Saving the Family Cabin, with Michael Smith of CPS Horizon Financial
The Estate Planning Podcast · · Guest: Michael Smith, CPS Horizon Financial
Episode summary
Bill Gross talks with Michael Smith, President of CPS Horizon Financial, about how families can keep a cabin or lake home in the family across generations.
Michael shares his own family's story: a cottage his grandmother bought in the early 1970s that passed to three siblings and then to seven cousins, and how buyouts created tension until his mother became sole owner and set up a trust.
He recommends a family meeting, written rules, a trust funded well enough to cover insurance, taxes, maintenance, and utilities, a reserve fund for big repairs, and trustees who are blood relatives.
They finish with life insurance as a way to fund the trust, rules on renting the property out, and planning an exit so a family member who wants out is not trapped.
Key points
- Hold a family meeting early to learn who actually wants the cabin and on what terms.
- Put the rules in writing: scheduling, upkeep, guests, and whether short-term rentals are allowed.
- Fund the trust so shared costs don't fall unevenly on family members with different incomes.
- Keep a reserve fund for large repairs such as a roof or furnace.
- Plan the exit: decide ahead of time how a buyout or sale would work.
Questions answered in this episode
How can a family keep a cabin across generations?
Michael Smith says the property is often held in a cottage trust or an LLC, with rules agreed in advance. His own family's cottage has been in the family since his grandmother bought it in the early 1970s. Watch at 0:01
Where should families start?
Michael suggests a family meeting to find out who wants the property and what the rules should be. Watch at 2:03
How should the trust pay for upkeep?
He recommends funding the trust so the income covers insurance, taxes, maintenance, and utilities, which keeps out-of-pocket costs fair for family members with different incomes. Watch at 5:22
Who should be trustees of a family cabin trust?
In his family's plan, only blood relatives serve as trustees; spouses don't have a say in running the cottage. Watch at 7:19
How can life insurance help keep a cabin?
Michael says life insurance on the parents can fund the trust. His mother's policy is set up to leave a few hundred thousand dollars for the cottage. Watch at 11:25
What rules should a family set for the cabin?
He mentions calling weeks for scheduling, leaving the place better than you found it, deciding whether VRBO or Airbnb rentals are allowed, and requiring adult supervision for minors. Watch at 12:50
Transcript
Transcript generated from YouTube's automatic captions for this episode and lightly cleaned (filler words and repeated words removed, names and web addresses corrected; phone numbers and email addresses read on air are replaced with a placeholder; [unclear] marks words the captions did not capture). It may still contain transcription errors, and speaker labels are not included. Timestamps link to that point in the video, which is the authoritative record.
Editor's note: Michael Smith works in Wisconsin, where trust, LLC, and property rules differ from California's. Bill Gross is a California real estate broker, not an attorney. This is general information, not legal advice; talk with an attorney in the state where the property is.
Editor's note: Insurance and trust structures depend on each family's facts and state law. This is general information, not legal, tax, or financial advice; talk with your own attorney, CPA, and licensed advisors before acting.
0:01 Welcome to Estate Planning Weekly. I'm Bill Gross, your host at Bill Gross Probate on social media. We get together every week with estate planning professional, attorneys, financial planners, resources, talk about how we can help our clients and ourselves keep more of our wealth and also more importantly keep the assets we want. And one of the people really struck me today was the idea of saving the family cabin. So often in probate or estate planning, it gets overlooked. It's not just about dividing up assets and money, but sometimes it's making sure you keep the asset you want, which might be the family cabin. A specialist in that area is Michael Smith of CPS Horizon Financial. Yeah, CPS Horizon Financial. Michael, thanks for taking time with us today. Thank you. You're welcome. Let's talk about that family cabin. What is the scenario that people miss and what can we do to help them save that family glue that family I'm not sure what the term would be but the asset that keeps the family together having fun together. Well, first of all, a family cottage or lake home or cabin in the woods often is a very special place for family members. Americans all across the country have second properties that are on lakes and cabins and things and my family is one of those. We've had a cabin or a cottage in our family since the early 1970s and it was originally purchased by my grandmother and we've been very fortunate that it's been able to pass along from generations and be mo used by multiple family members for a long time and that's kept our family close and tight-knit. But then as people start to pass away or families start to expand, it gets more and more complicated. So how do you keep that cottage or lake home in the family when the dynamics of a family change? And that's where having a cottage trust or an LLC or some kind of plan should be considered that allows that property to stay in the family for another
2:03 Generation or two. And that's what I thought we'd be talking about today as far as some strategies that you can utilize to keep the cabin in the family. Okay. Well, let's talk about that. So, what are some strategies? I mean, obviously, one strategy not to do is be so tight for funds to pay for taxes or for other assets. You have to liquidate things without regards to what you want to keep. So, let's talk a bit. What are some strategies people can use to keep those assets in their families? Well, one of the most important things to do is have a family meeting. So, let's say you've got mom and dad that still own the lake property and they've got three or four kids and the kids are growing up and they're getting married and they've got their own kids. So, grand and they're now the parents are grandparents and they're seeing their grandchildren grow up there as well. How do you keep that in the family? How do you try to figure that out when dynamics change so often? So having a family meeting expressly to discuss what the plans are, who wants the cabin, who wants the cottage, not everybody would like it perhaps. And so having a family meeting that says, "Okay, here's what are the plans for the cottage, who wants to stay involved in the cottage, who wants to be able to utilize it anytime they want. What are the rules of the cottage?" Having that open discussion is step number one and to have that clear understanding what the rules are.
3:22 And the second aspect here is get it in writing. What do you want to do with the cottage? Who's going to use it? Son Jeff now lives, you know, half a half a country away, still loves it there, would still love to be able to utilize the cottage whenever he's back home, but realistically, he's only home a couple weeks a year. How feasible does that make sense? Then you've got the family member who only might live in half an hour away and doesn't even go up at all and doesn't and hates the place. So having a good understanding of what that dynamic is and who wants to stay involved is again very important. And then the second aspect is to develop the written plan. Do we set it up as a cottage trust? Is it an LLC? What are the rules for that? And so from I'll just share a little bit about my family experiences. My grandmother bought the c my grandparents bought the cottage back in the 1970s. And when my grandmother passed away, it went to her three children. So my mom, my aunt, and my uncle. And for 50 years that worked out great. I grew up in the cottage, my cousins grew up the cottage. And then as people started to get married and move away, it's got a little more challenging. And we realized at some point when it got when the three siblings were owners passed away, it was going to get passed to seven children. So my cousins, and I was the oldest, the youngest are in their early 30s, and everybody's in a different financial aspect. Everybody's living in different parts of the country. It would have been very challenging. So in this particular case, one by one, some of the siblings decided to get bought out which caused for some tension at times. And although it's now just my mom owns the cottage, we haven't even seen my uncle or my cousins in a couple of years. So that was not what my grandmother intended. But that's what the that's exact what happened. Now that my mom is the sole owner, we've finished up a trust where my daughters and my sister will be able to continue on with the cottage.
5:22 Enjoying the usage as much as they want, come and going as they please and just being able to say, "Okay, that looks like this cottage is going to last another generation or two, and I maybe I might be able to see my grandchildren grow up at the cottage." So, having some kind of a plan in place is so important. Well, it sounds like the fundamentals of good communication apply here like does everything else in business, right? And planning ahead of time. So then it comes down to once you've got the rules kind of established and everybody on the same page and you set up the cottage trust, then it's a matter of okay, do you fund it? How do you how do you get assets into the trust? So that's where maybe mom and dad or the, you know, the patriarchs are saying, "Okay, we're going to put some money into the trust." And so when we're gone, there's an account that's going to be there that can be utilized to help pay the upkeep. And ideally, at least what's happening in my family as well as some others in our neck of the woods is there's enough money in the trust where the interest that the investment earns is enough to keep up for the insurance, the taxes, the maintenance, utilities. So, there's nothing coming out of pocket for the next generation. And that can be very important because the next generation might be in different economic fields. Someone might be making well into six figures. Or people are barely scraping by yet. How are they going to maintain the cottage if the people who don't have the funds who love the cottage but just can't afford to do with the upkeep? So having a having a trust funded and enough money generated to pay those expenses keeps the out-of-pocket cost fair for everybody and allows the family to be able to utilize the cottage with not with little to no out-of- pocket expenses.
7:19 So you interest I was thinking along the way is yeah you could leave the property in the trust but at some point somebody has to pay the property taxes and insurance and insurance is becoming a bigger issue here in California particular in areas where you have cottages or you know rural areas insurance is very expensive but still you could anticipate that funded enough and have the interest and returns on the fund cover the expenses and it could grow a bit you know I guess there's rules on how much you have to pull out. And so does that mean that somebody administers that trust on a annual basis at least who writes the check I guess for the insurance and the and the taxes and I guess there has to be some sort of return done as well. Yeah. So I mean if you're doing a trust that the you know the trustees can be the entities that make sure that finances are invested properly, assets or interest that needs to be pulled out is done properly and bills paid. The trustees can do that. And who is this who's should be a trustee? That's up for the people who set up the trust to kind of decide, right? A lot of families just say it's only family blood. So, and using my family's example, when my mom passes, it'll only be myself and my sister. I'm married, my sister's married, but our spouses, although they may or may not be involved in the cottage of much, will have no say over what decisions are being made. And that's way that's gives good protection for the inheritance to keep and the trust to keep going to family bloodlines. I'd hate to have something where I pass away and my wife gets remarried and now that entity that person now is involved in the cottage and my wife passes away and all of a sudden that a man I've never met is now in you has control over the family cottage. That's what we're trying to avoid completely. So it's only going down bloodline. So when I pass, it'll go to my daughters and eventually my grandchildren. So that's the intent as far as trying to figure out who a trustee is and who has decision-making processes. And in decision-making
9:22 Processes, it's also making sure bills are paid, insurance is up, the taxes are done, but also any maintenance. And that's where you have a good discussion with the family members and trustees as far as, okay, we need to get a new roof done. How are we paying for that? Well, if the money's in the trust, it comes from that. It can it can come from that. You don't have to sit there and worry about usage and on who can pay for what and who can afford anything. If the money is in the trust, that is how that proceeds as far as annual upkeep and also ideally a little bit of growth in the trust. So that even though you're taking money out each year from the trust to pay the expenses, there's still enough money in there to have some growth. So when a major expense comes up down the line, that's where the money can be coming from instead of having to come from pockets of family members who may or may not be able to afford it. Well, and this is often overlooked in real estate in that, you know, businesses will, you know, depreciate an asset and they have if they have real estate, they'll depreciate say the lifespan of the roof, lifespan of the carpet, lifespan of the fixtures. And often times individuals don't I know I'm involved with a nonprofit has a building that's free and clear. They don't put anything aside. Well, then all of a sudden when they have to redo the air conditioning units that cost $50,000 for a commercial unit, they don't have the money versus if you know, well, you probably have to replace the commercial air conditioner every 20 years. You put aside the 12th every year and it builds up. And I imagine with a family property like this, you could do the same thing. We can kind of estimate, you know, things require money. Let's put aside that money on a annual basis out of the proceeds and then when something comes up, there's already money there for repainting or woodwork or whatever. The dock gets blown out by a hurricane, you can you have money there, a fund of some sort to put it back in. And so all that all that gets down to imagine is planning and communication like everything else, right? And what if the parents or the patriarchs don't have a decent amount of money to put into a
11:25 Trust? Maybe, you know, maybe there's of modest means or something. Well, that's where a life insurance policy on the patriarchs could make some sense. Do you get some, you know, for example, going back to my family, we've got some assets that will be set aside for the trust, but we've also got a life insurance policy. So when my mom passes, there'll be a few hundred,000 that'll go from the proceeds of life insurance into the trust to help fund the trust. And again, enough money kicked off each year to via interest to be paying the expenses. Wow. So life insurance factors into that as well as setting aside proper amounts of money as well as the documents. Okay. Well, any other strategic tips as far as the process for maintaining this? Obviously, good communication, planning. I think life insurance is a tool to consider. I think also setting aside a budget to cover expenses are some good tips you've given us so far. Anything else that we're missing that we need to be aware of? I think it's also a matter of making sure that like I said, good communication, but also establishing solid rules and making sure those rules are followed throughout the course of the of the time that people family members use the cottage. Some family members, some families just say, "Okay, we're calling weekends." So, we're drawing names out of a hat, and this, you know, Doug gets to use it this week, Sarah gets to use it that week, Jenny gets to use it this week. Well, is that the kind of structure you want your family to have?
12:50 And if that's what you want, that's absolutely fine. Our particular is come and go as you please. You know, just have common courtesy to let people know that, hey, I'm heading up. So, that way there is not a lot of private time in our family, but we don't mind that. We like that. I like it when my cousins are able to attend and we enjoy that. And it's kind of just here are the rules for when this happens. And it's always important to realize that when you go to the cottage, you go to the lake home and you're when you're ready to leave, you leave it as good if not better than how you found it. So if you know, so nothing's worse than coming up there and finding a dirty dishes or dirty, you know, stuff around the cottage or a lake home. Have clear rules on that. It sounds nitpicky, but believe it or not, if you don't have those written rules and understood by and signed off by everybody, it's going to get abused and someone's going to be irritating somebody else because they didn't take the garbage out and it stunk up the place or whatever. So, as irritating as nitpicky as it is, sometimes, you have to realize a lake home or a second cabin or something like that is you is a second home. And you have to realize that it means it needs upkeep just as much as your primary home. And making sure there's clear understanding who does what is incredibly important and it avoids a lot of arguing and fighting down the line. I imagine as generations change, you know, I can imagine that my brother and I might get along a certain way and have certain expectations and yet our kids might have different. So as you go to the next generation, having those rules laid out, again, that's just good communication and planning ahead of time. I think rules are really a combination of planning and communication, right? Communicates in writing. You planned ahead to write the rules and by doing that you help you do your best to minimize conflict. There'll always be some conflict but at least you do your best to minimize it. So having a good set of rules would seem to be important. And if you're talking about the next generation too, you know, start explaining the rules to that when they're teenagers. So there's clear expectations as to what those are.
14:51 So as they grow up, it's like, okay, this is never even questioned. You know, it's this is how this is how the rules are. This is how it's going to be and it's understood. You know, there's a couple of the things that really since we're kind of talking about rules a little bit here, things to take into consideration that are often forgotten. What if you're the kind of family that says, "Oh, okay, we're calling weeks and someone's going to be a different family member takes each week." What if one of those family members chooses not to go their week, but rents it out via VRBO or Airbnb? Is that going to be allowed? I you're going to if you're if you've got that lake home or that cottage, I think that has to be clearly understood whether that's going to be allowed or not because your precious home is being rented out to strangers and you don't have any say about it because there's nothing in the rules saying you can't do that. So that's incredibly important to try to nip that in the bud. Another aspect too is what about when is when does it make some sense for minors or children under 21 to be allowed to be up there without adult supervision? And that's going to be clear. So my family, we are always allowed to have friends up, but I always had to be an adult or one of the owners of the cottages there. I mean, which was just smart because I know what I was like when I was 16. I was an idiot, you know. So it's one of those, you know, I would have got myself in trouble if there was no adult around. So let's skip over this part here. We didn't need to go any detail.
16:11 I think I did actually. I'm thinking about now. I'm trying to think when I was in high school. I think we went to somebody's cabin. I think we did do some idiotic stuff. So, we're gonna skip this part of that. We're gonna edit this part out of the podcast. So, Oh, no. That's what we leave it in. That's fine. Detail, but the important aspect is to realize that, you know, have in the rules when it's going to make some sense to allow people to go up there without supervision, right? And if your if your 20-year-old is mature enough and you trust them, that's great. If not, does it make some sense to have an adult or someone with ownership still there? Right? It's incredibly important to have those discussions with the family. I think you're right. And plan ahead and have it in writing makes a lot of sense as well. And then again, the writing it out, that's a complicated question. It sounds so simple. Hey, I'm entitled to a week a year, five weeks a year. I want to get some money out of it, but look, I'm in real estate. There are plenty of cases where people have gone in on an Airbnb or equivalent and decided they want to stay. And in California, different states are different. California is probably the worst once they're in the door. It's tough getting them out and so you can end up putting yourself in a real legal predicament if there's such you know such mistakes and such. So I would say be careful. I would really urge against that if it's if you're if you're in essence time sharing it or sharing with people I would not allow them to rent it out because I think you're just asking for trouble. It's just too difficult.
17:40 Absolutely. Yeah. Okay. So, and then at some point in time I imagine if you have some sort of a cabin and everybody agrees, they may want to sell that. They may want to buy a new one. They may want to sell and buy their own. I guess that's also something you have to put in the rules if you're allowed that or not allow that, right? So maybe grandma doesn't want it sold ever. Or maybe she allows that if the owners get together. But again, I guess the answer there would be make sure the communication's clear and plan ahead. And by that would be in the rules and in the details of the trust if you allow that or not. Correct. Absolutely correct. And having it clearly understood because let's say there's you know ultimately there's four trustees there's a couple of brothers and sisters or something along those lines. If someone wants out how are they what's the exit strategy? And you can have it structured where they really don't have any equity because the tr they don't nobody owns the tr nobody owns the cottage. A trust owns the cottage. So, do they if they want to walk away from the cottage, can they force a sale? Well, in some states and in some structures, yeah, they could force a sale or be forced to bought out. Or you say, look, the cottage is owned by a trust. You're a trustee, but you don't have any ownership. So, you know, if you want to walk away, you're not going to get anything for it until the everybody agrees and then the whole cottage collectively is sold. So someone might not be able to get any inheritance out of that because they technically don't they're not an owner of it and they can't necessarily force a buyout.
19:12 So it all depends on what you want to structure and unfortunately that you know families dynamics change, divorce, death, disability, job change, relocation change. And if you want to be able to for some people it's like I'm sorry you don't get to use the cabin as much because you live half a country away but that you that shouldn't be a penalty to the rest of the family. If everybody kind of understands that on the front end, it's then they can make adjustments and if a parent wants to make adjustments to their estate plan to say, "Okay, these three are going to be trustees of the cottage or the lake home at this one because they will never be involved in it. I'll make adjustments with the estate plan so they get something down the line." Those are the conversations you have while people are still alive and you can have them and that way you can effectuate the desires of the person who is creating the trust, right? That ultimately the idea they have a plan, they have a vision and we want to be able to fulfill that vision. And it has to be flexible enough to accommodate changes that they anticipate, but it might be grandma, grandpa want the cabin forever in the family because they want to say to you, maybe it's a reason why you don't move out of state because you have this resource. If you live here, you can use it. If you move away, you don't. And we want to keep our family together. And that might be a benefit. And I know for me personally, I benefit that my we only have one child. Not for lack of trying but the way life worked out but we already have two grandkids and they live near us and it's a big part of our life one of the real pleasures of our life is being near our family and I and I was recently a funeral where the grandkids are all spread across the country and those grandparents don't have that pleasure and so I think it's one of those things where if you own a family asset a cabin of some sort you want to use that to try to keep your family together when you're gone as your legacy I guess that's your privilege And Michael is somebody who can help you do that. So, okay. So, Michael, you're, if somebody who's interested in working with you, kind of give me kind of an overview. I know you don't spend all day just on cabin trust. What would kind of the bigger picture be look like for your basic business? So, I'm
21:16 What's called an insurance brokerage general agency. So, I work a lot of people with when it comes to life insurance, disability, long-term care insurance. A lot of my clients are financial planners and attorneys and accountants and insurance agents whose clients are looking for insurance, but I often get called into to work directly with their clients when there's they have an insurance need. And so when it comes to like the family cabin here, insurance is one of the options or one of the solutions that could help fund the trust. Life insurance can do that. But again, if somebody's just looking for some life insurance for estate planning purposes to pay the estate taxes or the secure act has made it a little more challenging to inherit IRAs, there's insurance solutions that can be utilized for that. So, I'm a great resource for that because I don't work for one insurance company. I shop the market and try to find what's in a client's best interest when it comes to their insurance needs. Well, Michael, I appreciate you sharing this with us and obviously you're a world of resource and information. People should reach out. Your contact information is on the banner as well. It will be in the description. And if someone wants to get hold of you, cpshorizon.com is the company. I'm sorry. Cpshorizon.com is the website and CPS Horizon Financial is the company. Reach out to Michael Smith and his contact information is on the screen. Michael, I really appreciate the chance to get into detail with you today and thank you for sharing, you know, obviously one aspect of business and I think this is just shows how powerful insurance is. We think of insurance as not enough because it really becomes a tool to leverage so many different goals and the key is what do you want to accomplish and somebody who's knowledgeable of all the tools available can bring those tools to resource for a family. So, thank you for your time today. I really appreciate it.
22:59 You're welcome. And for the rest of you, this is estate planning weekly. We get together every week with estate planners as well as with professional service the industry to help us be more effective with our customers, with attorneys, vendors, and such. I'm Bill Gross Bill Gross Probate on social media. Please check out the podcast if you like it. We have a Facebook group. We can continue the conversation. You can have questions there as well as referrals, looking for referrals or to receive referrals. Love you to participate. If you have other questions or areas you like us to talk about, put comments down below. Please like or subscribe if you like this. And as always, make today your
More The Estate Planning Podcast episodes
- Estate Planning Is More Than Just Documents, with Texas Attorney Jeremy Cleverly
- Think You Don't Need Your Life Insurance Policy? Here's How It Still Benefits You, with Lisa Rehburg
- The Danger of Computer-Generated Estate Plans, with Debbie Babb
Related
- A guide for successor trustees
- How long does probate take?
- Probate attorneys and podcast guests
- The Estate Planning Podcast: all episodes
- For attorneys & fiduciaries
Educational media, not legal advice. Guest views are their own. Hosted by Bill Gross, The LA Probate Expert, a licensed California real estate broker (DRE #01022275) brokered by eXp Realty of California, Inc. (DRE #01878277). Bill is not an attorney and is not a Probate Referee.