Episode summary

Bill Gross talks with Joe Baratta, Senior Vice President and Head of Trusts and Estates for Bonhams North America, about how auction houses fit into estate work.

Joe explains that auction houses and estate sale companies often work together: the estate sale company handles everyday furniture and household goods, and the auction house handles pieces with significant value. He stresses that fiduciaries need proper values, especially for estates near the estate tax exemption.

He shares stories of overlooked treasures, including candlesticks that came with a dining set and sold for seven figures, and a modest Anaheim house filled with Tiffany lamps and art glass. He also explains regional art markets and how Bonhams covers about 60 collecting categories.

They finish with what families and agents most often miss, from blue-chip prints to rare magazines and collectibles, and how most of Bonhams' estate business comes through past contacts and law firms.

Key points

  • Auction houses and estate sale companies are not either-or; they often work together on the same estate.
  • Fiduciaries need proper values for personal property, especially in estates that require tax documentation.
  • Value is not always where you expect it; a modest house can hold a collection worth a large share of the property's value.
  • Have the contents reviewed by a specialist before anything is sold; a FaceTime walk-through or good photos can be enough to start.
  • Prints by well-known artists, first issues, and rare collectibles are commonly overlooked, while most ordinary collections have modest value.

Questions answered in this episode

Should an estate use an auction house or an estate sale company?

Joe Baratta says it is often both. An estate sale company may call an auction house when it finds something of significant value, and an auction house may recommend an estate sale company for the rest. Watch at 2:05

What kinds of items are not right for auction?

Joe says minor antique furniture, minor jewelry, dishes, and crystal are usually better suited to an estate sale than an auction. Watch at 7:28

Can ordinary-looking items be valuable?

Yes. Joe describes candlesticks that came with a dining set bought decades ago; the family did not know what they were, and they sold for seven figures. Watch at 6:30

How many collecting categories does Bonhams cover?

Joe says Bonhams has 60 collecting categories worldwide, with specialists assigned to each, from ceramics and fine art to jewelry. Watch at 10:55

Do expensive homes always have valuable contents?

Not necessarily. Joe says many high-end homes are furnished with custom or high-retail pieces that do not hold value on the secondary market, while a modest Anaheim house he visited was full of Tiffany lamps and American and French art glass. Watch at 14:14

Where does Bonhams' estate business come from?

Joe says most referrals come from people he and his colleagues have worked with before, and new business usually comes from law firms, or from a beneficiary referred by an attorney, CPA, or trust company. Watch at 21:40

Transcript

Transcript generated from YouTube's automatic captions for this episode and lightly cleaned (filler words and repeated words removed, names and web addresses corrected; phone numbers and email addresses read on air are replaced with a placeholder; [unclear] marks words the captions did not capture). It may still contain transcription errors, and speaker labels are not included. Timestamps link to that point in the video, which is the authoritative record.

Editor's note: Auction results and values are as described at recording and vary by item and market. This is general information, not appraisal, tax, or legal advice.

0:02 I think we all know there's a range of estate sales. I mean, I don't know about you, but I've driven by neighbors and seen signs saying estate sale and turns out most of it is just a bunch of junk that Goodwill won't even take. And then there are legitimate estate sales that are done with fine, you know, auctionable items, artwork, and collectibles, and expensive personal property. And that's where companies like Bonhams come in comes in. We're really lucky today to have Joe Baratta, who is the head of the V the SVP and head of trust and estates for Bonhams North America. Joe, thank you for joining us today. Absolutely. Thanks for having me, Bill. So, I think obviously, you know, I'm a real estate broker and my focus has always been the real estate piece, but the non-real property, the personal property, can be both important in terms of emotions and also can be significant financial. And then I think more importantly, a fiduciary has responsibility to handle things in an appropriate way regardless of where that fits out. So, try to help us understand where do you fit into the puzzle of estate planning with higher-end estates. Sure. So, working at Bonhams, the trust and estate department kind of handles two parts of the process to which we would engage by professional fiduciary. Often it is an appraisal of the estate happening to be taxable, and the fiduciary attorney, CPA, whomever is filing a 706 estate tax form, we are happy to come in when appropriate for those level of tax files to do an appraisal for the tangible personal property or as you said, the non-real property for what is appropriate. So, if a collection has fine art, jewelry, motorcars, or standard items with which we live in which we kind of categorize as general contents, and then all different specific categories based off of what a collector may have, we will provide a full appraisal in order to fulfill that part of the obligation by the fiduciary on the tax. Now, you now have the tax support. And you should have the beneficiaries, and now what do you do? So, that's more of the

2:05 Situation in regards of how an auction house can be of assistance over an estate sale company because there is a fit for both. And it's not always one or the other. There are many times in which there is a collaboration between the auction house and the estate sale, whether the auction house brings in an or recommends an estate sale company, or an estate sale company comes to an auction house in order to state, "Hey, there's something here that could be of significant value. It's not going to reach the same market that my local sale would." And that's kind of the best way in which to kind of think it over. So, if there are items that need whether regional because there's some incredible regional auction houses in Southern California as well as throughout the United States, and then or internationally reach, a company similar like Bonhams where you know, you need the marketing tools that are behind it and that the item should be sold in a more appropriate location than just in Southern California. So, it needs to be offered in New York or it needs to be offered in London or Paris or Hong Kong or Geneva or wherever it may be where the center of that material is best in order to maximize value because obviously that is what the fiduciary's responsibility is to market it so that the item reaches its fair market value. Willing buyer, willing seller, open marketplace. And that could be, you know, auction in that situation. So, Well, hold on. Wait. And like there's a lot there. I know you're an expert in this, so let me unpack it a little slowly here. So, we have estate tax from which your taxable amount which is $15 million per person, $30 million for couples based on the latest tax law, but you're not talking about $15 million of personal property or more. You could have a you could have real estate of $15 million and then a $100,000 piece of art that has to be appraised and documented properly for by the

4:08 Fiduciary in order to do their job correctly. So, it's not about $15 million of material that you're talking about. It's really an estate that much triggers the requirement for certain tax requirements and certain documentation requirements. Correct. So, yes. So, that $15 million total to which a that being your Oh my gosh. Of course I'm now totally blank. The minimum to which an estate tax would be filed, everything after that amount is going to be taxable. That includes the real estate, the stocks, cash, tangible personal property, small business interests, etc., etc. We are one piece of that pie that fills you know, that $15 million bucket. And so, yes. So, an estate that has, you know, a $15 million estate, you know, probably is not going to have, you know, two or three million dollars of personal property. You know, usually there's a bit of bit better diversification on that. But if it's a $15 million estate, you know, chances are you could have three-quarters of a million dollars of personal property there. And whether that's some paintings on the walls or a major piece of jewelry or watch, some motorcars that have been collected, etc. Or maybe something that they don't even know about. And that's really when you need the auction houses to come through because we do have the specialists.

5:28 If you have a blue and white bowl that's sitting on your dining table, does do most people know the difference of whether it's an 17th or 18th century piece of Chinese work or 19th century piece of Chinese work? Or is it Japanese? Or is it another Asian? Or is it European design in the Asian taste? Those are all completely different values that even I don't really know the differentiation. I can tell the difference between Asian and European, but not necessarily what the value is based off of the century and the artist. So, that's where you need specialization. There are plenty of stories of situations where things have been sold without the appropriate eyes on it. There's a great story of one of my colleagues who's up in Portland, and there were a pair of blue and white candlesticks that were purchased alongside a standard mahogany dining set, you know, the ones that we have

6:30 Seen every house or our parents or grandparents may have had from like the 1940s. And when they bought the dining set, the seller said, "Oh, you should probably take these dining sticks. They've always been These candlesticks have always been on the dining table. They're kind of part of the package." And they're like, "Fine." So, you know, they didn't know what these candlesticks were. They reached out to one of my colleagues, and these candlesticks sold for, you know, seven figures. So, Ooh. That's a nice candle. That's a nice little add-on, correct? Yeah. So, but if you're a fiduciary, that's like the biggest nightmare you possibly could have is if you haven't had your due diligence done and had somebody come through and identify that's a possibility of a potential value and that you give it away, and then all of a sudden, you know, your beneficiaries of the estate have what we call that roadshow moment when they're on TV and go, "Those look really familiar." And then my gosh,

7:28 Kicking your E&O, right? For your malpractice. So, And you hope it goes that high, seven figures. If nobody has seven-figure insurance coverage. No, they definitely don't. So, the way that auction houses work alongside estate sales is, like I said, is a very collaborative, you know, market. There are things that just are not appropriate to sell at auction, whether it's kind of minor antique furniture, if it is, you know, minor jewelry, you know, dishes and crystal. Those are types of things that we don't really offer at Bonhams. And so, we'll say, "Hey, you know, this is the best thing to do is speak to your Realtor®. We have some people whom we're happy to recommend, but the chances are your Realtor® and the group with whom they work have a great list of vetted estate sale people that have done well for the firm in the past. And they know their market and they know how to market to the neighborhood or the region in which you do so. They don't need that international market and the cost of shipping and the cost of all the other things that go to it when the things are not, you know, 5,000 or more. So, it seems like there's two different distinctions that you bring to the table from some of the estate sale companies I work with in the past. One would be, like you say, the regional specialization, meaning certain art is maybe not appreciated as much in Southern California. So, maybe they have moved here from the Orient or moved here from Europe, and the piece they have is very valuable, but there's just not that market here in Southern California. But like you said, by addressing markets in New York, London, or wherever, you can, you know, maximize the value by broadening the market to I mean, so I think I imagine there's certain pieces or certain types of products or material that has like a specialization that you can bring to the table.

9:22 Absolutely. I mean, you could have It's not even just Europe or Asia. It could be just here within the United States. There's so many regional markets for fine art here within the US. So, whether that's Pennsylvania Impressionism, if that is, you know, Hudson River School, Texas. You know, everyone has their own In California is a huge regional market in plein air work. And so, there's different markets. So, that if you bought something or your parents had brought something and you came from a different location and brought those things, you know, selling a collection of Pennsylvania Impressionist pictures in Southern California may not maximize the value. You may need an auction house that has a larger American department that can kind of focus on specific regions within the sale because those buyers know where to go. And so that's something that one must take into account. I also know I'm a avid fan of Antiques Roadshow by the way. I watched it for years as well as Pawn Stars. And while that's television, I get that's not real life, but I do realize is that there are specialists and sub-specialists on certain products and that by going to that sub-specialist you're going to really either avoid a mistake or unlock the value that you would not otherwise if you're just going to somebody who's a generalist who might be a great person and well-intentioned, but they may not really appreciate as you mentioned the particular Asian country, the particular century, the particular style of product. Talk a little bit about what you bring to the table. You must have a staff of people who have some of these specialists or you have a Rolodex of people have those special

10:55 Yes, so Bonhams has 60 different collecting categories across the world and specialists that are assigned to all of those. So whether it's ceramics European or Asian, if it's specific artwork genre, you know, old masters which terminates between whether it's actually by the hand or school of a specific artist or if it's a museum copy that may have been done in the 19th century. You know, fine art against all these different genres. Jewelry, you know, is it a piece of designer silver jewelry or is it one of the big fine pieces that you know is should go to a big auction house because it has the big brand Rodeo Drive types of names. Is it someone who can actually identify, you know, a red stone as being a real a real ruby or a synthetic ruby? And if it's a real ruby, where is it coming from because all of that is really important in order to maximize the value. And so, you know, you don't want to again sell something for less if a professional had at least not laid eyes on it before. My background before I was in trust and estates was I was a generalist appraiser. So I was the guy that came into the houses and evaluated the furniture and the carpets and the silver and the decorative prints and the dishes and the crystal and things like that. So I worked with the estate sale companies all the time because there were a lot of those types of items were not appropriate for auction. You know, we had to do what we had to do at the appraisal side and it's not necessarily something that we would offer for sale.

12:27 So then, you know when there were something then we could have a separate conversation. And again, that conversation goes both ways. There are plenty of estate sale people that know that there are certain items whether it's because it comes from a celebrity if it's by an artist that is well-known whether nationally or regionally, they want to do well for their client too and they also obviously don't want to have a reputation of being the one that sold something off that was, you know, later found out on Roadshow by the successful buyer. It seems to me there's two categories of cases that may come to your attention. The one that I'm probably more familiar with is, you know, fairly ordinary house, but all of a sudden you find something that obviously has tremendous potential. Maybe a collection of magazines like from the first edition or the first I had a client who went down and had every Playboy from number one or comic books Superman. I know it's very collectible, very expensive if you have the right stuff, right condition, if it was stored right and all that. At least it's worth a phone call for one thing. But I imagine you also get involved where there's a whole house of stuff. What you know, what's the percentage? You know, is there a is there a general rule you would say of a house 5% 10% 20%? Is there a way that you look at this saying, you know, accepting something abnormal, you know, like a particular collection, in general a house is worth $10 million has X amount of personal property. Do you have a kind of rule of thumb there that you use or there?

13:54 Mean especially here in Southern California. We all know there's houses in certain neighborhoods that are worth, you know, 10 15 20 million dollars and you could walk in and there not be a single item that's appropriate for auction. You're so right. I thought it was just my experience, but you're so I've seen them where I can just say it was like an office building. They always had like a couple desks and a fax machine in the old days or copy machine and

14:14 Very sterile. It's, you know, they're maybe buying things that are custom or they're from, you know, a high retail place like Restoration Hardware or something of that kind of level that's really high quality, but may not necessarily translate as much to the secondary market. Especially with custom furniture, custom upholstery and things like that, they're made for those spaces. So you know, you could have a 15 20 million dollar house in Beverly Park, Beverly Hills, Brentwood and there not be really anything appropriate for auction. However, there've been many of times where you can walk into a house and it be just literally filled from, you know front door to back door of incredible things. One of my favorite estates that I did at my old firm was at a company called Abell which is a real you know, regional powerhouse here in Southern California. And they we had did an estate where the people called up and it was like a standard three two bedroom bathroom in Anaheim. And not in a great part of Anaheim, but like in Anaheim, not too far

15:16 There's not there's not a great part of Anaheim. There's a you know, nice part of Anaheim. There's not great. Having lived in Having lived in Orange County, I can just tell you there's no great part of Anaheim. So we walked in the door and the first thing I see is a Tiffany lamp and I look around the corner there's another Tiffany lamp and this house was filled with American and French art glass. Like every cabinet They had I think three or four lamps. It was not like something you would ever expect pulling up to that house. But the people collected they collected glass. They loved glass. They had a history of being in Anaheim so they had no reason to really leave and you never know. So that collection could have been worth 50% of the value of the property. Wow. And that's I mean that's as rare as, you know, the other example too. But you do get both. So no one should really assume that because you have a you know, a three two ranch house in a working class neighborhood that someone may not be the right person to see it because maybe the decedent's parents were in the military and they were in Asia, you know, before the war. And they were buying things or a lot of incredible collections have come from families that have historical missionary families. You know, they were in Hawaii, they were in China, they were in Japan, you know, in the early 20th century and late 19th century and have incredible things that have come through just by being there doing their service for their faith. But in the end they collected things here or there and you never know or there's a lot of situations of families that left you know, Jewish families that left Europe not necessarily even during the Holocaust, but may have left Poland, you know, during the you know, the reign of you know, the Russian reign and have made their way to a lot of people went to Shanghai besides coming to New York. And so

17:18 They were able to acquire incredible pieces of Asian works because they just happened to be, you know, in China before, you know, China fell during the Communist regime. So history in a family and how things were acquired or tastes that one may have is as important sometimes as the address. What if you were going to give one piece of advice to either real estate agent working with estate sale company or estate sale professional for the type of thing to look for you say this thing is commonly overlooked but is definitely worth exploring whether it's auctionable or not. What are the one or two things that you would say are most commonly missed or you would urge somebody to just double check before you assume it's not of any value. Double check with me on this one. I mean I think you should have everything kind of reviewed at least a walk-through and it doesn't have to be a physical walk-through. It can be a FaceTime or just some great pictures. I mean as you as a Realtor® you're having you know, photos done for you know, to prep it. I mean I guess it depends on how the photos are being done. Is it being done when it's staged and ready to go or before you start the process. But we want to get through photographs really quickly and say like, oh that looks really interesting or you know, I think this is just more appropriate for a local estate sale company. What is there really to look for? I mean the market for furniture is tough overall if it's considered traditional furniture. So, you know, dining sets and living room suites and things like that, they're tough to sell. Most houses that are being built and remodeled today don't have that kind of formality of the traditional rooms. They're looking for that kind of great room that needs a an overall continuity in the design on how things are. So if you're calling about, you know, your mahogany dining set, chances are it's not going to be for us. Dishes, the market's really tough. The market for stemware, glassware, again really tough. People don't entertain like our parents and grandparents did. You know, the last thing I think on many people's mind is

19:22 You know, wanting to you know, have a party for six or eight people on a Friday night after you've done a full day of work. Like that isn't something that goes through people's minds now. Right. I mean find the paintings on the wall are always kind of appropriate to look at. Especially if you recognize a name. You know, there's a lot of great prints that are out there by the blue chip artists that anyone who took art history 101 or one of most likely 102 for the prints would recognize those names. It's always great to run those by. There can be real money in those types of things that were picked up for being for cheap, you know, 40, 50 years ago. But there are things too that people look at that I think have thought of there being value. And this isn't to discourage anybody from asking a professional, but there's a lot of things that because, you know, they think it's old, it means it has value. So, the definition of an antique is anything that is made 100 years ago or later. So, today we're looking at anything that was made before 1926 is considered an antique. That's really a lot of manufactured furniture. That's furniture that you could buy in the Sears Roebuck catalog.

20:40 It's Industrial Revolution. There's probably not a lot of money there, even though it is an antique. It's

20:49 Right. Certain styles it may not be. The paper you mentioned though, magazines. Like if you had a full collection of Playboy, the super majority of that value is going to be in Playboy 1 with Marilyn Monroe. The other ones are more of like an eBay market. They're not necessarily an auction market. Right.

21:08 Because even if you were to sell that as, you know, Bill Gross's collection or Joe Baratta's collection, the value is going to be in that number one. The rest is just bulk. Yeah. Same with baseball cards. I find that there's a couple cards that are worth a fortune and the rest are really just take them to local, you know, retailer and buy the you know, get the wholesale price for it and you're lucky. But if you happen to have, you know, the Ken Griffey rookie card or the, you know, whatever, Michael Jordan rookie card, that's where the real money is. You can have boxes and boxes of collection, but there's about two or three cards that are really worth the bulk of the money there, I think. It's generally

21:40 A lot of those collectibles, you know, baseball cards, stamps, you know, most people say, "Oh, I've got a collection of stamps." Well, they're all canceled unless they're something really rare. Again, I don't know about stamps, but I know enough to know that the majority of things that people have are not worth a lot of money. Yeah. So let's kind of we kind of come in wrap up a little bit cuz I went a little over time, but want to ask you a question from a business point of view. Does business come to you most commonly through estate sale professionals who have things kind of out of their range? Is it coming from an attorney? Or is it coming from a family that knows how to dispose of these things they're doing on their own? Sure. So, the majority of business referrals come through, people with whom myself and my colleagues have worked in the past. New business usually comes from a law firm that we have met, at a conference or had prior work with one of their colleagues, whether, you know, at the same firm or at a different firm. Or the recommendation of a beneficiary from their attorney or CPA or trust company. So, that's how it usually go comes directly. Or there are people that still do just call us because we're or one of the names in the in the I don't know, not the literal phone book, but when you're looking on Google for this type of service, that's what we do. Or they've hired an estate sale company and they say, you know, Mary Smith from, ABC Estate Sales, that I should call you. You know, there's a couple things here that she doesn't believe is appropriate for auction. I see a part of the estate sale is more appropriate for auction.

23:16 Got it. Well, it's like very similar to our business that we get from a couple different angles and try to try to keep that flow going. Well, Joe, I would appreciate, you know, giving us a really a great high-level overview of auctions versus the estate sale process that maybe the rest of us are more familiar with. Obviously, we all want to have that Roadshow moment, find something and give you a call and find out if it's legitimate or not. We have your website, bonhams.com is your website and has your contact info and then down below, I have your contact info with your phone number and email. Anybody watching this, please, feel free to contact him or contact me if I can put you together. Joe, thank you so much for your time. I really appreciate giving us this insight and education into the auction process and look forward to working with you soon. Thanks, Bill. Have a good afternoon. And for Estate Planning Weekly, we get together every week. Often most often with estate planning attorneys, but also professionals who can help us be better at our jobs and our serving our customers. If I can help, please reach out at Bill Gross Probate on social media. As always, make today your best day ever. Thank

More The Estate Planning Podcast episodes

Related

Educational media, not legal advice. Guest views are their own. Hosted by Bill Gross, The LA Probate Expert, a licensed California real estate broker (DRE #01022275) brokered by eXp Realty of California, Inc. (DRE #01878277). Bill is not an attorney and is not a Probate Referee.

Schedule Consultation