Special Needs Planning, with Estate Planning Attorney Andrew D. Atherton
The Estate Planning Podcast · · Guest: Andrew D. Atherton, McGuire, Wood & Bissette
Episode summary
Bill Gross talks with North Carolina estate planning attorney Andrew D. Atherton of McGuire, Wood & Bissette about special needs planning: helping families plan so a child or loved one with special needs is protected and can still qualify for government programs such as Medicaid and Supplemental Security Income.
Andrew explains why this is a specialist's field. Benefit rules change often, and staying in regular contact with case workers is how he catches small changes that can have a large effect on a plan. He gives the example of North Carolina real estate exclusions for Medicaid, which different counties interpret differently.
Bill and Andrew discuss the shortage of fiduciaries. Andrew says many corporate trustees do not want trusts under several million dollars, so his firm hired a lawyer who built a team of paralegals to serve as agent under power of attorney and as trustee for individuals.
The conversation closes on the reasons for a trust, such as a special needs child, a second marriage or other family dynamics, why Andrew gathers a lot of family information when planning, and the value of having litigation experience nearby when drafting.
Key points
- Special needs planning protects assets while keeping a loved one eligible for benefits such as Medicaid and SSI.
- Benefit rules change and can be interpreted differently county by county, so staying in touch with case workers matters.
- Many corporate trustees will not take smaller trusts, which leaves families looking for fiduciaries.
- Andrew's firm built a team that can serve as agent under power of attorney and as trustee.
- Whether you need a trust often depends on family dynamics, such as a special needs child or a second marriage.
Questions answered in this episode
What is special needs planning?
It is estate planning that protects assets for a person with special needs while making sure they can still receive benefits like Medicaid and insurance. Andrew Atherton's practice also covers programs such as VA benefits, Medicare and SSI. Watch at 23:45
Why use a special needs specialist instead of a general estate planner?
Andrew says there is a dramatic difference: benefit rules change, and if you are not in consistent contact with the case workers who interpret them, you can miss small changes that have an enormous impact on the plan. Watch at 3:36
Do Medicaid rules vary by county?
In North Carolina, Andrew says, there are several real estate exclusions for Medicaid, and each county interprets them differently, for example how joint ownership with right of survivorship is treated. Watch at 5:38
Why is it hard to find a trustee for a smaller trust?
Andrew says many corporate trustees do not want trusts under roughly two to five million dollars, and even in that range they push clients to call centers. Watch at 17:08
What has Andrew's firm done about the fiduciary shortage?
About a year and a half before the interview, the firm hired a lawyer who built a team of paralegals to serve as agent under power of attorney and as trustee for individuals. Watch at 17:08
When does a family need a trust?
Andrew says it depends on the reasons: family dynamics, a special needs child whose benefits must be protected, or situations like a second marriage. That is why he gathers a lot of family information when planning. Watch at 23:45
Transcript
Transcript generated from YouTube's automatic captions for this episode and lightly cleaned (filler words and repeated words removed, names and web addresses corrected; phone numbers and email addresses read on air are replaced with a placeholder; [unclear] marks words the captions did not capture). It may still contain transcription errors, and speaker labels are not included. Timestamps link to that point in the video, which is the authoritative record.
Editor's note: Andrew D. Atherton is an attorney in North Carolina, not California, and describes North Carolina law and practice in this episode. Bill Gross is a California real estate broker, not an attorney. California rules differ in places. This is general information, not legal advice; talk with a lawyer licensed in the state where the property is.
0:02 Welcome to The Estate Planning Podcast and you know when I initially launched this podcast as a real estate agent I really was on a soap box to make sure we as Realtors® and financial professionals don't just do a transaction but help our clients prepare themselves in the long run for things that can come up. Estate planning is so central but within estate planning there's so many different niches and one of them that we're going to talk about today we really have an expert on attorney Andrew Atherton on the subject of special needs planning. Andrew thanks for joining us today. Thanks I'm excited to be here. So of all areas of law how did you get involved with special needs estate planning in particular? You know I kind of fell into it in the legal field you don't sort of jump out of our specialized within law school typically and coming out of law school I was working for a small firm doing family law divorces and child custody and things like that and that was a tough road. It was not a practice that I really enjoyed all that much to say the least and decided to kind of look for other opportunities and a in a boutique firm in Greensboro where I was living at the time had an opening for a special needs elder law attorney and I thought well why not try this and it was a perfect fit. It's got a lot of you're helping families that have a lot of complicated dynamics within it and so there's fair amount of social work related to maybe the legal field you're looking at not just you know solving one particular legal issue you're really kind of looking at their entire family situation and dynamics and working through a little bit of a
2:06 Sort of social work type atmosphere and I sort of really get invested with sort of helping people and it was just a great fit. Wow. Well I do think that anytime we can be more holistic in our approach to solving customers problems right? For me as a real estate broker I could just sell the house but if I notice titles named at least in California of the individuals and not in the estate plan then at least I should ask the question hey have you considered you know have you thought about? If I notice they have kids who are special needs you know have you thought about that there's some special issues that may you should maybe consider. Not that's my job to force them but at least ask the question if I if I care about them why would I not at least make sure they're aware of that. That's why I have this podcast. And you bring up a fascinating point you know in law school you said they don't really push specialization. You know if I was on the national board of law schools I'm not nobody's asking me to help out there I would make people specialize in something just like engineers specialize in one discipline of engineering I think history you know history majors pick a particular focus on their history. I think every attorney I know who enjoys the practice does well successfully has a good reputation has a narrow specialty and maybe they bleed into holistically other areas but I just think that's so important and for us as when we look for attorneys we should be finding people who specialize in these areas to get the better service for clients rather than just a generalist.
3:36 So talk a little bit about how your time you know delving deep in this topic and I don't want to be a modest about it but as a real estate agent I don't want to take a special needs situation to just any attorney who legally could write the estate plan. I want somebody who specializes in this. Talk a little bit about the differences of your experience versus somebody maybe who just does general estate plans. Yeah I mean I think there's just you know there's a dramatic difference between sort of general practitioners and that's it's almost gone out of style. I mean you find that there are general practitioners that are that happen in some small towns and things like that because it they just have to sort of broaden their focus but it becomes very difficult particularly in the special needs planning niche because the rules are so complicated and varied we're talking about not only state law we're talking about an overlay of federal law and those aren't all sort of court cases and statutes but there's regulations and there's you know and not only just even regulations there each you know sometimes in sort of the benefits planning realm and dealing with government benefits like Medicaid and then you've got and housing related things housing benefits you've got sometimes even county specific like regulations and rules then how those are get interpreted by you know your particular county. So you have to stay very sort of if you're not laser focused on the area and communicating consistently with colleagues
5:38 In that in sort of that area you're not communicating with case workers and those folks sort of interpreting the rules and sort of overseeing qualification then if you're not doing that communication on a very consistent basis then you're not you may be missing changes that may be minute but have a enormous impact on what maybe the plan what happens with the plan so one example of that is that in North Carolina here we have a number of different exclusions related to real estate in a lot of Medicaid sense but each county interprets that exclusion differently some counties let it happen so that joint with right of survivorship real estate is excluded and some interpret that to only be tenants in common real estate and in North Carolina those two things are dramatically different and deal dramatically you know are handled dramatically different when somebody passes away joint with right of survivorship becomes owned by the surviving owners and tenants in common interest passes down to heirs and so and that gets interpreted different ways by different counties even and just knowing other lawyers across the state that specifically do this and we have a listserv that's pretty active and hearing what's happening in each county it takes a lot of effort to stay up on that information and I think if I were a general practitioner it would be really hard to try to deal you know family law criminal law all of those things and still stay up on the small detail that's happening in some
7:43 County that you know I don't often speak to. You know it's true I'm not an attorney I'm a real estate broker but I'm a affiliate member of the LA County Bar and I belong to the listserv for the estate planning section and it's a way for me to learn. I see attorneys ask questions and I get to see the answers in some cases. And sometimes you'll see somebody who obviously doesn't do estate or trust law ask a question and the and the way they pose it you think oh I hope that's not my client who's calling them because you know I mean I'm glad they're getting advice and mentorship and help on one hand on the other hand this stuff is very complicated and it does vary by county and I you know one small example it's interesting in San Bernardino County if you have a probate hearing for authority you submit the order ahead of time the judge approves it and they'll print it out and the judge will just pull it out sign it hand it back to you. LA County they'll disregard anything before the appointment hearing date. You have to then after hearing submit the order then the judge gets to it if it's right then the judge signs it. It can be two weeks. So good practice is in San Bernardino is bad practice in LA County and it You say well why would that be so different? You know two different guys run or two different people run two different organizations and so you have different counties and that's why it's so important to have an attorney I think that works in a county you know to avoid these kind of problems.
9:09 Yeah absolutely and it I mean it's very similar and you see that kind of across the board particularly in areas of the law that have so many different overlays of rules and regulations and statutes and case law all of those things are a good place to sort of miss something or you know I would think that estate planning as it relates to special needs that in terms of business development that your business either has to come from other attorneys although that's tough sometimes to get them to acknowledge their other area or maybe wealth planners or people who deal with people's wealth. Where in your case if you're able to describe where does the what's the what's the source of business that drives your referrals or our business into your practice? Yeah so I mean primarily we're getting business from referral sources and it can be anything from you know CPAs wealth planners other lawyers are you know pretty good drivers of business and particularly in it when it relates to like special needs planning elder law work because it I think folks recognize that it's not that it's complicated and hard to you know they're worried and nervous about doing those things we do get a fair amount of referrals and business from real estate agents and I think it's right I think it's important that you see your clients as like whole people and make sure that they're you know getting advice as to what they should be looking at least issue spotting helping to issue spot a little bit for them and send them into a good direction
10:59 I know you've been at this a while and have a pretty good following so I'm not sure how much time you spend still doing business development versus business coming in based on your reputation but for attorneys that are looking to develop more business in this area what are the activities like how is it you get attention from fellow attorneys or wealth managers or accountants or real estate agents what are the things you do besides my podcast which is the best source of free marketing nationally what are the things that you do or would or see colleagues doing that are effective in positioning themselves not as too salesy right cuz attorneys they're turned off if it's hey I'm the best you know estate planning attorney for special needs they don't want to hear that but they are looking for the best attorney in special needs so how do you handle that yeah so I mean the things that tell young lawyers or even lawyers that are looking to move in this practice even if they're not so young is some of the best ways is get involved with your sort of elder law bar either that's through like your local or your state bar your local bar if there's a elder law group or section of that bar that's a great opportunity to sort of get involved with meeting attorneys doing your practice around the state and getting involved with groups even nationally like the National Academy of Elder Law Attorneys or the Academy of Special Needs Planners those sort of groups are good even from a national perspective to both gain knowledge and to and to sort of meet folks that could potentially be referral source type folks and then I think getting involved you know a lot of times with like local bar for referral type things and then you know if we're any aside from sort of referral type sources
13:03 We do a fair amount of speaking not necessarily offering sort of the free lunch or dinner in order to do like more of a sales marketing but we'll do a lot of sort of just information sessions similar to like this to churches you know nonprofits those groups that help folks with disabilities and things like that churches to me seems so natural for this in that you know not that they want to change necessarily people's plan but there's so many people who feel committed to their church or my case I'm Jewish synagogue and you know if they had a way to automate that process their desires and turn them into a legacy they would and you can with a proper state plan and if you don't have a state plan you're going to lose a lot of it and overhead on top of not getting what you want I remember I during COVID when we had the I took my wife to get a vaccine and it was this huge church in LA when I say huge it was like a stadium there were like I don't know 5,000 parking spots and we're lined up like eight lines 20 deep and I remember thinking you know if you could have like a state plan template and get all these people signed on but I see so much wealth lost through the process that was one of the things one of the things that drew me to the podcast was I think churches and in general charities are such a great opportunity for promoting estate planning which is not hey give us more money but really hey if your plan is to give us more money here's a way to do it and a way to do it effectively and in peace one of the things I wanted to ask you is I you know are I'm sure there's more elder law requirements as our population gets older physically and then you know mentally has declines special needs it seems like that's just exploded in terms of you know whatever reasons medically that we have more and more people who have very special needs or we're better identifying them I guess one or the
15:05 Other for sure so these numbers are growing one of the areas that I see that have to grow with it and is not is fiduciaries because often times you know if the parents don't have somebody to take care of the child I just had a case recently with a with a elderly man who he only had one child the child didn't really want to help him he really needs an attorney he trusts they really need a fiduciary cuz he just can't physically sign the papers to sell a house do you see that as a increasing requirement in your practice and I don't see enough people entering that business I try to encourage people I have a good friend who I helped get into it tell me about what the role of fiduciaries in special needs planning and elder law planning I mean we see that as like a as a big a big issue big area in which there's significant need but because you're right there's you know the baby boomer population is actually retiring like we're seeing and they're all sort of aging and needing help and assistance and things like that and we're seeing a lot of those folks that either for one reason or another either don't have family members to help them in naming as things like powers of attorney or trustees under trust and or just don't have family members that they would necessarily trust to name them in those positions and so that sort of along with the fact that a lot of the local banks at least in North Carolina that have traditionally served as trustee role for folks have gotten consolidated and gobbled up by groups like Wells Fargo and things like that and so our local trust folks have moved to big behemoths
17:08 That don't really want trust for less than two or three four five million dollars right to manage and even in those numbers of you know two to five million they're pushing things to call centers and things like that and so it's hard there are some you know we've identified some like local regional type trustees that still are kind of operating but one of the things that we did as a law firm is about a year and a half ago is that we've actually hired a lawyer and she's built out a team of paralegals that we will operate as power of attorney and trust for individuals you know as planners it's we are careful to not necessarily sort of just how our services as like a sales type thing we want to sort of draft from an independent perspective but we felt like we were getting so many people asking hey can you do this yes that we just needed to say yes we'll figure out how we will do this and so we're new at how this is working in fact we had about four weeks ago a whole day in which we were trying to re reestablish our operating procedures and things like that to sort of you know further reduce the cost to people for those services but it has definitely been an area in which we're seeing struggle and you're right when we mention that we're operating as trustee we often get lawyers a little nervous about hey I don't want to do this
19:10 And we've had lawyers and law firms reach out and say hey would you guys agree to be named in some of our documents and from a sort of limited perspective we've tread a little bit into that but haven't jumped feet first in it because it almost seems like the volume could be a little overwhelming I'm sure I mean I live with the administrator I see how you know they'll tell you the attorney oh yeah I've got this and they hang up and they call me up and they have no idea what they're doing you're getting into they have no idea you know what how tough some businesses are you know when you manage a two million dollar estate it's like managing a two million dollar business. And if you if you haven't done that, you don't know what it's about. If you have done that, you know it's a lot of work. It's not you don't run a business like that, you know, easily. It's it The people who do run it easily have done it for years and are experienced at it. So, it just seems to me this is a area that the need is exploding. I don't see the supply catching up to it now. I would think with AI it would be one of the jobs that can be maybe made more efficient. But you can't replace the human. Like the if one job that cannot be written out by AI would be a fiduciary by definition because you need a human being to make these decisions, right? So, I'm really on a campaign to try to get more people to take a look at that as a career choice cuz I think I know my clients need it and you're saying the same thing I think to some degree that your clients need it. Yeah, I'm sure you're saying it. I mean, if I'm saying it on the East Coast and you're saying it on the West, we know that the you know, entire country's probably falling short on being able to offer that service and you know, for one reason or another even as sort of regional banks used to do that, they're not sort of picking up and continuing that.
21:10 Well, they barely do checking accounts anymore. You know, there was a time I grew up in an area where like your local bank was like your local neighbor. You would you'd open a passbook account with them. You knew who they were. They sponsored a little league team. Nowadays no offense I know you're in North Carolina. No offense to North Carolina banking, but Bank of America and some of these other companies they're just you know, they're just taking our tax money I think and churning money and making billions of dollars and they're really not in the business of serving customers. And you know, being an administrator of an estate or helping special needs as a trustee or power of attorney, these are very personal, complicated, you know, difficult jobs. Not simple. Oh, they absolutely are. And it takes more than what like, you know, that you could really do to like a call center or something like that. I think you've got to know people a little bit better to operate in a lot of those roles. Well, anybody out there watching this who happens to be a fiduciary and crosses multiple states, I love to interview for this podcast because every attorney I think to some degree is looking for another person that be able to offer. I don't know necessarily that like in Andrew's case you would you would recommend somebody else, but you might at least give them a couple names to research on their own. I just don't I just don't think there's enough people in that industry to cover the need. So, let's just talk about we'll wrap up a little bit come forward looking.
22:36 2026 beginning of the year, where do you see the economic of the industry of the practice of laws and estate planning and what changes do you see in your practice let's say for this year? You know, I mean, I think a lot of things changed last year when the state tax exemption amount federally jumped to 15.1 million permanently with a inflation adjustment on it. And so, I mean, it changed a lot of estate tax planning and made a lot of those things sort of not really all that necessary. Now, you know, if you're in states that have an estate tax like California some of the, you know, north northeastern states, then you still probably want to do some estate tax planning, but you know, that's where I think you really delve more into family dynamics and you know, family dynamics planning. That it doesn't mean because you don't have an estate tax that you no longer need a trust or anything like that.
23:45 Right. So, you're you know, you start to get into what are our reasons for a trust? Are there family dynamic reasons for a trust? Do you have a special needs child in which you need to make sure assets are protected and the child can still get benefits like Medicaid, insurance and things like that. Or, you know, family dynamics like a second marriage and those things. And so, it becomes very
24:15 Sort of family driven, which is why, you know, when we're doing planning, we start gathering a whole lot of information about somebody. And it almost seems intrusive for folks. They're like, why do you need all this personal information? That's because what the plan does is really based on what your whole sort of family situation is. That's a whole another, you know, demographic change that causes more need for estate planning also is instances of divorce has risen so much. Remarriage marriage with kids already, all those create a potentially legal challenges that left unaddressed can rear their ugly heads. And you know, I think I've seen estate wealth chewed up as much by litigation as by taxes. And so, I think you're exactly right. These things are important to plan for. Yeah, I mean, if you can think through all of that and prevent it from going, I mean, one of my partners does entirely estate and trust litigation. And if I can keep stuff out of her hands, the better off I've done for the family in trying to keep it from, you know, thinking ahead how much further in ahead can we think and You know, the plan clear but it's clear.
25:36 When I was new in the space, I used to look for attorneys who did both estate planning and litigation feeling that the litigation would help you write better plans and avoid problems. I came to realize they're typically two different people, right? The person who's good at the estate plan tends to be much more personable, nurturative cuz you have to dig deeper. You know, your effectiveness is the communication and relationship. Whereas as litigation, your effectiveness is I think just not having a heart and you know, claws and d- you know, big teeth and all that. No, I but it's just a different My experience is a different personality. But having them in your firm, I think it's important. That way you can talk to each other hopefully at lunch, find out what's going on. If you have a problem, you can walk it across the hall. It's not like a different attorney. I think people feel abandoned when the attorney says, I don't do litigation. You need to find another attorney. To me that I always felt like that's not really serving your customer. That's serving your business and in the long run not effective. So, it's interesting to hear that you say that. Well, I know We've got seven planners. Sorry to interrupt you in our in our and we do we draft our own sort of base forms and documents together. And we meet quarterly to update those. And our litigator comes to those meetings because
26:47 Beautiful. She often says, hey, wait a minute. You don't You may not want to put that clause in there. Beautiful.
26:56 Yeah, and you don't like it when she does that I guess in practice. Although I had you appreciate that she does it because you avoid having to bring the file over to her somewhere down the road, right? Right. Yeah. Yeah. Well, look, I know I've gone a little longer than I planned. I really appreciate your time Andrew talking about estate planning, particularly elder focus and special needs. If you want to get more information, his contact information is below. And we also have a link to his website. It's M W B from McGuire Wood & Bisset. M W lawyers.com is the website. If you search on attorneys, you'll see a picture of him all dressed up and looking sharp ready to go to court. Andrew, thank you so much for your time today sharing with us about some of the issues on special needs. And hopefully anybody who has more questions in the area would feel free to reach out to you. Perfect. Thanks, Bill. I really enjoyed talking to you. Always. And for the rest of you, this is Estate Planning Weekly. We get together get together every week usually with an estate planning attorney or vendor to help us be more effective in our work. I have any questions, comments. If you think you should be interviewed, let me know. I'm always looking for great guests. You don't have to be as great as Andrew to be on the show, but love to get great guests. If I can help in any way, I'm at Bill Gross Probate on social media. As always, make today your best day ever. Thanks so much.
More with Andrew D. Atherton
More The Estate Planning Podcast episodes
- Family-Centered Estate Planning, with Sati McLafferty
- Florida Estate Planning, with Attorney Jamy Barreau
- Business Succession Planning Strategies, with Tax Attorney Keith E. Phillis
Related
- A guide for successor trustees
- How long does probate take?
- Probate attorneys and podcast guests
- The Estate Planning Podcast: all episodes
- For attorneys & fiduciaries
Educational media, not legal advice. Guest views are their own. Hosted by Bill Gross, The LA Probate Expert, a licensed California real estate broker (DRE #01022275) brokered by eXp Realty of California, Inc. (DRE #01878277). Bill is not an attorney and is not a Probate Referee.