Legacies Earned and Protected, with Attorney Zachary Whitman
The Estate Planning Podcast · · Guest: Zachary Whitman, Elysium Law APC
Episode summary
Bill Gross talks with Zachary Whitman of Elysium Law, a California firm he runs with his wife Natalie. She handles the transactional side, estate planning and routine probate and trust administration, while Zach's practice is now more than 95% litigation. That lets a trust administration that turns into litigation stay inside the same firm.
Zach says there is no avoiding litigation, only mitigating it, and the biggest decision in an estate plan is who you name as successor trustee. Naming the oldest child by default can lead to a fight if that person is not financially literate or has conflict with siblings; sometimes a middle child or a professional fiduciary is the better choice.
The second big mistake is not funding the trust. Zach says online platforms just hand over a document, and the only asset an attorney can directly control is real property, by having the client sign a deed at the signing. In California, an 850 petition, often called a Heggstad petition, can move an asset into a trust without a full probate, but contested ones are common and expensive.
Zach also recommends reviewing documents every three to four years and after births, deaths and marriages, especially older trusts with mandatory A-B-C splits written when the federal estate tax threshold was about a million dollars. He closes with advice for heirs: if an administration shows no progress at six months, it is probably appropriate to file.
Key points
- An estate plan cannot prevent litigation, but a careful plan can reduce it.
- Choose a successor trustee for ability and family dynamics, not birth order.
- A trust you don't fund doesn't avoid probate; sign the deed when you sign the trust.
- Contested Heggstad (850) petitions can cost far more than funding the trust correctly in the first place.
- Review your documents every three to four years and after major life events.
Questions answered in this episode
Does having a trust prevent litigation?
No. Zachary Whitman says if somebody wants to cause a fuss they will; there is no avoiding litigation, only mitigating it with a document that holds up to scrutiny. Watch at 3:13
What is the most common estate planning mistake that leads to litigation?
Zach says it is the choice of successor trustee. Someone with their own finances in a mess, or who is not financially literate or is in conflict with siblings, is likely to lead to litigation. Watch at 6:18
Should the oldest child always be the successor trustee?
Not necessarily. Zach says the oldest child is the customary default, but a middle child who has always brokered between siblings, or a professional fiduciary, may be more appropriate. Watch at 7:52
Why do so many trusts go unfunded?
Zach says online platforms give you a document but don't fund it for you. An attorney can have you sign and record a deed for real property, but bank and brokerage accounts need follow-up. Watch at 12:21
What is a Heggstad petition?
In California, a petition under Probate Code section 850, often called a Heggstad petition, can confirm an asset belongs in the trust without a full probate. Zach says opposed petitions are common and can be expensive. Watch at 16:44
How often should I update my estate plan?
Zach suggests a review every three to four years and after births, deaths and marriages. Older trusts with mandatory A-B-C splits, drafted when the federal estate tax threshold was about a million dollars, are a common update. Watch at 27:01
Transcript
Transcript generated from YouTube's automatic captions for this episode and lightly cleaned (filler words and repeated words removed, names and web addresses corrected; phone numbers and email addresses read on air are replaced with a placeholder; [unclear] marks words the captions did not capture). It may still contain transcription errors, and speaker labels are not included. Timestamps link to that point in the video, which is the authoritative record.
0:03 Welcome to the Estate Planning Podcast. I'm Bill Gross at Bill Gross probate on social media. We get together every week and issue a new episode with leaders in the estate planning field. Typically attorneys, also some vendors. Today we're I'm really excited to have somebody who I've known when he was at one of the biggest firms in San Diego County and now has actually gone off and I don't know start his own firm, started a firm, part of founding a firm. He'll give us the details on it. Zachary Whitman from San Diego County. Thanks so much for joining us, Zach. Thanks, Bill. Appreciate it. So, founder, partner, sole proprietor. What's the deal? Alisium Law, tell us about the background. Yeah, so it's a firm ran and founded by my wife and I. So, my wife is a fellow attorney, estate planning attorney. The stars just kind of align and it was the right time for us to join forces and open our own practice. So, we launched Alisium in kind of the fall of 2024. So we're going into kind of our second half of our first year as a as a new firm but an existing business. So I got the junior partner of the two. It sounds like Yeah, she's in charge. That's for sure. And I know you do estate planning and trust estate administration as well as probate litigation. Kind of describe the percentages of business. How much is estate planning? I know you have a different approach to it than some other firms do. That's why you started this.
1:21 So give me an idea of the practice as a whole and what you do individually. Yeah. So, my wife Natalie, she handles primarily the transactional side. So, she does a majority of all of our estate planning where she's creating and implementing the estate plans, the routine administration. So, your probate administrations, your trust administrations, and then any kind of overlapping business law. She handles primarily all that. I'm at this point 95% plus litigation. So I do the other side of the coin where she's doing the transactional side, I'm doing the litigation side and it allows us to do kind of full service representation. So if a trust administration ends up passing into litigation, it stays within the same firm. We don't have to hand it to somebody else. Just kind of goes down the hallway. So yeah, it's I mean we're primarily a litigation firm. I think it's a very booming business right now, the probate litigation, but she's significantly busy as well. So maybe 6040 litigation, transactional, but we're doing we're doing a lot of estate plans. We're doing it a little bit different, too. So, we're kind of younger professionals in this line of work and we're bringing a different approach to estate planning where we're really focused on the now instead of too worried about the future and avoiding some unnecessary pitfalls within the estate planning world where families and friends get into overbearing trusts that they don't need to be in and helping avoid litigation. So, it's really a litigation avoidance mindset to steer our clients into making really wise decisions to avoid some of the pitfalls that we typically see in this line of work. So, as a real estate agent, I often deal with probate attorneys who don't do probate litigation. I often deal with estate planners who don't do estate litigation.
3:13 If they're sole proprietor, that means that by definition, you're going to somebody entirely out. And I do know a few like you that not only are partnered with the other half, but the other half is their life partner as well. So, it seems to make a lot of sense to have those. And it gives me the comfort to know that if there's a problem, you'll stand up to it. Most people have the misconception that well, I can avoid litigation if I have a trust or I can avoid litigation if I have an estate plan. And the answer is no. Actually, the more mighty probably more likely to have some litigation no matter what it is. Talk about that a little bit. That misconception and what are the most common types of litigation that you get involved with? Yeah, I mean there's no avoiding litigation, right? If somebody wants to cause a fuss, they're going to cause a fuss. There's just no stopping it. So, that's your professional legal op. Let's say that one more time because I can say it. Where what the hell do I know? There's no avoiding litigation, right? You a trust, there's no magic plan. There's no magic pill. There's no special forms that if somebody's intent on litigating, you can file lawsuit almost anywhere in California and file a lawsuit, right? Exactly. Yeah. If there's if there's a beneficiary that wants to cause havoc, they're going to cause havoc. And that's just that's just part of it. A trust goes a long way to helping guide the parameters of what we're dealing with, what assets we're navigating, and what the intended plan was. But there's no stopping a proper or self-represented individual from initiating litigation. It's that's kind of just the structure of our system.
4:42 Going back to the constitution, the founding of the country is really what we're built on. And so there's no real avoiding litigation. There's mitigating litigation. So that's our approach is to mitigate litigation. Create a document that's as bulletproof as possible. You dot your eyes, cross your tees to make sure your planning process is above board. The document holds up to scrutiny because that's really your duty as an estate planning attorney is to create a document that's going to control and be valid. There's hopefully 10 20 years before our documents are getting administered, but you're we're working today for a future administration. So, we need to make sure we're doing it properly to avoid litigation. And that's really how we structure our planning process. We're asking questions, right? We play devil's advocate with our clients. If they want to make a decision that we think is unwise, we're going to try to ask them poke holes in their logic of why you want to do that. And if they can't agree, then they get to have a conversation with me about what as a litigator why I would attack that or how it would be a poor decision within their estate plan. So, we're really trying to make sure we're not just typographical people. We're not just putting a document together. You're paying for a trust and an estate planning attorney to guide you through that planning process. And it's that's really where we really focus and prioritize. My father was an attorney and he used to say anybody can sue anybody for anything. Yeah. And there's enough money involved somebody will.
6:18 Yeah. So what so within the realm obviously that there's a lot of things in business one you know can be involved with and mitigate and owning a house and mitigate but within the realm of trust administration where you're trying to control the distribution of assets what are the most common mistakes you see made that get exploited by bad guys or if you're representing the potential beneficiary that you exploit of poorly drafted or improperly drafted trusts. Yeah. I mean, the probably the most common mistake and probably the biggest decision in your estate planning process is who you name as successor trustee. If you're picking a poor successor trustee that has their own personal finances in a mess, they've declared bankruptcy themselves. They're drug addicts, alcoholic, they're not wise people to manage money on somebody else's behalf. And that's probably the most common litigated element is the trustee is not being as forthcoming as possible or we don't trust them managing the funds so we want them removed and somebody else put in charge. It's probably the most common litigated element within this line of work. And probably the second most common is poorly funded trusts. Well, let's start let's start with the first one. Go a little deeper on that one because I'm in that world all the time. So the wrong successor trustee. So, the mistake made often is, well, I'm going to pick the oldest child because he's had the closest relationship with him or her. Maybe they're the most successful in their line of work.
7:52 So there's some defaults as to why you might pick that. What might the characteristics be of the right successor or the right process to determine a successor? Yeah, I mean it's really asking the questions of the relationships, the dynamics, how do they work within the family? Does it need to be a family member? There are professionals out there that do this for a living, professional fiduciaries. There's really a lot of questions to be asked about that individual. The standard customary is the oldest child or the oldest son is the one that's in charge. If they are not financially literate, they're not independently successful, they have animosity amongst the siblings, it's probably going to lead to some form of litigation. Whereas maybe the middle child that's always acted as the broker between the other children or the other siblings, maybe that's the more appropriate person to put in charge. It's ultimately going to cause grievances. I mean, there's always animosity towards your other sibling of why were you picked to be in charge? And that's always going to end up as some kind of element of disagreement of why did you pick this person? And they feel slighted. I should have been the one that's in charge of the trust. I'm not the name trustee of my dad's trust. And that could be a problem because my older brothers are in charge and we'll see. So there's always that stigma of I need to put the oldest in charge and that's often maybe not the right decision. If the kids are at each other's throats now, maybe this is time to put in a neutral that's just going to marshall the assets and everybody gets what they get is always a viable option.
9:37 As the oldest who went down that road twice. If I had, you know, a chance to I guess you always could decline, but you it's hard decline your parent when they ask you to do something. But I mean, it's a job. I mean, the reason why trustees get paid, the reason why the administrator in a probate has a right to charge statutory fees is because there's work involved. And I think that's the other part that like any other business, there's people who approach their work with a customer service attitude and solve problems and anticipate problems and do it and there's other people who begrudgingly fill out every piece of paper. Well, but you're getting paid to do it and that's the challenge there. The other question is when you have multiple choices in the family for a successor trustee what's your what you advise or is it again based on questions letting people know they are or are not the successor trustee or they are or not the second or third choice. How do you advise customers? Because I it seems to me that when they discover that upfront and they know that, yeah, maybe there's some resentment, but in general, but when they're surprised, it's kind of like, you know, the explosion's bigger when it's a tighter wrapped piece of dynamite. So, how do you advise customers on how to tell multiple, you know, siblings, you know, children, who the successor is and who is not?
10:58 Yeah, I mean, the terminology I like to put in front of the clients is this is your document. So it's really up to you of what you want to tell your family. You're might be changing this document many times over the course of the next 101 15 years. Maybe you're going to have a falling out with that child and then you've already set the threshold that they're going to be the ones in charge. It. I tend to think I don't encourage them to divulge all the information and say this is what my plans are. If you're going to disinherit somebody, you might want to give them a pretty good idea why they're getting disinherited or at least the attorney should document the file to make sure they know why they're getting disinherited because that can come as a surprise. But who's in charge? You probably want to if you're starting to fail in health as you get older, it maybe makes sense for them to know because they might need to assume that role during lifetime. And so it's really a case by case scenario, but a younger family in their 50s with kids in their teenage years, they don't need to tell the kids that you're going to be the one in charge because who knows what it'll be when you eventually get around to administering. So obviously a lot of questions, a lot of possibilities that need to be discussed in detail. You know, we hit over a couple of them on the first mistake, which is the successor trustee.
12:21 The second most common mistake you mentioned already was forgetting to fund the trust. I literally am the broker of record for a $40 million trust with $20 million worth of real estate. But I not a trust of an estate. It's a probate estate. They went to the estate planning attorney. They met the estate planning attorney numerous times. They wrote big checks for the estate planning advice. They got a great proposed document in a beautiful binder, but they never signed the document and never deed the property and put it into the binder, I.e. Didn't fund the trust. So, let's talk about common problems that prevent that and what are things you might do to help people avoid those mistakes. Well, I would say that the probably the biggest mistake is using a online platform, right? The legal zooms of the world, they don't do the effort to fund it for you. They just give you a document. There's a lot of estate planning attorneys that do the same type of approach. You don't meet with the attorney more than maybe once or you just trade some emails and they send you a document. If they if they're not giving you a good enough road map, you're probably not knowing you need to sign a quick claim and go record it with the county with your pecore and doing all the right steps. And so using a reputable good estate planning attorney that's going to take the time. Yes, it's going to cost a little bit more money, but it's better to do it intentionally and with a reputable attorney that you're going to get it done right than cutting corners.
13:49 And you can always find a drive down the highway, you'll find a post there on the side of the $500 trust. They're not going to do the effort to make sure it's funded. They're not going to walk you through making sure your bank accounts or your retirements get beneficiary designations. It's really that's a really important part of the process for the estate planning attorney. You're not done when the documents are signed. You have to get it funded. That's part of the responsibility of the attorney to help with that process. So now you say that and I agree 100% as a businessman, not as an attorney. I'm not in the bar association. I'm not a bar. I'm not an attorney. But as a businessman, the customer hired you to solve the problem. They didn't hire you for your legal advice and then them go about their job. And there are consultants that do that work. But I believe the customer's intention when they hire the attorney for estate planning is to solve the problem. The problem is not solved unless the estate plan is executed and the assets are funded in the plan. And to me, that's a minimum standard that I know is hard to live up to. Now you're taking on responsibility for your client's actions, which nobody none of us want to do that. Sometimes we have to push our clients and they're upset with us because we're being too pushy. We're being too much followup. But at the end of the day, that's what makes us effective and valuable to our customer.
15:11 Yeah. I mean, the only asset I can really control for my clients is the real property, right? I can have them sign a deed at the signing appointment. I can physically go record that. I can't go to your bank for you. I can't go to your brokerage accounts and change beneficiary designations. So, it is important that we follow up with that and do the duty to our clients. I'm not going to say it's malpractice, but it's as close as you probably want to get to not help get these trusts funded. It's that's you're giving them an empty document. You took their money. You might as well do it the all the way and get it done. I'll say it's bad business. As a business person, I would be a judgment on the legal side of it, but and whether it's malpractice or not, that's a legal answer. But in terms of business, you're not doing your job. You're not serving the customer. You're taking your check, you're getting paid, and the customer didn't receive the value they thought they did. And they won't discover it, unfortunately for five or 10 years. And it to not call them back and say, "Hey, by the way, I gave that to get signed, you know, a month ago. Where is it at?" To not follow up, you know, you'd follow up if they owed you the check. You'd follow up on their payment. You know, we all have different methods for following up and getting paid. We need to have one as well on completing those documents. And so, let's talk about what that looks like. You have a trust. Now, you've done the estate plan and maybe one piece of property is outside of that of multiple. Maybe it's another state. Maybe it's purchased after the estate plan and wasn't done in the trust. Talk about the litigation involved in that to try to get treated.
16:44 In California, we do have a process called petition. Heggstad petition. We have such procedure. Most states don't. Talk about though what kind of litigation might you see. Who's going to argue that? Who's going to who's going to make that difficult? Yeah, it's actually a pretty common occurrence is a in a opposed Heggstad petition. It's under the section 850 petition. So we use the phrase Heggstad refers to the estate of Heggstad, but it's fall. It's an 850 petition. A lot of states don't have it. They make you go through the probate and then you administer the pour-over will to put it into the trust. Heggstad, you get to kind of circumvent that process, which is nice. But there's always somebody that says, "Well, I he wanted they intended to keep it on me and that's was their plan." So that it's going to go outside of the trust to this person. And it gets all muddled and then you don't know what the true intentions were and it gets hostile and that's a good opportunity for some form of elder abuse or caregivers taking a property. It's a lot easier to kind of get it under the cloak of night when it's not already in the trust. I believe having interviewed attorneys in about 25 states so far, I don't believe there's anything like the HEX petition option in any other state. I think that's unique to California. There's other types of deeds we don't have, but in terms of the ability to go back in time and say that should have been the trust and we'll treat it that way. I think that's unique California and it's not inexpensive.
18:22 It's not simple. It can be done. It's a fix, but it's going to it's going to cost you I'll say this. You know that mistake to fix it costs more to getting you the right choice in the first place by like 10 times. Yeah, I mean it very well could. It's I mean estate plans are modestly priced, but a ongoing litigation can cost hundreds of thousands of dollars. Yeah. If it's opposed. I have a couple right now that are contested Heggstads or contested 850 petitions that were fighting over whether this should what was their intention to put it in the trust or not to put it in the trust and that's a that's a big fight and it can cause problems. I have a client who came to me and his father created a trust for the purpose of providing for his wife. I think it was like a remarage so it was like the next wife the first wife I think passed. Second wife. He wanted to try and he listed the assets and excluded two pieces of real property that today are worth, you know, if you were to sell them worth, you know, million, $2 million each, but he clearly left them out for the benefit of his son who would have through probate been the inheritor. Now, maybe he should have had a separate trust and named them. Okay, that's true. He didn't take that extra step, but the it looks like the wife sold the property on the basis they were in the trust and was able to kind of and now he has the son has a lawsuit claiming an 850 petition after the fact.
19:51 Looks like he won that and now they have to go back and claw back the property from the from the title company get money back or some sort of a claim. So these are very complicated issues that small little things you don't think about end up becoming major issues. So what else comes to mind as a major source of litigation? I can think of one or two, but you know, your practice quite different. What's one or two other things that you think of as regular sources of litigation problems? Yeah, I think right now we have a very big influx of conservatorship proceedings while the elder is still alive and they have estate planning documents, but Alzheimer's or dementia, cognitive decline is started, we get a lot of these after the holidays when we finally get around checking on family. We spend time with grandma and grandpa and realize they need some more help. And so we end up in conservatorships which are they're supposed to be the le the least restrictive option, right? The court's not supposed to grant a conservatorship if we have other resources, estate planning documents, wills, trust, powers of attorney. But if those are questionable documents, then we have a contested battle between brothers and sisters on who's going to be the decision maker for mom and dad. That's a hotly contested issue. And it can be very litigated over who's in charge and that's a big fight. If you are acting as trustee or power of attorney for mom and dad while they're living, your responsibility to account and inventory assets, your marshalling starts at that moment you take over, not when mom and dad die. And so then you end up with disagreements between siblings about whether you're appropriately spending on mom and dad's care. And that's a really uncomfortable conversation to have that I think you're overspending on food and care for mom so I'm inheriting less down the road. That's not a that's not a good position to put yourself into. But
21:53 Those are arguments that are made on a regular basis. I've seen living been in court. Sure, you've been part of this, but I've seen court arguments where the one child took mom to the doctor's appointment and they stopped at McDonald's and they turned the receipt for both of their hamburgers, fries, and Cokes and the attorneys arguing only moms is paid for and you're supposed to pay for your own. And like really, like, you know, but I mean, technically, I guess that's the law. Or depending on the circumstances, but those little fights, you think, well, what's the big deal? You're paying your attorney hundreds of dollars an hour to sit in court and discuss that. And then you have the courtappoint attorney. You got this attorney, that attorney. It's just amazing these fights. Have you I don't know if you followed the case with Jay Leno. Have you heard about this about Yeah. First off, I want to say I think he's one of the finest human beings in the world. I came to know him recently through a fundraiser. He does an amazing number of fundraiser comedy events where he headlines and he charges a fee and then he donates back the fee at the end of the night publicly and writes a check on top of it and because he has no kids and he wants to be active and recently I was at one where he like three days before fell down a hill and had a broken rib and an arm and a cast and his face. He still came to the event that we were a part of. Yeah. But it turns out for all the attorneys fees he must have spent his career. How much if you were to guess he must have made $100 million. So you know in attorney's fees along the way millions of dollars in attorney's fees.
23:25 Somehow his wife's medical advanced directives weren't set up properly so that he literally has a public case for guardian for conservatorship in order to provide certain medical decisions. What a tragedy that nobody took care of that along the way. How could that be? I mean the decisions of in lifetime decisions are probably the most uncomfortable conversation of the entire estate planning process. Yeah. What do you want to happen with your body? What do you want for artificial nutrition, hydration? Do you want to be cremated or buried? Those are the most uncomfortable conversations in the in the process. And so oftentimes people kind of shy away from them. They try to kind of rush over that element of the estate planning and it's as crucial as any part of it to make sure your documents are in order so your agents can take over. Your healthcare agent, your power attorney agent can take over. And a conservatorship process is not quick and easy. It's probably the most drastic thing a judge can do other than incarceration, right? They these judges are taking your constitutional civil liberties and giving them to somebody else. So they take it very serious and they as they should and as they should. I think we put them down because we make it sound so honorous. It should be honorous to take away somebody's rights like that. Yeah, it absolutely should. Especially if you're talking about memory care assisted living facilities. You're deciding where they're going to live, if they can leave that property or not. If it's a locked 24-hour facility, that's a it's essentially incarceration. And they if it's not in their best interest that they don't want it, they're entitled to council to advocate on their behalf as court-appointed attorneys. It's very difficult. Even when everybody gets along, it's still very difficult. And if you just make sure you do your documents, your estate planning documents properly, you nominate a conservator within your estate planning documents if necessary, it helps shortcut that and make the process
25:27 Easier and hopefully avoid it alto together. And I guess update the documents. You know, I recently had I happen to be Jewish and our synagogue is hosting an event, I came to find out, that includes an organization that deals with the unique religious obligations for religious Jewish people. And they're hosting our synagogue with Cedar Sinai and health screening and estate planning attorneys and so on. And I go, "Wow, I didn't know about this organization. They're going to be in my synagogue. I should show up." And they had a nice little, you know, downloadable document on, you know, what you should consider if you're religious, you know, as part of your, documents. Oh, okay. Look at this. I think, well, gee, we didn't do that. Wow, we didn't do that. Wow. I'm looking. And so I print this out. Here's my wife, and I say, look, honey, we're going to go to this event on Sunday, and we need to use the deadline to force us to turn it in. I'll do one, you do one, and let's get done by the week before, which was yesterday. Neither one of us have done it because it's so uncomfortable yet it's only important you know it's never a problem till it's a problem then it's a problem and I think it's one of those things that really evaluating your needs and getting it done properly and then probably updating it so let's talk a little bit kind of lastly you know I'm sure you've written some estate plans on that side of the of the firm or your prior that were done that are perfect but I imagine there's some that you did when you started that the laws have changed or the circumstances have changed so much that the estate plan really needs to be updated and hasn't been. Talk about how you address that problem or what you advise your clients.
27:01 Yeah, I mean the documents need to be looked at every couple years. Usually three to four years is a good opportunity to take a reassessment. The big life events, births, deaths, marriages are good times to take a look at what the plan is. The biggest thing we're updating right now is the tax planning mechanisms in these trusts. A trust drafted in 2001 2002 where the federal estate tax threshold was a million dollars are very restrictive. The mandatory bifurcation trusts, ABC trusts that have these very rigid rules on administration when the first spouse dies and it handcuffs the surviving spouse into what they can do and how they can live and it makes it more difficult. And with the federal estate tax threshold at where it is and no foreseeable change coming in the next couple years, these families of modest wealth one to $10 million do not need ultra restrictive estate plans. They don't need irrevocable planning. They don't need mandatory bifurcations. And we are updating that to make them a more modern document, a more current of a disclaimer or discretionary trust to allow for easier administration for the surviving spouse.
28:19 Maybe there's still a reason to keep it in the bifurcation, but let's make sure it's appropriate and not just because of a tax bill from 2001 that's not applicable today. We need to look at today's environment. We estate plan at our firm as if you're going to get in a car crash leaving our office. What are we going to do today? If you die today, what are we going to do? What do you want to happen? That's going to change. These are supposed to be living documents that adapt and develop with you. And so, if we're looking three to five, 10 years down the road, well, maybe your plan still works, maybe it doesn't. And it's a lot easier to amend a trust than it is to create a trust. And it's lower thresholds of capacity. It's a it's a much different process to amend a trust than to create one. So, it's better to get started early, get them in place, and then check on them. And if the if the federal state threshold drops down to a million dollars again, call in all of my clients. I go through my rolodex, make sure we touch base. What's your estate worth? What do we need to do? It's better to be, in my opinion, it's better to be reactive than proactive when you're talking about ultra overrestrictive decisions that are going to make it more difficult on the surviving spouse. And that's my biggest concern when we're planning is when the first spouse goes, what are we going to do? Second spouse goes, what are we going to do? And you don't want to make it so that the surviving spouse has restrictions on access to funds. They might need it for care and health. And so that's probably the biggest area we're looking to update right now for these estate plans from 20 years ago, but even estate plans from 5 10 years ago are very overbearing and unnecessary.
30:13 And so it's easier to just kind of clean them up, have them be more modern, have them be a wellthoughtout plan, and make sure you got you got what you want. And it's organized and good to go. On the litigation side for business development, you know, I know oftentimes people call me and say, "Hey, I need a attorney. You know, I have a argument in with you know, with my brother or whatever he and then you find out what it is that well, you know, he hasn't responded to in a timely manner or I haven't heard from him or I don't like what he's doing." and I try to explain to him that, you know, litigation is an expensive process. Now, it's one thing to hire an attorney and get consulted and get and pay for a couple hours and have them review documents and tell you what your rights are, what you're missing. It's another thing to expect that attorney without substantial assets on the line or money up front to actually litigate on your behalf. Talk a little bit about what's the what's the phone call look like to you from the inquiry to the actual trust litigation lawsuit or trust litigation client on your part? Yeah, I mean we always start with what's the issue? What are we what are we mad about? What do we think is inappropriate? If we don't have a strong enough claim for some for impropriety or in improper behavior, the gate stops there. But if there are unreasonable actions or we're concerned, well, then we got to look at what we're what we're really dealing with. Is it worth it? Right? Some families just want to watch the world burn. And I have clients that say I as long I'll take zero as long as my sister gets zero. And that's there's a world for that. It's not a pleasant world, but there's a world for that. But for mo most part, if you're spending money on an attorney, you want a return on your investment. So you need to be able to demonstrate that there's an asset worth going after. Most of the time, it's real property. That's the biggest asset 90 plus percent of the world will own is a real property. Has it been sold or can we put a Liz
32:15 Lis pendens on the property to stop a sale and making sure that we can recover at least enough to cover the attorney's fees or make you feel more comfortable with moving forward with the administration. But we it's kind of a global look at the situation. One, is it is it inappropriate behavior justifying continuing the conversation? And then is it is there enough worth it to get back what you want? And if it's if it's money you want to inherit, you want more inheritance, then we got to make sure there's assets that worth going after. If it's if it's just vindictiveness, then sure, we I'll take your money to keep litigating, but it's probably not in your best interest. And so and you and a lot of the courts, the probate courts are a little bit more cooperative. It's not as hostile of a court system as some of the other court systems, family laws, criminal. The judges are going to ask you, "What are you doing? Is this worth it? Why are you in my courtroom fighting over nothing? I've litigated over ladders. Was it appropriate?" Well, it was legally appropriate, but was it morally right? And that's ultimately what it comes down to.
33:35 I'm just curious. I don't know if you can answer this question, but it just it strikes me. What percentage of the phone calls you get there are the nature I'm mad at my brother who's the administrator of the trust end up in, you know, some sort of litigation or objections or at least a nasty letter from the attorney to get them into action. Is there a percentage that you know, track or is there a percentage of your mind that you that you of those? Is it 20 to one? Is it 10 to one? Is it 200 to1? What's the number look like? Yeah. Well, because you must get some amazing phone calls. We get We get the best stories. That's for sure. We I would I would record your calls and then make like a reality TV show or some of those situations. That's what my mom is put trying to put something together like that. She thinks that's a good idea. But yeah, it's probably five to one is a is the world of breaches of duties versus some form of other type of probate litigation. We get a lot of trust contests where we're invalidating the document, but probably five to one is financial grievances between siblings. And it's a great opportunity for early settlement, early resolution in my opinion, especially if there's trustee counsel and beneficiary counsel. It's our job to make sure we're guiding these clients appropriately to see if we can reach resolution. And if there's an opportunity to provide enough information and stop it at the front door, then that's great. And I think more attorneys should do that and take the opportunity for early resolution. But it's not always going to work. You're going to end up with a fight sometimes, more often than not. If there's if there's distrust, there's distrust. And there's really no coming back from distrust. And that's probably the cornerstone of most of my cases is distrust. Whether there's actually smoke behind the fire behind the smoke, it's to be seen.
35:29 But it's all founded in I don't trust what they're doing or what they're telling me. Let's do some exploratory. And then if we find the answer is it's above board, great. We can shut it down. But if there is concerns and we need to keep scrutinizing, then we can keep scrutinizing. The common case I get in probate, which I'm sure is similar in trust, is there's three heirs, three brothers, sisters, siblings. One lives in the house, claims to be the greatest caregiver in history of the world, dedicated his life to his surviving parent, and has lived there and either the administrator of the probate or they're named in the will to be the executive. And it's been a year and a half they haven't done anything. Now, in probate, I don't know the law, but from a business point of view, I can advise my client, listen, they're going to have to sell the property at some point. They're going to get charged back for fair market rent from the time they've had the property because they have not acted responsibly. And so, the sooner they sell, the cheaper for them. But they're not going to believe you when you tell them that. They're not going to believe me if I say that. They need an attorney to write a letter that convinces them and lays it out for them so they finally get into action or they need to see an actual document that's filed. And so I say you have to get an attorney to do that.
36:46 There's no there's no shortcut to that. And I would say about a third of the client, a third of the recipients get the letter and go, "You're right. We'll sell the property. The jig is up." But at least at least a third or twothirds can't they can't sell the house. They had no responsibility. They had no ability to budget. They've never been responsible for their lives. And it really requires, you know, hardcore litigation to at some point force them out. What's that look like in trust? Because you don't have the same kind of you don't have the standing yet, right? They don't h it's a longer distance to get to where the judge is going to hear you, I would think, in a trust case. What does that look like on a trust situation? Yeah. Yeah, if you I mean if you're a beneficiary of a trust and the admin the trustee is not administering it properly, you can bring a removal action to have them removed and put you in charge or so whoever the successor the and the document in charge to take over and at that point they can start marshalling the asset. I have a few right now where we're evicting a beneficiary from the property and they keep saying, "Well, you can't evict me. This is my house." Well, it's not your house. It's not. His mom's house. You just happen to live there and unfortunately you got to go. And so that's probably too common as a beneficiary that's effectively a squatter and wants to stay in the property and they think they're entitled to it because I've lived here for 40 years and well mom didn't give it to you. I'm sorry. It's this expectation of inheritance where I feel I'm owed something because that's what my mind says. Well, the document says something different. So, it's very similar process from a probate administration versus a trust administration. Except for a probate administration, you're already in the proceedings getting scrutinized by the court. I go back to Judge Kelly, who's one of our good longerving judges here in San Diego.
38:41 She's on the court of appeals now, but she taught me a good lesson early on in my career when I was I was slow playing at administration. I was keeping my client in the property and very intentionally and she removed my client as the administrator and said, "We don't rent property in probate. It's your job to marshall. That's what we're here to do. We're not watching properties. We're not waiting for the market. We're not trying to grow the estate. You are marshalling assets. If you're in a probate administration, you are marshalling that asset. And that's why you're on pretty short timelines. You have four months from letters issue to have your inventory and appraisal done. You have to have final distribution or status report within one year of letters issuing. So it's they have deadlines and for a reason and the court will remove an administrator for slow playing the administration and that's pretty common straightforward across the board in the state of the California that if you're slow playing an administration you take too long you're sitting on that property they'll put somebody else in charge to take care of it and they have full range to use the your inheritance against you to evict you and that's how long so to use that same time but how long would you advise somebody they'd have to wait as a trust beneficiary before you could file that motion to remove the trustee. Is it a year? Is it six months? Yeah. So, well, normally when you send an information demand letter or document demand letter, there's a 60-day response period. So, that's the first thing as a beneficiary you want to get moving is get your demand out, start that 60-day clock. But if we're three, four months into an administration of a trust and we're not seeing progress with the property, it's time to perk up. And so take a take some time, have some reasonable discretion in the morning period. We're not running next day after mom dies to court to say you haven't sold the house already. That's not appropriate. But if you're a trust is supposed to go quicker than a probate. That's why you do the estate plan is to expedite administration. So,
40:45 If you're 3 months in and you're not seeing any progress, it's worth asking the question. If you're six months in and you're seeing no progress, file. It's probably appropriate to file. You're a year in, file on the next party and get moving. Yeah, that's why I would say is you need to talk to the attorney because that a year already, that's abusive in my book. And it's gonna come out of that beneficiary's pocket most likely anyhow. But at least the sooner you get started, the sooner it finishes. Well, look, we've gone on forever. Zack, you obviously are an amazing resource. I always appreciate talking to you and you've been a guest on my podcast numerous times. For those who are interested, I think the best way would be to get in touch through your website theelysiumlaw.com and we'll put up on there. It'll be in the description as well. And right there on the website, if you go, there's a little button you can push to set up a contact to schedule consultation right there into his calendar or her calendar as appropriate. And it differentiates. In fact, let me just show her the page. I love this personally because oops it you're using I think calendarly or some sort of a calendar page that goes right into what type of matter is it books times right there. Now my calendar is not available booked up. So that said you get the appropriate answer your question right away from a proven track record great attorney and her husband Zach as well. So yeah congratulations. You're coming up on one year, but congratulations on the new firm, but I knew you when you were at one of the larger firms in San Diego, and I know you've been successful practitioner down there as well. So, I really appreciate your time. Thank you so much for being with us today, Zach. Yeah, thanks, Bill.
42:24 Appreciate it. And for the rest of you, this is estate planning weekly. We get together every week with Oops, lost my spot there. We get together every week with a state planning attorney or vendor to help us get the best service for our clients. And hopefully you get a chance to see different approaches. Different states have different rule, different laws, but the principles are the same. And even different counties have different procedures, but the principles are often the same. So hopefully it's helpful to you. If you like it, please like, subscribe. You have questions or comments, put them in the comments down below. As always, make today your best day ever. Thank you so much.
More The Estate Planning Podcast episodes
- Avoid These Mistakes in Estate Planning, with Attorney Liran Aliav
- Family-Centered Estate Planning, with Sati McLafferty
- What Is a Well-Executed Estate Plan? with Beverly Hills Attorney David Soffer
Related
- A guide for successor trustees
- How long does probate take?
- Probate attorneys and podcast guests
- The Estate Planning Podcast: all episodes
- For attorneys & fiduciaries
Educational media, not legal advice. Guest views are their own. Hosted by Bill Gross, The LA Probate Expert, a licensed California real estate broker (DRE #01022275) brokered by eXp Realty of California, Inc. (DRE #01878277). Bill is not an attorney and is not a Probate Referee.