How the Delaware Statutory Trust Works as a Real Estate Tax Deferral Strategy, with Lyndon Grey
The Estate Planning Podcast · · Guest: Lyndon Grey, LPL Financial
Episode summary
Bill Gross talks with financial advisor Lyndon Grey about the Delaware statutory trust (DST), a way for real estate sellers to defer taxes through a 1031 exchange without managing a replacement property.
Lyndon explains that DSTs are recognized in IRS guidance from 2004 and are offered by large institutional real estate sponsors, and recommends sticking with needs-based property types such as grocery-anchored retail, medical, senior living, and well-located apartments.
He covers typical $100,000 minimums, diversifying across three or four portfolios and several states, how the qualified intermediary holds the money, and why the seller must still be in escrow when the exchange is set up.
Bill compares DSTs with traditional 1031 exchanges, where buyers often end up in a third-choice property under the deadlines, and they discuss DSTs as an estate planning tool for older owners whose children don't want to manage rentals.
Key points
- A DST lets a seller use a 1031 exchange to defer taxes while owning a fractional, passive interest in professionally managed property.
- Call the DST adviser and set up a qualified intermediary before escrow closes; after closing, it is a taxable sale.
- The 45-day identification and 180-day closing rules still apply.
- Diversify across several portfolios, property types, and states.
- DSTs suit owners who are tired of managing property; a traditional 1031 may fit an investor still building a portfolio.
Questions answered in this episode
What is a Delaware statutory trust?
Lyndon Grey describes a DST as a way to complete a 1031 exchange into a fractional interest in large, institutionally owned real estate. He says the structure is in IRS guidance from 2004 and is offered by major real estate sponsors. Watch at 0:54
What kinds of properties are in DSTs?
Lyndon recommends needs-based portfolios such as grocery-anchored retail, senior living, dialysis centers, industrial distribution, and well-located apartments, and warns against new sponsors promising unusually high yields. Watch at 4:44
What is the minimum DST investment?
Lyndon says the minimum is typically $100,000 per portfolio. Watch at 12:36
Should I put all my exchange money into one DST?
For a sale in the $1 million to $4 million range, Lyndon suggests three or four portfolios across property types and several states. Watch at 16:40
When should I contact a DST adviser?
Lyndon says just before or during escrow. The money must go to a qualified intermediary; if escrow has already closed, he says it is a taxable sale. Watch at 18:22
Do the 1031 deadlines apply to DSTs?
Yes. Lyndon says the same 1031 identification and closing deadlines still apply, but DST portfolios are already vetted and financed, which makes identifying a replacement easier. Watch at 23:32
Transcript
Transcript generated from YouTube's automatic captions for this episode and lightly cleaned (filler words and repeated words removed, names and web addresses corrected; phone numbers and email addresses read on air are replaced with a placeholder; [unclear] marks words the captions did not capture). It may still contain transcription errors, and speaker labels are not included. Timestamps link to that point in the video, which is the authoritative record.
Editor's note: DSTs are securities. They are illiquid and carry real risks, including loss of principal, and yields are not guaranteed. Lyndon Grey's statements about tax treatment, debt, and credit are his own. This is general information, not legal, tax, or financial advice; talk with your own attorney, CPA, and licensed advisors before acting.
0:01 The goal in building wealth isn't just making money. It's how much you keep. And that means you have to watch expenses to have a profit. It also means you have to watch your taxes and or tax strategy to keep as much as you can. And while most people in real estate who are professionals and many investors know about certain strategies, 1031 exchanges for example, I came across a strategy a few years ago that has gained acceptance, gained popularity, gained I think effectiveness. And one of the practitioners I met in person a couple years ago who's explained this to us in the past, Lyndon Grey, is back with us today to talk about the Delaware Statutory Trust Program. Lyndon, thanks for coming back and joining us.
0:41 Thanks for having me. Appreciate it. So just explain kind of a high level overview what is a Delaware statutory trust or DST what is it and kind of how does it kind of fit into the IRS revenue codes?
0:54 Indeed. So just to back step back a little bit I think the reason it's gaining popularity and credibility is because when people do their deep dive they realize it is in the IRS code. It's there for public in the public domain. However, the no the average person doesn't really seek that information out on their own and a lot of CPAs and so on might not even know it's available. So when they see the facts that it's there in public record IRS code, it gives them a level of comfort. And then when they move on to the players in this space, they're the players that bring the DST to market, they're the big institutional real estate owners of assets. So, when we patronize our local Whole Foods or Trader Joe's or CVS's and stuff, these properties are owned by these multi-billion dollar real estate players. So when you drill down to that from that level you realize they have the inventory and they have the scale to bring that inventory to market. So when this law was passed in 2004, they basically realized, okay, let's carve out some of our portfolios and provided for that mass affluent demographic, that older client coming into looking to scale down, looking to lessen their headaches, especially in high tax states, New York, California, etc.
2:31 And California, for example. Exactly. With the with the laws that are coming out of Sacramento, they're so onesided. They the t the owners of these assets are just about had it up to their eyeballs in basically inertia and laws that are seem so redundant and favor just the tenant. So when you put that all together, you realize as an agent who's out there in the field facing these clients with multiple assets, older generation, that's a tool for their toolkit to overcome that objection. I don't want to sell because of the taxes because they don't wish to just sell that asset and do another 1031. Then this is a tool that agent can come up with and say look this is an option that's in the books it's legitimate let's explore it etc when this law was first passed I think one of the reasons why it doesn't have more following today is like many things is a new thing and people rush in the market and oftentimes aren't good players don't do they have the scale they have the compliance they have the you know the risk that they have to you know that if they went bad that they would affect their brand and what's happened I think over the last in particular last five years seven years is as these big these bigger institutions said hey we can do that and we can you know trade on our good name or leverage our good name to make investors feel comfortable with our track record and over time these investments have continued to be good.
4:14 So talk the thing that's interesting though is you're not talking about a particular class of product. You're really talking about the tax strategy but can be it can be applied to a variety of real estate products. So as an investor if I'm selling property commercial multifamily industrial and want to get into a more a less hands-on maybe less risk of reasonable reward less risk property. What kind of properties are available? What's the menu look like of choices I would have looking as a DST as an alternative to a 1031 exchange?
4:44 The menu out there it runs the gamut from A to Z. However, the big players in the space like you mentioned init when this law came out some of the hype around it attracted some nefarious actors perhaps and didn't have the scale and the breadth to really do these transactions successfully. But the to eliminate or to mitigate the bad times in the economy and so on the you want to stick with the necessity based portfolios meaning the grocery anchor the senior living these are necessities the kidney dialysis centers etc. So when there's a bad downturn in the economy these are needsbased institutions as opposed to wants. So the wants are your raw store, your things you want but you don't need. So when we had CO for example, there was a the moniker essential services was so prevalent because there's a reason that essential services was out there. The grocery stores were allowed to stay open. The medical facilities were allowed to stay open. So, if you are a landlord to these players, they are paying their rent like clockwork because they're essential. They're not closed. So, you stay with those players. If you're putting a portfolio together, you stay with the Aclass amenized multifamily assets that are right next to major universities or employment zones, etc. Why? Because those tend to attract a well-heeled client. Where during COVID that client, that tenant was able to roll out of bed, turn on their Zoom call and be productive. Even though they're they could go out and buy their own house if they wanted to at 2425 look at working at Facebook or some of the big tech companies and so
6:49 On but they choose to be in an amenitized facility with rooftop pool dog park etc and pay their rent when even when COVID happened. So that's where you want to definitely stick into that needsbased category and don't be seduced by some new player coming out with a six and a half% yield when we all know the market doesn't really bear that. So they do a lot of financial engineering and take monies from reserves to pump that yield up and then when pressure comes on them in terms of the economy they can't support that yield etc. They run into some hardship. So the Inlands of the world, the JLL's of the world, the Ares of the world, the Hines, those are major multi-billion dollar asset players. $500 million of real estate for Ares and JLL and these guys. So that's how you try to mitigate the downturn. So I believe is a you know there's a whole wide variety of products available from multifamily industrial commercial retail. I think I saw one that was a one of these power centers for computer you know data centers.
8:09 Well yeah the data centers. Yes. And again these are big players who do things correctly. This isn't like your cousin and his and your uncle trying to raise some money for investment. These are multi-billion dollar probably multi-tens billion dollars institutions that do these things regularly. And so when they go into a market, the one I saw was like right next to I think University of Arizona where you have university, you have businesses growing, you have companies relocating, it wasn't just anywhere, it was a place, you know, there's a strategy behind it. It was a you know an A-level with some contracts ahead of time type of business. So are all those types of products available to an investor to choose from?
8:47 Indeed, they might not be all available at the same time. How? Because the DST market, it's not like buying shares of Apple or Amazon on in your brokerage account. Those are always available when the markets are open. The DST market is a finite dollar amount of equity for any one deal. So an Amazon distribution facility might be a $200 million transaction. However, once that equity comes in from clients that are in escrow and so on and they meet that $200 million number, then that deal is closed. So someone who wants that Amazon deal, it might not be available at the time they wish to have it. However, there's always another industrial type asset might be FedEx distribution facility, etc. Or the small bay industrials. So, it's no coincidence in that small bay space when we call up because we need a new tire tomorrow. We woke up and saw that our tire on our car was flat. You call Pep Boys or you called Tire Rack or whatever. Oh, I need this tire that tire. Oh, we can have it here by 3:00 a.m. What do you
10:00 Interesting? Where do you think that tire comes from? It's that small bay industrial where they're an hour or two hours away like in this instance maybe Riverside County where they warehouse all of that stuff and they truck it in based on that particular zip code. Everyone calling for those products, a new battery, a tire, etc. And bam, they call you at 2 a.m. 2 p.m. And say, "Yeah, that tire is here now that you called us in the morning for. It's here. Bring your car in. We'll put that tire on, etc." that small base space is very strategic in terms of getting product to the end user and so they basically are big players in the DST world as well. But yeah, they're not always available on any given day, but when a transaction comes to market, someone is in escrow, at least three or four portfolios can be utilized to fill that client's need.
11:05 It's funny you say that about tires in particular because that was my experience when I was younger. You know, you go to a store and they had what they had and if you need a certain size, certain type, they would have one or two or three choices and they would tell you how good those one or two or three choices were. Nowadays, you know, we go to Goodyear store and often times they recommend a tire that's not a Goodyear product. They don't really care. There's a business behind all that and it always is available the next day or if I'm in the morning, the end of the day. It's always available within about a half a day's time depending on when I take it there. So you're now you're saying that this is really kind of building the backbone and the and the network wiring of the economy and so people chance to participate in that. So give me an idea what's a because I know for me personally as a real estate agent typically the candidate that I present these things to is selling a multifamily or properties been their family industrial commercial a couple million dollars where they've they have some comfort because they've had this asset let's say multifamily they know multifamily they either have a management company or they've managed it themselves they know that product they know that area that may or may not want to stay in the area from Los Angeles, you may be fine with it, you may not be fine with it. And the DST presents an alternative as well as a way to diversify. Talk a little bit about how what's the minimum investment typically on these investments and talk about the opportunity or do you recommend diversification amongst the number of them for somebody who's new to this?
12:36 Indeed. So the minimum is very reasonable 100,000 to any one portfolio. And if you're in Los Angeles and you're selling, even your dog house is worth a couple hundred thousand. Just being facetious. But certainly
12:54 Exactly. But certainly someone selling a duplex around town easily anywhere from six to a million, 600,000 to a million, etc. So, a 100,000 is the minimum. And they certainly can diversify. And the DST world, you won't find them owning multifamily assets here in Los Angeles or California in general. Why? Because, as we said earlier, it's an anti-landlord state. So, you're not trying to pick up assets here and be bothered with state regulatory requirements and all that. If they're buying property in the Tennessee, in the South, in Denver, in Arizona, Las Vegas, things like that. They're more
13:41 You did show me a good deal a couple years ago near USC, some student housing. Yeah. Has some unique characteristics. The opportunity zone. It was near USC, very high-end at a time when they were bringing a lot of international students. I don't know how great that investment would be now with potential changes but there are multifamily for somebody who's so interested in those kind of pro properties.
14:03 Yes, there are multifamily assets. That particular USC property is an inland property and that's specific to an opportunity zone. So, the opportunity zone, believe it or not, the census when the bill was passed in 2017, they took the 10-year census 10 years earlier. So, around USC was one big opportunity zone. So when that property was given the go-ahead to be built, Inland came in and basically aligned themselves with the builder and said, "Yes, we will sign a le letter of intent to buy this upon completion, etc., etc." So now that asset, I viewed it few months ago. It's very awesome. It's not a walking distance from the campus. The bottom floor they're going to put in a Buffalo Wild Wings. Has a rooftop hangout, pool, etc., bike racks and quiet rooms and all of that kind of stuff. So yeah, the multifamily space is certainly one that's mo mostly in those other states I mentioned when it comes to the DST world, but in the opportunities world that's the one exception because student housing is very turn much to turnover. No one is staying there for 5 10 years like a multifamily and exhausting the rent control laws. These guys are moving out. At least a third of the portfolio turns over on an annual basis, graduations, transfers, etc. And then that other third comes in and fills that fills those up and they bump the rents three, five, 6% depending on the marketplace.
15:49 But yes, you do have multifamily assets. And that gives clients a good way to diversify outside of California and own in other areas where the cap rates are better, the cash flow is better, and they're less they're much more friendly to the to the owners.
16:09 So, some of you selling a multifamily here in LA and they're maybe netting $1.5 million of which, let's say, just a hypothetically 1.2 two million is a taxable gain and wanted to you know reinvest that money into something that's going to defer the taxes. Could they buy theoretically 12 different $100,000 investments? Is that a strategy or they can find three or four they like and buy, you know, three or $400,000 of each? Is that do people diversify or do they need to put the money into one particular investment?
16:40 No. For something that size one to two, one to four, I certainly would suggest three to four different portfolios. 300 here, 400 there, and so on. And you can have a multifamily, an industrial with an Amazon distribution facility, a small bay industrial, like I mentioned, senior living is a good niche as well within that under that multifamily umbrella. I did a transaction with senior living three properties in three states, Tennessee, Missouri, Arizona. Was cash flow about 4 and a.5% at the time. And so yeah, those three and then another area could be self- storage that could kind of fill out that space where you have diversification geographically in multiple states, three to six states perhaps. And then you have geographically diversification in asset type, industrial, multifamily, senior living, self storage. So you can certainly give yourself a good portfolio like that.
17:51 Talk about the mechanics. You know, somebody sells a property, they're in escrow, they know they're going to end up with about, like I said, use that example, $ 1.5 million property. You know, they their cost basis is 300,000. So they have about 1.2 to of potential taxable interest that they want to defer. You know in a 1031 exchange we get an exchange company who acts in the middle and basically the money goes to the exchange company and then the exchange company in turn buys the property on behalf of the client. What does it look like for DSTs?
18:22 So basically the accommodator has to be introduced just for all the real estate professionals out there. They know even if they did a traditional exchange, they have to have an accommodator added to that transaction. So nothing is that's no different with a DST 1031. So if the client clients and agents that I work with once something is in escrow, I tell them that's a good time to call me just before escrow or once you're in escrow for sure. So then we can look over portfolios that are available at the time and then we can perhaps even reserve a dollar amount of a particular portfolio that client might like because as they get closer to escrow closing they will kind of jump ahead of the line if you will to secure that reservation. So the monies have to go to the accommodator. A lot of times the client is not aware of that and so it's up to the agent and myself to certainly let them know an accommodator needs to be done because I've gotten a call or two in the past and they're like, "Oh yeah, I closed escrow the other day. I'd like to do a DST." And my question is, "Are you still in escrow?" If you're out of escrow, it's a taxable event. You have to be in escrow to make that tax transfer deferred in perpetuity. So that's a very important piece of the puzzle. Once it's there, we look over the different portfolios, exchange emails, conversations, etc. And then once escrow closes, monies go to the accommodator and then we complete the documents just like you're closing escrow on a traditional transaction. And then those documents then go back to the accommodator. The accommodator sends that information to the client saying, "We're in receipt of this subscription agreement saying you would like 400,000 in this Amazon distribution facility,
20:25 DST. If this is what you wish, then please sign these documents so we can wire the funds to Inland, etc. And fill that order." And then they get a closing statement showing what they've bought. They get a percentage ownership of that portfolio. They get the in the income starting out the next month that will hit their checking account like clockwork. They get a simple 1099 at the end of the year to take to their tax man or woman and they can do the taxes on and a couple of key points. They can use the tax person they can use the pass-throughs on that portfolio because a lot of times clients have exhausted all their mortgage or all the depreciation on the asset they're selling. So their tax deferral or tax pass-throughs are virtually non-existent. So when they go into a DST portfolio you do ride the coattails of that leverage for your benefit. So if someone got 50,000 in income, they might declare taxes on 35,000 because of mortgage interest deduction and other write offs that come with that portfolio.
21:40 So and I the hardest part of a 1031 exchange for the client and I and I once heard Grant Cardone, I think he's the only person I ever heard with the courage to say this. He said he does not do 1031 exchanges because it never worked out well for him. And he said that and I remember thinking, gosh, he's so right. You know, it sounds great on paper. It looks great on paper. I could take my multifamily and trade all the money into this other property and pay no taxes. That sounds great. In reality, you got identified property, which is the hard part because you made your money probably buying the property at a really good deal. And now, you know, when you're coming in as a 1031 exchange, you're going to pay the full market price at best for that deal. And that's if it closes. That's if you do your due diligence and decide to move forward. And it's funny what Grant said was I identified three properties. One I loved, one I was okay with, and one because I could only find two. What always happened was the one I loved turned out there was a problem. The second one that I was okay with also had some problem and I always ended up in a third property that I never would have bought, but for the exchange, and therefore my return was lower on all this money I had made. And as a result he's you know I think recommends against it. That's my experience as an agent. I've never had a customer close into their first choice within the time frames provided. And if and I'm just trying to think if I ever have one and if I have I'm sure it was a just a race to get them to decide because it's not you only have a certain amount of time to do that. Talk a bit about the process on a DST. If I am in escrow to sell my multifamily and let's say we clear contingencies, we're closing in two weeks, 30 days. Is that a reasonable time to find them? And like you said, you could reserve some because what you'd want to do is I guess identify some, find out they're closed out and have a tax issue on your hand.
23:32 So what does that time process look like? So you still have the same 45-day and the 135 to close. The thing about the DST and what makes it attractive, if you don't have the stress of trying to find a portfolio or find another property, get it get it financed, get it get check the title and all of these kind of things, get it inspected and all that for the for the for the land or termites and all that. That stuff has already been done. It's analogous to you going to a restaurant and you're looking at the menu and you see the fish, the meat or the veggie entree. They have all that stuff in the back ready for you to give your order. They don't have to go out and get it. So, same thing when you come to a DST provider like myself, they that person is an escrow. I tell them what portfolios are available. They've already been vetted. They've been financed. They're on the shelf waiting for clients to close escrow and look at these options for their tax deferral DST. So once they reach to that point, no problem in finding the portfolios, multifamily, etc. You might not find the self storage that you wanted to get that was out two months earlier because now it's been all gobbled up, but certainly there are other portfolios that can fill the void to make sure you can identify something within that 45 days. So, it's much easier in the ID process and in the closing process as well because the closing process is all about completing some documents and then if you had debt on your property you sold, you don't have to worry about it in the DST world because the portfolio you go into with debt basically absorbs your debt coming in and makes you 100% tax deferred. So, that's the beauty about the DST world. The debt on your FICO score now drops off. Your FICO score
25:36 Goes up. The debt now is inland or Hines or JLL or Ares. That's their debt. You're just on there as a as to absorb it.
25:49 And these providers are in the business of developing these projects regularly because that's really their business, right? They're not they're not just investors. This is their mode of investing. They put these projects together, they keep a piece, they get a piece to manage, and they do the next one. And so, I think the difference there versus going to the market looking for a replacement property is, you know, there's a there's a market of replacement properties. And I think if I had to summarize it, if I summarize our discussion, I would say I don't think the DST is as good as the 1031 in theory. It just is in practice. And I think that's number one. And number two, I think that the 1031 might be more appropriate if you're early in your career and trying to build up a portfolio of properties that are in a niche that you want to dominate or manage. But if you're at the tail end of your career or you inherit a property that's not suitable for you, the DST gives you a way to get a good return without the risks and the headaches and the management requirements of the 1031 exchange. And so again, you know, there's trade-offs here of what you're getting. But I think it's a fascinating opportunity that presented to customers of mine and some have looked at it and move forward and some haven't. And I think that's the key is to have those options and get the best option for you. Lyn, I know you're available to help people who are considering getting in this field. I'm going to put your information on the screen. Also, I know you're very active on LinkedIn. Is that the best way to reach you? Either LinkedIn or down below we have your phone number.
27:13 Yeah, the phone number, LinkedIn. Either one is fine. And I must I will say this. I speak to Realtor® associations or company offices whether it's Compass in Beverly Hills or
27:28 Okay, that's competition. Don't do that. Pardon me. Or KW. My friends are No, it's I'm just funny joke. I'm kidding. But I always preface it by saying yes, the DST is not for everyone. I am not trying to tell an agent to do DST if they have a traditional 1031. By all means you do your traditional 1031 that's your money maker. You b sell this property 1031 into another etc. This tool is for that demographic that's older ideally and is just tired of being hands-on. They've built their wealth. They have 10 12 property around town properties around town. They're 75 or 80 etc. They're looking to scale back and their grown son and daughter does not wish to inherit those assets and manage them themselves either. They have their own careers. They're living in other states etc. This is a good estate planning tool additionally to manage that pass on of assets to the next generation where they get the passive income and so forth. I think the other scenario is for somebody who has made money here in LA and is either looking to move for personal reasons and or diversify or move out of Los Angeles. You know, how do you do that? Well, one way is yes, you could, you know, take your a huge chunk of money and buy a property somewhere else. You also can invest with somebody else along them and watch their numbers and watch their procedures and watch their mistakes if that's the case or watch them how they resolve items. And so for me personally, I was looking to get into multifamily.
29:01 I invested as a limited partner in Texas and Florida and the one thing I learned was I don't want to be involved. I really it's just too much for me and you know I it's not true for everybody. It's true for me. But I think that this is a way that if somebody wanted to say, "Hey, I built my life fortune here in LA. I have 10 projects, one selling. Well, why not move one and buy a new one in Nevada or Tennessee or North Carolina or someplace else that you think is a good market?" And let's do the heavy lifting while you learn that market. And that's really where the DST's I think offers some tremendous opportunities to consider. So Lyndon again thank you for those who want to reach him. Again his contact information will be in the description below. Phone number [phone number]. You know Lyn I said this before we started. I always learn what I talk to you. I really appreciate your education first approach. I try to do the same. Thank you so much for being of service to the people watching my podcast. I really appreciate it.
29:51 My pleasure and thanks for having me and have a great rest of the week. Thanks so much. And for the rest of you, this is Estate Planning Weekly. Who get together every week normally with attorneys talking about the strategies of estate planning, but I do think that DSTs are an important resource that are really underutilized in our market. And so hopefully this is helpful to you today. If you want to continue the conversation, you can go to our Facebook group, the Estate Planning Podcast, and you can look for referrals there or ask questions there and get them asked. I'm at Bill Gross Bill Gross Probate on social media. If I can help in any way, please reach out. If you like this, please like it, subscribe, ask questions, put in the chat maybe where city you're from. As always, make today your best day ever. Thanks so much.
More with Lyndon Grey
More The Estate Planning Podcast episodes
- Passive Income Solutions for a 1031 Problem, with Alan Fruitman
- Family-Centered Estate Planning, with Sati McLafferty
- The Financial Freedom You Deserve, with Michael Scarpati of RetireUS
Related
- A guide for successor trustees
- How long does probate take?
- Probate attorneys and podcast guests
- The Estate Planning Podcast: all episodes
- For attorneys & fiduciaries
Educational media, not legal advice. Guest views are their own. Hosted by Bill Gross, The LA Probate Expert, a licensed California real estate broker (DRE #01022275) brokered by eXp Realty of California, Inc. (DRE #01878277). Bill is not an attorney and is not a Probate Referee.