Episode summary

Bill Gross talks with Keith E. Phillis, a tax attorney with DarrowEverett, about business succession planning. Bill sees the result of no planning in real estate, where a business or property sometimes has to be sold in a hurry, and Keith explains how to plan for both who owns the business and who runs it.

Keith says owners need to think five years ahead: who will benefit from the wealth the business generated, and who will make decisions the day the owner no longer can. Using sports franchises as examples, he and Bill discuss family members stepping in, the role of long-time non-family employees, and building a management hierarchy before it is needed.

On taxes, Keith explains why heirs need liquidity. An estate tax bill can come due within months of a death, and he suggests structures such as pledgeable shares so heirs can borrow against the business instead of selling it. He also covers state estate taxes: snowbirds who move their domicile to Florida can still have property, such as land in Rhode Island, taxed where it sits, and some states have exemption "cliffs".

Keith describes a resurgence of trust protectors, which can amend a trust after it is set up, and how they are being used to move appreciating assets such as real estate out of a taxable estate. He closes with his view that tax planning is about paying no more than the law requires, and that it is one of the few areas of law where the value can almost always be quantified.

Key points

  • Succession planning covers two questions: who owns and benefits from the business, and who runs it.
  • Plan about five years ahead and build a management hierarchy before it is needed.
  • Heirs need liquidity for estate taxes; structures such as pledgeable shares can avoid a forced sale.
  • Moving your domicile does not remove property in another state from that state's estate tax.
  • Trust protectors add flexibility to irrevocable trusts and are being used in estate tax planning.

Questions answered in this episode

What does business succession planning involve?

Keith Phillis says it is about two things: who will own the business and benefit from its wealth, and who will run it. Owners need to think five years ahead about who will make decisions the day they no longer can. Watch at 1:11

What happens if a business owner dies without a management plan?

Often a spouse or child steps in, or the business is simply left to heirs who may not be able to run it. Keith says the answer is building a management hierarchy in advance, including long-time employees who are not family. Watch at 4:15

How can heirs pay estate tax without selling the business?

Keith explains that the estate tax bill can come due about nine months after death, and suggests structuring the business so shares can be pledged as security, giving heirs a way to borrow rather than sell. Watch at 12:33

Can moving to Florida avoid state estate tax?

Not entirely. Keith works with snowbirds who establish domicile in Florida, but if they own land in a state like Rhode Island, that property still goes through that state's estate when they die. Watch at 18:55

What is a state estate tax "cliff"?

Keith explains that in some states with an estate tax, going even $1 over the exempt amount can make the whole estate taxable, so that last dollar costs a lot. He describes the Rhode Island and Massachusetts exemptions as of the recording. Watch at 21:39

What is a trust protector?

A trust protector is a person who can amend a trust, for example to add beneficiaries. Keith says the concept used to be seen mainly in asset protection trusts, but he is seeing a resurgence of trust protectors in tax planning to move assets out of a taxable estate while the exemption is high. Watch at 22:46

Transcript

Transcript generated from YouTube's automatic captions for this episode and lightly cleaned (filler words and repeated words removed, names and web addresses corrected; phone numbers and email addresses read on air are replaced with a placeholder; [unclear] marks words the captions did not capture). It may still contain transcription errors, and speaker labels are not included. Timestamps link to that point in the video, which is the authoritative record.

Editor's note: Keith E. Phillis is an attorney in Rhode Island, not California, and describes Rhode Island law and practice in this episode. Bill Gross is a California real estate broker, not an attorney. California rules differ in places. This is general information, not legal advice; talk with a lawyer licensed in the state where the property is.

0:02 So estate planning most commonly we talk about dividing up the assets after somebody's deceased and that can be property my experience as a real estate broker primarily or liquid assets stocks bonds or relatively liquid assets financial assets and such but one of the most common ones and sticky ones is a business and when we talk about preparing an estate for after life or whatever that one of the issues is we have to cover both succession planning both for ownership who owns the assets it which can be fairly obvious sometimes and who's going to manage it. And so today I'm really excited to have an attorney Keith Phyllis who specializes in not just estate planning but specifically talking about succession planning. Keith, thanks for joining us today.

0:43 Yeah, thank you for having me. So I only get involved when the succession plan is zero didn't pass and the only rails go well I can't run this thing. And so there was no planning at all and we're we just end up having to almost I want to say fire sell the property or fire sold the business but maybe maintain it and then get it for sale. What is the proper approach to proper succession planning that includes both who gets the value as well as who manages the business going forward?

1:11 Yeah. Yeah. Absolutely. The management side is, you know, for those who haven't thought, you know, five steps ahead or in many cases five years ahead. It's really who's going to own the business and who's going to benefit from the wealth that's been generated through this business. But you really have to think about who's going to be running it because oftentimes, and I work with a lot of people in the real estate industry, oftentimes you'll think of that as, you know, we've got this, you know, this portfolio of companies, we've got a property management company, and we've got all these rental units. They might have as a going concern a lot of value. You could certainly sell them, and real estate is a very, you know, liquid asset in a lot of markets. But, you know, when you have something like that, like a portfolio of rental properties, you know, whether it's your portfolio of three families or you've got larger apartment buildings, some people have portfolios of single families, oftentimes there's more wealth that you can pull from that type of business by having somebody that's going to step in and continue running it. Keep it as an ongoing concern. You know, and oftentimes business owners have actually gone through the efforts to make sure that these types of businesses are able to generate profit year-over-year. So really, you know, the difference is the management. You know, you need to have an idea there. You know, we're recording this the day after the Super Bowl and regardless who you voted for, rooted for, there's an estate planning aspect to that, which is the former owner of the Seahawk Seahawks passed away and he was a great manager. He helped build Microsoft famously. And the way his family structure ends up there's nobody really who wants to continue to own and run the business in the way that he did very hands-on with a very clear as concept and yet they had a temporary management setup where I think it's the sister if I remember right is running it now and then preparing it for sale and gee they won the Super Bowl what a great way to prepare to sell an asset so I

3:14 Guess the concept must be there's somebody who has to step in at least temporarily is that often a family member who maybe doesn't want to do this for the rest of their more commonly a professional you bring in from outside. Who are the what are the options when you deal with that temporary status before you decide we're going to do it full-time?

3:31 Yeah, for organizations that are that large, you do have those different tiers of management hierarchy in place. So you're really just removing, you know, typically the top level of decision-m authority, which in a business, you know, like an NFL franchise, that top level, they're not they're not calling plays, they're not running training, they're not managing facilities, but there's a lot of damage that can be done if they are making the big ticket decisions and they are out of their depth. So often times you know you really look at what size the organization is and determine what level of management structure you need built in place and if there is no existing management structure you need to build that out

4:15 Or you know oftentimes we have a lot of people that you know as you mentioned there with the Seahawks you have a family member step in sometimes it's you know the you know the husband or the wife passes away and their spouse steps in. Sometimes the kids you know will step up into that role. You know, oftentimes people just will leave it to the heirs. You know, if you if you pass away and you leave you know, your entire business to your daughter, well, she owns the business now and she has to make all the decisions.

4:46 But, you know, really it's about building that management hierarchy and making sure you know who's going to be making those decisions, you know, the day you can no longer make them. And you know, oftentimes we do have people that do get their children into their business and that's usually, you know, the era parent of their business. But it's, you know, you also have to take into account those who aren't related. You know, if you've had somebody work, you know, for you, working with you for 20 years, they might not like that, you know, you know, an heir that has not stepped foot in the business before

5:22 Is now their boss. Some of these things look more difficult than they are to use the football case because it's such an easy one to look at. It's one thing to have somebody step in decide, you know, do we fire the coach or keep the coach? Do we pay this contract this guy more instead of 20 million a year, 25 million? Those are relatively small decisions. You need professionals to do it well. I think anybody can do it poorly or do it average. But there's major decisions like capital, you know, capital improvements. And you know, to use the example of the NFL, you'd be buying a new stadium and sometimes it's not just a stadium, but it's a whole complex and somebody who's not maybe at the top of their game making those decisions or not making those decisions can affect the football team. And I imagine the same true in the business that if they're not, especially now we are with AI and with so many you know onshoring versus offshoring of manufacturing. I imagine that businesses in many cases have major capital decisions to make that maybe even the founder was stressing over that now somebody who's not as involved in the business just may not be equipped to make the decision.

6:21 Yeah. Yeah. You and know and it's sometimes it's you know the decisions and the major decisions and there's the terms you know a new stadium if you know if you or I stepped into that role and we had to make that decision I'm comfortable that you know with enough reason and enough you know thinking through the problems that are coming you [snorts] know two years three five years down the road we could come to the same decision but that doesn't mean we're going to get the same terms you know a lot of NFL franchises when they build stadiums when they, you know, some of them will move cities. They usually negotiate, you know, big incentive package from, if they're moving cities, they'll get a great incentive package from the new city. Sometimes they spent decades working on, you know, the terms of those types of deals, you know, the lenders that they've been working with for decades. You know, trust me, if anybody offered me the Seahawks tomorrow, I'd take it. But it's you know I can't guarantee that I would come to the same terms that you know the late owner would have. And part of it is really you know I mean bringing you into that you know you certainly I'm sure would prefer to have a you know a two-year runway, five year one runway 10 year really see what deals are in process so that you know when you or I have to step into that role we're getting the best deal we can.

7:42 Well, and in a you know, even a what you might call a small business or a mid-size company where you have maybe 100 2005 employees. I had a mentor who had a manufacturing company of electronics and he had like four facilities in one city and another one in a neighboring city. And to your point, you know, he knew the city council. He knew, you know, what the city wanted. He knew what they would give him as far as, you know, permits and changes and, you know, for the good of the city, too. I mean he was there when it was smaller and helped it grow and employed a lot of the people there. So it wasn't just like he had some sort of crooked relationship. He was part of you know helping that city grow into an economic power and you know the son just doesn't have those personal relationships. He doesn't have they may call him but he doesn't have the years of good judgment and understanding and all and even a professional from the outside knew that business just may not have the same savvy. So I imagine really it's a challenge to you know you can pick a professional a great you know professional fiduciary or maybe great you know CEO temporary CEO or new CEO but the problem is going to be do they have the same you know resources that the deed had and in many cases the answer is probably going to be no and I would imagine a lot of the heirs are going to say well by default no we just want to sell and get our cash we don't want to sit around and watch this thing deteriorate so part of it is I imagine you know you make these decisions but I imagine often times there's let's just say input from the peanut gallery after you've done your work.

9:12 Yeah. Yeah. No, and you're going to run into that, you know, virtually with every succession plan is, you know, who what are the opinions going to be? Not, you know, not just, you know, the peanut gallery, the people outside that, you know, are looking and saying, well, you know, did they monetize the business, right? Did they take care to ensure that, you know, this legacy that was built will last? But even internally, you're going to get that. You might have somebody who's, you know, who's working the front desk that might have specific opinions and you know the, you know, you get that kind of outside peanut gallery commentary that, you know, it does affect you mindset wise. But, you know, if you start losing the faith of people that are inside the business that might be helping you run it, even if it is a small business, you know, unless it's a if it's purely a sole proprietor operation where it's a oneperson show that has you have to deal with that a little bit differently. But if you've got employees, they're going to have opinions, too. And so, you don't you don't just owe it to the estate to maximize value. You also owe it to those individuals to make sure that you know that you their service to the company over the years is respected as well. And oftentimes I do find that you know in a lot of cases think specifically of a client that you know he would develop insurance you know brokerages and then ultimately sell them. When he'd do that, he'd have conversations with the full team. He said, "I don't plan to, you know, pass this down to my children. The succession plan is I'm to sell the brokerage and, you know, I'm going to negotiate that you know the as part of the economics that are worked out, you will always have a role here. I might not be sitting there, but I want to take care of you." And a lot of people do end up in especially in small businesses they have that sense of loyalty to their team members and

11:16 That's you know that particular client also went a step further and took part of the proceeds and put it into a trust of which the you know some of the employees were as long as they've been with the company you know so long they would actually from that. So there was an economic component too like you might see with larger businesses that'll give equity or options. Another famous case here in LA is the Lakers where the owner, Jerry Buss, longtime successful owner, real estate developer, passed and has, I think, four children that have an interest in, four heirs. And the problem there is that no matter who would want to take over, there's a taxification, right? Somewhere along the line, they had to come up with, if you have a, you know, billion dollar company, hundreds of millions of dollars of taxes. I think that the Lakers were valued at $5 billion. So, it's about a billion dollars of taxes or some ridiculous number that's beyond my pay grade. So, I imagine that, you know, at some point you have to plan ahead for those taxes. Yet, the challenge is I'm sure you're aware that the numbers change, right? The laws have changed for good, for bad, for good, for bad. But even if it's for good, that just changes your whole strategy. So, talk a little bit and I know you talk about a five-year horizon. How do you talk about a fivey year horizon when the tax laws have literally changed seems like about every four years?

12:33 Yeah. Well, the way you would approach that might be giving your heirs liquidity, you know, availability. You know, you might know, well, I'd like to have a plan in place. Here are, you know, here are lenders that I work with that I've got a relationship with. You know I need to restructure my debt or just you know the first time I put the debt in place structure it so that the shares can be pledged because obviously a lender is not going to lend a billion dollars to you know to each of these heirs without having security but if you've got state tax bill coming due and let's say you know state tax neutral you know at the federal level let's say it's 40% you know get rid of the credit if it's 40% you're going to be expected to come up with that, you know, nine months down the road. You know, you barely finish grieving and then now you've got to pay this huge bill. You don't want to have to have a fire sale, you know, on a franchise. You'd rather take your time if you don't intend to step into business or own the business long term. But if you can access that liquidity through debt, then that'll put you in a position where you can pay these taxes and then off of the future profits or you know future gain from a sale, you can pay back that line. But if you don't have those relationships and you haven't been involved with the business, that might be a daunting thing to go to lenders as you know the as the former owner. You know, if you're setting your family or your heirs up to be in a position, tackle that.

14:09 They need to have those relationships. And that's part of kind of like the five-year plan where in that five-year period, you have, you know, you prepare the future owners, you prepare the future managers of the business, and all of your different vendors, contacts, business relationships. They all need to be prepared for this move, too. Certainly, you don't want to broadcast, you know, that, you know, if there's some sort of health condition or there's something that might shake confidence in the business, but there are other ways to put, you know, your family and your managers and everybody else that you see on day-to-day basis in touch with these different contacts you have and just let them know you rely on them. And you want your family, your managers, your contacts to be able to rely on them as well. And you know set that relationship up so that when it's needed it can be accessed and I mean you do that in virtually every industry you know everybody who's been a business owner knows it's about the relationship you have

15:07 And it's about the trust you build over time you know you need to apply that in the same way to putting those that'll take over for you in the right position to access those relationships

15:20 And again using a sports because it's just so you know in the news and easy to the Lakers and it seems like other teams, the Yankees, another one where they brought in like a strong minority partner, you know, and to use your five-year plan like four years ago, somebody who would be suitable to take over but not push out the family members and leave the family members as minority owners, maybe leave the family members as the figurehead for a period of time. That's what's happened, I think, in New York and for sure the Lakers, that's exactly what's happening there. Is that same structure available for you know manufacturing businesses or other large you know non-sports businesses or that just is that unique because of the celebrity staffs of sports owners. So it is it is something you can do and oftentimes people will do that where they'll start offering equity pieces to you know partners or co-owners or even you know have form a joint venture and that way they can make sure that there is somebody in there that has that vested interest that is looking out for the long-term viability of the business and your family still maintains you know access to that accumulated wealth. It's even more common when the family members don't want to be involved in the business long term. They want the wealth like you built that during your life and you know I won't be the first person to say it and I won't be the last but as a tax attorney like don't pay more taxes than you have to do your planning.

16:46 But you know your family wants to access that wealth and they want to benefit from that. You need to have a good plan and if that involves bringing in a partner you do that. I see that very often on construction, you know, companies where Makes sense. You know, you'll have you'll have a contractor that's been a contractor his whole life

17:05 Says, "I don't want I don't want my, you know, I don't want my spouse to have to, you know, work in the work in this industry. I don't want my children I want my children to go sit behind a desk where their hands don't, you know, don't get cut up by concrete every day, you know, where they're not running out to job sites to turn off water and put out fires all hours of the night. They want something different for their family, but they've got, you know, a loyal employee or a loyal friend that's been in the industry, you know, that knows how to run those types of operations and they'll bring them in. And it's not an immediate transition of move all the equity over. There might be a buy sell agreement in place. And that is, you know, truly the form of business assession isn't always I'm going to pass the equity to my family. Sometimes it's I'm gonna I'm gonna, you know, line up a sale. Could be a buy sell. You can, you know, pull equity out of it through debt and just, you know, fully integrate your family into it. But there's no right or wrong way to get somebody, you know, into to keep running the business or do a full exit. But if you're going to build this wealth up, you know, find the best way to preserve it for your particular family, your particular business.

18:20 One of the topics I know you talk about is state, right? There's the federal and the laws go up and down and there's changes and that gets a lot of attention, but in many cases the state taxes can be can be variable based on your strategy. Now, I'm in California where it's probably more common for companies to be California only because if they're multiple states, they're typically going to incorporate another state. Just avoid the whole California thing. I know that you're based in the East Coast. Talk a little bit about the issues regarding state estate plan taxing and companies being taxed at the state level.

18:55 Yeah, absolutely. So, we I run into this very like very frequently. We've got a lot of clients that, you know, the term we use is snowbird. They live in New England during the summer and then they live in Florida during the winter. But as the years go on, they decide maybe I want to spend more time in Florida. Maybe I want to establish domicile in Florida for income state purposes. Well, if you are a developer and you own a bunch of land in Rhode Island, for example, but you live in Florida, well, when you pass away, that land located in Rhode Island, it's going through your estate. It is still going to be taxed in Rhode Island. Even if you live in Florida, but you know, there are certain restrictions on that. Real estate and we'll stick with Rhode Island for now. Real estate in Rhode Island that's located in Rhode Island. That's the site is it's going to be subject to state estate taxes there. Personal property, however, so that could be everything from desks, chairs, cars, or it could be intangible, you know, like you know, stock in a company, contracts, only the person property that's located in the state is subject to that estate tax. So, you know, oftentimes you can put a plan in place. You we do this for our developer and real estate asset owner clients all the time. You put together a trust or LLC corporation structure that allows you to either remove the whole asset from your state or convert the type of asset into an asset that's not taxable. So, for example, if you have an LLC in Rhode Island that's a you know, a pass through entity, you could convert that into a Ccorporation for tax purposes and then have those Ccorporation shares be intangible and the value of those shares is not going to be captured. You know, there are there's a, you know, a lot of intricacies that go into navigating the different states. But, you know, it's something that I do see other people miss that they just don't

20:57 Think about is how do each of these different states define, you know, your taxable estate. And so, you know, kind of getting at where's the liquidity event when, you know, when how's the family going to be able to afford the taxes? If it sounds bad paying 40% of the value when you don't have a liquidity event, you know, tack on, you know, depending on the state, you know, four to 16% on top of that,

21:22 Like California. Yeah. Yeah. Nobody likes when they get that California tax bill. Nobody likes that. That's always that's always a tough one to say, I didn't know I had to pay that. Well, yeah. Welcome to California. It's why the weather's so good because we have to pay for the weather, I guess. Something like that.

21:39 And you also, well, and then in states like, you know, you might even have a tax cliff where once you hit there, you know, they'll a lot of states that do have a state tax, they have an exemption or an exempt amount. Rhode Island, it's one and a half million. In Massachusetts, they just raised two million. But in some states, you might have a cliff where this you go $1 over that amount and all of it becomes tax at which point like really that last dollar is costing a lot,

22:06 Right? And I guess it also affects different strategies on having multiple trusts. Sometimes you have a family with different interests and different purposes. And so you to make sure each trust I guess hits below those limits and those affected states. I know we're doing a very intricate estate plan with one of our clients now. And you know they're trying to be mindful of well you know for now the exemption is higher but it could go down. So we have to think about you know this property is more than the exemption amount. So it's one of those things where they're very complicated. That's why you guys got paid a lot of money to think through all these complications.

22:36 Yeah. Well, and oftentimes when you have those, you know, those complications you're navigating, I've seen a, you know, a resurgence of using trust protectors.

22:46 So, which is it's a concept that you used to only see in asset protection trusts where people would make plans to set aside money that they can't access. But on a rainy day, there's this trust protector that can amend the trust and add beneficiaries. And so if you need to access it, that's, you know, permissible in many states. Now, I see that from a tax standpoint, too, where people want to get assets out of their taxable estate while the exemption is as high as it is. And with the one big beautiful bill that, you know, that passed mid year last year, we saw that, you know, the federal exemption, you know, the federal unified credit was set at 15 million adjusted for inflation and became permanent. You know, they historically would have sunsets, you know, every, you know, every five years, every 10 years, you know, and so on. What's permanent? Well, if you gift $15 million out of your estate and then the exemption, you know, that the and with the next administration or the one after that drops to 10 million, you don't have to go back retroactively and pay taxes on that. You got the benefit of the higher credit. And so I see a lot of people that are looking to get assets out of their estate just to hedge against any changes. If it keeps going up, they can always give more. But, you know, if you have a an asset that you know is going to appreciate a lot, you can move it out of your taxable estate. You know, if you've got a construction business, you can move you $15 million worth of value out of that business. And then if it ends up going up to being worth,

24:17 You know, 30 million, 40 million, it's already outside your taxable estate. You're still drawing paychecks off of it working there, but a lot of people are doing that, but because of the uncertainty about whether or not they might need to access that capital,

24:30 Right, they will put a trust protector in place. In particular, I think that works for real estate that which you might I mean, I guess everything's different, but in California, our real estate value is mostly the appreciation over time. And so, if you can get it out now, yeah, it might double or triple down the road, but it's already out of the estate. So you're you get the benefit of that kind of t I won't say tax free but tax deferred or you know outside of the estate limitations. And so that's why in setting up some of these complicated trusts I see the one thing they want to move out the real estate when they can because you know you can't you can't it's not going to go down in value most likely it's probably only going to go up and whereas other assets aren't as likely to go up at the same rate as a general rule. Yeah. Well,

25:14 I was I was just going to say with real estate, there's also the added benefit of, you know, with that appreciation in value or new income coming off of it. If you have an estate of $30 million and let's say you know, you're a single parent, $30 million, so you can't double up with your spouse. If you put $15 million worth of the business out, but you structure it as an intentionally defective grant or trust, the value is out of your estate, but the income taxes as that business keeps generating income. Those taxes could be paid by you out of the money you kept in your estate. And so you're spending down your taxable estate while growing, you know, their estates. And so it's a it's a pretty useful set of, you know, book of tricks that we have with trusts to really get the benefit of a lot of tax, you know, tax law.

26:05 I wouldn't call them because they were intended, but you know, there's gaps. I, you know, I was invited in I have a clients in the state, a $40 million estate, and they have about half real estate and half stocks and bonds. And so I was invited by the fiduciary into kind of the tax planning and estate planning meetings with the tax attorney and this and the various attorneys of all these trusts. And you know in my mind I'm calculating the expense of these legal fees, right? And the and the I guess CPA. I mean you know you're talking about tens of thousands of dollars to put together the time to review these things. But as he explained that particular gimmick of having taking out the income, leaving the taxes against the part that's in the estate over time, you know, they save he had one strategy save like $5 million. Well, that paid for everybody and the food at the meeting. So that's and the rent. I mean, that was a that was a good day. I see that sometimes people bo at, you know, the incredible expense that attorneys can cost, a great device can cost, but the purpose of that is to get the incredible benefit of people really know these tax laws and these tools.

27:12 Yeah. No. And I and I often tell, you know, clients and contacts that I'm a I say, I'm a tax attorney by trade. Every attorney gets asked, "What do you specialize in? What are you an expert in? What do you do?" I say, "I'm a tax attorney by trade. I started off in tax and it's still the core of my practice because tax touches everything

27:31 And with an added benefit. It's one of very few areas of law where you can virtually always quantify the value that you're

27:39 Yes. Yes. You just as you put up the you know the math it's all equations. If we structure it this way and this number continues to go up here and we're going to keep these assets, you know, in your taxable estate, so the basis steps up, then after all of that math is done, assuming these variables, you know, you are going to save $5 million

28:04 In that meeting, six. In that meeting, I met the attorney. He's a nice enough guy. He looks nice enough. He dresses nice enough, you know, nice law firm. They all sound, you know, very impressive address, blah. But he worked through those numbers and it was kind of like an engineer talking about some sort of you know physics equation at the end and we'll say $5 million. I'm like did he just say $5 million? Like that's a lot of money that if he just didn't and in this case the deedent he actually had an estate plan. He never executed it. So he really was in testate. And so here we're after the fact trying to figure out what to do with everything that there's still some opportunities to save a lot of money with the right advice and with the right tactics.

28:43 Yeah. Yeah. And I'll say it again. I would never advocate for anybody to pay more taxes than they legally have to, right? And the benefit of the estate and gift tax, you know, structure in the US is there are a lot of tricks in the bag that they're, you know, it's a feature of the system. It's not a bug. It's not an exception. It's not a carve out that somebody didn't notice when they were passing a bill through Congress. These are all features of the system. The laws are set up the way they are. And it and it doesn't just stay in the state and tax realm. You know, we have also, you know, just your general you know, calculation of gain where you've got basis and you know, and then of course the income and the difference between what you received and what you paid and put into that asset. That's your profit. You're getting taxed on that. Well, in the estate tax context, when you pass away, the rule is anything going through your taxable estate, that basis is going to step up to fair market value as of your date of death. So, you know, there is some out there to say, you know, like with that client, you said it's got half real estate, half of it's in securities, stocks, and bonds. Well, we want to keep some of that real estate in your taxable estate because if you if you bought it and built on it and you put a $100,000 into something that's worth a million dollars, the second it goes through your taxable estate, somebody sell for a million dollars, there's no income tax on that.

30:08 There's no gain. Yeah. Well, and I think, you know, sometimes people think of these as gimmicks or tricks. The reality is I think our country was founded with these principles. I know George Washington famously fought for bankruptcy law because he had seen DTOR's prisons in Europe and how detrime detrimental they were not just to the individual but to society as a whole to give people a chance to start over and trust being a way to avoid taxes. I mean we fought a revolutionary war to avoid paying taxes. So it's not surprising that we would as a country I think pre just be predisposed and I think oftentimes people feel embarrassed or some sort of stigma but the reality is these laws were written they you know Congress has attorneys and they have experts in this field and they wrote them for that way and those are the rules of the game and just like in a sport you know if you're allowed to tiptoe along the sideline in football you should be able to tiptoe along the line on tax as long as you follow the law. I'm not talking about doing anything illegal, but I think the ethics are that you should, like you say, why pay more taxes than the law requires you to.

31:08 Yeah. Yeah. No, and that's you know as much you know jurisprudence as we have on taxes and as much as it's baked into the fabric of the country it's really something that you know there were ages where people you know prided themselves on how much they had to pay you know in taxes you know back when the marginal tax rate had the highest rate you know 70s 80 90% well it was a it was a social status to say I had to pay this amount Now the social status is using my expertise, my advisors, and my planning.

31:46 How do I shave it down to pay as little as I legally have to, right? And that's and there's nothing wrong with that. It's really, you know, it's really how the system is set up currently and that's, you know, a function of our country as a society. Now there is a line that some of your I won't say colleagues but people in your practice in your industry cross and u sometimes inadvertently right you make decisions kind of assessing what you think with your best guess what the IRS is going to rule or the state's going to rule and there's a certain amount of discretion on those decisions and that's inadvertent and then there's other things that are clearly deceptive that people do and advertise And it's very it's very enticing to pay no taxes for using some sort of tax gimmick. So, you know, what are common lines that you see crossed that you would tell somebody, you know, take this opportunity now to say you should probably double check if they're saying this or if it looks like that, this is something you should avoid.

32:50 Yeah. Yeah. I think one of the most common things that you will see is people coming in and saying, "Well, I wish I had done X, Y, and Z three years ago. Can we just paper that over now and then I'll go amend my tax returns?" And that's something that, you know, you're asking to get audited. Like if you know people don't I guess the average person doesn't take into account that there's a large amount of information that's gone to the IRS there's a large amount of information that can be derived from your bank statements and if the IRS asks your bank for copies of your bank statements they are not going to fight the IRS in court for you

33:31 Right it's you know a lot of times that there's such a rich history of information that can be pulled right from you know from these records the second would be cutting the corners on how transactions or how documentation is structured. You know there's a concepts in tax law about form over substance or substance over form. So, form over substance. If I write a document that says purchase and sale agreement and then right at the top, that's the title. That you know, we have that on every page in the footer. And then you say, well, actually, it wasn't really a purchase and sale agreement. It was a lo it was a lease on for tax purposes. I'm still going to carry this asset on my books and that is a lease and not a capital event. And so, I don't have to recognize all the income right now. I'm going to recognize it over the next 10 years as they're paying me installment payments. Well, if the documents written to say you sold it, the IRS is going to say form over substance. Even if they're paying you over the next 10 years, you that your agreement said that you sold it. The opposite side of that coin is substance over form. If you write a document that says purchase and sale agreement, but then structure it where it's a complex leveraged p purchase of an act, you know, an asset and you know, you don't actually take title for 10 or 15 years until all of the, you know, all the lease payments are made and then there's a big balloon payment.

35:01 Well, the IRS can come in and say, "We understand that you wrote a document that said it was a purchase because you wanted to accelerate that gain right now, but we think based off of this structure that there it's a lease with a buyout, you know, purchase of the asset, a purchase option at the end of the lease." And they can look through the terms and say, "Here are the terms that line up with this being more like a lease or, you know, like a finance purchase." are going the other direction. But, you know, there's a few doctrines that the IRS will look to. So, you know, what you put on your tax return and what you claim is going to be actually the you the correct structure of the transaction. The IRS isn't bound by that. And so, there's other key details that you want to make sure like the way you recognize things for tax purposes is always in line with that. And that's why we get CPAs involved. You know, we want to make sure that every client who has a complex tax strategy, their accountants are involved every step of the way. And so for reporting purposes, they understand what they're reporting.

36:06 Well, again, I think the thing that I came away with when I was for the first time really involved in the meeting room over all these plans was it's kind of like big game hunting tax planning as opposed because then normally and it's definitely worth talking to experts. Keith Phillis, your partner at Daryl Everett. And I have on your we have here the page. Oops, I got the wrong page up there. Your company website is dary.com and if you hit if you click on the team members, you'll find his information and then down below we have your contact information if you want to get a hold of him personally, his email address and the office phone number as well as the website. Thank you so much for sharing with us. I think really obviously this is very intricate you know topics but I imagine they're also very by personal situation and so if somebody had questions about this applying to them what's the best next step for them?

37:00 I would invite them to either send me an email at the email address on the screen or give me a call at the office if I'm not readily available you members of my team can put you in touch with me. Oftentimes the first the best first step is just making the call, sending the email, and having a conversation. Because oftentimes that first conversation sparks new ideas and helps things kind of fall in place in your mind.

37:27 Well, look, I appreciate personally the chance to work with you again and get some more information as well as to share you with our platform of people across the country, real estate agents and attorneys trying to help people, you know, keep their wealth and pass it on to the next generation as effectually as poss as efficiently as possible. So, thank you so much for joining us this week on Estate Planning Weekly.

37:45 Yeah, thank you for having me, Bill. And for the rest of you, this is The Estate Planning Podcast. We get together every week and issue a new episode, most commonly with estate planning attorneys, sometimes CPAs or related vendors, to help us learn how to more effectively serve our clients on protecting their wealth and how we can help them in that process. If I can help, please put a comment here, reply, email, put a comment in the in the social media you're watching this at or reach out. I'm at Bill Gross Probate on social media. And as always, make today your best day

More The Estate Planning Podcast episodes

Related

Educational media, not legal advice. Guest views are their own. Hosted by Bill Gross, The LA Probate Expert, a licensed California real estate broker (DRE #01022275) brokered by eXp Realty of California, Inc. (DRE #01878277). Bill is not an attorney and is not a Probate Referee.

Schedule Consultation