A Nearly $4 Million Elder Abuse Verdict Over a House, with Attorney Bill Chapman
Probate Weekly · · Guest: Bill Chapman, MBK Chapman PC
Episode summary
Bill Gross talks with Orange County trial attorney Bill Chapman about a Long Beach case, reported in the Press-Telegram in September 2023, where a jury awarded his client nearly $4 million for elder financial abuse.
Bill Chapman explains how an experienced investor bought the home of a 78-year-old woman who was bedridden in a nursing home after a stroke, without an agent or attorney, and had her sign with a notary at her bedside.
He walks through how California's elder abuse statute applies to anyone 65 or older and why the lack of representation and documentation made the case.
They also discuss the cost of taking a case like this to trial, the judgment that voided the deed, and why every transaction with a vulnerable seller should be documented and represented.
Key points
- California's elder abuse statute protects sellers 65 or older; a buyer who knew or should have known the deal would harm the seller can be liable.
- Discouraging a vulnerable seller from getting an agent or attorney is a major red flag.
- Document everything: representation, disclosures and the seller's understanding of value and options.
- Taking an elder abuse case through trial can cost several hundred thousand dollars, so early, reasonable settlement matters.
- Agents who see an unfair deal with an elderly seller should speak up; it may protect both the seller and the buyer.
Questions answered in this episode
What happened in this case?
Bill Chapman says his client, then 78, had a stroke that left her paralyzed on one side and bedridden in a nursing home. After she received a notice of default, an investor arranged to buy her home, and a notary showed up at the nursing home to have her sign the deed. Watch at 2:03
What does California's elder abuse statute require?
He says that if the person is 65 or older, one of the easier paths is to show the defendant knew or should have known the transaction would harm the elder. He proved it largely through the lack of documentation and protection for his client. Watch at 22:42
Why did representation matter so much?
Bill Chapman says the key was that the buyer discouraged her from getting representation. With an agent or a lawyer involved, the deal would have been documented and the problems would likely have been caught. Watch at 24:47
How much does a case like this cost to litigate?
He says taking it through written discovery, experts and a jury trial can run several hundred thousand dollars, and contingency-fee lawyers for this kind of case are few and far between. Watch at 28:54
What did the judgment include?
He says the money judgment was about $4.66 million, with a motion for attorney's fees and costs still to come, and the judge found the grant deed null and void so the property returns to his client. Watch at 35:07
What kinds of cases does Bill Chapman handle?
He describes himself as a trial lawyer who handles business litigation across many industries and topics in multiple jurisdictions. Watch at 45:27
Transcript
Transcript generated from YouTube's automatic captions for this episode and lightly cleaned (filler words and repeated words removed, names and web addresses corrected; phone numbers and email addresses read on air are replaced with a placeholder; [unclear] marks words the captions did not capture). It may still contain transcription errors, and speaker labels are not included. Timestamps link to that point in the video, which is the authoritative record.
Editor's note: This episode was recorded in October 2023. The amounts and case status described are as of that date and may have changed on appeal or later motions. MBK Chapman's website now describes the firm as a homeowner-side HOA law firm.
Editor's note: Bill Gross is a California real estate broker, not an attorney. This is general information, not legal advice.
0:00 Every Thursday at 4 p.m. Pacific Time 7 p.m. Eastern to help real estate agents investors attorneys best practices and probate real estate I was really excited the other day when I read a couple weeks ago I read the news about an about an elder law abuse case victory for a local client and a local attorney and the more I looked into it seems to be the kind of thing that we as Realtors® come across and we say man I wish there was some attorney that would be able to do something to fix this situation in many cases we can't and I had the opportunity to reach out and speak to Bill Chapman who's a local attorney based in Orange County who helped us Long Beach woman get back money I guess really award for $4 million or nearly $4 million look excited to have attorney Bill Chapman on the call with us Bill thank you so much for joining us hey good to be here Bill thanks for inviting me so you are an attorney and you do more civil litigation is more the focus of your business and this hens a quest over into elder law yeah my practice area was really business litigation but I've been doing this for 40 years so I started in Insurance defense I've done some plent of person injury different types of law exposed to family law probate law and so forth so I know my way around the courtroom is probably my main claim to fame and when this came up I just you know heard the story and it just really resonated with me so I jumped in with both feet so we'll put the link to this particular news version from The Long Beach Long Beach Press Telegram and my assistant Jess on the call she's from Long Beach recently from Philadelphia Long Beach women St out of house awarded $4 million in Elder L views and what also caught my attention on this case was that the defendant or the I don't know what to ter be criminal the object of the person who perpetrated the C the
2:03 Swiming was a real estate investor pretty prominent one who had all kinds of related underway so this is the article that appeared and you had a chance to talk to him so can you kind of give us and I know there's things you can talk about and things you can't talk about so I don't want to cause any problems we want our we want you to be as successful as possible can you give us kind of what was about this case that got your attention and what do you think the Court ruled that verified your case you bet well the my client Suzanne Jorgenson is just a sweet lady she's currently 80 at the time she was 78 years old and at the time of this transaction she a couple months before it had a stroke and left her paralyzed on the left side she also has bedsores is bedridden essentially had been in and out of nursing homes for the prior year or two and she had a home six blocks of the beach in Long Beach in the alus beach area for those who know that area and it was an older home but she had she had owned it for almost 50 years and she had let her since she went in the or actually before she went in the nursing home she had allowed her sister a mentally disabled sister to live in her home and then she also rented out the garage to a kind of a handy band that I think was just kind of a freeloader but paid her $300 a month rent but anyway she got a notice of default from her bank and she panicked and thought oh my goodness she you know she's a lay person she thought this letter meant she's GNA imminently lose her home by the way it was valued about $800,000 and she had owed about 40 Grand on it so obviously had done some refi or whatever but still very little owed relative to the equity in
4:07 The home she panicked and said oh my goodness they're going to foreclose they're going to come in tomorrow sell my home at a fire sale they'll take all the money I get nothing my sister's out on the street and so she told this handyman or he brought the letter to her in the nursing home and she opened up looked at it and she said well what do I do and she knew that worked as a handyman for a wealthy real estate investor and she said hey can your boss help me in some way maybe give me a loan or do something to save this home and he said well I don't know let me let me set up a call she didn't even her cell phone was dead she didn't know how to fix it so he loaned her his phone and she ended up on a cell phone call for all of about five or 10 minutes with this wealthy real estate investor who had 31 owned 31 properties primarily in Los Angeles County but a few others around the country and in the conversation she asked him if he could help he said well no I don't I don't think I can give you a loan but I might be interested in buying your house his pitch to her on the surface well at least to her sounded not only reasonable but she called him her savior she said oh my goodness he said I will let your sister live there for Life but I'm going to have to fix up the property I'm going to have to get a loan now the guy's worth $30 million but he said he had to get a loan on it so you have fix it up first get a loan and to get the loan he said he'd have to get a renter in there and he said your sister will be in part of the house rent out the rest of it and that rent will pay the loan back so that allows me to do this thing and she said oh you're just the most wonderful person I have ever met and that kind of thing and so he said well I'll get have my lawyers drop some documents and you know
6:11 Formalize this and whatever I think she had a couple of calls with him about 10 minutes total or something well one day a notary shows up in her nursing home and says I have a paper for you to sign she says well what is it he said I'm a notary I can't talk about it I just got to look at your driver's license get your print and so forth and she thought the handyman had told her that this nice guy this investor is going to help her out had actually already paid off her mortgage so she thought oh he paid off my mortgage he wants some note from me saying that I owe him this money or if I die you know he'll get the money back so oh and she had to she couldn't really read very well she had glasses but she didn't have them with her so she went ahead and signed this what ended up to be of course a grant deed no promisory note no purchase sale agreement no trusteed no escrow nothing and so she signs us not knowing what she did and then she just you know she's bedridden she's sitting there in the nursing home and then what happened is once he got title and recorded it he went in there and sure enough he started doing his so-called repair work didn't have licensed contractors he's not a licensed contractor didn't pull permits just started you know Patchwork doing some whitewash painting some really superficial type repairs and then and then she he told the sister that he now owned the property now that he's fixed it up he said I own the property and we're going to evict you and so the sister who is mentally disable abled just went berserk she got in a Camaro car old Camaro car that she had in the driveway start driving around she went to the public library looked up the names and phone number of a long lost cousin that
8:15 She remembered and miraculously calls up this number and gets a hold of her long-lost cousin she had hadn't talked to in decades and said hey can I come see you they said okay come on over yeah we remember you come on over she went over they lived in Huntington Beach she told them what was going on and they said well let's go find out we need to do a little investigation they actually had a friend who was a real estate broker who looked up the property and sure enough confirmed that this guy had a title to the property so they met with my client in the nursing home said hey we need to get you a lawyer this is this is really bad what's happened you no longer own your house but we want to try to get it back for you and she said okay so they became the guardian ad lium for my client and actually started funding I know Bill when you and I spoke one of the questions of these cases is this lady has no money there aren't many lawyers who will take this type of a case on a contingent fee especially with a wealthy real estate investor who's going to hire the best lawers he can find and just dump unlimited money to bury the little lady who can't afford to really litigate so these cousins fortunately they had the resources to retain us and initially paid us hourly for the work but it didn't take too long where they said oh this is getting really expensive and we said yeah okay well we'll switch it to a hbrd so we did that we lowered our rate and took a little contingent fee and then after a little while farther they said you know we are really this is really expensive we just we're getting into expert Witnesses getting ready for trial and by that time I like to find out you know there's always two sides to a story so we did our Discovery and just you know the defendant was just a crook that's what we call him is a crook and is that a special legal term crook yeah it is it is you can call him defendant or whatever you want but I just call him
10:19 A crook in a suit maybe but anyway he you know he hired a law firm he just started in fact I tried I called them as soon as they made an appearance I well maybe they've got a lawyer who's going to you know be reasonable and understand the writings on the wall and so I asked him if they wanted to talk settlement and he said oh well yeah we do we would like to talk settlement but we need to do Discovery first so I knew that was code word for we're going to try to bury you in Discovery and I said okay well I know how to play that game let's go do some Discovery so we went through all these depositions of precipi witnesses and then they called me and saidyou know oh we've done all these depositions now are you still interested in talking settlement oh back up one early in the case I also wrote a demand letter to once she got a he got attorneys we wrote a demand letter which is pretty typical and we set forth all the factual background the documents or lack of documents and we itemized our claim for damages under the elder abuse statute common law fraud in the inducement and so for and so forth and attorney's fees under the statute doubling of the property that was taken and so forth and we came up with a demand of eight well we said if we go to trial we think we can get $8 million but we are willing to compromise we'll settle for $6.5 million and their response was well we will give your client the house back but she's got to pay $260,000 for the defendant the crook claimed that he spent that much money in these repairs and she didn't have the money and just said you know there's no way we're gonna and the cousin said no way we're going to do this so you know it got no their little offer was just phony so we went ahead and did experts we did written Discovery document production subpoenas I even subpoena the he got a bid from a
12:25 Contractor a general contractor for $265,000 claiming this was the work that was actually done well problem is the bid was in August of 2022 which is after all his work was done the transaction was January 31 2022 he started work in February finished in August has a bid in August after the work was done so I called up the contractor and eventually subpoena him talked to him and I said youou know what is this bid after the fact he said oh well I'm a tenant of this gentleman the defendant he called me up and asked me for a favor said he wanted me to prepare a bid he didn't say it but I think he probably told him the amount that he wanted to bid and the guy you know did this fully loaded bid on this work never went to the property didn't do any work on the property and then I asked the defendant for all his records for this so-called work because my broker had gone out there and like those of you who are a broker you know you know what how to look at a property and probably know if there's been repairs my broker friend said hey I can you give me 100 Grand I can fix any house up to get it ready to sell you don't need $260,000 that's outrageous and he went out there and he looked at it he said bill they didn't spend anywhere near $260,000 that would have been a beautiful remodel you know state-of-the-art top of the line this is just a bunch of Patchwork and so then I hired a general contractor licensed general contractor expert witness went out there took pictures took his tape measure measured everything got an appraiser out there and so forth and the general contractors went through what he saw the work that had been done and the quality or lack of quality and he said the value of the work if you hired handymen which is what this guy really did was about 60 Grand not 260 but 60 Grand so we presented all of this
14:28 Evidence at Tri and it was evidence we felt of not only you know that he transferred this property improperly took advantage of the lady but he did it maliciously he lied and in fact he was lying in court I caught him cross-examining him was amazing because he had he had written Discovery responses or had his pleadings he filed a cross complaint against my client for what he claimed was $260,000 and at trial I started cross-examining him on this work and his claims and he said oh I didn't I didn't read that I said sir you signed this under penalty of perjury in a relating to a case in a court of law you're telling me you did not read that before saying oh I my lawyers you know they handle that I just sign it oh I mean he just went down really fast now he started sorry I'll wrap up this long answer to short question but the guy took the witness stand in fact when I deposed him I told my clients this guy is going to be tough to cross-examine he walks in the room shakes everybody's hand oh how you doing oh yeah where how many kids do you have what's your family this guy is a schmoozer but he was really smooth he seemed like a really nice guy on the surface one of these you know wolf and sheep's clothing and so anyway it was it was really a battle with him he started his direct examination saying oh I have terminal cancer I have a son who's disabled when I found out about this situation the lady had her disabled sister it just tugged at my heartstrings I wanted to help her I didn't need the money I just you know wanted to help her out but in the end there was just an avalanche of evidence why didn't you have if you promised to pay $300,000 why didn't you sign a promisory note why didn't you have sign a trust deed why didn't you have a purchase and sale agreement you've done
16:30 You've bought 31 other properties you're not a novice at this he said oh I need a you would need a broker to do that and I'm the buyer and the seller gets the broker and I told her if she got a broker it' cost her 30 40 Grand and she didn't have any money so he said I have an alternative I'll handle it myself and you can save the money so he just totally Hoodwinked on the whole thing wow well obviously there's a lot to unpack and just what those of you on the call this is meant to be interactive feel free to raise your hand put a question in the chat box we're streaming this Live on YouTube Facebook and Linkedin and I see we have a nice following there as well so if you have questions as well monitoring the chat boxes feel free to put questions in as well so wow there was a lot to impact there most of the people on the call today are real estate agents one of the things that struck me was this guy's a Realtor® yet he's buying as a principal yet he didn't have any kind of contract LED alone a standard car form California Association realter form or some sort of a template for he might buy it off his Depot the only documentation he had on the transfer property was the Grand deed correct yeah exactly so to me that's a red flag right there yeah right number one number two I looked at I pulled the file up and there was no tile insurance right because there'd have to be some sort of proof of who she was and documents and such so his intention was I guess all along to transfer the property and hold on to it either rent it out or something along those lines he had no you know it doesn't seem like he wasn't looking to flip it this is a wealthy guy doing this was not some Fly by Night operator no and you're right he had a history of his properties he was Buy and Hold and rent them out that was what he did in fact he even said in trial I asked him what in his deposition then again in trial what his style of investment was he said well I like to buy when property values are depressed
18:36 And so I thought well that's what you did here you heard of a l little old lady who's got a notice of default and she's in a nursing home paralyzed on one side bedridden so you decided this is a property you could get at a low price right and I think this is one of my challenges with distressed properties is it's one thing when it's an out estate owner and they have a bunch of property properties and they don't be bothered with it they're willing to sell it at a discount but this is really you know a lot of the distress properties really Tak advantage of these situations and so it's why I was really excited to bring it to your attention second what Clues if you were if I was a real estate agent and I come across this deed what Clues would you say to me as an attorney would be clues for me to be careful maybe this person isn't capable of making the right decisions right at some point this case comes down to even though she signed something she didn't have the capacity to understand what she was doing and she was misled you know he said one thing yet in real estate it all comes down to writing so at some point the court must have assumed I think that the client wasn't capable making own decisions is that a fair assumption well that was an interesting issue and the answer is a little nuanced because my client was if you talk to her she's Lucid she under in fact they did an independent medical examination with a psychologist who does this for a living as an you know an expert in this field and he concluded that she had capacity well my cross-examination of him was doctor you said you did this and I was at the examination so I knew what he did said you did this examination you ask her questions like what day of the week is it do you know what your name is who's the president you know count to five frontwards and backwards name some cities what animals what are your favorite animals and he
20:38 Said yeah I did that and I said so you ask her questions like what are your favorite animals and name off some big cities that you know of and from that you concluded that she understood the fair market value of her home she understood her options as having you know 90% equity in this property and that whether she needed a purchase sale agreement a promisory note a trust deed you concluded all of that from this examin oh well that's beyond the scope of my retention in this case b but I find that she had capacity so he was playing word games semantics and that is she had capacity at a certain basic level but she did not have capacity to understand what she really the kind of representation she needed right like under the law a 17-year-old might have capacity in actually but we don't allow them to make real estate transactions because they don't have the capacity to understand really what they're doing in this case the attorneys the doctor saying she has a capacity to understand certain facts but she has just enough capacity to be misled by a guy like this what weighs in if anything the fact that the crook to use your legal technology is both a sophisticated investor and a real estate broker licensed and educated versus a your PL your client who is a lay person how much responsibility does an investor have when buying from a lay person and or a real estate agent when acting as a principal buying from a lay person now they have special obligations and a certain risks in those kind of transactions yeah and that's another excellent question that did come up because the issue of what duties the buyer this crook had to the seller legally there's really no Duty from on a on a real estate transaction as you guys probably know between the they're adverse parties but the real issue the way we framed it in this case and
22:42 And under the elder abuse statute wasn't that he breached a common law Duty or other statutory Duty like that like a fiduciary or something like that he had no specific Duty in that sense however under the statute it's actually a very strong statute to protect elders and that is if a person is 65 years or older in this California law maybe different other states but 65 years or older and there's a lot of different ways to show things called undue influence and so forth but if you boil it down to the real the easy path to show elder abuse the only other thing you have to show is that the defendant knew or should have known that the trans action would be harmful to the plaintiff and the way I did that the way I saw the easiest path to prove that was exactly what you said earlier Bill the lack of documentation she had no protection I said what if what he said he paid $300,000 but he said I had to I had to fix up the property I had to get a renter in there and then I had to get a loan and so forth so what is the date for that what is the due date for that payment there's no specific date and so when it's not in writing it's a morphus like that you've got nothing she's unprotected so I argued that the sheer lack of documentations alone was sufficient to show that she was harmed by this transaction and because of his expertise he knew it or should have at very least should have known that now he wasn't he wasn't actually I should clarify sophisticated real estate investor not a licensed real estate broker so he had he always had Brokers and he said he said well the seller always gets a broker and we just share the broker or whatever so he pawned that off but it was enough to show his sophistication because when you do 31 transactions and you have ongoing
24:47 Rents coming in lease agreements and you're you know getting new tenants and you're doing repairs this guy had been doing this for 20 years so he knew what he was doing right so if you get repeat one more the standard or if I could summarize it 65 or older the defendant if you're buying a property from somebody if you should know that it's harming the person you're buying from that could be determined elder abuse just that any distressed property almost without fail is that undue harm right it sounds like you're using that leverage that situation yeah and the obviously the key I think going back to an earlier question I think the real key here to why he went down what in particular with the fraud and all malicious suppression was because she he discouraged her from getting representation and if she had representation she all this would have been documented could have been you know a real estate broker is not going to let their seller agree to accept payments in the future in this amorphous way and nothing is in writing right you know it just it was just wholly undocumented which left her completely exposed I have to say my career I can't think of an exception when a client has brought me a transaction they were ready to sign where there was no agents involved it was always a disaster without exception and the reason why the investor pressing them to sign right away it's always well if you don't do this right away I'm G to back out or whatever it's because the deal is so bad that once anybody looks at it's going to fall apart like a house of cards least that's my experience yeah in fact the as you the other another factor that we mentioned as Bears repeating and that is the fact that she had a notice of default she's in a nursing home she's bedridden you know it puts it creates a distressful situation not just the marketplace some kind of distress on the
26:51 Marketplace but her personally her life she was in a very emotional state and has a disabled sister living in the home things like that all of these factors show that I think heighten that responsibility but again key would have been to have if she had representation if he had either paid for somebody or got a lawyer for her and you know there were a lot of other options but he decided to just go for it and tell her don't bother hiring anybody I'll take care of you and save you some money is what he said now I don't know that you would get involved in this but maybe you do know I imagine a guy who does this once does it more than once well yeah that's the that's another question everybody asked me and because of the way these cases are handled judges typically will constrain you to the facts of your case and for me to go out and try to do discovery on 31 other properties would have been extremely expensive they would have fought me on everything so we didn't go into all of that but I think the jurors were certainly thinking about that I know people that I talk to about it my wife is convinced oh this guy you know if he did it here he's done it to lots of people I would think other people in Long Beach be giving a phone call saying can you take a look at this real quick for me or somebody should be doing that for you I don't maybe I'm gonna go research those cases and bring them to for finders or something give me you know we you talked about it in the first question but just to understand I get phone calls from people who have facts similar to this not the exact same and maybe not as egregious but similar and it's a case where I say to them listen this is litigation you have to hire an attorney you have to pay cash out of your pocket most likely and I said it's probably gonna cost $100,000 or more to get to a trial not to mention if you win and the other party appeals that's a whole another level of expense in such is that a is that a reasonable range am I am I giving people fair
28:54 Business advice not legal advice but business advice in that case yeah you're probably low the cost you know is going to be several hundred, if now again everything is relative and if you if we like the demand letter we did if they had been reasonable the attorneys had you know advised him properly or whatever he came to his census you know and we settled early be a lot less than that but to take it all the way through the written Discovery experts and fighting every step of the way and a jury trial it's going to be several multiple hundred thousand dollar unless you can find an attorney on a contingent fee which like I say they're few and far between I don't know anybody that would take this because there's a high risk the lawyer has to do all the work up front and even though it looks like a great case you know you don't know what a judge or a jury's going to do with it and so you have to you instead of getting paid every month you have to postpone until and now after the trial we have to go through an appeal it's not another year or two right and I think that's I customers understand that there is litigation routinely done on contingency most likely automobile accidents employee injury cases but there's kind of standardized case laws standardized insurance companies there's kind of a range of settlements kind of preset and each case looks kind of the same this is so varied there really isn't a industry that would take this on contingency unless you Happ to know the attorney or somehow you catch him on the right day or tug his heartstring I don't know of any that would take a case like this on contingency and that's why I heard about your case it made sense so they put some money up took it to a certain point and then it had to become a concy eventually anyhow I think yeah and Audra asked a question did the client have any other relatives another good question not real well she had she had a sister who lived in Nevada but her sister had financial difficulties so she really had no one else the could help in fact
30:59 She fortunately found this one cousin and his wife who had the resources and were willing and able to help ironically the defensors tried to turn the guardian ad litem and his wife who were there in the courtroom into the bad guys and said we wouldn't be here if these people weren't you know trying to drum up some litigation and get rich on this case and they've loaned all this money and they're going to get paid back some money on this they're going to get their fees SP and I said ladies and gentlemen are you kidding me these people are ones that finally helped yes they put their own hard-earned money on the line and they may get nothing back but they did it out of their heart because of the love for their cousin and they actually are standing up and helping for and now they're condemning them this guy does not get it right and I think that just inflamed the jury more they're the hero if there's a movie of this case they're the heroes I think yeah exactly well you and we have we met Damon or somebody good-looking play you it' be hard to find a good-looking actor for you but the I think the heroes would be the cousins who put the money up otherwise this doesn't get very far oh yeah they were great Witnesses and they are the real heroes here because you know they took a risk and they found someone to a lawyer that would be able to help them so again kind of outlining a movie here because the story is so interesting Leslie asks a bunch of questions was the sister able to come back in the home or where did she end up the disabled sister well yeah it's I'm not I mean this is nothing I'm sorry go ahead oh go ahead I'm sorry okay yeah so looking at the question from Lesley was a sister able to live in the home during this time or did she have to move out great question and that is a point they made the sister actually is still living in the home and never got formally kicked out they threatened her and then they got the cousin and then we filed the lawsuit and started that and
33:03 So they claimed that their one of their defense was hey we were I the defendant said I was trying to help out see I never kicked her out and left her in there and we said well wait a minute he didn't kicked her out in the beginning because he had to fix it up to sell it and then he threatened to kick her out and then the cousins got involved and it kind of exposed him so he certainly wasn't going to do then now one interesting other fact is 10 months into the litigation after we had already filed a complained and litigated the case their attorney wrote us he had never paid the money the 300 Grand he said well I had to fix it up rent it out get a loan and I never got that so they said we don't think he owes anything right now but to try to resolve the dispute over the purchase in closes a check for 300 Grand which he said he didn't have a year earlier but once he got sued and the spotlights on him he all of a sudden came up with three of course he had the money any day of the week but the letter said this is to complete the purchase of the home well at trial I blew that up and showed that to the jury and I said look they claimed that the reason he couldn't pay more than 300 Grand because he had a disabled this disabled sister in the home and so it devalued the property well his letter with the check doesn't say that the sister gets a life estate there's no promise to that so they're still planning on booting her out oh man they couldn't they couldn't recover from that then I think there's a couple other questions did they ever come back and try to settle again they did but it was very weak effort again they what happened was they came back and said you want to have talk about settlement and I said well yeah but you know now we've been through all this litigation cost and expense I said we our original demand was 6.5 I said we will come down from that but not a lot and if you come in and want to do a
35:07 Mediation and lowball us we're not even interested we're not going to do that and then they responded their lawyer wrote me back and said if you'll agree that your 6.5 demand was rather High we'll agree that our walkway thing was rather low and I said they still don't get it and I wanted to go to trial on a case like this I thought this is one oh we got a yeah we got Zoom BB stuff going there spammer Sor anyway but back to the question so they did oh the final judgment is another question we have a judgment right now of 4,659 456 but we are also going to be filing a motion for attorney's fees and costs and the Judgment although the monetary judgment doesn't include the fact that the judge well the Judgment also says the judge ordered made an order and a finding that the grant deed was null and void and unenforceable so the property comes back to her the current value our appraisal said our appraiser said is 850,000 so if you add all that up and what we anticipate will come in attorney's fees and costs it's going to be in the neighborhood of $6 million or more wow now the your trial is purely Civil Right damages right and is there a criminal element I mean is there anybody here paying attention saying well look what this guy did that is there crime involved here or is it just kind of not really or we're busy with other stuff yeah I talked to my a friend of mine who's in the DA's office in Orange County he wouldn't be prosecuting it so he's a good friend of mine so I ran it by him and he said Bill the da is probably not gonna prosecute this guy I think the reason is because although in civil in Civil Court we were able to present
37:13 All this evidence and convince a jury this guy's a crook in a criminal trial he's going to say obviously they have a higher burden than we do in Civil Court they have to prove it Beyond A Reasonable Doubt and so they're going to get him crying again on the witness stand hey I was trying to help her out I you know I didn't kick the sister out I really meant well I you know and the problem is what they should have done in this trial I think a good criminal defense lawyer would do with them is say just confess just say I did I was wrong I shouldn't have done this he doesn't have to say I intended to steal from her but what he should have done is saiding oh I really screwed up I should have documented I should have had her got a broker for her I did so many things wrong I'm so s he should have if he came to me at the beginning of this I would have said I want you sit down right now and sign a grant deed back to her no questions asked about paying this $260,000 back she just deed the thing back to her boom but he didn't do that they played this kind of hard ball hard to get cat and mouse game and a lot of lawyers do that you know they got paid a lot of money he's a narcissist so he want wanted to you know have his cake and eat it too and I think it just you know the world caved in for him so just a quick kind of housekeeping where we're at today really fortunate to have with us today Bill Chapman who's a civil litigator who came across this case of elder abuse and I found the article in the Long Beach Press Telegram that describes it in detail and we'll put a link to the article in the description afterwards you're welcome to read all the details or you can just Google search long beachwoman swindled $4 million you'll find it that's how I got to it bill is a partner I think the lead partner name partner of MBK Chapman if you go to MBK chapman.com has their information detail contact number phone number and such and you'll see all kinds of great information about what
39:15 They do in their business if you're interested this is Probate Weekly we do this every Thursday 4 P PM Pacific 7 PM Eastern you can register and get reminders at Probate Weekly.com on the Eventbrite we also continue conversation in our Facebook group Probate Weekly as well we have 3,100 members across the country looking for referrals attorneys real estate agents other probate content if you're interested in building there and then I had a survey last week where do you get data for probate and so we try to have this kind of content to help you build your business be more successful interesting all the leads in Probate money tie C this is probate money is a California only product I found fascinating and then foreclosure daily in a distant thirds in terms of services then going to court also tied for the lead and then I also have a real estate email marketing master class I did this last month and we have great success with it we're gonna do it again in November if you're interested feel free to check that out it's only $97 it's a hour line class in four followup half hours lastly all my information is on my link tree link T.B gross and you'll see all the different things that I'm doing with me and my team and all my social media and all that okay so question another question that comes up to me at least is I see on I see advertise online Identity Theft Protection Services to where I sit it doesn't really affect like this kind of case this would not have protected I don't think are you aware these services that are being marketed to protect identity theft and the theft of your property I don't believe though if she formally signs a grand deed what kind of identity theft is going to protect her yeah I don't think so because she admitted that she signed the document it was her so it wasn't it wouldn't really fall I don't think in the classification of identity theft her identity wasn't an issue here it was again it was an elder abuse it was a sophisticated real estate investor taking advantage of a
41:20 Little old lady in her time of need man this just it just violates everything that we want in our business all this get into this business I think at some point to help people and then you watch somebody who is sophisticated take advantage of it if you have questions if you're on the live stream YouTube Facebook or LinkedIn feel free to jump in there and on if you're watching on the zoom call of course raise your hand put in the chat box don't put any vulgar chat I saw that I come in the door and I knew right away I stopped the unmute yourself so we wouldn't get the video and the pornographic video these guys are fond of putting in there but I missed the chat box part to cut them off on there so as investors we have people on the call investors or as Realtors® we represent investors who want to get a good deal and there are cases where a good deal is from some elderly person 65 or older I guess is the legal definition where's the threshold between getting a good deal and doing something that you know is a disadvantageous to the other party well yeah I think probably number one for me was would be that you want to make sure that the if it's a an elderly fragile person disabled any way they really need representation because if they don't have repres professional competent representation then you are staring in the face of a monster you may you may get bitten badly because people who look at it afterwards or Monday morning quarterbacking or whatever PE lawyers like me they're going to look for every possible angle that you took advantage of this person if they have representation that guess what then you ask say well ask the representative again not someone who's a phony representative but a real representative to protect this individual and then obviously the other things that we talked about that are kind of red flags is that you would want to avoid is this
43:24 All has to be documented it has to be done professionally right and this wasn't done that way and that's what got this guy into trouble you know I saw a case in fact it reminds me taking a look at this and maybe talked about it where my client was selling some land his neighbor owned other lots and that neighbor was elderly I want to say in the 90s and to the point where his children tried to force him in Conservancy because they thought he was selling the property too cheap he on his own signed a contract where the sophisticated investor had a very sophisticated attorney prepare the document so you have a sophisticated investor with a sophisticated attorney elderly man with no attorney or agent signs a contract they're literally in Conservancy Court arguing we need to approve the sale because if not we're facing penalties of $195,000 on $2 million property and I thought well by definition that's elder abuse right nobody signs a contract where if you don't sell a property you have those kind of Damages in today's market that's that just doesn't happen unless you're taking advantage of somebody almost by definition so we see these cases and again just repeat for the call the two standards he set were one they should have some professional representation which means you as a real estate agent or somebody as an attorney and then second those people almost automatically if you have me as representative or imagine Bill not that you do this kind of law but if you did you'd require some kind of documentation of some sort whether you call it a contract or purchase agreement or memorandum or there's a piece of paper with somebody's signature on it I would think it dur the day right yeah exactly and that's what's going to protect everybody here okay so look I know that this a little different topic in rard than what we deal with in Probate but on the other hand these are cases that maybe don't go to probate because they don't get litigated or we should avoid these things reasons why we should have a state planning set up have a trustee set up maybe somebody helping the elderly person making these decisions the documents done correctly that was the real Point behind all of this so Bill look I time is really
45:27 Valuable I really enjoyed the story I enjoyed you giving us more information in the background tell us what kind of cases obviously we have on the on this call and we'll be watching people who look for civil litigation attorneys what's this case obviously in some ways is exceptional that's why I have you on what's the most common case that you do business with that you bring the most value to your customers on yeah I it's funny hard to say because I really my expertise in the courtroom I try cases and have tried some very large cases in multiple jurisdictions I do business litigation but I do quite a quite a variety of different Industries and different topics give you an example if you ever hear of someone who has a legal issue relating to false advertising under the Lanham Act where the question is relates or the expertise in the case is stereochemistry nomenclature then I would be your guy because I have litigated up against Merc on a stereochemistry nomenclature case where the question was whether the capital letter L in the acronym L5 mthf which is metr tetrahydrofolic acid calcium salt whether the capital letter L describes the Kos stereochemistry of the gamic side acid chain or the pteridine ring so I learn these different areas I've done fire science a lot of Fire cases in the past products liability Securities fraud I just did an oral argument regarding anti- slap which is first amendment kind of stuff so I do a become an expert in different areas but I like to get up in front of juries and courts and educate the judge or the judges in different areas so the whole thing with the L capital l or not is that like a pickup line you using a bar to pick up on young girls or what that's really impressive bill really interesting yeah well I should
47:28 Add I've been married for 42 years the same woman four kids and six grandkids so I haven't tried it in the bar but yeah it's a good joke it when it comes up people say what do you do and I tell them about stereochemistry nen cure then my wife walks away and says I you can get a ride home later again I the one person who's not impressed with your knowledge on that matter I'm sure is your wife even though she benefits from the pay from that so okay so we put in the chat box his website again it's MBK chapman.com and then his phone number [phone number] we'll put that in the description of the video as well and oh that number Bill the number I'm not sure if that's maybe a fax number or something the phone number to our office is actually 391 should be on the website so that other one I'm not sure what number that is okay so one more time seven 67 it's 949 area code 767 3910 I'll put it in the chat and I'll put it in the description on the video on the YouTube as well bill again just first as a as a professional in the business and as just as a Californian getting into advanced stage myself thank you for your work congratulations on the great work you did and continued success and getting paid for it and getting your client hopefully fully restituted and protecting so thank you so much for your work and second thanks for being the call today educating us Realtors® investors on really being careful and I think the lessons I walk away with are just again reminders make sure the other party has some representation to protect yourself and make sure it's documentation of whatever you're agreeing to yeah you bet and thanks for having me on your program bill and I gotta say shout out to all of your listeners because they are really Heroes as well because if this guy had instead of discouraged her from getting representation had referred
49:31 Him to one of your listeners we wouldn't be here he wouldn't have this problem yeah and I'd like to think one of my one anybody this call would say hey this is way this isn't fair this isn't done right we need to document and protect you maybe the deal falls apart that's probably why he didn't do it right at the end of the day he knows but probably it's hard to say this there's not a Realtor® that would do this I hope that's the case but I don't know sometimes I'm a little discouraged with my colleagues but hopefully on this call we're all learn today the importance of doing things properly so again Bill thank you this is Probate Weekly we do every Thursday at 4 pm Pacific Time 7.m Eastern we live stream it on YouTube and Facebook and Linkedin you can watch past episodes. Prate weekly.com I'm Bill Gross I'm a broker here in LA California building a national team of real estate agents focused on probate real estate and again Bill Chapman thank you for time today thank you everybody for being on the call thanks
More Probate Weekly episodes
- Trusts, Wills and Family Fights, with April Rosenberry, J.D.
- Probate and Trust Litigation, with Attorney Greg Aslanian
- Understanding the Probate Process, with Attorney Beti Bergman of Peninsula Law
Related
- How long does probate take?
- A guide for successor trustees
- Probate attorneys and podcast guests
- Probate Weekly: all episodes
- For attorneys & fiduciaries
Educational media, not legal advice. Guest views are their own. Hosted by Bill Gross, The LA Probate Expert, a licensed California real estate broker (DRE #01022275) brokered by eXp Realty of California, Inc. (DRE #01878277). Bill is not an attorney and is not a Probate Referee.