Episode summary

Bill Gross talks with Greg Aslanian of Trust Law Partners, a litigator who came to trust and estate disputes from insurance defense work on serious injury cases. Greg explains how he decides whether a dispute makes sense to litigate, noting that getting even to mediation can cost six figures once experts and time are included.

Greg describes the three claims he sees most: undue influence, lack of capacity and financial elder abuse, which often appear together. He explains the factors courts look at in undue influence cases, including a confidential relationship, active participation in creating the document and whether the result is unnatural, and why shifting the burden of proof is not automatic.

Bill asks what real estate agents should watch for when a seller's capacity is in question. Greg's advice is to trust your gut when someone clearly does not understand what they are signing or someone is hovering over them, and he explains why medical records often show a person as alert even when they were not at their best.

The conversation also covers why judges need compelling evidence to void a document that is valid on its face, hourly versus contingency and hybrid fee arrangements, the caretaker statute in Probate Code 21380, and the fact that California law is the same statewide while court procedures vary by county.

Key points

  • Greg says a dispute generally needs to be worth at least about half a million dollars to make hourly litigation sensible.
  • Undue influence, lack of capacity and financial elder abuse are the most common claims and often go together.
  • Shifting the burden of proof in an undue influence case is possible but not automatic; it has to be presented to the judge properly.
  • A gift to a caretaker is presumed to be the product of undue influence under Probate Code 21380 unless a certificate of independent review is obtained.
  • Some clients prefer contingency or hybrid fees so they do not have to fund years of litigation themselves.

Questions answered in this episode

When is a probate dispute worth litigating?

Greg Aslanian says that for hourly clients the dispute should generally be worth at least about half a million dollars, because getting a case even to mediation can cost six figures once expert costs and time are included. Watch at 3:25

What are the most common claims in trust and estate litigation?

Greg names undue influence, lack of capacity and financial elder abuse as the big ones. They are intertwined, and he says most cases that involve one of them involve all three. Watch at 10:02

What do courts look at in an undue influence case?

Greg describes whether the person who died had a confidential relationship with the alleged influencer, how actively that person participated in creating the document, and whether the result is unnatural, such as cutting out the children in favor of an outsider. Watch at 13:46

What capacity warning signs should a real estate agent notice?

Greg says it has to pass a smell test. If a person clearly does not understand what they are doing, or someone is hovering over them telling them where to sign while they seem confused, trust your gut. Watch at 21:01

What is the caretaker statute?

Greg explains that under Probate Code 21380, a gift to a caretaker or someone who helped create the trust is presumed to be the product of undue influence unless the person making the trust obtains a certificate of independent review. Watch at 36:56

Can trust litigation be handled on contingency?

Yes. Greg says his firm has hourly clients but also offers contingency and hybrid arrangements, which relieve clients who do not want to risk their own money paying litigation bills. Watch at 32:50

Transcript

Transcript generated from YouTube's automatic captions for this episode and lightly cleaned (filler words and repeated words removed, names and web addresses corrected; phone numbers and email addresses read on air are replaced with a placeholder; [unclear] marks words the captions did not capture). It may still contain transcription errors, and speaker labels are not included. Timestamps link to that point in the video, which is the authoritative record.

0:02 Welcome to Probate Weekly. I'm your host, Bill Gross at Bill Gross Probate. We do this every week. I get asked all the time about a dispute. You know, my brother this, my father, my cousin this in a probate case. I want to get an attorney to take him to court. And I often say to them, you just don't understand the cost or the enormity of the process. And often times people run to a local attorney or a pro an attorney that does probate filings and administration. Not understanding that litigation, particularly in California, is a whole different animal. I'm really lucky. I'm a member of the LA Bar Association as an affiliate. I watched the list serve and I saw a couple attorneys recommend Greg Aslanad from Trust Law Partners as a probate litigation attorney. So I've never been sued by him or involved in a case directly. Actually, we were it turns out I think on a case. But anyhow, that said, welcome to Greg from Trust Partners. Hi, Bill. Thanks for having me today. And just geography. You're based in California. Where is your office located? Where do you We actually have several offices throughout the state. Our primary offices, I would say, are San Monteo, so the Silicon Valley area and Los Angeles. We also have offices in Santa Barbara, as well as San Diego and Orange County. Actually, Orange County is a recent addition.

1:20 Important. Nice. So, all the nice spots throughout California. So, let's talk about you're a litigation specialist in this area of probates and trusts. How did you end up in the litigation side of that? Did you start with probate and trust and move into litigation or are you a litigator that found this niche? I'm a litigator that found this niche. I have litigation defense background meaning that I used to work for a law firm that insurance companies used to rely upon when their clientele got sued. You know, catastrophic injury cases, big rig accidents, you know, other type of serious automobile accidents. Whenever somebody gets involved and is at fault and they get sued, insurance companies typically hire outside counsel to represent their insureds. And I was one of those attorneys. So litigation is you know in my blood. And then I eventually transitioned into this area of law and have found it to be very interesting. Interesting is a good word for it. So when people call me with disputes, you know, I try to get a range of how much money is at risk or how much is a dispute and what kind of resources they have. Oftentimes it's something relatively minor, you know, under $100,000. And I tell them, you know, you can get an attorney who's going to write a really good letter for you and hopefully move them off the dime. But if you really throw down the gloves, so to speak, use a hockey analogy, and to go to the mattress, it's going to cost money, in general, how much if somebody is going to not pay as they go along, but turn to you on a contingency basis saying, "I have a dispute and there's real estate involved. There's blah." You're going to look at that. Obviously, you have to vet it based on what you think are the merits and how likely you are to be successful, but there has to be a certain amount of money available for you to take the case on to make it make business sense. Give me a guideline. How do you make those assessments or what do you tell a customer in that case? Sure. It's somewhat of a case-bycase analysis for us. You know, it depends on what the

3:25 Dispute is, the level of difficulty, and whether or not it makes sense to litigate. Sometimes client, you know, a dispute could range from, you know, fighting over knickknacks and personal property items, to millions and even billions of dollars. And we've seen that entire kind of range of case. But as far as what it's worth for hourly, I would say the dispute should be, you know, at least a half a million dollars. Generally speaking only because of the expense that comes with litigating and getting a matter to trial. Most cases, albeit never make it to trial, but oftentimes even to get to mediation, it's going to cost six figures pra practically speaking, you know, experts eat up a lot in costs and then you have the amount of time these things this area of law differs from many others. For example, you know, personal injury or even employment because they're so case- specific. So having cookie cutter documents is not really a thing in our field. They're all custom. It's very bespoke to what we do. And each case is very specific in its fact patterns, the types of dispute, and the evidence that you're going to present.

4:49 So it is very custom to each client, and they're getting a very customized product. Typically, does business come to you referred directly by a consumer or by a other financial professional, Realtor®, accountant, or by another attorney? All of the above. I would say the most qualified cases, meaning that the ones that are viable, that we could even do something on, generally come from other attorneys who kind of recognize the potential pitfalls that a lay person just off the street or even, you know, a victim, for example, may not recognize. We get calls and we take them and we speak to these nice people all the time. But generally, if it's a call coming from the public, it may involve matters and disputes that are long past the statute of limitations. You know, mom or dad passed away in 2005 and I was supposed to get, you know, the house, but my brother took it, for example, and it's been, you know, a decade since that took place. And trying to claw that back is not going to be a successful effort. Now, not only is it a matter set of limitations, but I imagine the facts of the case as well as the dollar amount that's being argued over has to be significant enough to warrant it, right?

6:12 People call me, you know, somebody's entitled to $100,000. It's unfortunate, but you really can't litigate. You can object. You can file forms and letters, but when you actually talk about taking it all the way through litigation, at some point it's going to cost you more than you're going to get back if you pay for it. Yeah, I agree with that totally. It's you know, we're fortunate in a sense that we live in the state where real estate prices keep the economy and the value of these cases buoyed. Even in you know the most the outskirts of habitation and habitable areas real estate even in those areas are worth hundreds of thousands of dollars and you could have a few parcels of land even if they're undeveloped that might be worth something significant but usually single family residents things of that sort you're topping you know you're bottoming out at a million bucks no matter almost where you are in the state so yes you're correct yeah that's what it's getting to these days So, in getting business from other attorneys, you know, obviously you're fairly well known. I mean, based on what I've seen, do you still actively do things to develop business? I appreciate you're on my podcast today. Is this a regular part of your business doing business development? Are you pretty much just more about intaking referrals? How does your business look today as a business development? We absolutely do business development type activities, meeting with folks like you, getting the word out. People really don't realize that our cases oftentimes whether it's an attorney a Realtor®, an agent or some other type of professional or a lay person, our cases are usually staring them in the face. They've heard everybody's been touched by a circumstance or situation that we could probably help them with. It just they don't recognize that the claims exist or are there unless they're so flagrant and obvious in their nature that it screams to them that oh you know you should really do something about

8:13 This. But you know I'll give you an example right now. I'm handling a case where the decedent the person who passed away was divorced from his ex-wife back in the early 80s. But they continue to hold title to a specific piece of property as joint tenants and which means that you know the survivor between them takes it. However, it's not that clearcut because there was a divorce judgment in the case. Although it didn't identify that property and say what's to happen with it or how it was supposed to be divided, the estate of the decedent still has a claim. And our efforts are going to be to try to claw back half of it now. Because it was our client's separate property. The other side doesn't see it that way. But the law is on our side and we're talking about that's I think it's a forplex, a four-unit apartment building. So again, a couple of million bucks. What are the two or three most common fact patterns of cases that you've been successful with litigate? Are there common ones or is each one different? There's a through line. There's a similarity between the cases and I'll tell you what they are. Our primary causes of action in this area and causes of action for people who are unfamiliar with that term is just the claims you're suing on. There's a handful that we exercise in what we specifically do. It's you might have heard of them. Undue influence, lack of capacity, and then financial elder abuse. Okay, those are the big three I would say in this area.

10:02 There's others that can be tacked on that are relevant and even, you know, substantial in the weight they carry and the dam damages they come with. But undue influence, lack of capacity, and financial elder abuse are the big ones. They're somewhat intertwined. And you know, generally speaking, most situations call for all three. Sometimes not, but most of the time I would say all three apply, if they apply at all. But yes, th those are the ones. An undue influence is you know the decedent the person who created the will or the trust their free will was broken and they made a modification to the document or they created a document that they would not have otherwise done but for right that influence that's exerted upon that person. Usually the fact pattern we see elderly set of parents or an elderly individual if it's not just one person you know who's going through all kinds of medical issues or failing health or declining cognitive ability and then you have a child an outsider a caregiver a new spouse you know the end of the Cole Smith situation come swoop in and have a document executed by this giving them either the lion's share or everything, cutting out the people, you know, oftentimes the children of the person who has passed away you know and getting everything. So we see that a lot.

11:42 Yeah. I would say as a real estate agent I see that pattern also from the other side. So let's talk about undue influence. You know, on one hand, one, you know, the most caring, giving, remaining child in the house who's, you know, been with mom or dad for the last 10 years of their life. You know, in their mind, they're entitled to everything because they've done that. And the other siblings by default are going to assume whatever is done was unoured. And unless, you know, I'm there to watch and talk to the decedent, you know, how would you really know the difference between the undue influence? What are the common kind of signs or characteristics of undue influence? Now, you know, one obvious, you know, answer could be well, if they just did anything in the last 30 days of their life or last 90 days of their life, but at the same time, you can you can imagine a scenario where there's somebody who, you know, regrets their life and wants to make a change in the last 30 days. So, what are the characteristics or what are the signs that is crossed the line to be undue influence as opposed to influence? Sure. You know we're weary of even a little bit of influence the things I typically look for you know how did the document come to be prepared because the moment pen hits paper and that document is executed is the relevant time period you know what condition was the person who signed that document in you know what were the circumstances of its creation who contacted the attorney or sometimes it's not an attorney that prepares these documents who contacted them, who conveyed the you know the terms of the trust or the will to that person, the person who created the document. How involved were they? You know, how medically frail was the person who signed a document in situations like that. So, you know, the vulnerability of the victim becomes a factor. You know, whether or not the

13:46 Decedent, the person who passed away and created the document and the undue influencer had a confidential relationship. You know, did the decedent trust that person? Are we talking about a child where it's kind of a natural a natural relationship or is it some caretaker, a neighbor, some other outsider, a friend? And you know the level of participation if they were actively participating in the creation of the document and then you know the equity of the result it's called meaning that how fair is the result? Is it unnatural? You know cutting the kids out and giving it to you know a friend that they haven't seen in 20 years or an ex-girlfriend that's been out of the picture for half a decade. Is that normal? You know obviously you'd argue not but you know it depends and then you have to assess the evidence. The difficulty of litigating these types of cases is the one and only person who can really kind of tell you what's what is no longer around. So you're piecing the case together. It's an investigation. That's what makes practicing in this area very interesting and stimulating for somebody like me. You know, it's you're trying to pull a Columbombo move and one more thing, right? Like, and just bust out that piece of evidence that you hope you can find. Sometimes, you know, these bad guys, I'll call them, do such a good job of hiding their tracks or doing things in such a way where it's they get the benefit of the doubt as to whether or not what they did is, you know, crosses a line or not.

15:28 Sometimes that's not a clear line. But I would think even a case where let's say it's one child and the and this trust appears out of nowhere that you eliminates the other two children and it was created you know you know two weeks before death. It was done at a local you know online and notarized by a local place down the street. It was obvious it was all kind of put together. That son's going to say, "Hey, dad wanted me to have everything because I took care of him. The other kids abandoned him and make his case." I would imagine as a as a litigator, you still have to prove that case. I mean, you can't just walk in and say, "Hey, it's a son. He wrote the other people. He obviously created the document. He didn't let the other kids talk to him." The judge is going to go, "Oh, well, you must be right. I agree. We'll invalidate the trust." You get paid money, I believe, to make that case in a format, in a process, and a procedure that the judge has the ability to overturn those documents. Is that a fair assessment? I would say so. I think that's fair. You know, it's not so clear-cut. It's never so clear-cut. You know, we, as a result of what I mentioned earlier where we don't have much direct evidence, circumstantial evidence is allowed to come in, you know, witness statements, and things like that. That's really what you have to rely upon. But you still got to prove up your case. So what happens is one of the one of the interesting wrinkles of this area of law is that if you can prove a handful of things in a case of off so let me take a step back for a moment. The plaintiff the person bringing a lawsuit always has the burden of proof in civil cases. I mean that's the case across the board I think even in criminal but I don't practice criminal so I'll let that be. But we have the burden of proof. But what happens is if you are able to demonstrate the you know kind of the basic facts of undue influence the burden can shift on the other side to prove that there was not undue influence. Not an easy thing to do. And

17:33 What I've been told by many a judge and retired judge is that judges don't like shifting the burden. It's called because it could go up on appeal and judges don't like you know when then their decisions and orders are appealed. But it is something courts are able to do and shift the burden and then it becomes a responsibility of the person who's being sued to rebut that presumption and prove that there was no undue influence there. But to get there, you've got to you have to get to that point. Meaning you don't Yeah. And that's why you have to pick the right attorney to get to the point because it's not it's not automatic. It doesn't care doesn't matter how clear the facts are. You still got to put it on paper in the right format. Get to the judge in the right way and get the judge's attention. I think is one way to kind the way I kind of think about Absolutely. And look, it's, you know, if you have a lawsuit on your hands involving this area law, you want somebody who knows what they're doing. And the reason being is they could spot things a mile away or know what to look for or know how to look for certain things where somebody who's not familiar with this area of law and not familiar with the courts as it relates to trust and probate work the counties you know there's a lot of pitfalls for people who try to a go it alone or hire somebody who's just you know a lawyer off the street or does everything and dabbles in this.

18:56 The so the second area you mentioned was capacity and as a real estate agent that's an area that comes up to us as well because the same people who might get a trust done or will may want to just sell property listed for sale get a contract sold and the question is you know what kind of capacity do the customer have so I guess the and I can imagine as an attorney there are times that you want to invalidate transactions done based on capacity you want to validate a trust or you want to validate a sale saying there's undue influence or but or in this case they have the capacity to make those decisions. What are signs that somebody doesn't have capacity that you would say as a real estate agent, I should be alerted to as being a defining point? Meaning, it's not our job to determine it, but it's our job to be aware of it and get proper guidance. Sure. There's a couple of standards that apply to capacity when it comes to this area of law. But I'll go with the lower one. I'll explain the lower one because it's a lot easier to digest and that seems to be the standard that's applied across the board even when the higher standard should be the one that's applied. But it's called testimeament capacity. So does the person who's making the decision know what their property is, know what their familial relations are, and understand the consequences of their actions. It's a very low bar. And it's very easy to meet. Oftent times, you know, even people who have dementia and things like that could satisfy those requirements. That's the standard that applies to wills, simple wills and simple trust like an amendment for example to a trust that only changes let's say a percentage or an amount of a gift instead of it you know completely being restated or restructured. But there is a higher standard called contractual capacity that applies to trust. That's you know a higher threshold but again like I said courts have been very lax when it comes to capacity. There's been some decisions

21:01 Handed down in the last handful of cases that really kind of bottoms out that claim. I mean it's got to pass a smell test bill. You know, you see a person, they're clearly not appreciating or understanding what they're doing. You see somebody kind of hovering over them saying, "Oh, yeah, mom or dad, you know, sign there." And they're like confused about what's going on. You know, you got to trust your gut. I mean, that's the first thing when you're dealing with a person while they're still alive. Now, I deal with them nine times out of 10, nine and a half times out of 10 when they're passed. So, I'm looking at medical records, you know, medical records from hospitals, primary care physicians, everything in between. And you know, you'll see on there alert and oriented, you know, as the person, place, time, and or sometimes you see, you know, you see Alzheimer's on there, you see dementia, that's already a big red flag. You look at their medication list, see what type of medications they were taking and how it could potentially affect their ability to understand what they're doing. So, you kind of have to become a half a doctor or at the very minimum, you know, have an understanding of what to look for. And at this point I've interacted with so many experts medical experts in that field who whose job is to assess and then testify as to a person's mental capacity that you know what the signs tend to be and there are tests you know there are tests to assess you know I went through this with my in-laws and one thing I noticed was that they would be different throughout the day in the morning they would get up and after a while they were you know aware and seemingly normal. And then as the afternoon went on the in this case Alzheimer's became more obvious and then later in the day it was they were you know obviously had no capacity and so of course when do we take them to the doctors during the day because it's

23:04 Easier to get them in out of the car easier to get them to comply with the doctor when they're functioning at their height. And so of course all the medical reports are going to show their alert because you're there at you know 11 o'clock or two o'clock in the afternoon. If ever the doctor appointment was at 5:00 pm it'd be wow he's you know really lost a lot of capacity. And so what as a real estate agent I had that experience once. I went to somebody's house at like 11:00 in the afternoon and I had a reason to call him back like at 4 and it just didn't make sense like on the phone and then this guy called me really upset who was his son. He's like young at me as though I was trying to cheat this guy. Like, why are you upset with me? Well, didn't you see him? And I said, "Yeah, I saw him. He looked I mean, normal to me." And he goes, "When were you there? You just saw him. Didn't you meet me at 4?" And I said, "No, actually, I was there at 11:00." And I said, "I called him recently." He goes, "Oh." He goes, "Yeah, he's pretty cognizant in the morning, but come afternoon, he's doesn't have capacity." I It's tough. It's tough because that's a very kind of common theme that we see and hear about. And what we've been told again from the input of judges, and what we've seen, you know, in cases is when you don't know, the benefit of the doubt goes towards the person having capacity. I've been told once by a retired judge who was acting as our mediator and you know the medical evidence was really strongly suggesting that this person did not have capacity but we did not have a letter from a doctor saying look you know this person's been assessed and they cannot make their medical decisions. Sometimes in rare instances we do have that and those are great. But if you don't you know but that what that judge told me is look we're going to assume that if this person is incapacitated for 23 out of the 24 hours of the day that document was executed in that one hour where the person was lucid. It just they're gonna play it safe because what you're asking to do and what we as

25:08 Attorneys oftentimes representing people are asking to do is for a judge to basically tear up a legally valid document on its face. Something that looks fine, you know, is signed, is notarized, or it's witnessed, whatever the case may be, it's valid on its face. You're asking them to void it. So, you better you better come with strong evidence, you know, very compelling evidence to void it out. And you're also talking about removing somebody's free will after they're gone. And you know I you know I remember in I'm in LA court a lot and whenever Britney Spears had a hearing there'd be like these big demonstrations a big news event and people were very passionate about it and you know on both sides and I remember discussing with somebody and I said you know it should be a very high bar to take away your rights. I don't know about her case and I don't, you know, don't know the facts at all. But I'm just saying philosophically for somebody to lose their right to make decisions on life. That's the ultimate right. At some point, you're no longer a human being. You're just like an like a horse with a with a leash around your mouth or bit in your mouth and you're going to do what people tell you to do. It should be a high bar to take away people's rights. Not saying on any particular case, but it's right that judges are hesitant. I think that's a I think it's a healthy thing. There's a little bit of judicial modesty in that regard. Yeah. I and I tend to agree with you even though sometimes it works against me. But again, it's the cases that come to us, we vet them. So, not that, you know, we take anything that comes through the door. The ones where it's, you know, you really kind of raise your eyebrows as to whether or not there's a case there, we're not going to take that. But something's got to got to certainly look wrong. And you know with each passing case that we process and handle and conclude you know our ability to spot you know the problems potential problems become sharper. So we really try to fine-tune our intake process and vet the cases and our clients because not every client you know is honest and forthcoming. Some of these people see a

27:12 Potential payday and they're opportunists. So, we have to be very careful about that. You know, the opportunity could swing both ways on these cases. So, I can tell you there's a f there's a pattern to that attorney who'll take any case, which is they get the case like a week before the hearing and they're substituting in. They know they've been an attorney or two before them. They tend to be older, smaller firm, maybe a oneman shop. And, you know, I see that over and over. I've learned how to go in the cal bar and check and vet it that way because for me as a real estate agent, I want to know is this is this claim going to be legitimate or is this just somebody trying to throw something against the wall? I had a case recently where we had a decedent and the bad sister got a deed in notarized in Mexico transferring everything to her, but the deed was the guy had died like 12 years ago and the deed was dated like five years after he died. Well, obviously it wasn't him, right? Then it turns out she deeded it into a trust and I knew the attorney who did the trust and I called him up and said look I'm not here to argue the case with you but when you do a trust do you go back and check you know no we just they gave us the deed say this is my property and they transferred I said oh FYI you might want to look at this one here's a death cert here's the date of the deed and looked at appreciated because you're not going to vent it the same way on a trust document as you are in litigation but you have to I think see you know who is this person where they coming from if you're getting a litigation, we spend a kind of time on a case. Yeah, absolutely. I mean, you know, we're in one of the rare areas of law where I depose quite a few attorneys. So, that's, you know, usually the first person whose deposition I take is the attorney that prepared the document, if there is an attorney that prepared the document. And you'd be surprised how flatfooted some of these attorneys are caught. You know, when you really start to scrutinize their practices, it's like, what do you mean you didn't meet? What do you know? You did this all over the phone. How did you verify that the person you were speaking to was who they claimed to be, you know, or

29:16 You just communicated via email? Again, same problem. Like how do you verify the person on the other side is who they claim to be? So, it's dangerous for attorneys and it both kind of shocks and dismays me sometime how easily attorneys kind of almost assist with this type of stuff and only to later regret it because now they're being you know deposed by somebody like me and you know their whole kind of practice is being scrutinized and picked apart. I don't want to do it. I don't take any kind of pleasure from it, but you know, then again, it's my job. And the other thing that I wanted to kind of touch on is we our firm trust law partners, you know, we really have to believe in your case to take it. And the reason I even bring that up is because we're one of the few, very few law firms, especially of our size, that take these types of matters on contingency. Clients come to us from all walks of life. Some penniless on the street. I've had homeless clients before who come to us and they're like, you know, something, you know, I'm no angel, but something stinks to high heaven here. I'm not being given, you know, a copy of the trust or I'm not being given my inheritance or I'm not being given XYZ. You know, can you help me? And that person or those types of people would be, you know, completely out of luck and they're underserved and unserved most times. So, as long as they have a viable claim and they appear credible, and we do our research before we take cases on. So, they might, you know, we were provided a set of facts and then we investigate it as best we can. You know, we help these people. We help these people. So, we're standing shoulder-to-shoulder with our clients going into battle. It's not I'm we're not mercenaries in that regard because

31:19 It's not like, "Oh, I don't care what the outcome is. I'm going to get paid either way." No, that's not the case with us. And we take pride in that. We have hourly clients. Those people are usually more affluent and they could afford the high rates that come along with litigating in kind of a specialized area or like a niche. But some people it just makes sense to do it that way. Other people don't want the risk. Don't want to have to pull a second mortgage on their homes to, you know, try to get their rightful inheritance. I agree with a prominent litigator in Orange County who had a huge victory. I want to say it was $50 million or so. The clients came to him originally paying by the hour. They had a the victim was now destitute, but she had a sister who was able to, you know, I think finance a couple hundred,000, which they thought was plenty. And as it went on and things dragged on, and the defendant, you know, got more and more aggressive defending himself, it cost more and more. And fortunately, their case, the TR was able to flip it to a kind of a combined of, you know, cash of friend and then contingency forward and s to the end and won and everybody got money and it all worked out. Thank God. But that being able to do it contingency, I think is an important piece because if you're not able to and they run out of money, then you're stuck and you put invest all that money into a process and another attorney is not likely to pick it up at that point. You're really you're really just stuck. Yeah.

32:50 You know and you'd be surprised the type of people who are interested and opt for a contingency. We've had you know clients or potential clients come to us and their names everybody in the United States would recognize and we're talking about you know billion dollar cases and they're like well you know we spent millions and millions litigating this case for over a decade. That was a very complicated case. But we're tired of it. You know, we're looking to switch up and we want somebody who could do it hybrid as you suggested where it's part contingency, part hourly, or contingency altogether. And it's a relief to most people to be offered that option of contingency because, you know, again, they don't have to worry about how they're, you know, taking food off the table if a bill becomes exorbitant, you know. So, yeah, it's a big stress. Yes, it's a big source for people and to have that option is important. So you we mentioned three factors, the third being financial elder abuse. Describe what financial elder abuse looks like and what's a common fact pattern there. It's very similar to undue influence. So you know you're if you have one, usually you're going to have the other. It just the benefit of financial elder abuse and the reason we like to plead it where the facts supported of course is it comes with a civil jury trial. Financial elder abuse is a civil cause of action, a claim that you know, well, I won't reveal all my tricks, but it's something you could allege, but jury trials have a way of applying pressure or leverage because in probate court, you do not have a constitutional right to a jury trial. Your case is being heard in front of a single judge. Whereas financial elder abuse, you have the benefit of a jury. Juries, you know, it could help you or it could hurt. I mean, it depends on which side of the

34:52 Case you're on or how your client is perceived, but if utilized properly, your client is going to be sympathetic and the bad guy is going to look like a bad guy, and juries like to punish. And when it comes to financial elder abuse, it comes with you know other benefits such as being able to seek punitive damages, punishment damages, you know, aside from what's been taken and aside from recovering what has been stolen, you also get, you know, the big slap on a wrist, you know, which jury can could assess against and levy against, you know, a wrongdoer. Yeah. I mean, there's all kinds I'm happy to go through. Well, and when people hear about outrageous punitive damages, they need to understand the point of it is to be so punitive that not just that person, but other people stop that activity, right? It's meant to be such a deterrent that the bad guys, not just the one on trial, will stop. And that's really the message we're trying to send through the punitive damage, I think. That's right. Punitive damages are meant to be a deterrent as well. What so I'm sorry I interrupted you. The what's what are the most common or one or two factor patterns you've seen on financial elder abuse? I know, you know, I have another podcast on reverse mortgages. There was a time when they would do a reverse mortgage, take all the equity out, invest it in some overpriced annuity, turn the t the assets over three or four times and end up, you know, taking all the person's money. And that changed because of so many lawsuits on the reverse mortgage that the product actually changed. What are common financial elder abuses that you see? Mortgages or taking stocks in stock portfolios and turning them over. What are the common patterns? Oftentimes we see financial elder abuse present itself when you have somebody the bad guy getting involved with the decedent prior to their death. And usually siphoning money out, you know,

36:56 Liquidating investments, just stealing cash out, right? Stealing, you know, I've seen anything from gold bars being stolen from somebody, you know, to pieces of real estate being stolen, just taken. That's how we see it. It could be from a family member, it could be from a friend, it could be from a business partner, it could be a caretaker. Caretaker is a really bad one. Caretaker. There is a caretaker statute that's probate code 21380 that says you know if it's given to a caretaker or somebody who helped create the trust there's a presumption that the document is the product of undue influence and it's you know automatically void that gift to that caretaker unless they do you know they can take a step and obtain what's called a certificate of independent review. So, the person who, you know, executed the trust sits down with another independent attorney who asked them a host of questions and then signs a document that says, "I've spoken to this person and you're good to go." but I've had I've had a felon caretaker who was in the real estate business. She was in mortgages and was you know popped for mortgage fraud on a federal level and she had a restitution order that I came to find out later. So this all came to light way into the case. But what was presented to me was you know there's an elderly husband and wife passes away. The elderly husband, you know, keeps on the caretaker that were hired for the both of them when they were both, you know, still alive. And all of a sudden, you know, her whole family moves into the house. You know, the husband's the gardener. The son's, you know, does maintenance around the house. And you know, old man buys a car for the caretaker. That's how it starts. And then, oh, she's very nice to him. And he

38:59 Because he's, you know, of advanced age and his cognitive abilities are not as sharp as they used to be, allegedly because he was gone by the time I got to the case, falls in love with the caretaker. Sure. Yeah. And then they go on a cruise together, but he doesn't know that her family is also tagging along on a cruise in a separate room. Nothing goes on physically or romantically between them, but you know, this person lives with that hope. And he's paying for all of it, you know, and all of a sudden his house, the deed gets transferred or left to the caretaker in the trust responsible for Yeah. The kids are completely out of the picture now from the trust standpoint. And you know, of course, this person, you know, this decedent that had no idea that he was dealing with a snake, a convicted felon who had a restitution order of over $800,000 by the federal government. I actually that was an interesting case because despite uncovering all this evidence she refused to cave. We went to one mediation and she was defiant. She was defiant and it just you know shocking really because you know she's facing down a pretty brutal thrashing if we go to trial. And they agreed to go to another mediation down the road several months after the fact. But before the second mediation, I reached out to the Department of Justice and I poked around. I'm like, you know, there's a restitution order here. How does it affect, you know, if this person were to take under this trust, you know, would you guys just vacuum it all up? He's like, absolutely.

40:41 You know, satisfy the judgment. And so we got the Department of Justice involved. I got to meet a couple of really awesome you know, US attorneys. And you know, she finally came to her senses and relented. Sometimes you need to you need to think outside the box to litigate these cases. And we were fortunate enough to restore our client's inheritance. Hope they're not coming for you there, Greg. I'm hear the in the background. Well, look, I kept a little bit longer than we scheduled. Obviously this is a very broad area. I imagine no two cases are the same. I appreciate kind of giving us a great overview on probate litigation. If somebody's has a case that they want to talk to you about particularly an attorney you know and I say as real estate agents we want to vet the case before we bring it to somebody make sure we have an idea of what's involved and what the issues are but if somebody's interested what's the best way to reach I know we have your website trustlaw partners.com is the website and then and there's a phone number is that the best way to reach you to talk about a case it is we also have a for a submission you know you could submit a request for a consultation we're probably one of the only firms that has an actual attorney like licensed practicing attorney who does the intake process. Usually, you're talking to a secretary or sometimes even just, you know, some call center somewhere that just takes basic information. Not our firm. You're talking to an attorney from the jump. And or at the very minimum, the first consultation will certainly be with an attorney. But that is how you can contact us by email, by phone, however you are clients, please or potential clients, please. They're welcome to reach out. They can also reach out to me directly. I'm happy to happy to talk to anybody. My email is g oanlawpartners.com and I'm happy to answer any questions. I'm not stingy with my time. Fantastic. Well, we'll put that in the show notes for later as well as up on up on top the contact information and really appreciate your time here and again and just to

42:45 Wrap up I guess really serving all of California primarily. Excuse me. Absolutely right. Yeah. Yeah. B California and then what I always tell people is the laws are the same throughout the state. The procedures are different in different counties and cities obviously different courts but the laws are the same throughout the state and trust all parts is a big enough firm that has offices throughout you said through all the nice cities unless in California. So again Greg thank you so much for your time today. Really appreciate you sharing with us and we look forward to talking again soon. My pleasure Bill. Thank you for having me. Thank you. And everybody else this is Probate Weekly. We do this every week. We talked to leading attorneys, also vendors in the business to help us learn how to be more effective dealing with our customers and building our business. Whether you're an attorney, a real estate agent, or a vendor in the business, probateweekly.com. We continue the conversation on Facebook. The group is Probate Weekly as well. Put your comments there, questions. If you're looking for referrals, it's a great place to do that. As always, I'm Bill Gross. Bill Gross probate on social media. And make today your best day ever. Thank you so much. And Greg's gone. Very good.

More Probate Weekly episodes

Related

Educational media, not legal advice. Guest views are their own. Hosted by Bill Gross, The LA Probate Expert, a licensed California real estate broker (DRE #01022275) brokered by eXp Realty of California, Inc. (DRE #01878277). Bill is not an attorney and is not a Probate Referee.

Schedule Consultation