Episode summary

Bill Gross talks with Abraham David Benhayoun, a Miami attorney who works on pre-immigration tax and estate planning, about the tax surprises that catch people who move to the United States, and what it costs to get the timing wrong.

Abraham gives a common example: a business owner from Latin America moves to the US and then sells a factory or other assets back home. Once they are a US taxpayer, that sale can be taxed here. Tax treaties and foreign tax credits help, but he says they do not always prevent extra US tax. Planning before arriving, which he calls pre-migration planning, can sometimes reduce or avoid that tax.

He explains the two main tests. For income tax, being in the US 183 days, US citizenship or a green card can make you a US taxpayer, and the substantial presence test counts part of your days from the prior two years. For gift and estate tax, the test is domicile. He also covers the US exit tax for people who give up citizenship.

The second surprise is for foreign people who simply own US assets: Abraham says they have only a $60,000 estate tax exemption, not the much larger exemption available to US citizens, and the usual domestic trust tools may not work as easily for them. Bill and Abraham also discuss FIRPTA withholding on sales by foreign sellers and the extra paperwork foreign owners face.

Key points

  • Selling assets abroad after becoming a US taxpayer can trigger US tax; plan before you move.
  • Abraham says the 183-day rule and the substantial presence test decide income tax residency, while domicile decides estate and gift tax.
  • Foreign owners of US property have a much smaller estate tax exemption than US citizens, according to Abraham.
  • Under FIRPTA, the buyer generally withholds a share of the price when a foreign person sells US real estate, so plan sales early.
  • Work with advisors who understand both the immigration and the tax side.

Questions answered in this episode

What is a common international tax mistake for people moving to the US?

Abraham David Benhayoun says a typical case is a business owner from another country who moves to the US and then sells a factory or other assets back home. Once they are a US taxpayer, that sale can be taxed in the US, which often surprises both clients and other professionals. Watch at 1:02

What is pre-migration planning?

Abraham describes it as planning done before you arrive in the US. Depending on how far ahead you plan and the type of property, it can mean paying much less US tax, for example by using the primary residence exclusion on a home in another country. Watch at 7:14

When does someone become a US taxpayer for income tax?

Abraham says US citizens and green card holders are US taxpayers wherever they live, and someone present 183 days can be treated as a US taxpayer. He walks through how the substantial presence test also counts a fraction of days from the prior two years. Watch at 10:17

What tax test applies for gift and estate tax?

Abraham says the test for gift and estate tax is domicile, meaning where you live now and expect to keep living. He notes that many visas are non-immigrant visas, which affects whether someone can have that intent. Watch at 10:17

How much estate tax exemption does a foreign owner of US assets have?

Abraham says a foreign person who just has assets in the United States has only a $60,000 estate tax exemption rather than the large exemption available to US citizens, and the trust tools used for domestic planning do not always work as easily for them. Watch at 20:07

What is FIRPTA withholding when a foreign person sells US real estate?

Abraham explains that it is not just a form: the buyer has to withhold 15% of the purchase price and send it to the IRS. There are ways to apply for reduced withholding, but he says everything with foreign sellers tends to take longer. Watch at 22:30

Transcript

Transcript generated from YouTube's automatic captions for this episode and lightly cleaned (filler words and repeated words removed, names and web addresses corrected; phone numbers and email addresses read on air are replaced with a placeholder; [unclear] marks words the captions did not capture). It may still contain transcription errors, and speaker labels are not included. Timestamps link to that point in the video, which is the authoritative record.

Editor's note: Abraham David Benhayoun's practice is based in Miami, Florida. Tax and estate rules differ by state and change over time, and figures are as described by the guest at recording; California readers should check California law and get individual tax advice.

0:02 So, you pursue the American dream, you weave your way through the whole maze of US immigration to be able to establish a business here, work here legally, live here legally. You have a business here, but woah, what happened to all of a sudden the tax liability? Are you going to get taxed for things that should be taxed in other countries? Are you going to be a higher tax rate than you need to? Very complicated and very specialized field. I'm really lucky to have today a man who's internationally from originally Venezuela, practices law out of Miami, one of my favorite cities, I guess I would say, my former my former residence, to specialize in estate planning as it relates to international business people, Abraham Beniyun. Thank you so much for joining us today.

0:41 Thank you for having me, Bill. Pleasure to be here. So, I am I imagine you must have an occasion to have a to have a client you tell them something go, "What? I don't tax on that. You wrong." What are one of two biggest mistakes people have made that came to you before they came to you that maybe you were help able to remedy or that or you can't remedy?

1:02 So, that happens all the time. Not just clients, but also other professionals just because this area is so niche and so unknown that people are often just very surprised by things that they're going to be taxed on. So, I'll give the first example based on sort of the story that you gave a few minutes ago about someone coming into the country and then, you know, getting a visa, starting to work here. A very typical thing that happens is if you're a business owner in, let's say, Latin America, where you're from in out of the United States, you move to the US, and then you sell, you know, your factory that you had down there or you know, whatever assets you had in that other country. Most people tend to think that, well, when I move to the US, the value was $500,000 and I'm selling it for 550,000, so I should pay taxes in the US for 50,000. And you know, that kind of makes sense logically because the 50,000 is what you made while you were in the US. However, that's not how it actually works as far as the tax code is concerned. The way they actually analyze it is, well, what was your basis? Meaning, what did you pay for it when you bought it? And then there's going to be adjustments that you could make or that you may have to make such as if you're using it for business, you can you have to take off depreciation or if you made improvements, then that's going to increase your basis, but they're going to care about how much you paid, you know, 30 years ago when you bought that or you built it or whatever it was and then if it was in business minus depreciation and they're going to want you to pay tax on all of that even though it's located in a different country, even though most of the gain was made in that different country, you're now a US taxpayer.

3:00 And a US taxpayer Lucky you. Well, [laughter] to some degree, yes. I mean, this is a pretty wonderful country. Yes. And you're you know, the fact that you're a taxpayer, that means that you're living here. So, congratulations.

3:13 If you have to make if you have to make enough make enough money to pay taxes, at least you're making money, right? Exactly. There you go. It's a good problem to have, right? But you still have to fix it. It's still a problem. So, yes, even though logic, you know, would tell you maybe you shouldn't be paying taxes here, you would have to pay taxes here. Now, that doesn't mean you don't pay taxes in your home country for that gain. That means you're going to have to pay taxes there and here. Now, is that double taxation? Maybe. There is sort of two ways that governments try to fix that. One is treaties. If there's a treaty with your home country, great. You're not going to pay taxes twice on that. They have make sure to work out, you know, to work all of that out, so you should be fine. If there is no treaty and I was mentioning Latin America, in Latin America we only have Venezuela, Mexico, and Chile that have treaties with the US. Venezuela being the surprising one.

4:18 Yeah. Yeah, but other than that I lived in Florida in the 1980s and I would say like half of Miami's business was coming from Venezuela back then. It was so wealthy, so active. It's the last 30 years of Venezuela really suffered, but Venezuela was a key trading partner particularly in the South of the United States.

4:38 Yeah, Venezuela is a very wealthy country. Was. Yeah, and so historically, you know, there was a saying in Venezuela that you would go to a different country and you would always say, "Esta barato, dame dos." Oh, it's cheap, just give me two of them. Right? Cuz Venezuela had so much wealth that everything seemed like it was not expensive. But yes, I agree. Since, you know, since Chavez started getting power then everything sort of went off the rails, but what's interesting is that the treaty was signed with Chavez. So

5:11 Interesting. It's interesting. Yeah. So anyway, if you're from those countries, then great. You have that treaty. If you're from Venezuela, you might have other issues, but not the double taxation with the US. But if you're from a different country in Latin America or, you know, elsewhere that doesn't have a treaty, then the only process that you have is what's called the foreign tax credits, which is you pay first in the place where the money was made, and then in the country where you live. So you would come to the US and you would say, "Well, you know, I paid whatever, let's say $100,000 for that. And let's assume there was no depreciation and no improvements just to make it easy. And you sold it for 550,000, so you made $450,000. Okay, so you paid over there, let's say, just call it around [clears throat] $150,000 in taxes. So, what you're going to do is you're going to come to the US and you're going to say, "I What should I be paying in taxes for that?" [clears throat] well, that's going to be depending on your, you know, your effective rate, is it long-term capital gains, is it not, etc. But if it's more than $150,000, you're going to pay the difference here.

6:32 If it's less, then that's called a foreign tax credit that you should be able to use all of that tax that you paid in that other country to lower your tax here. Now, that's sort of the big picture in the theory of it. It doesn't exactly always work like that. You often do [clears throat] have to pay, you know, some additional tax anyway, even if, you know, you should have paid, let's say, 100,000 here, but for some reason the types of tax or whatever, they didn't exactly match and therefore they didn't give you the full credit, but you're [clears throat] going to get some credit for it. But the important thing is that you need to be looking out for that, making sure that you're filing properly. And more importantly,

7:14 [snorts] going back to your initial question, if you had planned before you came, you [snorts] may not have to pay anything at all. There is different types of things that you can do, depending how far in advance you're planning, depending on the reality of the situation, what type of property it is, that can make you, just pay much less taxes here. For example, if it's your primary residence, you might be able to use the primary residence exemption even if it's in a different country. So, all of those things that you need to think about before you come. That's on the I guess moving to the US side, that's what we call pre-migration planning.

8:02 I've heard that, pre-migration planning. I've never even heard that before. It's fascinating. Yeah. Makes sense. I mean, cuz once you've come in, now you're kind of stuck with a certain set of rules versus being able to design it to fit your needs.

8:13 Yeah. What we have done in the past, because there is a lot more things you can do if you don't come into the United States within 5 years of doing certain types of planning, you can get much fancier, you know, you can do special types of trusts and things like that will just really help you out on the income tax side of things. Either, you know, we talk to people who are coming in with like EB-5 we call them visas, but it's not really a visa, they process to get a green card. Those processes take a long time, and a lot of people don't need to be in the US while that happens. They have their business going elsewhere, they just want to move eventually here. So, in those types of cases, it's much easier to make all these fancier and better result type of plans just because they don't have to come in and live here for the next 5 years. And then, there's other things that you can do with different types of visas, and I don't know how much in into the weeds you want to get with it, but for example, if you're on a student visa, you don't have the same rules as if you're on in basically any other type of visa.

9:34 So, it's stuff you can play with if you have a good immigration attorney to work with. Meaning you take some classes, be a student, and that extends your time here without establishing residency here.

9:45 Exactly. You know, I and I know people who moved to other countries, but they still want to be here a lot. Maybe they have kids, family, whatever reasons. They like America. In some in one country I know, France makes a point of not being here half the year, like 300 you know, he'll be here whatever it is, 182 days a year, but not 183. And he has all on a calendar, and makes sure he doesn't overstay, and makes sure he gets out of town on the right flight. Is that is that there certain limits, but you can be here for almost half the year?

10:17 Yeah, there are limits. It's actually interesting. The law says if you're here 183 days, then you're a US taxpayer for income taxes. So, there's two types of tax, right? There is I mean, there's a million types of tax, but essentially it basically boils down to two types. Income tax and gift and estate tax. For gift and estate tax, the test is domicile. Domicile is just the regular law definition of domicile, which is where do you live currently, and you expect to keep living there either forever or for an unknown amount of time. That's domicile. So, if you want to be domiciled in the United States, you need to have a visa that will allow you to have that intent. Many visas are non-immigrant visas, and they require you to tell the government, I'm coming in for 3 years, 5 years, whatever it is, to do this project, and then I'm leaving. Okay, great. So, if you did that, then you're not domiciled here, and then you're considered foreign for estate and gift tax purposes. Which, by the way, we need to go back to that, because that's You asked me for two examples, I gave you one.

11:35 The other one is based on that situation. But for income tax purposes you can either be a US citizen, doesn't matter where you live, you're considered a US taxpayer, or a US resident, meaning you have a green card. Also, doesn't matter where you actually live for taxes. You might have an issue with your green card if you don't actually live here, but for tax purposes, it doesn't matter. If you have a green card, you're a US taxpayer for income tax purposes. And the third is what's called the substantial presence test. And this is the one that you're talking about. So, the law says if you're here 100 183 days, great, you're going to be a US taxpayer for income tax purposes. But, we don't calculate the 183 days just looking at this year. We're going to look at this year, we're going to count every day that you're here as 1 day, which makes sense. Plus, we're going to count 1/3 of the days that you were here last year as days for this year, plus a sixth of the days that you were here 2 years ago for as a day this year. So, essentially, if you come every year for long periods of time, the magic number that we usually talk about is 120 days.

12:52 If you're here 120 days, then you're okay because you don't pass that test because 120 days from this year plus a third of 120, that's already 40, from last year, so we're at 160, plus a sixth from 2 years ago, that's another 20, so we're 180. So, you're still good. Probably if you go over that's when we start having the issues. Now, if you got over the 183 days with this calculation, but you weren't actually 183 days this year in the US. Let's say that you were, you know, 120 days 2 years ago, 120 days last year, and then 135 days this year, whatever it is. So, you're over. But you weren't actually here over 183 days, then you can file with the IRS a closer connection statement, which is where you tell the IRS, you know, "Hey, I overstayed not visa-wise, I just overstayed my 180 days, my substantial presence test calculation, but I didn't spend here more than half the year, and all my connections are really to a different country. I really live in Brazil. My whole family's there.

14:14 You know, my kids go to school there, whatever. I just overstayed this year because my daughter had a kid, and I stayed helping out and whatever, but I don't really live here." And the IRS will usually accept that and let it go and say, "Fine, you're okay." You don't really have that option if you overstay 183 days in the actual year. That you could only get away with if you have if you live in a treaty country, and then those the treaties have what's called tie-breaker rules, and then, you know, they will determine you're considered a resident of which country because that's another one of the advantages of treaties, which is you're not going to be a resident of both countries. You're going to be a resident of one. If you're in a non-treaty country, you could be considered a resident of both countries by both countries, which is a terrible situation to be in. So, that's probably what your friend is doing, counting the days.

15:12 The tax rates in other countries, are they typically higher than US, lower than US, or there's just a wide variance, and it just depends?

15:21 There's a wide variance, It depends. You have all types. It used to be different when the IRS when the US had a higher tax percentage before the first Trump term. But now that everything changed, you know, especially the corporate [music] tax, that changed a lot. It was 35% now it's 21. That's a huge difference.

15:49 Right. Then the foreign exchange but not as much. I have a bunch of friends. The company I'm with IPO'd years ago and their compensation included a lot of stock. And so I had a number of friends become millionaires on stock. And in order to avoid cuz this is like the 90% of their net worth was the stock grant in the in their cases. And the plan they came up with was to move to Puerto Rico. Is that Is that still a thing? Is that something you get involved with clients helping them plan that process?

16:21 It is still a thing. Many people do it. It's something that I actually haven't been involved in before. I've been involved in two partial situations like that. But in both cases the spouses said "No. We're not moving anywhere and you're not going anywhere. We'll just pay the tax that we have to pay." whether that was a smart decision or not you know, it's a personal choice, but yes, people do that. You know, you have to do it right. You can't just say, "Oh, I now live in Puerto Rico because I'm renting an apartment there." You have to like actually move. And that's where people sort of don't want to do it anymore. But if it's a large enough amount of money, then yeah, it could be worth it. Right. Now, if we're thinking of foreign people there is actually a different analysis that you could do. This we have done. So, let's say you're a you know, you're a foreign person coming to invest in US and you know, you're in type of company that you expect will

17:34 [clears throat] increase in value substantially over the next few years. So, you know, a lot of people would just want to come and get a green card and then just sort of when that happens, figure it out then. Right? The problem is that the reason that people that you know, moved to Puerto Rico and they didn't just give up their citizenship as we heard of other people doing like one of the founders of Facebook, right? He gave up his citizenship and moved somewhere else.

18:01 Singapore, I think. What's that? I think it was Singapore. Singapore, okay. Makes sense. So, the reason that not a lot of people do that is that when you have a US citizen giving up his citizenship, the IRS will do an exit tax. And essentially, the exit tax is we're going to calculate the value of everything you own now and we're going to pretend you sold everything.

18:34 Wow. So, it's a pretty difficult situation, but if you're one of the Facebook founders and they you know, the current value of your stock is valued at you know, whatever you could possibly sell it at because you can't really sell it to anyone probably other than other insiders or you know, maybe whatever limitations they had, it's going to be substantially different from where your company is actually traded in the in the public market, right? And then okay, so it made sense for him to do that. But again, if you're coming in from abroad, you get a green card, you have it for eight years, congratulations. If you give up your green card now, you're going to have an exit tax. But, if you were here, let's say, as an investor visa, and you never got a green card, then you just leave after, you know, or you just stop spending time in the US, even if you're not giving up your investor visa, then there is no exit tax. And the situation is, obviously, you know, completely different. So, you know, it all involves planning. You just You need to think ahead. You need to try to figure out what I'm looking at, how things are going to look in a not I'm sure you know not everything is for everyone.

19:54 But, all these things can be done. Right, if I can go back now to actually the second example that I wanted to mention, cuz I think this is actually also

20:07 [snorts] I think even more surprising to people. Cuz we talked about you're making money, right? You live in one country, you have the asset in another. You know, we have some kind of intuition that there may be taxes everywhere involved. If you have, let's say, a foreign person who just has assets in the United States, there is no $15 million estate tax exemption. They only have $60,000 in estate tax exemption. And the tools that we use for domestic estate planning don't necessarily work the same way or as easily for foreign people. One is culture. You know, it's You're going to create an irrevocable trust, and you're going to give a trust company, you know, the right to manage your assets. You're an American citizen, you've grown up with this. You're in a well, you know, wealthy family or wealthy enough that you have heard of these things happening. It's something that you can accept. If you're a, you know, Argentinian citizen, and I'm just picking out different countries at different times no particular reason.

21:26 But, you know, you're a South American citizen or a resident, you grew up there, you never heard of these things. You're going to give some bank you never heard of the local manager assets and they decided if they give you any money, you know, it's just not going to fly, right? And then also the funding is always much more complicated. Not that it's easy on the US side, but over here we have all these other rules. So, we have FIRPTA, right? I don't know if I should explain about FIRPTA.

22:00 Well, foreign individuals, but there's certain laws and regulations with foreign visitors that have financial restrictions that are not in place for Americans. And so, every real estate transaction we have to fill out a FIRPTA form to identify is the person subject to that or not.

22:16 Well, so [clears throat] I think I think of FinCEN. Oh, no, we do FIRPTA as well. Right, and that's for cash transactions. FIRPTA, doesn't matter if it's a cash transaction or not, it matters if it's a foreign person.

22:30 Yeah. And then it's not just a form, it's really a tax withholding. They the buyer has to withhold 15% of the purchase value and send it to the IRS. Sort of to make sure that they pay their tax even if it's a ridiculous amount. Now, there are ways there's like a FIRPTA certificate you can request and there's different types of things that you can do to try to not have to send that in, especially when it's not actually being sold. But it's complication. Everything with foreign people is more complicated. To get them, you know, they don't have a social security number. So, you get them an ITIN, and that's a headache. And getting an EIN for their company could take months. It's like you're back to the stone in the US.

23:23 Can be. You know, it's interesting. This is changes going on. Some good, some bad. The famous story I heard if you follow American football, quarterback for Seattle, No. I'm sorry. Quarterback Yeah. Who has a huge salary, I want to say 30 40 million dollars a year. When you play in the Super Bowl, they only give you a bonus for that one game of like $175,000. Of course, you know, they have endorsements, and there's other reasons why they want to win cuz it's fun to win the game. But, the bonus is 175.

23:57 Okay. But, in California, where the Super Bowl was played, the tax is based on how many days of a year you work in California. So, an athlete, you know, for a professional football player might play or plays, I think 17 games a year. And, you know, some of his home state and some in other states, New York, they travel, you know, Atlanta. But, in California, you get taxed for the money you earn, the portion of it in California, which is unique. Well, I don't think other states do that. In his case, cuz he makes I want to say 30 40 million dollars a year, and you divide cuz Super Bowl, you have to be there for the whole week. He couldn't just fly in the day of the game and fly out. They had to be there for the promotion. I mean, I thought more like I think it was 10 days actually with promotions and such. He actually paid several million dollars for the right to work in California. I don't know if it was 7 million, but it was it was hundreds of thousands of dollars that he lost. Now, I'm sure he's glad he won the Super Bowl, and that's the prize. But, the point is I guess I just want to say these laws are very complicated. You have state laws, you have US tax laws, you have immigration laws, and then you have tax laws in these foreign states. And so, anybody who's going through that, I you know, I've only heard people who didn't plan and found things bit them. And I think like everything else, if you plan ahead, maybe start to pay taxes, but you can pay less and possibly make it more agreeable. So, you know, Abraham, I know I spoke to you. A lot of this is over our my head, though I think I follow what you I think you bring up some really good points and I can follow that.

25:25 But certainly, anybody who's you considering moving here to the United States and or leaving the United States and has wealth and estate planning issue should talk to an expert who also is familiar with the immigration side of it, so you can not just suffer with the estate tax you have to pay, but can plan your immigration to maximize the estate options. So, Abraham, I just want to thank you so much for your time to going through it in detail. I know you've been very generous in the past. I appreciate you kindly laying this out today. If you want more information, it's been at law.com. And I have their website and there's contact information. Anything else you want to say before we wrap up?

26:03 No, thank you so much. Really appreciate you having me here. It's been super fun. Really fun. I thought I learned a lot. I really appreciate your time today. Well, thank you so much. And for the rest of you, this was Estate Planning Weekly. We get together every week and talk to estate planning attorneys. In this case, somebody who also brings in the immigration angle. And I think it's really important for those who deal with these larger estates that it's not just recognizing taxes you're obligated to pay, but by planning ahead, you can use the immigration strategies as well to eliminate your cost. So, I thought it was very helpful. If I can help any way, please reach out. I'd love to see you like this. Send me a comment. You can reach out to me at Bill Gross Probate on social media. And as always, make today your best day ever. Thanks so much.

More The Estate Planning Podcast episodes

Related

Educational media, not legal advice. Guest views are their own. Hosted by Bill Gross, The LA Probate Expert, a licensed California real estate broker (DRE #01022275) brokered by eXp Realty of California, Inc. (DRE #01878277). Bill is not an attorney and is not a Probate Referee.

Schedule Consultation