Episode summary

Bill Gross talks with Alan Fruitman, founder of 1031tax.com and author of The NNN Triple Net Property Book, about using a 1031 exchange to move from hands-on property into passive income.

Alan explains why investors exchange instead of cashing out, and the idea of '1031 until you die': keep deferring, and the heirs may receive a stepped-up basis. Bill notes that many heirs are not suited to manage property they inherit.

Alan describes how to avoid a failed exchange: do the research while the sale is in escrow, close 30 to 45 days after contingencies are removed, and try to close the replacement property well before day 45, with backups identified if needed.

They also cover what triple net means in Alan's book, the tenants and locations he looks for, long lease terms, and how his team sends clients lists of properties nationwide.

Key points

  • A 1031 exchange lets an investor keep more money working by deferring tax on a sale.
  • Heirs who do not want to manage property may be better served by passive triple-net property.
  • Most of the work on a replacement property should happen before the sale closes.
  • Try to close the replacement property well before the 45-day identification deadline, and identify backups if you cannot.
  • Good fundamentals still matter most: location, a strong tenant, and a long lease.

Questions answered in this episode

What is a 1031 exchange?

Bill Gross and Alan Fruitman describe it as a way to defer taxes on the sale of one investment property by putting the proceeds into another, so the money stays invested and keeps compounding. Watch at 0:41

What does '1031 until you die' mean?

Alan says that if you keep exchanging until you die, your heirs may receive a stepped-up basis, depending on the size of the estate, and inherit the property without the deferred tax. Watch at 2:02

How do you avoid a failed 1031 exchange?

Alan recommends using the time while your property is under contract to research replacement properties, then closing 30 or 45 days after your contingencies expire instead of a week or two later, so you have time to secure the new property. Watch at 6:11

What if the replacement property is not closed by day 45?

Alan says the safest plan is to close the replacement well before day 45. If that is not possible, identify backup properties as an emergency plan. Watch at 8:38

What does triple net mean?

Alan says that in his book, triple net means the tenant covers everything, including taxes, insurance, HVAC, roof, structure, and parking lot. Watch at 12:10

What makes a good triple-net property?

Alan looks for a great location, such as a main retail corridor, and a strong tenant that the internet and AI will not replace, with lease terms usually of 10 to 20 years plus renewal options. Watch at 14:45

Transcript

Transcript generated from YouTube's automatic captions for this episode and lightly cleaned (filler words and repeated words removed, names and web addresses corrected; phone numbers and email addresses read on air are replaced with a placeholder; [unclear] marks words the captions did not capture). It may still contain transcription errors, and speaker labels are not included. Timestamps link to that point in the video, which is the authoritative record.

Editor's note: 1031 exchange rules are strict and the details depend on your situation. This is general information, not tax or legal advice; work with a qualified intermediary, your CPA, and an attorney before selling.

0:02 So many real estate investors, as they get older and when they pass property down, realize that their heirs may not be suitable for it. Or if they pass, their inheritors aren't suitable to manage a property. They don't have the experience of what to do. There's possible tax consequences, legal consequences. A great solution for many is tax deferral through 1031 exchange, which can be very complicated. And frankly, as a broker, it's been nothing but difficult for me. But a man who not only has a solution, but wrote the book on that solution. He wrote the book called the net the NNN for a triple net triple net property book, Alan Fruitman of 1031tax.com. Thanks for joining us today.

0:41 Bill, nice to speak with you again, and thank you for having me on your podcast. So, the first piece of the puzzle, I think, is fairly well understood that a 1031 exchange is a way to defer taxes on the sale of one property by taking the profits into another property and not paying taxes unless and until you sell that one. That's Is that a short version of what 1031 does?

1:02 That's a short version. Yes. I think the reason people want to 1031 exchange as opposed to cashing out and paying the taxes is simple. It's compound earning. If you If you keep your money in real estate investments, your money will compound. If you're in the wrong property, a property that you don't want to manage, you don't want to own, it's too big, too small, the wrong location, tenants are difficult,

1:32 The location's not as good as it used to be, 1031 exchange out of the old property and into we'll call it a solution, a replacement property, is very effective.

1:45 And theoretically, you could end up never paying the taxes in that you can keep trading it up. And then, when you pass, subject to certain limits, the taxes are eliminated when the property's passed to your heirs given the current tax law in California and United States, correct?

2:02 Yeah. There is an old expression that says 1031 till you die. So, if you sell a property, all your taxes would be due if you 1031 until you die. Your heirs will get step up in basis and will be no taxes. Again, just depending on the size of your estate, but it's so not a nice little estate, your the heirs will inherit the property with no taxes.

2:34 And just to put a pin in it then, it's really like saying you could pay taxes now or you could take the tax money you're not paying and invest that with your profits in the next property and maybe never pay taxes if depending on your strategy, but that would be the goal 1031 until you die. It seems to me you're now taking your tax dollars and investing them and living off of the profits of that, especially if you never end up paying taxes on it.

2:56 Exactly. Exactly. You're Whoever inherits your property will appreciate you're not selling and paying all the capital gains tax.

3:05 And the reason why is we get what's called a step-up and we do on probate cases and in trusts, we do it, you know, date of death appraisal and based on that, the property is acquired at the new stepped-up basis and so all those taxes are forgiven in a sense, subject to certain limitations and I'm not giving tax advice, I'm just saying that's the strategy many brokers know. Now, here's the problem. It sounds great and for every real estate broker we started when we heard this the first time we had a commercial prospect go, "This is great. We'll do a 1031 exchange." It's great until it's not and the process for me was the client had to identify three properties that they would be glad to trade into. And I heard this said by one of my mentors, Grant Cardone. He says he never 1031s exchanges. Why? Because what he found was that he always named three properties, he never got the one he liked best. The second one was always a compromise at best. And the third one he's in a rush to name three and he's put one in that the end he never really liked. And so in his case, he cashed out. Now, you give an alternative to that which is you can maybe take properties that you like, but it's not as complicated meaning you've your due diligence period is much shorter or can be much shorter because you're buying something that is already established and creating triple net income investment yields to the investor, correct?

4:31 That is correct. But, can I can I kind of work backwards a little bit? Please. You're You wrote the book, so I'm just trying to get it out of you, but yes.

4:41 Your friend who doesn't like temporary 1031 exchanges there's a good reason why. And the reason is he didn't have good advice. So, what does that mean having good advice? In my world, for my clients, what I recommend is when your property is under contract, the property you're selling is under contract, you should be doing a lot of work with an expert broker. Whether it's me or somebody else who's an expert in 1031 exchange and replacement property for that exchange, specifically, when you sell a property, there's a contingency period. Almost every sale has that. So, let's say it's a 30-day or 45-day contingency or inspection period. And after that expires, you have a gap of time between when the contingencies expire and the earnest money deposit becomes completely non-refundable and when you close. So, if you have a good strategy in place, you don't just accept the offer from a buyer. I'll leave the when you sell a property, the terms of the price of the property, I'll leave it up to the seller. But I'll give advice on how to structure it, so it's very 1031 exchange friendly.

6:11 Here's how that works. When your contingency period expires, instead of closing a week or two later, you close 30 or 45 days later. And in that gap of time, and even before that, while your while your property's under contract and before the contingencies expire, I call that the research time. You're window shopping, you're studying, you're reading my book, you're talking to me, you're looking at properties that you can exchange into. That magic date, when the contingencies expire and the deposit becomes non-refundable, that's what I call a green lights day. Because you have the green light to go secure a new property. And as long as your contingencies on the acquisition don't expire until your closing date, so you won't So, let's today is June 4th. If you're selling a property and your contingency period expired today, June 4th. Let's say you close 30 days later, July 4th. You can use that month to find a property, put it under letter of intent, put it under contract. You have a 30-day contingency period after the contract is signed.

7:34 So, worst-case scenario, you keep the deposit on your sale, but If buyer doesn't show up for closing, you terminate the replacement property before you before that identification period expires. No big loss. And that's your worst-case scenario. Best-case scenario, everything on your sale happens perfectly. You close, you have a 30-day gap. In that 30-day gap, I'll repeat it again, you do a letter of intent, you do a contract, you begin your due diligence period. In a perfect world, you close that replacement property as long before day 45. On a temporary one exchange, you have a 45-day identification deadline and 180 days to close. And the start date for both periods is the same on the same start date. So, in a perfect world, you close because you did all this work up front. And you close your replacement property long before day 45.

8:38 Right. Go back to your friend and his dilemma. He found property, it wasn't the right property, or wasn't available. Lots of reasons why it didn't work. But the real reason it didn't work is his timeline itself. If he closed that property long before day 45, there's no identification anymore. It assumes it's done. So, if you don't close before day 45, yes, you should put backup properties down as an emergency. But the people that plan ahead and do all of the work up front, they're the ones who are protected. And they'll change your close if for some reason during due diligence there's a problem, and there's a mineral, survey, something that pops up, you have a good recovery time. You get out of that property, which is probably less than 1 or 2%. 1 or 1 or 2% in time. Very small

9:33 Or negotiate an extension. They might be willing to extend it. You know, if they if they understand you have problems on the other end and it's being resolved, they might give you an extension for weeks or whatever.

9:42 Well, let's say that there's a problem that you can't resolve. Now, because you did all the work up front, you get title to that property. Right. And you have time to secure new property well before That's how you That's how you protect yourself and make sure you get a good property and you don't get squeezed.

10:01 Well, I think the reason why Grant Cardone is against 1031s is he is a developer. When he's buying a property, it's almost always acquiring very large value add, but also you have permitting and all that, which by nature the due diligence for development is much longer than an existing property that's gen- on a triple net lease that's generating income currently. It's already the you know, you're buying a property with a Wendy's on it or McDonald's is there's a lease, there's a payment. It the due diligence is way different than if you're trying to buy a property and say, "Can we remodel the units and what are the apartments going to go for and you know, what permitting is involved? Can we add more units to it?" So, again, the strategy I think is in this strategy, your strategy is particularly I think appropriate in my world where the father typically is a real estate investor. He had a thesis. He had a strategy of a certain geography, South LA, Long Beach area in Southern California. A certain product type, industrial properties, multi-families. And they could work through the problems with scare most people off. That was their gift. That was their strength. But when they pass or when they get older, the next generation might be smart, might have good common sense, but they don't have that skill.

11:22 And so, now you have these they can't continue the same system father had. What do they do? Well, they don't want to pay taxes. Who wants to pay taxes on all that? But you can play the stock market and get some returns after paying taxes. Or, your strategy thing is ideal for that family member where they're going to just get returns. They're triple net by definition. They're just get They're putting money in and they're going to get a monthly return or quarterly return or whatever it is. And it's very appropriate for a particular person either aging out and doesn't want to continue to work, I think, or the next generation. Is that What's your profile of customer who does who transfers to 1031s triple net look like, too?

12:01 Yes, the it's not for the land developer, let's say. Totally different Right.

12:10 Type of buyer. The skillset of the buyer. My clients who want to buy a triple net lease property, let me define it for those who don't understand what triple net lease means. A triple net lease property means it's tenants. In my book, you know, if you ask a couple of brokers, you'll get a different answer. But, in my book, triple net means everything. Taxes, insurance, HVAC, roof, structure, parking lot, everything. When you have a triple net lease, when any of those items become a problem that need to be renewed, the tenants can't fix it themselves. They're going to pay for it. They're going to going to coordinate it. Everything. So, the profile for a triple net lease buyer is somebody who wants passive income. Maybe a professional, a doctor or a lawyer. Maybe somebody that's retiring and taken an apartment building that they've nurtured for decades who are retired from the management, the maintenance, and the tenants, and the vacancies, and even if you have a property manager, you have to manage your manager. So, the profile for a triple net lease investor is somebody who wants to buy a triple net lease property. It's somebody that wants passive income. It's really simple. Maybe older you're retiring, but that's the target client.

13:32 I think the other examples I've seen people buying selling and then buying passive income the other example is professional owned his office building, sold his practice and sold the building as part of the sale. And had you know tremendous gain on the building. And a tremendous potential tax liability. But he wasn't going to go open another medical practice you know and this is his veterinary practice and he cashed out into property that deferred the taxes, let him keep that money. But he got monthly income and that's really what he wanted. He didn't want to practice anymore and that worked out for him. So just talk a bit about then I know that in talking to you when we prepared and I've met you talked to you a few times that you have availability of properties across the United States which is another advantage right for people who you know I like I live in LA. If I'm retiring I'm probably moving I would think to Florida if I had to guess. I used to live there. I wouldn't want to have to keep stuck with a property in Los Angeles for sure if I can't keep my eyes on it. So you operate across country and are able to find people an opportunity in another state. And talk a little bit about what that shopping process looks like.

14:45 Yes. I maintain a list of properties I mean my team and I there's five of us behind the scenes that do that help put together what my clients see on a daily basis. So every day or once a week or once a month depending on the frequency that the client wants. I email daily list of properties all across the country. So there's no real geographic preference but only preference would be a great location. A great location might be the main corridor when you have Home Depot and Target and Chase Bank and McDonald's and all the national players that lined up on that retail corridor, that's where we'd like to be. And maybe near a university or a big hospital or a highway exit, that prime location. So, nationwide, prime location, national tenant, and usually with a corporate guarantee, it could be a Chick-fil-A and Chipotle and McDonald's and Chase Bank and AutoZone and Home Depot and Target and Walmart. These are the properties that my clients buy. And when they buy them, they have the parent company as the guarantor of the lease in most cases. Some are franchise guaranteed, but most are corporate.

16:10 And the leases are the primary term of the leases is between 10 and 20 years, and every lease will have renewal options. Most tenants are there for many decades. And if the tenant vacates, time is your friend in real estate. So, if history repeats itself, the value of the property should go up over time. So, if the tenant vacates, in fact, in my book, here's what my book looks like. I wrote the book, it's called The NNN Triple Net Property Book. And in my book, I have a chapter called The Two Happiest Days. Oh, there it is. The two happiest days of owning triple net properties. First happiest day is the day you buy it. Cuz you have a long stream, decades of uninterrupted The second happiest day, assuming you picked a good location, is when your tenant vacates. Because you get, let's say it's 2026. Your tenant has a 20-year lease, and they vacate 2036. So, the question is, how much will rent be in 2046? And the answer is, I don't know. But if history repeats itself, it should be significantly more than it is in 2026. So if they vacate in 2046, you can reach an empty car but you will sell it vacant and the expectation would be to have a nice income and an appreciation from when you acquired the property.

17:40 Yeah, the big players, you know, they're smart and they get you know, good leases typically back when they place it. Not to say below market but they don't overpay and they get good terms cuz they're quality tenants and they're desirable. But yeah, like you say, they lock in certain numbers 20 years ago. I would take a look at the other way. What were rents like in LA in 2006 that are now expiring in 2026. They may have had a 10-year lease with two 5-year options. And I'm a broker for a commercial property management company and I can tell you those longer leases, you know, sometimes you have cost of living raises. Sometimes, you know, you have caps. The larger tenants usually a little tougher negotiators. They're you know, they have teams of people who are pretty darn good. They're not going to overpay for the property. But when they leave, now you're releasing something that you wrote the contract in 2006. You never imagined the property would be as much as it is today and that's just any property you think about 20 years ago. You never would imagine they'd be worth what it is today.

18:45 How old is your friend? It's an old adage that has just tried and true in the real estate. How old is your friend? Well, look, I think that this is one of those kind of niches that, you know, on one hand, I can only you know, get so deep on and I don't give tax advice so I'm not in a position to do that legal advice. But I can say I think it's a great alternative. I literally had a customer call me yesterday and gave me your number. I don't know if they called followed up or whatever. You never know how works out but certainly I would say anybody who is in a situation where they have a property they have to sell with a significant tax liability, of course, you want to have good, you know, representation on your tax situation, your legal situation. But, the triple net is a way to go from a very active, hands-on investment strategy to a passive one where you can collect income and still appreciate enjoy the appreciation. Alan Miller literally wrote the book on the subject, the triple net property book. In fact, you can get the book or get is it e-format or to buy it? What Let me just see what kind of I'll click on it here. I So, they gave me a copy of it a while ago.

19:49 What? For any investor that comes to my website or if you're interested in buying triple net property, call me or fill out the contact form. I'll mail a free copy of my book to you.

20:00 There you go. Or, if you want to be anonymous and you want to read the book, on Amazon, I you have to make a profit, so I make it one penny a book. So, it's I think $4 $4.05 at one penny a book cost on Amazon if you want to be stealth and read it before you contact me. I'm just

20:24 And really, having read through Have you read the book and having read through your website, I think I would I don't mean to put it down, but I would say it's really just good solid fundamentals. I mean, at the end of the day, real estate has always been about certain fundamentals, cash flow and good accounting and good locations and proven types of properties, right? There's not really magic in it, is there?

20:46 No, there's it's This is real estate. Triple net property is real estate. So, what do you want in real estate? You want a good location. What else do you want? You want a solid tenant that is bankable, that can pass the test of time. We want We look for tenants that Amazon and the internet and AI won't replace. When you're hungry and you're driving down the street, you're not going to replace McDonald's and Chipotle and Taco Bell. Those are every type of tenants that the internet can't replace. So, this is it all comes back to real estate. And the better your tenant, the more stable your investment.

21:33 Well, again, Alan is the author, and 1031tax.com is the website and if you want to reach him [phone number]. Feel free if you can't write this down cuz you're driving or something, reach out to me. I'll be more glad to make a introduction. I've had pleasure of speaking with Alan a few times as well as his son and really enjoy their perspective I think of the market. It's really about I think again, not to put it down but say it's same as mine. Good fundamentals, you work at it hard. He's been in this space for a long time. A lot of people who I think are jump into these businesses and these niches and try to play it but this is a guy who's been doing it for a while. Alan, thank you so much for joining us today. I really appreciate your time.

22:10 Bill, thank you. It was it was really a pleasure being having this conversation with you on the podcast. Thank you. Thanks. And for the rest of you, this is Estate Planning Weekly. We get together every week and talk about how we best serve our clients. Usually with estate planning attorneys but in this case, here's a tool that if you are an estate planning attorney, we're going to talk to one. Talk about this as an option. If you have a property to sell, instead of paying a huge chunk of taxes to Uncle Sam and Uncle California, here's a way that you can defer those taxes maybe forever if you play the game properly. If I can help anyway, please reach out. I'd love your feedback on this episode. I'm at Bogart Probin on social media. As always, make today your best day ever. Thanks so much.

More The Estate Planning Podcast episodes

Related

Educational media, not legal advice. Guest views are their own. Hosted by Bill Gross, The LA Probate Expert, a licensed California real estate broker (DRE #01022275) brokered by eXp Realty of California, Inc. (DRE #01878277). Bill is not an attorney and is not a Probate Referee.

Schedule Consultation