Episode summary

Bill Gross talks with Liran Aliav of Aliav Law, an attorney who has spent years litigating trust and estate disputes and also advises on tax issues. Liran explains that many disputes start because a trust lacks contingencies, which forces the family to go to court and ask what the person who died would have wanted.

Liran describes the successor trustee problem: the people named in the trust pass away or decline to serve. His trusts include a way to appoint a successor trustee without going to court, which he says many online forms lack. He argues that the last 10 percent an attorney adds to a form is often the most important part.

Bill and Liran discuss funding the trust. Liran says that if a trust does not avoid probate, the client did not get what they paid for, so his office makes sure the deed is recorded into the trust. He warns that a property taken out of a trust, for example for a refinance, may have to be put back through a Heggstad petition, which can cost more and take longer than people expect.

They also cover what happens when no one can find the trust, why a safe deposit box is a poor place for original documents, and the growing interest in privacy trusts and related structures that California landlords use for privacy and asset protection.

Key points

  • Missing contingencies are a common source of trust litigation because the court then has to determine what the person intended.
  • A clause allowing a successor trustee to be appointed without court can save a family a court proceeding.
  • A trust only avoids probate for assets that are actually in it; check that the deed was recorded into the trust.
  • A Heggstad petition is still a court process with time and cost, not a magic pill.
  • Tell people where your important documents are, and avoid keeping the only original in a safe deposit box.

Questions answered in this episode

Why do do-it-yourself trusts lead to litigation?

Liran Aliav says that many disputes arise because a trust lacks contingencies, so the family has to go to court and ask what the person intended. He says the part an attorney adds to a form is often the most important part. Watch at 1:21

What happens if all the named successor trustees die or decline to serve?

Liran says his trusts include a clause that provides a way to appoint a successor trustee without going to court, which he calls invaluable and which many online forms do not have. Watch at 3:24

What if a house is taken out of the trust and never put back?

Liran explains that the court then has to determine whether the person really wanted the property back in the trust. A Heggstad petition can cost more and take longer than a probate; it is still a process that costs money, time and effort. Watch at 8:34

How does Liran's firm make sure a trust is funded?

He says funding is included in the fee. If he creates a trust that does not avoid probate, he has failed, so clients receive the deed showing the property is in the trust and the funding is taken care of. Watch at 10:37

What happens if the family cannot find the trust?

Liran says the family might petition the court to reconstruct the trust from other evidence, which is very hard. In the worst case, they need a probate, often combined with a quiet title action. Watch at 13:58

What is a privacy trust?

Liran describes privacy trusts, sometimes called land trusts, as increasingly requested in California, often combined with management agreements and LLCs, to provide privacy and asset protection for property owners such as landlords. Watch at 21:42

Transcript

Transcript generated from YouTube's automatic captions for this episode and lightly cleaned (filler words and repeated words removed, names and web addresses corrected; phone numbers and email addresses read on air are replaced with a placeholder; [unclear] marks words the captions did not capture). It may still contain transcription errors, and speaker labels are not included. Timestamps link to that point in the video, which is the authoritative record.

0:01 Welcome to Estate Planning Weekly. I'm your host, Bill Gross, at Bill Gross on social media, Bill Gross probate on social media. And here on Estate Planning Weekly, we interview attorneys often, attorneys who do estate planning, attorneys who in my I think I might say preventative estate planning, after the fact problem cleanup, which is estate planning litigation, and vendors to support us. Today I'm excited to have a local friend somebody who I've talked to over the years who does estate planning. He also does litigation. So give us some unique insights. Lori off. Thank you so much for joining us today. I'm happy to be here. So let's talk about estate planning. Though I do know you do litigation but as a result of that you see common mistakes or areas of attention that litigation kind of attracts. What would you say are one or two of the areas that most commonly either are mistakes or areas that need to be avoided or protected against in cases of estate litigation and to protect your wealth and assets? What I see a lot these days from the litigation standpoint is you have these trusts that are usually made online or a form of some sort and they're missing key provisions in case of contingencies.

1:21 Most of the time it's in case of the contingencies. And because of they don't have the contingency, we now have to go to court and ask what was your intent. And what would he have done or she and that itself is a big problem. When you have a attorney drafted trust, you usually avoid those contingencies. Not saying that attorney avoided trust. I mean, attorney made trusts don't go to litigation. They often do, but it's more with the lack of information in those forms. You know, you people think that they could I don't know use AI or go online and just get a form and change the names and call it a day. A lot of times that's not the case and it ends up costing the family dearly. So, it's interesting that you say it like this. You know, and you've been a guest on my other podcast, Probate Weekly, and not as an attorney, but just as a businessman, I tell people that 90% of the time, you're better off with a bad trust, done online, one of these online services, then nothing. And here you're probably pointing out that these online services you get what you pay for and if you get things very expensive you're can get a very limited set of circumstances. But I always feel like from a from a salesman point of view, if a customer at least has a bad trust, they can take that to a proper estate planning attorney and you can look at that and say, "Okay, well, you know, thank you for identifying these issues, but you know, and then you would ask the questions of those contingencies and create what I would call a an appropriate trust with the person." So, it's interesting to hear you say that's the area that you focus on is the contingencies. So, let's talk about that. I think one of the contingencies I see often litigated is the successor trustee, right? When the trust is made, initially it's the person

3:24 Who comes to get the trust written and then they nominate one or two people and those people over time either pass or don't want to do it. Is that one of the most common contingencies that people haven't prepared for? Yeah, absolutely. There's, you know, just in my trusts, you have a clause that says if all of them pass away, there's a way to appoint a successor trustee without going to court. And that's invaluable. Something that many of the online process don't have. Obviously, you could add it. And you brought up a point of hey, why don't you get a form? It's good for you at least you know 90% of the way or whatever it is and then go to the attorney and end up putting in the rest of the 10% the 10% that you're you would add with an attorney ends up being the most important 10% because you know let's say I'll just give you some numbers here right let's say you get a form online or you hire Legal Zoom or whatever it is and you spend I don't know 900 bucks on a trust right and you're saving let's just say a couple thousand dollars, which is great. Fantastic. You saved that money. Now, if that trust lacks something and I have to go to court, the minimum retainer for my fees are going to be $5,000 minimum. It could be a lot more for that. A lot more. It could end up being could end up being a lot more, right? It could be 10 thou. I mean, it just depends. Is there someone objecting on the other side? If there's someone objecting other side, you quadruple, quintuple it, whatever you want to do, right? It's just gonna be a lot more, right? So yeah, you saved a little bit of money in the beginning, but you created a huge mess for your heirs. And sometimes it works. I'm not going to say, hey, every single trust is bad, and you know, you might be right. It may work, but you know, people don't like to go to sleep knowing that their estate may work. Right.

5:29 That's something that I would not be able to live with if it was if I had to go to sleep as a non- attorney. Okay. Well, I, you know, I may have it done properly. That's not good. I want someone stand behind me. If there's something wrong, the beneficiaries could come to the attorney and go, "Hey, how come this occurred or how come you wrote it this way?" and the attorney could fix it and stand behind his documents and ultimately give the family peace of mind, which is really what you're after. Well, I sort of mean to diminish the value of your service. The opposite. I think in those cases where there is no need for contingencies, at least they have something better than going to probate court. But I think you're correct that the problem is it's never a problem until it's a problem. And then once it's a problem, it's a problem. And I think that's the challenge of this whole process. The other part is I saw a statistic that over 80% of online trusts are never funded or I'm sorry or even executed probably is also probably true but not funded. And so as a real estate agent we what that means to me as a real estate agent and those listening is that I literally have a client an estate a $40 million estate. They have $30 million of real estate and real estate related assets. And the decedent had gone to an estate planner several times and written a big check and gone it has a great binder but never executed it and never put the property into the estate.

6:59 Therefore, we're in probate court and at best his documents are a an indicator for the court. But even there's a contested because of the will that's not in this package. So let's talk about the importance. I think one of the things I like that you're local for me at least in Beverly Hills is that people could go see you and or see you in person. But how do you make sure and what can you do? Because ultimely you'll control your customer to make sure they end up leaving your office and executing the plan and then additionally putting the assets in the plan so what they paid for has effect. Okay, that's it's a great question. Essentially you're asking me, how do I make sure that the trust is funded? And when you create a trust, I always say to everybody, it's a bucket. It's a bucket that you have to fill up with all of your stuff. And if it's in that bucket and you pass away, then it goes by whatever you wrote in your trust. And it goes by without the need for court interference. However, if it's not in the bucket or you've taken it out, a lot of times people just take it out to put to get a loan or a refinance or because their child told them to put their names on it, whatever it is, they take it out and now it's not in the trust. Now, we have the burden to somehow go to court and petition and say, "Hey, you meant to put it back in the trust." Now, that's different than if I create a trust and you forgot to put the property into the trust the first time. That's a little bit easier.

8:34 But when you take it out, now I have to find your intent post you making the trust of whether you really wanted to put it back in. U which is much harder and usually doesn't fly in the courts. It is it is a fact intensive question whether we could even put it back in. And now you have to pay for that to put it back in which is going to cost you way more than the estate plan in the in general. So it probably more appropriate by the end of the day. The fact people say, "Oh, that's not a big deal. We just have to do a such and such a Heggstad petition is a term we use in California for that petition. But a Heggstad petition can cost you more and take longer than a probate." It's not like it's a magic pill. It's still a process and cost money and time, effort, and energy, right? If it's uncontested, might be faster, but if it's contested, it's probably takes longer. But back to your question, which was the main point is how do I make sure the trusts are funded? I am not going to just make you a bucket and do nothing, right? So, we're going to move the properties before you leave this office into the trust. And we're not only going to move the properties, we're going to move your partnerships and your corporations. All of those, a lot of people forget, need to also be in the trust, right? And many of these real estate investors have almost all their properties in LLC's and they go, "Well, yeah, I have LLC's. I have a trust. I'm good to go." Well, did you put the LLC into the trust? That's a huge question. And that could cost the family a bunch of money at the end of at the end of your life because those are not funded into the trust. And they have a special way. Every asset has a different way of getting into your trust. I can't just put a list together and call it a date. It doesn't work that way. I have to call banks. I have to record deeds. I have to draft documents to move assets like LLC's into the into your trust. So all of that is highly important when you're looking for an attorney, whoever it is, that

10:37 They do all of that and they include that in their service, which is right included in our fee. It's not an additional charge. It's if I create a trust for you that doesn't work, then I failed, right? If I create a trust that doesn't avoid probate, then what was the point of it? What did what did I what did you pay for? Right? So, that's how that's our promise to our clients is we make sure that you know you're going to get a deed in the mail. It tells you it's in the trust. Whatever it is, it's all in that binder or it's all taken care of in terms of funding. As a real estate agent, when I refer people, I always follow up because I can check on public records. Did it happen or not? And I and I feel like Liran's attitude there is, you know, I can't argue with the legal side, right? Some attorney and say, "I don't want to take responsibility. I'm going to give you some instructions and you need to transfer the deeds and you need to transfer your bank accounts and I'll give you a list of all things you have to transfer." To me, as a businessman, that's not satisfying the customer's problem. Right? The customer come to you just for legal advice. He came to you because he had a problem. I think legal advice is a component of it. And so from a business point of view, I would say if the attorney is not willing to follow through and get the bucket filled or fund the trust and that includes record, not just preparing the deed, I mean it's getting them recorded, making sure they get recorded, the bank accounts, getting the child transferred, verifying that. To me, that's the differentiation between somebody who's really serious about doing their customers work and people who are just looking to get paid for legal advice. And I know there's different opinions on that and I can respect other people, but I the way I do business is more like that. I you know I my customers coming to solve a problem.

12:17 So thanks for laying that part out. Let's talk about one of the other key things is that I find is a problem is they do a trust but somehow when some when the seed passes nobody knows where it is. And so I get this problem regularly as a real estate agent is the family come to me and say well the property is deed in the trust and we know what he wanted to do with it. Of course we just can't find the documents. We look through the house, you know, we look for clues on the documents of who the attorney might be, maybe try to search the notary, figure it out, but we get to the point where we can't tell. I also see in the LA Bar Association list serve chat thing where people say, "Anybody aware of a, you know, a Joe Smith or whatever." so what happens in that case? And what can you and what do you do, if anything, to help customers avoid being the I have the world's greatest trust, but I just can't find it when I'm dead. Okay. You pretty much touched up on almost all the things that we would tell our clients to do. You go search around the house for any sort of evidence of any attorney, maybe even bank statements for your payments that you made to the attorney so that you could go and contact that person. The deed itself could give clues as to where to search what attorney was involved. Maybe there's a notary like you said and you could go contact the notary. There's a lot of ways to do it, but ultimately if you can't find it after all of that and with the list serve and everything and you just can't find it, now you're stuck in a situation where you might need to file a petition in court to quiet title.

13:58 You might file a petition in the court to u based off of your other evidence reconstruct a trust, right? If there's like I don't know paperwork somewhere that shows what he intended he or she intended to do we could reconstruct it. It's a it's a very hard thing to do. And worst comes to worse we need to do a probate or a you know usually a quiet title mixed with a probate. So it's a it's definitely not a fun thing to hear. I cannot find the trust. Therefore, when you do a trust, there are some precautions you should take and you know, telling people where your important documents are and not putting them in a safe deposit because we don't have access to that without going to the court usually, which is kind of ridiculous if you think about it. I have to go to court without the document to get the document and then tell the court there is a document. That doesn't work out so well either. So, don't put it in the safe deposit box. Put it somewhere that they could find in a Usually I tell people in a fireproof safe. I'm sorry, not fireproof safe, a fireproof box that you could get on Amazon. U put it in your bookcase at home or somewhere that is easily findable. It's not a document that if someone takes people think, "Oh, I have the trust. I could do everything." No, you don't. So, it doesn't matter if people have copies if you if you really it matters if the trustee, the person listed, he might be able to do something, but a random beneficiary can't do anything with a deed or a trust just because he's a beneficiary. He or she is a beneficiary. So, that's a misconception that I see. It's like, oh my god, they stole my deed from my house. What do I do? They're about they're up to no good. They stole my trust. What could they do? It's not

16:02 Like they could magically move your property somewhere else. Now, I mean I in if you really go deep and with all the crazy things that you could do, maybe they could transfer, I don't know, fake notaries, whatever it is, but at the end of the day, taking a deed and taking a trust isn't an issue. So, you I don't know that you know this. My father was an attorney and he had a partner who did wills and trusts. So this goes back a long ways before you know you were born when I was quite young and I remember in their office they had like a like a vault with all the wills in those days and then later trusts of their clients and it was kind of expected in the old days that attorneys kept them and then there was a time period when attorneys didn't keep them as a general rule and for whatever reasons and then now I see attorneys have different opinions some say no I never keep it I always give to customer and there's a reason some say I always keep a copy for these reasons and now with online storage obviously there's a hybrid solution so where do you stand on how do you how do you handle customers documents as far as making copy available for them or do you store copy or you don't or you use online or how do you help with that? We store copies here in the cloud. The originals go to the clients themselves. They own all the originals. They have it, they get it. But most of the time the copies are good for all the things that I need to do. The only time that a an original is really needed is when you go to probate, which you shouldn't be if you have a trust, but if you need to go to probate because of some issue, you might need the original will. Not saying that you 100% need it. You could still file petitions based off of a copy of a will.

18:02 As long as you know there's people who are not going to contest those wishes. It should be fine. But the original is in my books goes is with the client and I think it makes sense. And then having stored copies I think is also important in that they can figure out that you're the attorney. They could figure out perhaps that you have a copy or access to a copy if they're the right person to get a copy of it. And again, I think it gets down to not the legal right or wrong, but the business side. And I think it's important that we solve our customers problems or prevent customers problems where we can. And that to me makes a lot of sense. So you mentioned because we tal this about mistakes in estate planning. You mentioned the lack of contingencies. What are one or two other, you know, mistakes or problems that you see in estate plans that lead to litigation that had they been written properly or written differently, rather than litigation, they just would have gone through the process of administering the estate. If anything, the contingency dealing with who gets an asset if someone passes away. So it's kind of like the trustee where we don't know what happens after he passes away, but the contingency of, hey, you're going to get this property, but if you pass away before, where is it going to go? And, that, you know, depends. You could, it usually says to their children, but what if they don't have children or what if the testator wanted it to go to a different person altogether?

19:38 You might have litigation based off of that as well. Yeah, those are I've seen I've seen where they designate say children then children get married and have bad spouses either get divorced or they never get divorced but they're separated and everybody hates that person and you have to wonder now I can't get in the head of the decedent but you kind of wonder they probably if they in retrospect could write it they'd write it differently but you know it is what it is and you're stuck unfortunately with what is and I think u a good estate plan will anticipate these kinds of issues and That's why you go to a professional like Liran Aliav. So Liran, look, I know I've kind of gotten here to the end of our time and I appreciate you're I know you're really busy. You mentioned to me that you're actually looking for additional staff attorneys on your litigation side and parallegals to help you both with estate planning and litigation. So I really appreciate your time. It's always a pleasure. I always learn so much to talk with you. The website is leaflaw.com and right on there you have a contact you have all the contact information. Contact us, register for webinar. Tell me about real quick before we run off. Tell me about your webinar. What's the goal of that? What are you looking to help people understand who click on that? That webinar is made for it's kind of like an intro to estate planning. People will understand why and what they could do with estate planning. You just said the divorce thing. That's a big issue usually for divorce of your children or your beneficiaries not your own divorce or your creditors of your children or the special needs of your children. Those are all addressed in that webinar. There is another webinar that we have that is for something called a land trust. And those are it's an asset protection strategy. It's usually done when you are want to be private about your name and who owns the property and you just you just have a higher privacy concern. And those

21:42 Are becoming a lot more common these days. They may have other names for the land trust out in the open, but essentially it's a privacy trust of some sort. And that is actually what a lot of people are asking for these days. So that especially in the highly litigious state of California where people are just filing lawsuits left and right and if especially with the real estate landlord issues that you're seeing these days where it's so difficult to be a landlord in the state of California and attorneys are happy to know that there is a bank that they could go to make a claim. Against these days. So, the privacy trusts do help in that situation. There's a mixture of things that we do together. There's management agreements p there's different kinds of LLC's that we set up from different states. All of that is geared towards privacy and asset protection. So some of those assets again should reach out to loflaw.com hit the contact button or book a call there and you can get with him. You know people one big misconception I get from trust is they'll say well trust to avoid lawsuits. I'll say no anytime you have money there's going to be a lawsuit. A trust will help prepare you for the inevitable lawsuit or deter somebody at an earlier stage from continuing the lawsuit. But it just seems to me I don't know maybe I'm jaded at this stage of my life. Wherever there's a lot of money, somebody's gonna file a lawsuit about something. And you better have your ducks in order if you want to keep that or keep it for your family and your legacy. Yeah, absolutely. Absolutely. Anyhow, Leon, thank you so much for talking. I really appreciate it and look forward to talking again soon. Of course. Thank you. And for the rest of you, again, this is the estate planning weekly. We get together every week and we have a different episode with attorneys like Liran. Both attorneys do prepare estates, litigate estates, vendors to support along the process as well.

23:45 If you like it, please like it, subscribe. If you have questions or something you'd like to see, feel free to reach out to me and let me know. I'm at Bill Gross Probate on social media. And as always, make today your best day ever. Thank you so much.

More The Estate Planning Podcast episodes

Related

Educational media, not legal advice. Guest views are their own. Hosted by Bill Gross, The LA Probate Expert, a licensed California real estate broker (DRE #01022275) brokered by eXp Realty of California, Inc. (DRE #01878277). Bill is not an attorney and is not a Probate Referee.

Schedule Consultation