Partition Actions for Inherited Property, with Elijah Underwood
Probate Weekly · · Guest: Elijah Underwood, Underwood Law Firm, P.C.
Episode summary
Bill Gross talks with Elijah Underwood, founder of Underwood Law Firm, P.C., a firm focused on partition actions, partnership disputes and real estate law.
Elijah explains what a partition action is, why it goes back to old English law, and the three common situations: unmarried co-owners who split up, siblings who inherit a house together, and spouses in a drawn-out separation.
He describes how a demand letter often settles things, how his firm prices cases, and how California's newer buyout provision lets a co-owner buy out the others at a value set by the court.
They close on how court-ordered partition sales differ from probate sales and how agents can earn referrals in this niche.
Key points
- Any co-owner of real estate can generally ask a court to partition it, which today almost always means a sale.
- Probate settles who owns an inherited house; it does not settle how co-owning siblings use or sell it.
- A letter or a filed case often pushes a reluctant co-owner to deal, because the outcome is fairly predictable.
- Under California's buyout provision, the court sets a value and the other owners can buy out the one who wants to sell.
- Unlike probate, there is no court overbid; the referee recommends an offer and the judge decides.
Questions answered in this episode
What is a partition action?
Elijah says it lets a co-owner who no longer wants to own property with someone ask a court to divide it. Centuries ago that meant splitting land; today, with single-family houses, it almost always means a court-ordered sale. Watch at 10:24
How does partition come up after a probate?
Elijah says probate decides who owns the house, for example a son and daughter 50/50, but it does not decide what happens next. If one wants to keep it and the other wants to sell, partition is how that gets resolved. Watch at 24:49
Will a letter from an attorney solve it?
Elijah says a letter or the filing of a case often gets the other side to engage, and he makes clear the firm will see the case through until the property is sold. Watch at 14:30
Do partition attorneys work on contingency?
Elijah says his firm offers what it calls a contingency option: it still bills hourly, shows the client the work, and is paid from the sale proceeds at a somewhat higher rate. Clients can also pay monthly. Watch at 16:35
Can one heir buy out the others?
Elijah says a model law aimed at heirs' property came to California and has since been extended to all property. It includes a buyout provision: the court determines the value, possibly with an appraisal, and the other owners get a chance to buy out the owner who wants to sell. Watch at 33:03
Is there an overbid in a partition sale?
No. Elijah says there is no overbid process like probate. The referee generally brings the offer they consider best to the court with a recommendation, the other party can object, and the judge decides. Watch at 45:21
Transcript
Transcript generated from YouTube's automatic captions for this episode and lightly cleaned (filler words and repeated words removed, names and web addresses corrected; phone numbers and email addresses read on air are replaced with a placeholder; [unclear] marks words the captions did not capture). It may still contain transcription errors, and speaker labels are not included. Timestamps link to that point in the video, which is the authoritative record.
Editor's note: This episode was recorded in October 2024. California partition law has changed in recent years; check with a partition attorney for the current rules.
Editor's note: Bill Gross is a California real estate broker, not an attorney. This is general information, not legal advice.
0:03 Welcome to Probate Weekly I'm Bill Gross and we do Probate Weekly.com every Thursday at our new time 9: a.m. Pacific Time 12: noon we also live stream it on Facebook and Linkedin as well as available for recording afterwards on YouTube and various sources on Bill Gross Out gross probate on social media and we talk about topics that are of interest to real estate agents attorneys investors looking to build their business in the Pro real estate space Probate Weekly is the program we have a Facebook group if you miss and want to continue the conversation called Probate Weekly.com easy to find if you're getting this on recording and want to go live you going to Probate Weekly.com and sign up all we need is your email address we'll send you reminders and links to the zoom so you can jump in and ask questions you can also see on your best on your favorite AUD formats and see past episodes on YouTube I'm really excited today to have an attorney Elijah Underwood who is with the Underwood Law Firm you'll know the last name matches up there a little nepotism perhaps we'll find out and in particular reason excited to have him is there are the California's Premier partition lawyers I came across them when they open their office here in La they're known throughout the state in the specific area of partition real estate so we have a chance to talk about that hopefully and learn about more what that means so Elijah thank you so much for joining us today hey Bill great to be back so of all the areas of law to practice in how did you end up focusing in Partition real estate yeah so it's a it's a longer story but I'll try to make get you know get to the point here basically it was I was a partner at a firm I was doing a bunch of different things and you know doing a bunch of different practice areas is kind of like trying to be a decathlete at the Olympics you know maybe you're okay at everything but you're never great at one thing and really what I wanted to do was just be excellent at one thing and around that time I found myself investing in real estate myself I bought
2:05 An apartment building I was meeting I was meeting with a lot of real estate developers and investors as clients and I was really involved with something called the Urban Land Institute which is an organization de devoted to development and improving our Urban spaces I was on the board of the local chapter and you know I just saw my life with you know real estate just loving real estate and real estate people and just finding that I clicked really well with real estate people kind of coming together with the law practice and finding well I don't I don't like this piece where I'm doing 30 different things and some of them I do well and some of them not so well and I just kind of had this realization one day what if I could just do something that I really liked all the time and involv myself with real estate more and more and spend you know not just my free time doing real estate exclusively but also my work life and it just occurred to me that sounds like a great life and it sounds like I would really enjoy it and it was something that I was particularly good at as opposed to other things I'm not particularly good at and so I just kind of had this idea for the firm and it's you know been going ever since you know it's such a great story for all of us but whether an attorney or real estate agent to find an area that I think both you're good at which means you're going to make more money per hour you work you're creating more value for your customers there's more opportunity and also you enjoy doing and I think as real estate agents some of us go through different phases where we love open houses we love door knocking we love cold calling but then we don't and you can design a business by finding a niche that operates differently that's how I got prate real estate so let's talk about par think about think about what your what Your what your readership or viewership may do right so if as a as a real estate licensee right as a real estate salesperson license you can do a lot of things right you could sell you know a single family home in your neighborhood
4:10 Where wherever that may be you know in Long Beach or in Ino or whatever it is right you have your you can be a local expert right but you with that real estate license I mean you could sell Class A office space in Downtown LA you could sell you know oil and gas leases right you could you could do commercial leasing on the Third Street prominade in Santa Monica right you can do a lot of things with a real estate license but most people don't right they are you know they say okay I'm going to specialize in apartment buildings or I'm going to specialize in you know this particular neighborhood in Brentwood or whatever it is right and so that's kind of how I've set up my practice is I just say listen there's some things that I think we're pretty good at we just try to do those things that we think we're best at and everything else we kind of leave to everyone else we talked before we start recording about my brother-in-law who focuses in right industrial property just in Southern California and how he's tremendously successful and one thing I've learned now as I look back my career the people were most successful always had a niche that they both were great at and enjoyed working in and those that combination that you expressed I think is critical so let's talk about specifically partition actions maybe again our average Watcher is G be a real EST estate agent who's maybe investor or deals with investors talk about the basics of what a roate partition action looks like sure so at its most basic you have two or more people who own real estate and one of them wants to sell and another one does not there's a couple main flavors that we commonly see one is you know boyfriend girlfriend buys a house together right anticipating they're going to get married but then you know before they can cross the finish line something happens right and so then they find themselves owning real estate together but wanting nothing to do with each other and you know and especially
6:15 With interest rates being so high recently with home prices increasing in value so recently appreciating so recently you know it's been kind of the house becomes this tug-of-war where one person really wants to say another one does not because they want to move on with their life right you know that's one main flavor another very common flavor is you know a brother and sister inherit Mom and Dad's house in Palos Verdes and you know maybe sister was taking care of Mom for the last seven years and she's kind of built her life in you know Palos Verdes after returning to do that but now that Mom is gone brother and sister own it and brother lives in San Francisco and brother says Hey listen I'd love to sell the mom's house because that could help me pay off my mortgage you know or put one of the kids through college or whatever it is and for sister it's there's some tension because you know she kind of has her life in this house which is now worth I don't know three4 million do right as long as it's not you know one of those ones falling into the sea and so it's you know there's some there's some tension there right there's an issue to work through and then we also have a third main flavor which is Real Estate Investors and Developers so we are doing partitions on industrial property you know Warehouse property here in La Agland and Stockton you know apartment buildings in you know Riverside right multif family so you know we kind of do all of the above when it comes to real estate because if it is real estate in California and you're an owner there's a there's a right to partition so again the three you mentioned are a relationship boyfriend girlfriend in my experience one's kind of bullying the other right they went into it as partners and now they're falling apart and the one says no I' rather keep it and you can't force me to sell the property well they probably can if they know the law and that's why
8:19 We're interviewing you today second being the inherited which is probably through a probate it's probably didn't have proper State planning because now you end up with two siblings fighting over the situation and you know the add the component I think the in your scenario well we'll get to that and the third being a developer so let's go back to the first want to talk about that as real estate agents we've all sold property to people who weren't married we weren going in what are you doing so what does the exit look like you know the girlfriend or boyfriend call you and say hey I'm in this deal and I went out and my former love interest Love Of My Heart a partner for Life a soulmate now has become a rat and can you help extricate me what's that process look like yeah so really a partition action almost you know all partition actions have like you know four main parts right so you file a lawsuit and unlike other types of lawsuits where you accuse somebody of wrongdoing it becomes very personal you know where you breached a contract or you committed fraud or you cheated me or something like that partition lawsuit is very basic it just says you know it has basically two parts one I'm an owner of real estate two I no longer wish to be and three that's it because there's only two parts right it's just a and b I own this real estate I don't want to own it anymore judge let me out it let me out of jail effectively right so the next step is in many instances there's a buyout process provided by Statute that just says Hey listen we're going to come up with a value for the property one person is going to have a right of first refusal to buy the person out if they can't afford it then it's going to go to step three which is a sale which will involve a Realtor® and then once the property is sold goes to step four which is kind of a distribution of the proceeds of the sale right so you know the word partition as you probably guessed comes from the word parts right and
10:24 And so it used to be you know back in Old England that you know two brothers inherited dad Farm you know Dad's 80 acres and they didn't get along together they could go to the judge and say hey judge I own this property with my brother we don't really get along we're cats and dogs you know it's 80 acres you give me the front 40 give him the back 40 it's all the same I just I don't want to be in business with him and so the judge would say okay that sounds fair let's cut that property in half let's cut that property into par let partition that real estate well you know in 2024 and most of us live in you know single family detached ranch style houses and so a judge is not going to you know physically divide he's not going to saw that house in half right that's insane but what a judge will do is sell the whole house and divide the equity into Parts you're partitioning the equity right and so in step four when the proceeds are de are divided between the parties is you know going to start with basically like a 5050 split but also look into okay well who put the down payment where there where there different amounts contributed somebody maybe that the property needed like a sewer upgrade so who paid for that right maybe somebody put it paid for a new bathroom right and we'll go with that whole part so when you have this you know this pot of gold so to speak to be divided the judge will go through all that make divisions according to law and there's a whole bunch of different legal principles involved but effectively at the end just say okay you know instead of a pure 5050 you know it's actually 50 you know 57 43 right or whatever the specific numbers happen to be there are some instances where it can be a true 50/50 but it really just depends on the facts of the case so on the case of the boyfriend girlfriend flavor my experience is the other party you know when they come to me and I'll say well the reality is you can force the sell you have to hire an attorney this petition process I'm not one I'm not giving you legal advice but you might want to go back to your
12:27 Boyfriend and explain to him the facts of law nothing ever happens a high percentage of time then when they hire the partition attorney like you before the lawsuit either a letter sent or a letter with a proposed lawsuit is a filing is sent and in my experience the a couple times we've done that the other party collapsed they don't realize they didn't have the right to hold it forever they looked at the law and said wow I'm really kind of vulnerable here and move forward so I imagine part of your business are is clients come to you and again let's think about specifically boyfriend girlfriend or that kind of individual party partnership are you involved in that or is that an attorne Before You by the time it gets to you we're now on the litigation freeway yeah that's interesting you know I'll tell you from my experience you know and again I used to do lots of different types of law right so I've done you know construction defect and easement issues and you know neighbor disputes and all these things right and so I've you know I've written letters in the past and you know generally by the time it gets to me it you know it's we're way past the letter writing phase right we're way past the talking about it phase because you know you don't need a letter from a lawyer to convince somebody it's real sometimes people just say well I sent them a link to your website said look at this you know this is something we can do and here's who I'm going to hire or whatever it is and still they're not persuaded right so generally the people who come to me there's a serious problem to solve now that said so we'll you know still try to engage in resolving the issue as quickly as possible with a with a sale or whatever so we will follow the lawsuit and then as part of the lawsuit package we include a letter that says Hey listen you know just to let you know this doesn't have to be contentious you can you know call us let us know you want to resolve this amicably work it out we'll drop the
14:30 Paperwork but if you don't you should also know that we're not going to stop until this is sold right so it's kind of got the benefit of the letter where you do want to engage the person and say Hey listen it doesn't have to be this big fight but the benefit of a lawsuit versus a letter is there's legal consequences to not responding to a lawsuit whereas you know a lot of times people will get a letter from a lawyer and they'll just throw it in trash and then the client says to me well I paid you know a couple hundred bucks to write a letter or whatever it was what did I get for my money and all I got was more delay and it sounds like this is a waste of time and then they're disillusioned with the legal process and with lawyers right and they say well you just you just took my money and I got this letter and there's nothing to show for whereas a lawsuit you know they can't just if they throw it in the trash you know there's consequences right the courts going to make a decision and proceed so it puts a clock on things which I think is helpful because it because what we're trying to is actually Force engagement we're saying Hey listen we you know there's this problem we want to figure this out but you know if you don't want to engage with us we've got a plan B and in fact plan the clock is already ticking on Plan B so it would be great if we could work this out you know without all the nonsense and there's probably not an ending where the property isn't sold one way or the other I think that's the thing that people don't understand is that at some you can delay and delay and delay if you're going to spend the money on the lawsuit but it's going to cost you money to delay and at the end of the day you're probably gonna lose I mean there's really not a solution called you get to hang on to it forever because you're obstinate that's not in the law at least so the challenge there though is that boyfriend girlfriend use the first scenario has to write a check to engage an attorney that the contingency has to at least cover the I'm sorry the deposit would have to cover at least the filing cost and to get to a certain phase are
16:35 The I imagine these are cases where you are estimating the case the cost up front and taking deposits it's not on a contingency basis typically is it so we'll do certain cases on contingency and I think I you know use the term a little bit differently than most lawyers use it I think most lawyers who use the term or most people when they think about contingency they think of like a personal injury attorney would take like a third or 40% of whatever the value is so what we do is we'll offer a contingency option we'll still Bill hourly we'll still show the client all the work that we're doing and then you know from the proceeds the client will just agree that you know we get whatever we've build right and so we just charge a little bit of a higher rate because you know we don't we don't lend money for free like the banks don't lend money for free we say listen you know there's a there's a monthly option we could pay on a monthly basis if that doesn't work for you there's an option to pay at the end we just you know the hourly rates are going to be higher you can do either one but you know we try to work with as many people as possible because we know most people do not have you know a pot of money sitting around for a lawsuit and you know we ultimately at the end of the day just want to be as helpful as possible to are you able to give the client an estimate of what the final cost will be or is that just something I mean I know that's difficult LW because you never know how hard the other part is going to fight who they're going to gauge what kind of nonsense they're going to play how do you C your customers at that point yeah so it's a it's a really nice question I think ultimately you know when you're talking about an estimate of cost what you're talking about is like an average right or a median you know right and what that is a function of is a function of data and so we did I did run the data you know I think in 23 for what our what our costs were we're going to need to run it in 24 you know because you know if you're doing again 20 different things
18:39 You don't really have a sense of what an average cost is because you don't have a data set right you've got these different data points and you're comparing pineapples and oranges right so you know what we do look at is because we just do partitions you know we can create a data set from which we can say okay we think the cost is probably going to be in this ballpark right so I can't say it's going to be an average but I could say you know 10 to 30k or 20 to 40K or something like that depending on some of the circumstances involved but at the end of the day you know I don't know what the ex-boyfriend's going to do I don't know if he's you know gonna be really reasonable okay now the lawyers are involved this is not something I want to deal with let's just figure this out sometimes people dig in you know it's you know they fight over it and they drag it out and they try to be difficult you know we have a number of cases involving you know domestic violence right these are these are not the best humans right and so you know they're prone to fight and they're prone to drag it out which makes it more expensive you know what we what we do try to do for clients is do is complete these lawsuits as efficiently and as quickly as possible and so that's what we do that is kind of our commitment is how can we figure this out as quickly as possible but yeah as far as the ballpark you know 103k 30 to 40K something like that but again I don't know if you know once I serve that lawsuit the person on the other side of it going to say this is this is way more trouble than it's worth let's just sell it or let me buy her out or let me engage a family member to help me get a mortgage or whatever it is I just I have no way of knowing that in advance but on the flip side it's not I see divorce cases where there's no end right literally there's divorce I'm sure you've seen as well the divorce cases where it's millions of dollars and running because it's like a war and they're just grabbing resources and throwing it at each other to me it
20:42 Seems like this is a much narrower discussion they can fight certain things but at the end of the day they're either going to buy out you or there's a court process and you're just getting the judge to decide which is going to be and then execute that and I would think that limits the costs at some point in the worst case scenario it does it does I mean I think that's you know when you're talking about divorce you're talking about somebody's you know entire life right you're talking about what does the retirement account look like you know what is their what does the monthly support payments look like what does child support payments look like what do we you know how does this impact you know the house right there's it's a it's a sprawl of issues right and I think as you identified with Partition you know we're generally not looking at well how much did ex-boyfriend make what's his retirement savings and what's his other property and did he cheat on her it's just kind of like what are what's the property ownership what are the contributions you know is there is there any reason this property shouldn't be sold and that's it now if we're talking about you know maybe the third flavor as I like to call it you know the real estate partnership development flavor you know there may be other issues involved with okay is this an operating asset right are we talking about you a hotel and maybe one of the partners was skimming off the top so you have some theft right so you could have other issues involved with that you know is there an LLC that needs to be dissolved and you know what else is involved right so that's a very different issue but to go back to the boyfriend girlfriend flavor I mean so you know one of the issues that could arise is do we need a domestic violence training or right you know so that could be there could be an additional cost there does the boyfriend you know we're dealing with this in a number of cases right now where the judge has ordered the property to be sold and the person who's living there refuses to leave or cooperate with the judge and so we have to do an eviction right as part of this right so there
22:46 Are other issues that could arise as part of it but I think you're fundamentally correct bill that it's basically a very narrow problem to resolve so let's talk B what you call the second flavor which is inheritance which Falls most commonly in Probate situation mom or dad pass leave a property to us two or more siblings the scenerio I see all the time is one of the siblings like you mentioned was caregiving living the property I think also as lost their ability financially to support thems in a house like that so they're used to living there they're used to living in that kind of a house and their options are to go off and rent a property they can't afford because they don't have any real income they don't want to they've been used to you know nobody wants to make change they don't have to and the other siblings are perhaps entitled to life-changing money on their own whether it be helping their kids their family or just paying their bills I've had literally people on welfare waiting to inherit a half million dollars where they could you know move into a better Care Facility to get medical care for example as a result so let's talk about when they when they discover there's a situation you now have a probate that's been open and there's already been a battle over that between the siblings and I imagine now you're working with a probate attorney most commonly that's going to help guide The Sibling through and make the decision hey we can force your brother or sister to sell that's a partition action is that how you get involved most commonly would be through the probate attorney actually you know people tend to come to me once the probate process is complete right because probate is just the default process for resolving ownership interests in property following the death of an individual right and so you know the law may just say okay you know there you know Mom and dad died and you know they only have two kids right and so it
24:49 Just goes they didn't have a will or a trust or anything like that so you know because they didn't have a will or trust it has to go to through probate but now that it's gone through probate you know the law just says okay to son and daughter and okay son and daughter you now own this property 5050 probate has nothing to say about like what happens after that right probate is just resolving the question of what do we do with the stuff that Mom and Dad owned right including some real estate right and so generally where I get involved is somebody comes to me and they say Hey listen I've got this order from a judge I got this probate decision that says I own mom's house in you know Palace FES again right and you know what do I you know can you help me because my sister has stopped returning my phone calls and you know and I really want to work it out with her but like she just she refuses to discuss the issue so it's generally following the probate but also I'll share with you know we have a number of instances where the will or the trust just says to son and daughter 50/50 right and so they skip the they skip the probate line right they skip to the end and they say hey you know I just got this letter from an attorney it's a and it contains a deed and it says I now own you know Mom and Dad's house but what do I do now because you know Mom and Dad didn't take care of the house so great at the end you know it needs it needs a roof it needs new sewer you know it needs like some paint and I don't really want to invest all this money just to have my sister live there but I also don't want to have a dilapidated property maybe I'm getting notices from the city of you know you know nuisance abatement or whatever it is and I don't I don't really want to invest that money that doesn't really feel fair and if I'm not going to get anything out of it what do I what do I do right so generally it comes to me in those forms following the
26:54 Probate because the probate just doesn't address you know the use of property once the ownership issues are resolved that's fascinating I can see where a trust would do that in Probate I've seen attorneys where the property says you know split between two or three siblings and say well we'll just divide it the interest I say whoa you got one living there you have the luxury now since you're in Probate of leveraging The Inheritance to that sister right because she's going to get let's say it's a moonar property she's going to get a third it so she gets $300,000 and in your case a partition action yes she might be held accountable for the cost but in her mind that's well down the road in the probate she's not getting her inheritance until the house is resolved the judge will hold her accountable for the eviction costs and the partition cost or any delays and that to me I was used as a hammer to the one beneficiary if they're not my client to say you're going to pay for everything to get yourself out at the end of the day the judge can take every single penny to the poster stamp to evict you and that's come off out of your pocket before you get one doll inheritance and the other thing is often these people use probate advances so rather than wait till the end of the probate they'll get money along the way but the probat companies are very concerned when they see that the person's fighting selling the property and so it's one of those things where I would recommend any attorney or a client who's in Probate don't so push this problem till after priv closes you have leverage you have a judge you're going to talk to you to cut the line so to speak obviously if it's a trust and you get de the populator call Elijah and work it out but if it's in Probate let's talk and see if we can't leverage that to our advantage so okay so then again that scenario you're talking about is not dissimilar to the boyfriend girlfriend in that it's siblings one of
28:56 Them's living there they need to make a decision what they want to do in my experience they have tip to around a little bit more they don't have the same poisonous thoughts about their sibling typically do about the ex-girlfriend or boyfriend but at the end of the day it's the same process right you're GNA file a lawsuit and either they're GNA sell or they're gonna have a court process yeah the fundamental background legal principles are identical I think you know with you know probate I think a lot of times right people are you know they're in they're in grief right they're in crisis they're you know their parent has died and so they're not necessarily thinking about property or it's just it's just not on their radar right but I think you know you make a nice point you can partition property out of probate obviously that's a big part of maybe you know what you've done and your experience you know but it also reminds me you know let's go back to the first flavor so to speak right the boyfriend girlfriend there's a kind of a subset of that flavor which actually involves married persons so we do not practice family law you know be for the reasons that we've described you know we just want to do those things that we do best but I have had a number of clients who have come to me and said Hey listen Eli bought this house you know got married bought a house with my husband got you know fully divorced still own the house with him and got this order you know in the dissolution decree says nothing about what do with the house it just says okay you're divorced you own it 5050 good luck and you know so now those people have had get the pleasure of the privilege of engaging the legal system a second time to sell that property because you know kind of like the probate example the issue was unresolved right it was just left out there and so as a result you know it's the problem needs to be solved and so that's you know we will help people in those instances solve that problem by
31:00 You know finally resolving the real estate piece of it another one I see some flavor of that flavor is husband wife and for whatever reason one wants to get divorced they file a divorce they're separated but they're not divorced yet and they own the house and they're negotiating and it goes on and on and on and one say well while we're negotiating I want the household like let's take the money and at least split some of it while we argue over the rest and the other ones just happy to live there for free in essence as long as it goes is that partition or is that a family law issue specifically yeah that's I mean look once they're separated if they're if they're legally married that's you know that's in family law and weer all those cases out it's really just a single instance where they again you know they were married they bought real estate they got fully divorced they have divorce decree they have a marital Separation agreement that's been approved by a judge it just says you know the house 50/50 and they say well what do I what do I do now right I'm I you know in many instances will'll try to go back to the family court and they'll say you're not married you don't belong here you got divorced you know get you know you can go and so they have to engage in a partition in that instance so you know that's how they'll end up calling us so let's talk about it now we filed the case one of the three flavors and now we're in process and the court at some point you mentioned there's two processes they have a bio process by Statute or a sale so let's talk about the bio process by Statute what are the procedures that looks you looks like what kind of Tim ta is that sure a couple years ago the legislature passed something called the partition of real property Act and the partition of real property act it was based on this national movement it originally began in kind of the Southeastern part of the United
33:03 States kind of you know Tennessee South Carolina that part of the world and there was an issue with people inheriting Family Farms and those people who inherited Family Farms you know it was generational farms and then but over time you know people only owned a fractional interest right they owned you know 116th of the family farm and they were bringing a partition action to have the whole thing sold and so you know there was this idea that's not the best way to deal with things there should be a buyout provision and so this law was this model law was formed and it came to California in originally as the partition of heirs property act in 2021 it's now been extended to all property and so it does have this buyout provision basically the court there's a couple steps to that the court will determine the value it's not necessarily based on an appraisal it can be but the court will just make a determination of value which is kind of an interesting concept if the court feels like it cannot make a determination of value independently it can order an appraisal once that appraisal comes in the court can use the appraisal can disregard the appraisal inste its own determination the court is not bound by that determination and once that appraisal comes in the court can say okay I deter I deem the value of mom and dad's house to be you know in Palos Verdes two million right and so you know sister you're a 50% owner you know here is a you know an opportunity to buy this property for $1 million based on the determined value you have 45 days to make an election and then from that you have 60 days to deposit a million with the court to facilitate the buyout process if you're unable to deposit a million dollars with the court within 60
35:06 Days then we will order the property to be sold so those theoretically that's how it's supposed to go there's a lot of little wrinkles in that you know as you might imagine selling you know a family farm or selling a fractional interest in a family farm in Tennessee kind of different than selling I don't know in a in operating apartment building in Santa Monica right where there's a lot of other pieces was this a good idea I think it had a lot of good pieces to it a lot of good Concepts I think the buyout provision is you know helps to inject some fairness but you know I don't think there was sufficient consideration given to hey you know if we have an operating asset you know like an apartment building like a warehouse and down Los Angeles you know how does this how do how do these different pieces intersect and you know one is one is just fundamentally not like the others right sure works really well if you're talking about Mom and Dad's house right that might not need that much maybe need some repairs things like that but you're talking about you know again pineapples and oranges these are very different asset classes with very different needs and there's a lot of wrinkles in the law that I think were just created a bunch of unanticipated consequences so is does one party get offered the chance to bite out do both parties get a chance to bid against each other what is that once the court makes a price how does that offer get worked through sure so it's kind of interesting and this is actually something that arises very frequently as a question is who gets the opportunity to buy out whom and the law is currently that whoever does not file the partition gets the opportunity to buy out the other so which is interesting because people will come to
37:09 Me all the time and they'll say Hey listen I own you know me and my sister inherited a beach house in monre that used to belong to Mom and both of us are very well off but we just could never stand each other right and so I want to buy it she wants to buy it we can't own it together because we can never you know we both want the Fourth of July we both want Thanksgiving whatever it is and you know I've offered to buy her out she refuses I don't really want to partition it I don't want to get rid of it I just you know if I can bid over her can I do that and unfortunately the law does not provide for that the law as it currently is written only permits the non-partitioning property the defendant as it were to have the right of first refusal in the property wow so theoretically the court number could be low by the petition by the filing party's Viewpoint and now they've ended up allowed the other party to buy it on the cheap now when you mentioned the deposit is that does that work with a conventional type of financing meaning to put the money into the account could I go to Bank of America get a home mortgage and have the proceeds paid off or does it have to be cash or some of the format for the court process yeah it's a it's an interesting question that arises pretty frequently I'm going through it iner instances right now where you know there is a I think from the Court's perspective is the way the way the law is written it just says you know there's supposed to be a deposit right so the court the process I think is your you know indicating doesn't really Envision how real estate operates practically especially real estate California well but think about it I don't know can you think of some differences between you know a family farm in Tennessee and you know a property in downtown La Jolla right it's like well I don't know yeah you know I want to sell this
39:13 Property in Tennessee and maybe the Family Farm it's 10 acres and it's worth $100,000 and you have a 10% interest well here's here is 10 grand right but you know if you've got a property in you know in downtown La Jolla it could be $45 million and so this idea that well you just come up with 10 grand and you just deposit it you don't need a bank you don't need third parties involved it doesn't really apply that neatly to California and the way that the world that we live in works right and these issues with financing so the law does not technically address that now what I have seen is as part of this process you know my clients will work with the other ones to or by Versa to kind of facilitate the sale you know at the end of the day it's about kind of allowing people to move on with their lives you know like being liberated from this bad real estate relationship so you know I think there is a lot of cooperation but you know not always and that creates issues well okay so I can imagine there hard money lenders maybe that they'll get the money deposited and then they'll refinance the property and get a more conventional loan and lower payment so I can see as the whole world of possibilities to get around that and then obviously if there's no buyout agreement the court forces the sale now I'm familiar with that process in probe Court I'm also familiar with the sheriff's heal process but I don't think I've ever seen a court ordered petition so are they frequent and what does that look like yeah I mean well I guess they're very frequent in my world so you know he said he said with a big smile well no I mean I you know I love I love what I do I mean and you know this is this conversation bill is reminding me of why I got into this process because I was talking to you know to go back to where this conversation started I was I was talking to people like you was going to Real Estate meetups you know I was going to Real Estate education seminars and
41:15 Learning about you know what is a what is a short sale what is an REO sale what is a foreclosure sale right like how do all of these different types of sales work and understanding that they have all have Tech technical aspects to them right there's different steps in the process to manage or how does a probate sale work how does a divorce sale work right there's all there's this whole variety of you know unconventional real estate sales and it was part of this process talking to people like you and just really enjoying the conversations that I was like Hey listen why is no one talking about partitions you know something I was familiar with as an attorney I said nobody's talking about this you know obviously following the crash you know everybody talked about foreclosure sales and you know short sales and Aro sales and things like that but I was like you know partitions is it's not the same but it kind of belongs in that in that universe so to speak right but to answer your question and in fact if you know if you're really interested on my website I've gone through and I've said you know what is the difference and I blog post what is the difference between a foreclosure sale and a partition sale what is the difference between a divorce sale and a partition sale what is the difference between you know an Aro sale and a partition sale so we actually got went through and looked at all the different technical requirements for them what does it differ between a probate sale and a partition sale right so different blog posts kind of detailing the differences if for those who are interested in learning more and educating themselves so we have information on that on our website because it was an intellectual curiosity to me but so at a technical level you know and in Broad Strokes there is a whole section of the code of civil procedure addressing partition sales the way they work is the judge orders the property to be sold typically we bring on a Realtor® to Market and sell the property we try to do it through commercially available means to try to get the highest price possible right
43:19 Unlike other types of you know law we're not we're not trying to go after anybody you know in particular you know we're just trying to say Hey listen you will get your share I think as you alluded to bill you know sister will get her share in the house right you know and we understand you know it's a tough situation but at the end of the day she's going to get a pot of money right and she will be able to you know do different things in her life but we ultimately want to get the most amount for the property for both parties right if we get you know $2 million instead of a million and a half dollars everybody benefits including the other side right so we try to Market and sell it through you know commercially available needs through a Realtor® once that you know Realtor® gets they have to list an end date for when offers are accepted so they have to say for example you know list on the MLS this is a you know a sale that's subject to court approval and we will be taking offers up until August 31st they have to be submitted in writing by 5:00 pm via email or mail to my office you know which is located at XYZ Main Street right what the Realtor® will generally determine which offer is best they have that Authority under the code of civil procedure they'll say okay you know this one is a is a cash offer this one is a finance offer this there's different prices they'll kind of make a determination among the offers of which is the most attractive make a recommendation to the court at the end of the day it's the judge who decides which offer to accept but the but the Realtor® referee will make the recommendation the judge will approve the sale and then from there it will kind of will send it over to Escrow and tile to go through the normal process to make sure that you know the buyer is able to
45:21 Obtain you know title insurance and process the you know the transfer as easily as possible so I know I spoke a lot but basically kind of the different ideas involved yeah no it's great so unlike probate where one offer is selected and brought to court to be confirmed in this case all the offers are brought to the judge maybe with a recommendation and at that point the judge makes the decisions there's no overbid process in court on a on a partition yeah it's interesting so the that's correct there is no overbid process unlike probate but I think like probate generally the referee will just will you know they'll say this is my recommendation I don't know that you know generally they'll say listen I received you know 10 offers or whatever this is the one that I think is the best is the is the highest and best value for the property and so they will they will just generally bring the one to the to the court and the judge will inquire now there is an opportunity for the other party to object I've actually gone through a number of Trials on this unfortunately where the other party says that's not enough money or I want to do this and the standard is whether the referee had another offer the Realtor® had another offer that was it's like 10% above the first 10,000 5% above that after so basically you know they can they can challenge whether the another offer was received that was better but I think I've won all of those trials you know generally it's a very high standard and the courts are you know they're looking after the interests of all parties But ultimately they see that a lot of times these challenges are raised just to kind of delay the process delay the inevitable unfortunately yeah so probably that happens all the time I'll give you a statistic I've tracked Probate Court
47:25 Confirmation petitions Plus years and about one quarter get approved at court three quarters are denied or half of them are continued due to defects in the petition or the process because the process is very particular and at that point you've already picked one and so the stakes are a little higher than the judge making the decision at that point so it is interesting is very particular I imagine those particularities are done before the offer is accepted because the judge wants to see it a certain way so very interesting so as far as the agent then is the petitioning parties attorney then determining what Realtor® they would to use is it's not the court appointing it's not a but it's really just relationships with attorneys that we've created value with hopefully and they as a result choose us to do the business yeah I mean so kind of like a divorce sale where you know the parties can submit different Realtors® to the court you know generally it's people who we are familiar with in the industry who you know we think are well qualified that will recommend but before we do that you know from my perspective I always you know look at it from how can I be of service to my client and so I always start with asking my client who would you like to use you know is there a Realtor® who you would like to use and if they have a you know a preference I you know I just welcome that you know I really try to welcome my clients's involvement as much as possible and if they you know obviously if there's a major problem with that Realtor® if they're brand new this is you know their first year in the industry or second year in the industry I might have to you know have a conversation about whether that's a good idea but you know generally I think as a matter whenever my clients
49:31 Have requested to use a Realtor® you know we just say Yes a lot of times however they don't have a Realtor® they want to use and so we'll make a recommendation or bring in somebody who he feels is has good experience especially somebody who has probate experience you know that's something that we'll look for is hey you know you want to do partition sale have you done a probate sale have you done a divorce sale how long have you been in the industry what kind of education do you have right so these are all factors that we look at to try to make sure at the end of the day the client's taken care of you know and really that's where we're coming from is just saying how can I help this client as much as possible right and so we just want to get them the best people sometimes the other side will say we think our Realtor® you know our Realtor®'s sister or niece or whatever or Neighbor Next Door is best and so there's other instances where we'll just say to the court hey judge you know how about this we've got this gal they've got this guy why don't you decide you know here are the qualifications and we'll let you choose and we'll put it to the judge and the judge will say oh I like you know flavor a better than flavor B and we say that's you know that's fine too but there is no really I know like the divorce the divorce law has a process for that the partition law does not but I don't I don't think we're missing anything without it but it's just not something that's you know set forth in the law the way it is in family proceedings and I think for those watching this you remember you know Eli working in Los Angeles County in California and the laws of everybody State and procedures by County but the principles are the same and you'll notice he wants to make his customer happy he'll defer his customer when they can I imagine if the customers inheriting a partition property where you know they're a modest family but they inherited some big industrial property you know you need an agent that can help with that industrial property or vice versa and so it's about you know working
51:33 With customers working with business people earning those relationships and I think the key for all of us is if this is the area we want to get involved with is do the research in your local market about partition actions I think there's tremendous opportunity for all of us to learn more and more importantly bring value to our customers so I really appreciate that you brought that look I know we've gotone long I a list of other areas maybe we can bring it back in another episode and go into DET tell some other parts but this is area a law that I think affects us deeper than we think I think it's one of those that affects us when there isn't a lawsuit by knowing what the outcome could be and helping advise our customers what their options are and to seek proper legal counsel so Elijah Underwood from Underwood law firm it's Underwood law hey Bill it's a pleasure to be here and yeah as I mentioned I mean I used to you know have conversations like this for free in my free time you know obviously there's no there's no M involved here either but I mean this is it was just talking about things like this and just loving the field and really loving how you know the law can help people get out of these situations you know I'll speak all over the state and I'll do a conference with you know 100 Realtors® and I'll you know kind of give them an introduction to partitions and PE you know I always ask at the beginning hey who's heard of partitions and nobody raises their hand and then you know by the time I finish I'll have you know a handful of people who come up to me and say hey I've got one of those brother sister issues going right now I've got a I've got a boyfriend girlfriend I've got two friends who invested in an Airbnb property together and it's gone totally sideways and I love being able to help people solve these problems and just have these conversations because it I don't know it just is fascinating to me personally well again it's good
53:36 Insight for all of us to understand that when we find something we like and we're good at we create value for people it stops being a job and really becomes almost a hobby that we get paid for so again separate even for the education thanks for the motivation and reminder of those important points well the you know the Lakers were never going to pick me up so I had to do something you and me both buddy I was I was say you know I want to play for the Lakers but I do the hard work to earn my way in and so it's one those things where you better find something you're willing to do every day so well okay thanks so much and again this is Probate Weekly we do this every week Probate Weekly.com you can sign up online get reminders watch the prior episodes watch it on your favorite audio format probate week.com I'm at buildg gross probate on social media or Bild gross probate. Comom if you want all my contact INF as always make today your best day ever thank you everybody and again thanks so much really appreci thanks Bill all right take care
More Probate Weekly episodes
- Probate FAQs, with Las Vegas Probate Attorney Lee Drizin
- Free Probate Business Resources from Executorium, with George Compton
- Probate Bonds Explained, with Phil Pavarini of ProbateCourtBond.com
Related
- How long does probate take?
- A guide for successor trustees
- Probate attorneys and podcast guests
- Probate Weekly: all episodes
- For attorneys & fiduciaries
Educational media, not legal advice. Guest views are their own. Hosted by Bill Gross, The LA Probate Expert, a licensed California real estate broker (DRE #01022275) brokered by eXp Realty of California, Inc. (DRE #01878277). Bill is not an attorney and is not a Probate Referee.