Episode summary

Bill Gross talks with Natalie Elser, a CPA and President of California Professional Accountants Group, about tax and business advice built around a family's goals rather than tax avoidance alone.

Natalie explains why she warns clients away from aggressive tax schemes, since California can come back a year or two later for the tax plus penalties and interest. She and Bill also discuss parents who deed property to their children during life, which can cost the children the step-up in basis and create a large tax bill.

They talk about Delaware statutory trusts (DSTs) as a hands-off option for owners who are tired of managing rentals, including their cash flow, lockup periods, and penalties for getting out early, and why good advice usually saves far more than it costs.

The last part covers speaking to clients in their own language and how Natalie uses AI tools: as a quick research starting point, never as a substitute for a professional who knows the family's situation.

Key points

  • Start with the client's goals; the cheapest tax answer is not always the right plan.
  • Aggressive tax schemes can bring back taxes, penalties, and interest when California audits.
  • Deeding property to children during life can cost them the step-up in basis; get advice first.
  • DSTs can give tired landlords cash flow without management, but money is locked up and early exits can carry penalties.
  • AI tools can be a starting point for research, but they do not know your family and can give wrong answers.

Questions answered in this episode

What happens if you use an aggressive scheme to avoid California tax?

Natalie Elser says California may come back in a year or two and ask for all the tax plus penalties and interest. She warns clients about the risk and leaves the decision to them. Watch at 3:25

Is it a good idea to deed a house to your kids before you die?

Natalie says people often do it with good intentions, but it can carry serious tax consequences. Deeding half of a $1 million property to a child shortly before death, for example, can leave the child paying tax on that half million. Watch at 6:47

Is good tax and legal advice worth the cost?

Natalie says advice from both the attorney and CPA could have saved one family about $100,000, and that people who see advice as expensive often do not realize how much it can save. Watch at 8:03

Who are Delaware statutory trusts (DSTs) right for?

Natalie says DSTs can cash flow well, especially storage, large warehouse, and large multifamily properties, but they are not for everyone because your cash is usually locked up for a period of time. Watch at 10:28

Why do some heirs prefer a DST over the family rentals?

Natalie says a DST lets the next generation be involved in real estate without taking on the whole operation their parents ran. Watch at 13:55

Can you rely on AI for tax and financial advice?

Natalie says AI does not know your family history, how many children you have, or your plans for them, so its answers may not be right for you. Use it to get ideas, then take them to a professional. Watch at 22:25

Transcript

Transcript generated from YouTube's automatic captions for this episode and lightly cleaned (filler words and repeated words removed, names and web addresses corrected; phone numbers and email addresses read on air are replaced with a placeholder; [unclear] marks words the captions did not capture). It may still contain transcription errors, and speaker labels are not included. Timestamps link to that point in the video, which is the authoritative record.

Editor's note: This is general information, not tax or legal advice. DST terms, fees, and liquidity vary by offering; review the offering documents and talk with your own CPA, attorney, and licensed advisor before acting.

0:02 One of the key team members in an effective estate planning team is the CPA, tax advisor, business advisor, also kind of they come some of us play several hats. And the lady here who wears several hats to helping families achieve their life goals, Natalie Elser who is a CPA based in Orange County. Natalie, thank you for joining us today. Thank you, Bill, for having me. I'm really excited to be here. So, one of the things we as we're getting ready to emphasize I've talked to you before about is the purpose of taxes is not just to not pay taxes. The purpose is to achieve our goals. Correct. Yes, there's an overall you know, we want to know everybody's overall goals, what their family goals are, their personal goals, their business goals, their wealth goals because that works in conjunction with tax planning. You can't just get in and just start saving taxes. We got to know what everybody's goals are so that way we can strategically do tax planning accordingly and we don't mess things up. And so, you know, I often have I'm a real estate agent and often I'll have you know, clients will say to me, "Well, my attorney said to avoid taxes, you know, not to buy this." I'm thinking, "Well, the best way to avoid taxes is to do nothing. You just stay at home and lay in bed all day and watch television, you'll pay no taxes and get welfare. That may not be the goal that you're trying to achieve." Exactly. No, it's that's exactly right.

1:25 That's the best way to avoid and that's the easiest way to avoid taxes altogether is to just literally do nothing. Right. Somebody going to sue you. If you if you do this, you might get sued. Well, if you got a bed, you might get sued, but if you stay in bed, you'll never get sued. But what you know, what's a reasonable risk is the question that we're asking. And so, it gets into tax also planning against is and sometimes you're probably making assessment on not avoiding all risk, but what are reasonable risks to take in exchange for what type of return. So, talk a little bit about how you get involved with that when somebody has an attorney or there's large money involved, how do you help us assess you know, we can we can write this off, we can take this deduction or we can use this plan. There is a risk of it being rejected, there's a risk of being audited, but there's also a reward and then how do we balance that? Yeah, so I mean, we're always walking through different strategies. We also have to look at everybody's business or their real estate investment as far as like what it would be ordinary and necessary within you know, that industry or in within that investment. You don't want to get too wild cuz you know, you have to be able to prove to the IRS if you were to ever get audited, there's a reason that you're doing what you're doing and it's not just simply to avoid taxes cuz that's not a good answer to give to them cuz they'll just throw it out the window. Right. So, there's a lot of you know, you and you I'll give you an example. I had a client who will remain anonymous. They are going to sell their business and of course, they didn't tell me they were going to sell their business until about 30 days out and they had already been working with their estate planning attorney and the estate planning attorney called me and said, "Hey, can we just throw all their shares in this South Dakota trust and avoid California tax altogether on this you know, more than $10 million sale?" And I was like, "No."

3:17 Well, you can. You can throw it in there and you can not pay the tax up front. You can do that.

3:25 You can do that and then when California comes knocking in a year or two and says, "Hey, you know, you did this just to try and avoid California tax on a California business and you live here in California, we're going to need all our money back plus all the penalties and interest." It's not a fun conversation to have with client. So, you know, so there's you know, risk that's crazy and obviously it's completely up to client. If they still want to go that route and do that's fine, that's up to them, but I'm going to tell them up front like this is what you're risking and that you are very high risk for being audited and the likelihood is going to be high and you're going to lose. So we're constantly strategically looking at everything case by case cuz not everything's a blanket statement. So, One of the common misconceptions people make or they do have their do-it-themselves estate plan is rather than do a plan, they'll just decide while we have one child, I might as well just deed them on the property. And so, I add on my favorite daughter or only daughter, only child to the property and while that might avoid probate and it might not avoid probate, it may allow them to control their life and then you're not. There's there can be some serious tax consequences to that decision.

4:44 Yes, there is some serious tax consequences. So, a lot of people do this out of the goodness of their heart. I mean, they're trying, you know, they think what they're doing is smart and actually lowering their risk and in case anything happens, you know, the kids are able to take over and shouldn't just say the kids, the beneficiaries are able just take over their property, no problem with their assets, no problem, you know, the court's not going to come in and question anything. Which in one regard is a good strategy as far as like thinking that way, but it creates huge tax consequences later on. So, something that we commonly see is where parents do this where they deed over a property 20 years, 30 years before they pass and it's in the kids's name and they don't realize that at point when they're deeding the property over to the kids, the value of the property as of that date is transferred over to the kids. And so, 30 years later when they pass and the kids want to sell the property, they don't get a step up to the fair market value of basis for full 100% because their names are deeded already on the property. So, they've taken this now they have this huge tax gain usually, especially here in California, which is where we are cuz our property goes up like crazy. And now the kids owe all these taxes on the sale of this property when it could have just simply been put into a trust strategically, transferred over to the kids or the trust as of the date of passing, the kids were able to do what they needed to do with their trust, sell it and usually would have ended up with no capital gain at all or no tax. So, they could have, you know, inherited that property tax free. And we see it a lot. It's time and time again. And like I said, the parents are trying to do it out of the goodness of their heart, but it's not the always the correct thing to do. It's usually not the correct thing to do. So, And I think you were talking about properties with hundreds of thousands of dollars, it has to be worth getting tax advice, you know, and legal advice and it's not going to cost but a fraction of

6:47 That, maybe 1% or less to just get some good advice as to what to do. But I see the same thing where people tell me, "Oh yeah, we don't need an estate plan. I already deeded the property to my daughter or my mom deeded it to me right you know, but right before she passed." Like, "Oh, okay. So, she deeded you know, half of that million dollar property you know, a month ago before she passed. Well, now you got to pay taxes on that you know, half million dollars and that could be a lot of money. And then and by the way, if you have no other assets, now you have to sell the property to pay the taxes. So, that's a whole 'nother area of problems that creates for us. Yeah, it creates quite a few tax issues and you know, at the time when the people are like, "Oh, I don't want to call a CPA or call the attorney cuz it could be a couple of grand sit down and have like, you know, an honest conversation with them." However, let's just say there is a $500,000, you know, capital gain. Here in California, it's a you know, probably a 20% fed tax rate there plus probably a 6 or 7% maybe even higher California tax depending on where your income is falling. So, you know, 26 or 27% on $500,000, you would be at, you know, a $125,000 tax bill, $135,000 tax bill. Whereas had you paid $2,000

8:03 To maybe had some advice from both the attorney and the CPA, could have saved you know, $100,000, which is obviously a significant savings. Right. And so, I think sometimes people look at the expensive advice as being expensive, they don't realize that expensive advice can save you a lot more money. I'm always I'm always amazed when I sit in meetings with clients and I'll see like, you know, a team of attorneys, there'll be a CPA there and then there'll be like the probate attorney and there'll be like the estate planning attorney and like the special tax guy on the point on that team and they're like, how much money are they spending per hour for this meeting? And then the guy describes how they use some tax shelter to or not shelter, but system and structure to avoid, you know, like a million dollars in taxes. I'm thinking, "Well, that paid for all the attorneys." He's like, "Yes."

8:51 Right? I mean, that's It's true. And sometimes even along the way if, you know, the client has a way to write off those fees, they're really not even spending the full cost of the check that they're sending cuz now they're getting tax savings on you know, you know, hiring the attorneys and the CPAs or strategists to come in and help with those things. So, usually at the benefit much so outweighs the cost. And one of the topics you have talked about before are Delaware statutory trusts or DSTs. And that's one of those things that you know, I as a real estate invest as a real estate investor and Realtor®, I've been conditioned to push 1031 exchanges. One of my mentors in business who's a huge real estate investor said he never uses it. Because while it's a great tax strategy, it's a terrible real estate investment strategy. Why? Because you have to identify three properties, you always make your money on the buy, it's always hard to find the property. So, if you need to and identifies two and three and if one's not available, you now settled for a less desirable on the buy side. And so, you know, in his strategy he just pays the taxes because he figures he'll you know, pay them eventually and he Here are the strategies he uses. But DSTs are one of the things that just sound too good to be true when people present them to me. Yet when I look at the investment brochures they include some of you know, really good investment opportunities, some really fine properties, they're all way cash flowing and such. Talk a little bit about your clients that use DSTs effectively and how do you see that as a tool in the toolbox?

10:28 They can be great investment strategies. Like you said, some of them cash flow very well. You know, especially ones that are like in storage units or in the very large warehouses such as Amazon buildings or huge multi-family unit properties. Those do cash flow very well. They are not meant for everyone. You know, because people have to understand that when they do Let's say they do a 1031 or they just straight up invest in those DSTs. Your cash is usually locked up for a certain period of time and you don't have access to it for a certain period of time. And if you do withdraw the cash, if they do allow you to at certain point, there's usually a huge penalty cuz you're withdrawing it early. So then you're giving up a lot. So, it is not for everyone. I don't think for most people who just you know, maybe have one single-family residential rental on the side or even a couple and they're just trying to avoid tax and they're like, oh, you know, maybe it's DSTs is a good option. Those usually aren't the ones that I'm you know, pushing a DST on. More of my families that have many multiple properties and usually the commercial properties and they're just really wanting to invest in something else that's going to grow and they don't need the cash. They have so much money that it just doesn't matter. Then we can look at DSTs as an option. And that's when I say, "Okay, well, you're tired of managing things. You don't really need the cash and if you want to you know, look at this as an option to avoid the tax you can. I just always put it as an option. I don't push them. But I have some clients that have made pretty good money off of them and some that have just made okay money. But I've never had a client that's lost money.

12:06 So. Yeah, these seem to be seem to be more like mutual funds you know, on cash flowing type of companies that are established and they seem to get you know, 7 8% returns regularly, maybe 10 or 12, sometimes three in a bad market. You have to get home runs. I think you hit the key term when somebody's tired of managing the property cuz the scenario I see is somebody who has five or more you know, multi-family properties and they built that business over 30 40 years and now they're in their 60s or 70s and they don't want to collect the rent themselves and the days of evicting people have changed. They don't want to do it that anymore. And so here this they love real estate and here's a way to be involved with properties or the next generation where you know, father built the business as multi-family specialist or industrial specialist, but the kids just don't have the training to manage the business. Yes. Yeah, that's a huge thing too is a lot of you know, just because you know how to do something doesn't mean your kids know how to do something just as equally. And especially I mean you as a parent also really need to assess your kids and if you're not teaching them along the way, you should probably be questioning them as you're doing your estate planning and your trust planning to see if they're really capable of taking on what you've invested in the past or if you should start getting that stuff ready to set up. Maybe the DST is a good option to be invested in knowing that you know, you may pass at a certain time or getting close to that time.

13:36 And your kids can inherit something that is just hands-off for them. Like it's just cash flowing and that's all that they're capable of. And it's just an honest truth that you have to have with yourself and not everybody's ready for that all the time or wants to face it, but it's a reality that comes up whether we like it or not.

13:55 Yeah. Yeah. We're not we're not here to control it when we when we leave. So, you know. And I also think it's a way for that next generation to play in real estate without having you know, they don't have to take on the whole thing cuz their father did. They don't really know much about it, but they might like the idea of being in real estate and so it seems there's a variety of different DST programs whether it be multi-family, industrial, storage as you mentioned. You know, AI centers are the big one now all of a sudden that you know, they these things seem to run in flavor of the month kind of things. So, I think certain investors are hot in they seem to pitch these things. You know, I know that in talking to you have a number of your clients are related to construction and I found out from talking to you one time the reason why is I think your father was a contractor or had some sort of contracting business. So, you kind of know that business and language. So, talk about the advantage of being an accountant with some specific industry specialty where you can really speak the language of the business owners. Yeah, I mean I grew up my dad was a pipeline contractor. He did water lines and sewer lines for municipalities and cities as I was growing up and you know we watched him as kids. Like he had four daughters, there's no sons, but still you know, he took us over to the job sites and even during college I spent some time with him out on the field and worked with him during the summer and then I would work with my mom in the office during school. So, I got to learn the background of things and it's really important because when a when a contractor is speaking to you and they're talking about equipment or risk or certain insurances or bonding that they have to have.

15:34 If you don't understand that, you can get lost in the conversation and your eyes start to glaze over and you're just like, I don't even know what you're talking about, but let's just focus on the tax and on the accounting numbers. And they don't have an appreciation for you because you're not speaking to them in their language. So, you have to understand all the things that are going on around them. And you have to be very blunt and honest with them. I mean, they do contracts for work. It's just like an attorney, they have to be able to read a lot of legal jargon. And so they're not stupid people. They can make really easy decisions on their own. They're not going to call you for every little thing and be like, "Hey, you know, I need to save five bucks this week. Should I go buy a printer?" No. That's not what they're calling you for. But they are going to call you know, for a million dollar contract that they're doing or a multi-million dollar contract. They need to know big picture. And you also have to be able as their advisor to be not only blunt and straightforward with them, but to not back off because they do have strong personalities because they are dealing with governments and big companies and those people have lots of lawyers and attorneys coming at them all the time. Like I said with the contracts, I mean, they're getting books, you know, they're this thick that they got to read through. So, you have to be able to be a strong person and really know what you're talking about and be assertive because otherwise they'll just run all over you.

16:56 So. Yeah. So, it's it is very helpful. And I've even been in rooms before where with other accountants who don't have that background and I've had to tell them "Hey, the client's eyes are glazing over and they're just getting frustrated and annoyed with you. You need to stop talking about you know, QuickBooks software.

17:16 They don't care. We're going to talk about the real issue at hand. That's your issue. That's not their issue. So, you have to be able to understand that stuff. So. So, you know, as we speak, you know, I've been in real estate for decades and you know, I see a lot of changes from paper to fax machines to you know, online changing things to in the last year it just seems like everything's just compressed. Like the rate of change seems 10 times faster and speeding up not slowing down. I think sometimes you're you know, you're in a situation where you go, "Okay, I can deal with this stress." and it picks up faster. And I'm not saying it in a negative way. But and but the industries around us are changing very quickly. And I know that there's a common you know, strategy which is it's not that AI is going to replace me, it'll replace the average person or below average, but it'll but it'll help hopefully by using this properly to be more effective, productive, valuable to my clients and leverage my time. Talk a little bit about your strategy on using some of these new changing AI tools. I know some of it is the vendor you use on your software, hopefully they're integrating it into their software. At the same time on your own you have to analyze things. Talk a little bit about how you're integrating these changes technology to your business and kind of what your strategy is going forward.

18:33 Sure. So we use it a lot within a lot of our softwares that we use to help us find the answers more efficiently. I don't 100% rely on AI, but it's a good starting point when we're doing a lot of research and confirming things that I already know. It's much quicker to get answers now. It's not like researching, you know, 10 15 years ago where you used to have to go back through all the libraries. You know, I can throw something into, you know, Google AI and it gives me back a at least a good minimum answer and then I can go from there. We also use it a lot within like our softwares where we're sending and receiving things from clients. Gathering delivery processes so that way people know every step of the way, "Hey, I'm missing something." Or you know, "Okay, you're done uploading things." And it makes that more efficient with the client rather than "Okay, hold on. Let me go back through all your documents. Let's make sure." And then 48 hours later I'm giving you an answer. So, we're trying to be able to get answers faster to the clients and we have to because other industries are faster. They need their answers quicker. And on the other hand, you know, a lot of companies use AI to answer the phones and then you end up in this circular thing where you can never get a hold of anybody and talk to anyone. And I personally hate that. I know all my family members hate that. So, we've gone we've stayed the old-school way where we do have live people answering the phones. We would do not have AI you know, generated people answering the phones. Even to get you to the right department. I always have somebody answering the phone. And if it's after hours, it does, you know, we still do leave the voicemail and my assistants will pick it up in the morning.

20:19 But I like, you know, a brain there. I don't want people get frustrated and annoyed that they can't talk to a live person. So. You know, I think business can be kind of like, you know, any other industry where there be different levels and you as an entrepreneur decide where you want to fit. You know, there's places that we make hamburgers cuz you want to run to McDonald's real quick and they hand you a Big Mac and you're able to run out the door. There's a place that make, you know, fast food and there's other places that make a gourmet burger and then you have to decide where you want to be. And I think your answering the phones is a big one cuz I know for me, you know, I'm so frustrated when I get to the to a person finally and they tell they tell me it's the wrong person like I'm an idiot. I'm like, you know, I answered your phone tree eight different ways, you know,

20:58 Right? And so somebody so Exactly. And so I think that's one of the things that I see in real estate. A lot of real estate agents using a lot of technology to answer phone and text. Like to qualify you via text. I'm thinking, why can't I just ask those questions to get them to the same spot more effectively? And if it can replace me, I guess I'm not very good, you know, I mean I don't I don't believe there's any AI that's going to replace me today on things that I do. And I better work hard to make sure that's the case. So. Yeah, it's true. Like I don't believe in AI is going to replace me at least in my lifetime. You know, possibly a hundred years from now. I don't know where we'll be then. But yes, the AI can replace some of the lower jobs, you know, as far as scanning easy documents like I was telling you about earlier like W-2s and 1099s. I obviously, you know, don't have to hand input all of those items anymore. But you know, the one thing that AI doesn't have yet is it's not able to read your personality, your family's dynamics, and what's going on in you know, internally. It can only just see the numbers. So, you know, I hear a lot of people they are like, oh, I get I get phone calls all the time. Well, I ChatGPT what it should tell me to do or how to invest my money and this is the answer it gave me. And I'm like, yeah, it's giving you the answer based on the number numerical information you put in there. But it doesn't know your goals.

22:25 It doesn't know your family history. It doesn't know how many kids you have and what you plan on doing with those kids. It doesn't know your kids' personalities or what your kids know. So, you know, the answers it's giving you actually may not be the correct ones for you. So, yes, it's good that you're starting to look and use those research tools to get some ideas, but you should all take that still to a professional who actually knows the right questions to ask. Right. Because that's just a starting point. Yes, like you can start there, but that doesn't mean that's where you're going to end up with the right place to be at. I also find that cuz I know I'm using these tools at a deeper level. Just to use your example, you know, a consumer at home used ChatGPT to ask one question and another then they ask these intimate financial questions which are influenced by the prior questions they have. And so ChatGPT is kind of assuming their demographic versus as professionals we should have all of the financial information. You know, kind of real estate I can update all the actual information on my specific property and my specific neighborhood that I'm talking about to give me very specific answer because I have the tool and I have the preparation and I'm doing this all the time. I've perfected the questions to ask. I think sometimes these tools is kind of like a like a shotgun. Yeah, you can shoot somebody with it. You may or may not want to if you just want to defend yourself and I think that's kind of these tools are very powerful in helping us with the right preparation and the right training and the right usage and experience. But they're also can like you say just give random answers. I see all the time in my case, you know, I do listing descriptions and I've been, you know, customizing my description tool because it was just default. It would just guess. It was a probate or not. It would say, oh, yeah, it's a probate. And oh, and somebody died in the house. No, that was the last listed thing. So, I've instructed it, you know, only if this form is here is it a probate and only if the death cert is there to discuss the death of the decedent. And it's one of those things where, you know, you can spit out an answer

24:27 And get in a lot of trouble. You know, cause a lot of problems for yourself. So. Yeah, you got to you got to be able to read it, too. Like the answers that it's giving you and you analyze what it's giving you. If you don't have a history and you don't understand it, you're not educated in that area, you don't know if the answer it's giving you back is correct. Yeah. I mean, even it's got and it does it keeps getting smarter, which is great. But I can tell you when I when I first started using it for research, I was double-checking it versus what was really going on. And I remember ChatGPTing a specific rule that had come out and it had the date wrong that it that it actually got implemented. It was off by two years. Right. So, had I gone off the ChatGPT answer, I actually would have totally led the client down the wrong higher ethical path.

25:15 You can't just rely on it. It's a common problem where if it doesn't know the answer, they're just throwing data. And it's like, you know, that should tell everybody here. You know, you have to give very specific instructions, but you got to watch it cuz it wants to give you an answer that you're going to like. And imagine what your life would be if somebody just told you everything you wanted to hear. You are you kidding me? Like I can have ice cream and cookies all day long and there's no health consequences? And ChatGPT sure enjoy it. And the ChatGPT feels like it's your friend, but you know, it's like that friend who encourages you to do what you shouldn't do. And so you be careful there. Yeah. It's not a true friend cuz a true friend is going to give you the honest truth.

25:54 Exactly. Yeah, unfortunately. Or your Stop eating cookies and ice cream. Well, or your spouse as it turns out who theoretically should be a friend, but you know, it depends what day it is when it goes. I look now I got a little long here on our time. I really enjoyed our time together and as always and I think that you really do a great job. I think sometimes of obviously you got to crunch the tax code, give people their answers, but at the same time I think understanding their circumstances and being part of the team. So, for somebody who wants to get in touch with Natalie or her team, California Professional Well, Accountants and the website is calproaccountants.com. And oh, I'm on I keep I keep going to the page with your team. I'm there's the main page. There's the phone number if you want to find if you want to get some specific information, give her a call, talk to the team members to get the details and the emails below and the contact information. Natalie, thank you so much for joining us today and sharing kind of your insights. I think more importantly the feeling that accountants don't have to just be bookworms in the back room crunching numbers, but should really be able to integrate with us and help us understand our goals and our particular features. It's true. There's more to life than spreadsheets.

27:04 Imagine that. And more life than and then AI, too, as well. Natalie, thank you so much. Have a great weekend. Thank you for your time today. And for the rest of you, this is Estate Planning Weekly. We get together every week with new episode. Usually with the estate planning attorneys or important vendors on our team to be more effective in our jobs. If I can help in any way, please reach out at Bill Gross Probate on social media. As always, make today your best day ever.

More The Estate Planning Podcast episodes

Related

Educational media, not legal advice. Guest views are their own. Hosted by Bill Gross, The LA Probate Expert, a licensed California real estate broker (DRE #01022275) brokered by eXp Realty of California, Inc. (DRE #01878277). Bill is not an attorney and is not a Probate Referee.

Schedule Consultation