right away so that first bill usually is pretty significant so let's talk about litigation as part of the mixture of your business and then I know you do estate planning because service ships I know you do probate Administration where it's not being litigated as well as litigation I know some attorneys only do litigation and don't do the others and you do both and I've heard both arguments so explain to me your decision in doing in additional litigation to State planning I.E avoiding probate as well as probe Administration explain your just your business choice on doing that wider range of work rather than just doing public litigation how does that help you and how does it help your client right so there's kind of two topics there so that there's costs so generally with me and my firm I will apply their retainer funds to invoices as they come due I will have the right to request the retainer be replenished but generally I don't do that I just kind of vet people make sure they understand this could be the cost in the long term and you know you need to understand that if you if you go down this path or you don't settle or things come up and you know if we can get an understanding on that I don't mind carrying a smaller retainer or not carrying an evergreen Rotator and then when I do incur costs I pay them and then I invoice the client itemize the costs in the invoice and then reimburse myself at whatever I paid the costs in general every filing fee for example in LA county is just under 500 dollars to e-file that publication you have to publish with a newspaper if it's like a city like Los Angeles it's usually a cheaper publication cost because it's very
16:25 It's very integrated the infrastructure is there if it's some obscure small City the publication costs can be higher if you need to personally serve someone you know that can that can be a cost as well so all of these things are kind of involved and like I said my firms practice is all pay it out of my business account and then I'll get reimbursed when I send out the invoice from the retainer fund so the client if they read their invoice they'll know exactly how much of their retainer is going to what and where and you know I think good billing practice is really important and I always tell clients personally you know if you ever have a question about them they'll call me talk to me about it I don't charge for the time to explain the bill to you because we need to trust each other or this isn't going to work as a client relationship now the second question you had was about sorry refresh my memory well expenses versus the total amount and what was the second one I was so in English in the first one I lost my track myself let me let me let me ask another first off real quick anybody watching this is meant to be interactive I see a couple questions I'm going to get to and we'll ask them but feel free to put number one any questions or raise your hand let's make it interactive and number two if that's also if you're watching on YouTube or Facebook on live streams bring your questions in there we had a shout out from by the way Diller we have a shout out from Jesse who I think is actually the client or prospective client who introduced us so he's watching on Facebook Hey Jessie how you doing so definitely for free so okay so now we talked about oh yeah I remember now we talked about the advantages of doing not just litigation but also doing estate planning which is avoiding right
18:29 Litigation and say planning to avoid probate and to me as a real estate agent I think that's a good thing because you see the messes and then should theoretically be preventing those messes on your next client but I know there are other attorneys who say no I just do litigation because I'm set up for that now we've set up to do the administration so explain to me how you're thinking for yourself as a business person and then for your clients right that was that was your that was the original second question so the so when it comes to kind of my practice areas so I kind of grit my teeth in Probate litigation and a trust case and a conservatorship case and that and they were overlapping issues and I feel like I did pretty well in there and I just kind of stuck to it the firm I was working for at the time like kept giving me the litigated cases to handle and you know it just never really stopped from there and I felt like I understood it well but then you have a lot of people maybe clients who have gone through the litigation with their parents estate or something like that then they're like well I don't want this to happen to my kids you know I can you do my estate plan or people just hear probate and they think Wells trusts and they think you draft it now I personally in my firm I do not draft the estate plans but I advise and I have a co-counsel who I work with who does handles my estate planning drafting he's the one who actually drafts it in my office and so it's just it's such an overlap and clients request it so often that I think it's almost a necessity to at least be able to help them with that and so I had to I had to make arrangements for that so
20:33 Yeah well one thing I can see where clients would naturally request it and you want to help clients you want to you know solve their problems on the flip side I can see where it's also a completely different skill set what might make you a great drafter of the world's best estate plan might not help you when you're in Probate litigation those are two different absolutely and then and then on the point of the kind of the definition differentiation with my firm is you know most estate planning firms do not do probate litigation at all so they don't see what goes correct so I mentioned I had a hearing this morning so at the hearing this morning we're litigating a case I actually represent a brother against his brother right and their father did an estate plan with a certain estate planning attorney and there were certain that the father who did the estate plan he wished to treat his two sons unequally so it was pretty foreseeable to me from the estate plan that there was going to be litigation once dad died because Dad was treating the brothers unequally the brother who was treated less well than the other brother was going to sue once dad died now there are certain things they sue to do to invalidate this trust amendment that was made you can invalidate it for example based on lack of capacity you can invalidate It On The Ground of what's called undue influence which is defined generally as exerting influence or pressure on someone to such a great degree that it overcomes their Free Will that's the definition of undue influence so it was foreseeable if I'm doing an estate plan it's foreseeable to me that when you're like treating one kid way better than the
22:36 Other kid that's going to result in a amendment to this to a contest against this trust amendment that you made that's doing that so what I would do is I would tell the person who's considering doing this trust Amendment hey you're in your 80s you're in your 90s whatever the case may be hypothetically during your 80s for example go see a doctor get the doctor to say that you have complete capacity you know X Y and Z maybe I draft a letter for them say present this to your doctor have your doctor sign this now we have really good records and documentation and a live witness in the form of a physician who can testify at trial and say I evaluated this person they have capacity them while they were alive and in my opinion as a physician they have capacity and I signed a letter to such a fact and then if the person says this is too expensive I don't want to go through this or I don't want to I don't want to deal with this fine but at least I advise them to do that right and then and then and then the attorney can also do certain things maybe the Sun who is treated better is here is there in the room when Dad is signing the estate plan documents that's a big No-No right that's something that shouldn't be done the attorney should say hey get out sit in the car you know I don't want to talk with you at all I only want to talk with that you know and sometimes estate planning attorneys don't do these things and it just boggles my mind because I'm dealing with the mess and the Fallout that's occurred and I'm just like gosh I wish I had certain better facts but that's not always the case so you know when you use some when especially if you're gonna do something like tree children unequally or if
24:43 You have I think the pro the term du jour is a blended family now if you have a blended family you know spouses bringing in kids from prior marriages especially with those kind of situations you want to hire an estate planner who's really cognizant and sensitive of all the foreseeable lawsuits that are going to occur in these sorts of mess not as traditional situations let's say and you can spend 90 of the fee but that last ten percent because the plan was done correctly creates all the mess the whole estate plan if they just got the doctor's letter would have avoided but by not doing that the statement has no real effect because you're still going to court to litigate the whole thing anyhow I mean it has an effect but it didn't have the intent effect which was probably to avoid litigation I would think at its core right and it and then if you're representing the trustee who has to take over and clear clean clear this up or be the target of these lawsuits and they have these documents they have a doctor's note that says you have great capacity they have something from the estate planning lawyer that says you know they no one had anything to do with this it was just me and the person I'm drafting the estate the estate planning documents for it was vetted they were of their free very well they you know they came in they were alone no one was in the room signing you know these are these are like I'm making the example like very bad just to illustrate kind of some of the faux pas they're they do happen I think they do happen but generally they can be avoided with some experience and sensitivity to the things that can come up but yeah absolutely and they might cost a little more but the
26:48 Cost a little more a little bit more the cost relative to the cost of litigation after a person's dead it's like it's like ten to one or Twenty to one it's not comparable at all you want to make sure when you're alive you're doing the estate plan correctly and I go around I've given presentations to you know different groups of professionals to facilities where you know 55 and older facilities and I just I try to encourage estate planning because I just I just see the Havoc that poor estate planning or no estate planning has after the person said they're never going to see it right I'm gonna see it they're not gonna see it right one of the areas that we come up with a lies real estate agents before somebody passes this capacity that it's not uncommon that and I've had it happen where I you know get a phone call and I go out and meet somebody and they want to sell their house we sign the papers and I've literally had somebody call me that day or the next day and say didn't you realize you didn't you know he was had Dementia or he was crazy I said well it was odd I mean I meet a lot of odd people that's kind of Life today is my very the way I grew up but he seemed me to be coherent of course you know I went to 10 in the morning and maybe by two in the afternoon he's not or who knows what medication does to people and you know I don't know his medical history and so you might my tendency just to walk away and not get in that but so how would you advise a real estate agent as far as deciding if somebody has capacity would you say if you have any questions to walk away from it would you say that you know share real estate agent to list a property should you know ask them if they have an attorney ask them for a medical letter or how would you advise or have you been in cases litigation where you know you were you're trying to validate a contact that was signed I haven't actually have a
28:50 Probate case where literally dad who's in his late 80s is it the doctors and Kaiser's doctor says you know what we he needs to have a conservatorship he can't make his own medical decisions daughter starts the conservatorship it's not done yet father signs a contract to sell multi-million dollar property and then of course the buyer jumped on that was a great deal and the daughter's like what do you mean he's we have a conservatorship we were they were in the queue to get to hear the hearing and the buyer hires an attorney for the man who basically defeats the consumer ship effort so the court determines it's not needed so the contract is valid and so he had these children really upset what advice would you give to real estate agents please meet a client and there's any and there's questions as far as capacity or what is the signs you would look for as an attorney yourself what do you look for and say oh this is a problem I need to back off here or you need to get some medical assistance foreign okay yeah no the that's a really good question I for you know I mean I can't give legal advice in this sort of format but I can I could just tell you what I would do right the are on the side of caution right you don't want to be accused of participating in any sort of elder abuse you know I and I face this the similar dilemma all the time hey you know I don't know Dad's kind of out of it mom's kind of out of it we want to sell a house like I don't think she can make it through the transaction can you do a power of attorney for her I'm like yeah if she has capacity to hire me sure but the fact that you've told me that it's questionable I'm not gonna do
30:54 That without a doctor's letter A recent relatively recent doctor's letter at the very least and then if I talk to them and I don't think as a late you know lay person in the sense that I'm not a medical professional as a layperson and I'm not comfortable dealing with them or I think there's something that they or ice have some sort of honest suspicion you know you got to turn it down there that it's just it's a bad idea now if in that situation you were talking about you know I'm sure there were certain sort of expedited procedures that could have been used to put a kind of a halt on these sorts of things but maybe they were not practical at the time I mean you gotta people under the law you're presumed to have capacity there is a presumption that the person you're Contracting with has capacity in general you can put on evidence to overcome that presumption but generally we're in the starting place where you know there is no there is capacity to in the starting Place of course you know if there's developmental disability something like this like it's going to be hard to justify any sort of belief on that but definitely you want to on the side of caution and you want to you want to have something in place and that's part of estate planning too like maybe and a good estate plan can I don't know if it's just me I think
32:57 It's freezing up again yeah not just you not yeah then you're in that same cost about a 50 to 100 Grand two to five years and it's gonna be difficult or more difficult than doing an estate Point yeah I think and I think as a real estate agent we won't be dragged into that after the facts make sense to be careful okay couple questions we have a couple of them went in for a while here let me try to knock someone out question talk about litigation funding assuming these needs litigation and obviously it's gonna cost them a lot of money are there options to borrow it money are there companies that Finance those kinds of deals and what does that look like I'm not aware there are kind of like several companies that do Advanced costs for a probate or technically my understanding of kind of what they do is they will buy your inheritance or they'll buy a share of your inheritance while the probate is pending but they usually won't make those sorts of loans if there's litigation involved right it's much more difficult for a lender from a lender's perspective because it's just so risky you never know what's going to happen as the lender they could be entitled to something they could be entitled to half of a 10 million dollar estate but they could be found guilty of financial elder abuse and then they are entitled to nothing because now they're an elder abuser right and you don't know how the judge is going to rule I mean we should have some predictability but it would require such a great deal of Investigation on the lender's part and of course not everybody is going to be forthcoming especially someone who actually isn't a user so I don't I don't see that I don't see it generally I think the only
35:02 Way to get around the funding issue is to have a claim that's a very high dollar amount that a contingency lawyer would want to take on and yeah I mean it's just it's unfortunate but that's the way it is and it's just it's something there's a market for it and if and if it was just so oversaturated probably the price would come would come down but it's just it's very technical it's not the easiest field of law to practice in and not a lot of attorneys for my perspective I think get into it this isn't empirical or anything it's just my observation but yeah it's tough to get funding in litigated situations however when there's no litigation and everyone's getting cooperating with one another all the beneficiaries and heirs it's going to make everyone's life a lot easier so sometimes you gotta just know when to hold them know when to fold them kind of thing and walk away and you know you might not want to invest and like I said a lot of clients call me and I talk them out of out of hiring me I'm just I'm just I just tell them look there's just so many unknowns there's so many risks because I don't want them to hire me and get disappointed and have unrealistic expectations about what I can do and often when they're coming to me they don't know all the facts we have to delve into the discovery process we have to subpoena hospital records medical records we have to subpoena you know Communications between the person who's supposedly done the abuse and we need to find all that evidence because it's not what you know it's what you can prove that's one of the most common things I say during initial consults to clients and so there's always risk involved I don't
37:06 Think it's risks that lenders have figured out a way to price and take on yet in the litigation context I think you're right it's expensive to prove all that I will say just in passing I do pro-advances I arrange them for my clients both through a company that I broker through as well as other companies so you can who needs you know ten thousand dollar twenty thousand dollar money for filing a probate routine matters that's something I do regularly and I do about two of those a month and glad any real estate agent on this call I do get probate dot cash every Wednesday morning I do a call and a little Mastermind group on that subject if you're interested to reach out to me the litigation I do know that there's banks that Finance litigation but they're really financing The Firm they know the guy every year bills makes two million dollars and he goes as a profit of whatever it is and they know based on that they give a credit line and then the attorney can use that and I also know that the attorney may have other settlements that are structured over five ten year periods so they know that money is coming in as well as there's liens on properties and so you know that's a different picture than just lend me a hundred thousand dollars so I can sue somebody nobody's in that business that I'm aware of I think with the exception maybe like workman's comp or kind of the personal injury where there's kind of a basic value of the case walking in the door to some degree but not what we're talking public litigation obviously it's so complicated and the lenders who are who are giving those attorneys lines of credit those attorneys have had decades probably of experience yes this will drop 10 cases yes that is the one case that is a winner there's a little there's and then there what to do not some Banker who's not you know trained in probate law or whatever so that makes total sense to me and that's really interesting and probably a profitable
39:10 Niche if you have the right Partners well plus the bank also gets the attorney's you know trust account money it's a lot that doesn't have interest on it they love those accounts and so there's a number of other services that go along I mean I've been on that business in those negotiations there's a lot that goes into that it's like I said it's not like they're going to lend somebody twenty thousand dollars to go sue their brother in appropriate litigation it's not it's never really quite that simple it might sound like that okay and then somebody asked do you mind telling us do you represent the better son or the other son that's on Facebook I think I think every attorney thinks they have the right guy and everybody thinks the other guy is the wrong guy do you guys ever get together and laugh about that like I thought I had the bad guy you had the bad guy but you all thinking please represent the good guys all exactly but every attorney says that I mean literally Jack Lupita's attorney does real estate law he said the same thing every attorney I've ever interviewed says that meanwhile there's two attorneys in every case so if you guys ever got a room and had to have an honesty challenge I'd love to see other no it's only because you hang out with good lawyers and not bad lawyers right no I can't go with you Jack and I pretty much any attorney that'll talk to me I'll no thanks that's true that's probably true I'd like to think that's true I like to think I deal with on honest ones okay let's get some specifics on real estate you know like I said I mentioned you earlier that just today I was in the L.A County Bar list serve I'm an affiliate member and I'd like to see what the attorneys talk about and one of them was asking about you know with covid less traffic in courts do you need to go to court in person as the attorney he was asking on a court confirmation sale and just for those who don't know in LA county and in California when you have a cell that needs court confirmation theoretically a buyer can walk in the door there's certain criteria they have to be have a cashier's check for a certain 10 of the overbid amount made out to this state and they have to be willing to bid and buy the property without any contingencies so theoretically that
41:14 Training should be there to check the check make sure it's made out for the right amount and take possession of it so it doesn't walk away if they want to vet the person they do that and with attorneys on video I'd represent a buyer as we would go to court and the attorney's not there not only could the attorney I think not do their job completely but the judge would get mad they're like well the judge would think I'm here and now we're going to wait for you to text and phone call and all that you're holding up the court the one thing I find about court is like judges it's like a downhill railroad like don't stop the train don't let the judge know you're stopping the train like blame it on somebody else or get out of the way because it's going downhill what's your what's your advice when a to an attorney and what's your advice to a real estate agent as far as Court confirmation can that be I know it can be handled outside of the Court do you recommend they show up in the day of anyhow yeah so card confirmation pretty much it's well there's always a way around Court confirmation you can always post a bond you can always have the funds a tied up and subject to court order put in a blocked account these sorts of things so I try to avoid Court confirmation other attorneys they think it's great because you get bidding wars and that and that can happen and I think it's really it's a it should be a collaborative process between the fiduciary meaning the person handling the state and or the trust or whatever holds the asset the attorney as well as the real estate agent because if the real estate agent their job is to sell their job is to get the highest price possible for the client so if they believe that connections the way the property is going to be best served in terms of getting the highest price through a court confirmation process then go that route
43:16 If it's not if it because I deal with the litigation side right so court confirmation process is just another opportunity for some ne'er-do-well heir or beneficiary to make a complaint out of nothing and increase the attorney's fees and costs so generally as the litigator I try to avoid that my clients try to avoid that because they don't want to get caught up in more litigation than they have to be in terms of non-lineated cases you know I've seen I've sat in courts and I've seen two buyers just go back and forth and bid up the price a couple extra 100 Grand and that's great for you know who's ever selling it and if you can get that or people just showing up unexpectedly I've seen Brokers come in there they've never done a court confirmation they're representing the buyer they're you know a nightmare to deal with and they have all these demands and they don't understand why there isn't a sale contract and you know I mean and it's tough and sometimes you have to deal with people like that because that is that the best situation I would just say to Brokers it is your job as the broker to know what you have to do at those hearings it is not the attorney for the trustees job to advise you're not their client you know a lot of brokerage firms they have their own attorney that gets involved that maybe they have on retainer to advise them of certain situations and things like that and that's that I think is a good model because I've had interactions with brokerage firms and they have kind of In-House counsel or someone they contract to and they're knowledgeable about these things and they advise their Brokers so their broker isn't making any sort of mistakes like this for example I had to sell in a conservatorship a commercial building in Monterey Park and
45:20 The broker showed up he had the cashier's check he had the right amount but it was made out to his clients and I'm like this is not this is not okay and exactly kind of what you have what happened as you described kind of happened the judge wasn't upset at me but we had to come back instead of doing it in the morning we had to come back again in the afternoon so the judge was nice and gracious enough to give us an afternoon a lot to let us to let that broker remedy his issue of making out to his own client to buy to buy a property that's probably only going to happen if you as the attorney for the state support that right they're not the judge is going to do it unless these are my experience they're gonna turn to you and say do you want to come back and if you're on board with it they'll go along with it and if you're not the judge is not going to do the right thing unless he turns on board with at least that's what I've seen is that your experience yeah I mean it helps I mean just having a good reputation and a judge that's been in the courts long enough to be comfortable doing things like that because you know maybe a newer judge or a less experienced judge like won't even think of that as an option and you know that happens too and then just like well you know you don't have the cashier's check you didn't transfer it to the seller I'm gonna dismiss the petition and if you want it come back file a petition again notice it again and you know you don't do that really is a tough break for and I've seen that too I've seen I've sat in and seen that now in terms of how have things changed in the last three years since all the shutdowns yeah I tend to I like it because I don't have to physically go to court anymore I could just call in on the phone and I think the vast majority of attorneys do that for status hearings or even cell confirmation hearings but
47:24 You are right there needs to be a transfer of the initial deposit whatever that amount is and somebody needs to be there to accept it and somebody needs to be there to give it so certainly makes sense for you know at least the Brokers to go down to the court I think I think that would probably even make the most sense for all involved to have the buyer's broker and the seller's broker there maybe the attorney if the seller's broker is not as familiar because if the cashier's check is made out wrong things like this or maybe they can be coached or prepped ahead of time by the attorney But ultimately probably best for the seller their attorney is there because they're ultimately are going to be responsible for all these things well a minimum some ease of either and if the attorney and the Realtor® work together well great and if not somebody's got to be there I think that's what you're saying the other question in the in the bar list served today was just interesting today I had some good questions was one of the attorneys laminating the term probate expert now for the for information my website's the LA Probate Expert and I always tell people that my staff is expert is not based on a destination but a process I think a real expert is somebody who's always looking to improve always looking to learn more and grow other business the attorney was pointing out that you can get a little thing for your email certificate for about two hours class and that they don't really seem to know much what do you see when you're trying to vet a real estate agent for your client maybe your client recommends somebody and you realize it's a little more complicated but you want to know does this Realtor® really have what it takes what are the things either you look for what questions do you ask the vet attorney to I'm outside the vet the Realtor® to be able to properly assess for your client if they're good or not yeah it's oh man that was a money question too
49:29 And we lost them okay you know he didn't want to answer that he has a bad connection hi Bill there you are oh I don't I'm sorry I don't I don't know what's going on there you are okay got it okay all right yeah so this is the thing in my experience I'm not a very pushy person you know I have enough fights to handle in my business so I try to kind of minimize conflict wherever I can because I just see how destructive it is but you know in this context especially it can be very good in other contexts but you know it usually they have a broker by the time they get to me and they you know this was their mom's friend and the person that she would have you know and it's just like I don't know I mean it's I just like I said in the answers of to a prior question don't ask me like what do I have to do as the broker to make sure I'm fulfilling all the legal obligations that I have to sell the house because it's like I'm not your attorney that's not my job to know it's always better to use somebody who's familiar with probate for a probate sale for a trust sale even outside of a provincial even a trust sale I know there's certain disclosures that need to be made up front to the to the agent's clients as well as to the buyer you know they and it's also helpful to know things about like lease pendants I always try to tell the Bro there's always certain things I try to do I think one of the attorneys in the gallery kind of brought it up in one of their comments check the title check the title do a preliminary title report pay a hundred fifty dollars to see
51:34 What the title company says title is because I can look at the deeds and I can have my opinion on what the title is or what title should be but at the end of the day and for practicality purposes what title is what the title company says it is because they're the ones who are going to issue the title insurance and it's not expensive to have a preliminary title report done often Brokers with good connections and good networks they know title officers they can get it done for free but even if you have to pay for it's usually like under two hundred dollars and it's and you really want to know if there's a title problem before you go into escrow before there's a contract with time of the essence and consequences if you don't if you aren't able to complete your end of the sale as the seller because that's going to give rise to problems for the seller and that's the last thing anybody wants so you know it's great that you know you know you have a friend or a relationship but yeah there's definitely a very noticeable difference from my perspective of using a broker who knows probate versus one who's never done a probate or this is their first probate and they're just asking me an appropriate questions and things like that and it's just it shouldn't it's going to be beneficial to all involved to use somebody who knows probate that's the end of the day well let me offer you if you find a Realtor® who doesn't send me I'll coach him up for you at no cost and all my cases we get a prelim right away for free to this state because you're 100 right it only matters what the title company says will happen and I had a case recently we're a big title company had a prelim with a long old uninsured deed and they were saying well we'll clear it up and we'll wait to the end I said no you need the report needs to be corrected now
53:37 Before we go down the road because I don't want to tell my attorney well renesco oh we can't close and they wouldn't budge and I just really found another company who underwrote it and I changed and the guy called me up and said I said well you're upset you're the one who's gonna waste my time and my clients time and that can't happen so there's a difference between tile companies reps also and Tower copy reps they're really no probate and can get these things done so yeah entire title is just I it's a nightmare it's a horror I can't say enough bad things about them they're all billion dollar companies they never pay out on anything because they make it so difficult to get title insurance I feel like they take no risk whatsoever any risk they're not comfortable but they get a premium it's like yeah premium for a risk if something happened 40 years ago we don't have some sort of record to justify it and nobody's come after it for 40 years and you're going to refuse to issue Title Insurance over it's like I don't know it's they the demands of title companies can be very unreasonable that's why you have to kind of nip this in the bud as soon as possible and work on it because the stuff that they ask for at times in difficult situations it could take months years to get and you don't you don't want to get a buyer involved or a potential on fire to sit through that and be frustrated and they're crazy broker whoever you know hopefully not but the client they introduced us those are two Deeds two and a half million dollars there's no question as a real estate professional as a former expert witness they were detered wrong they should not have transferred title we and we had written proof now maybe not enough to win in court that's a different question but to anybody who reads the document says clear the problem is the proven Court would cost hundreds of thousands of dollars meanwhile they got their premium and their premium dollars are sitting in the bank accumulating money and they've got a building and they're and they
55:39 Want to talk to you about the problem they're not even interested you know any other insurance company you have an accident they look at it and they have to settle but some of these tough companies I don't understand how that works either oh yeah and they'll and they'll and they'll hire lawyers and fight you yeah on your claim and they know what they're doing okay so yes sorry for any title officers listening but this is just our experience yeah sorry but not sorry okay I got some questions to hang in here for a while we're going to wrap up here in a few minutes let me knock out real quick real estate commissions on a probate I know there's a local rule in LA county court confirmation sells no more than five percent for homes no more than 10 for vacant land are you over any other limits on commissions as it relates to probate listings or is it what the buyer and seller agreed to I mean the seller and the listing agent agreed to I mean there isn't a hard and fast limit such as the LA County local role on the broker commission but there is a limit in a sense on the trustee or the executor because they have to act in the best interest of the estate and if conventionally Brokers charge six percent some Brokers now maybe they charge five percent because they're the real estate prices increased you know you can't go too outside of the norm or the market so yeah can the trustee like give a broker 20 and contract and then it gets paid out of escrow sure but you know they're really opening themselves up to getting sued but I mean unless there's as far as I know I don't think there's any laws that would limit the commissions I just want to give a quick shout out Alan Paul's on the on the call here California best title they're the company I took too I got this you know you marketing email from him and I had
57:43 This problem this top company I was going around and around and around with them and I said you know Alan take a look at this one if you guys explain the case why I thought the towel company was wrong if you guys can underwrite it I'll counsel to open this with you and I'll give you a second one as a thank you and he turned around and got done within a day he got it done a new prelim before The Old Company guy called me and said why'd you guys cancel that's right well I'll have to get your information from him because a flexible title officer is unheard of well now flexible the title officers as far as they know Allen may have tied him down put a gun in his mouth and made him do it personally I don't care as long as they drew the title that's Alice's job right what's great about my channel company though is that the guy who runs my title Club he's a very experienced attorney that did a lot of underwriting title work I ran the whole entire Department had a major title company so he's got plenty of title law experience and real estate law experience here we go so that's you have to have a winning team the other ones you're saying a bankfall counting their money so Alan thanks for your help on that yeah okay and let's wrap up a couple more questions I see a bunch of people with your information in the chat box make sure you save the chat box before we leave here and if you want to catch somebody reach out to me let's see now fine okay if we're probably owned by tress and trust is lost that's this is a common problem that I get which is the problem is deeded in a trust oh great it's a trust you avoid probate nobody can find the trust what's the what's the solution to that unfortunately more common experience I think the more estate plans to get done the more lost trust arguments there are yeah I mean right yeah and that's important right to what is State planning to that is also another problem that comes up often in handling a case now it's like the you have the trust right but
59:48 The pages that say who the beneficiaries are and who the trustee is once the settlor dies you know all the important stuff it's missing all of a sudden right so yeah that happens so it just if the trust is lost then yeah you can petition to have it reverted to the estate but then if the trust was created by two people who's the state does it does it go to does it go to the survivors is it separate property of one spouse or the other's community property it I mean I that it's just a it's just a big can of worms now if you if you have enough information about the trust you can also petition the court to create the terms of the trust let's say you know the attorney who drafted the trust they don't have the actual original trust document it's lost but they have notes or they have a recollection like this is what mom and dad wanted this is what they told me this is what the trust said I don't I don't remember you know I don't have the actual trust argument but this was well now you can petition the court to reform the terms of the trust or basically recreate the trust it's there's various options you know I mean to do a petition that's just going to require one hearing where everybody's getting along I would say you know fifteen thousand on the high end in attorney's fees is probably reasonable as an estimate without like further information but then if it's reverting to the estate now you have to open an estate so you have to open the estate first so that there is an estate representative to transfer it to or there's a personal representative to transfer the trust property or what would have been the trust property too
1:01:51 Well it's not like there's always something and thank goodness that gives you delay work to do for the foreseeable future and to continue to provide for you and your family your growing family by the way you have your first child boy or girl my son Leo was born that's right February 18th so he's about 19 years 19 days old today so wow it's just been great to experience Parenthood but it's been very the Sleep the lack of sleep I should say yeah but you know it's a joy and yeah thankfully it's even affecting his internet foreign yes so that's a blessing for us and anyone who hasn't had kids yet I encourage you to do so because you don't know what you got into what you got in you until you do it because it really it can have the potential to bring a lot out of you a lot of love and ability that you otherwise thought didn't know you that you had well enjoy and you should bring much joy and look forward to hearing continue good news from you and your family thank you so much for being on our call today thanks Bill and thank you for everyone for their questions and hospitality and if you want to get a hold of a dog to talk about estate planning conservatorships probably or litigation which is a specialty it's lion heartlegal.com is the website Lionheart legal as interesting his son's name Leo the Lion and Lionheart legal is his Law Firm it has his contact info there if you want to get a hold of him I know we covered a lot of stuff today I'm a little over time so I'm sorry about that I enjoyed speaking to him but we went a little late for those of you who are in the LA area we have the
1:03:54 Lariic.com lyric the L.A County real estate Association investors starting in about an hour and a half in the Culver City area at the eyman center go to l-a-r-e-I-c.com that's free there's free parking you could get there early enough I'll be there as a vendor in podcasting it as well and then don't forget on Facebook I have probate experts as our free probate group if you have questions comments if I get your questions from this call today feel free to put in there promote my other calls on there Tuesday I'm sorry Wednesday we have probate get probate.cash is Wednesday mornings 8 30. You can get details at probate experts or text me or call me I'm on social media at Bill Gross exp thank you everybody for a great call though I think again thank you have a great week everybody we'll talk to you soon thank you
More Probate Weekly episodes
- Probate and Trust Litigation, with Attorney Greg Aslanian
- Escrow Services in Probate Sales, with Charity Skore of Granite Escrow
- Title Company Litigation in Probate, with Attorney Courtney Writer
Related
- How long does probate take?
- A guide for successor trustees
- Probate attorneys and podcast guests
- Probate Weekly: all episodes
- For attorneys & fiduciaries
Educational media, not legal advice. Guest views are their own. Hosted by Bill Gross, The LA Probate Expert, a licensed California real estate broker (DRE #01022275) brokered by eXp Realty of California, Inc. (DRE #01878277). Bill is not an attorney and is not a Probate Referee.