How to Help America's Aging Families Find Trusted Attorneys, with Mark Mottershead
The Estate Planning Podcast · · Guest: Mark Mottershead, Silver Shield Media
Episode summary
Bill Gross talks with Mark Mottershead, founder of Silver Shield Media, which markets estate planning and elder law firms, about how families now find attorneys online.
Mark explains that referrals used to drive most of the business, but people now ask their phones detailed questions, and recent changes in Google's AI-driven results create an opening for smaller local firms. Bill describes checking several AI tools and finding he did not show up as a top probate agent despite his content.
Mark recommends pulling the common questions out of client conversations or podcast transcripts and answering them on the firm's site in an FAQ format, keeping the Google Business Profile current with photos and updates, and making sure the office location and details are right.
They also cover Google local service ads, answering calls quickly, asking for specific reviews, and Mark's pay-per-consultation pricing model.
Key points
- People now search with detailed questions, so answer those questions clearly on your website.
- Keep your Google Business Profile accurate and active with photos, updates, and correct location details.
- Answer inquiries quickly; missed calls and full voicemail boxes can hurt how Google rates your business.
- Reviews that mention specific services and outcomes help more than generic praise.
- Track cost per signed client, not just cost per lead, when judging marketing.
Questions answered in this episode
How has online search changed for estate planning attorneys?
Mark Mottershead says people used to search for an estate planning attorney near them, but now they ask detailed questions, such as what to do when a parent is in the hospital. He sees that as a big opportunity for smaller firms. Watch at 3:54
How can a law firm get picked up by AI search?
Mark suggests pulling the common questions out of client conversations or podcast transcripts, answering them on the firm's site in an FAQ format Google can read, and keeping the Google Business Profile active with photos and updates. Watch at 6:33
Why does the office location on Google matter?
Mark says Google wants to give its users the best answers, so the map pin for your office, your entrance, and your parking details need to be right. Watch at 9:39
What are Google local service ads?
Mark says local service ads appear at the top of the page in a given area and are priced per inquiry rather than per click. He pairs them with an AI voice agent so calls are answered, including after hours. Watch at 13:20
What makes an online review useful?
Mark says a hundred reviews that just say 'great service' do not help much. Google looks for specific phrases, so ask clients to mention the service you provided. Watch at 17:32
How much do local service ad leads cost?
Mark says Google's charge varies by state and city, roughly $50 to $150 per inquiry, and his firm charges a fee on top, aiming for a target cost per signed client. Watch at 21:48
Transcript
Transcript generated from YouTube's automatic captions for this episode and lightly cleaned (filler words and repeated words removed, names and web addresses corrected; phone numbers and email addresses read on air are replaced with a placeholder; [unclear] marks words the captions did not capture). It may still contain transcription errors, and speaker labels are not included. Timestamps link to that point in the video, which is the authoritative record.
Editor's note: Advertising costs and search features are as described at recording and change often. Attorneys should also check their state bar's advertising rules.
0:02 As a small business and particularly attorneys, it'd be nice just to be an attorney, but the reality is in most cases you're a business person. Unless you employ a large firm, if you're in a small firm or a partner of your own firm, priority day has to be where is the business going to come from? And it used to be my father was an attorney, used to be you just did good work and more business came to you. But as the work market's gotten more competitive in every industry, it requires more and more thought to what do we want to put out in the market so we get those referrals? How we stay in touch with people who talk to us and convert that into business. Well, excited to have today Mark Modersitzki who is the founder of Silvershield Media which is a media company which in part focuses directly on estate planning attorneys, how to help them generate the business, and has two pieces of the puzzle that I think every attorney should look at and have a solution for either on their own or take a look at his. Mark, thanks for joining us today.
0:55 No, thank you, Bill, for the invitation. And so I think I see the challenge attorneys have of either not enough business or so much activity that's not paying turning into revenue where they're paying a lot of money for their ads and not getting the results or getting a lot of work. So, talk a little bit about how you see the problem and where you where you position yourself to help solve that problem.
1:17 Yeah, I think in the past attorneys would have relied a lot on referrals and it was probably a steady business because they had a certain network. But of course, with the introduction of the internet and now mobile phones, that has turned into a completely different ball game now because perhaps the referral network is dropping off, but it's been replaced by this wave of people with mobile phones in their hands, cell phones in their hands. And so, people are just looking up looking for help and there's a massive change that has just happened, I say just about 3 months ago in Google, that is really exasperating this issue. And so, as you say, it's a feast or it's often a feast or famine. Maybe the phone doesn't ring, and then the phone rings off the hook, and they don't have the staff, especially the smaller practice, to handle the influx of inbound calls. And so, what happens is the attorney themselves probably will act as the third receptionist and is trying to field calls and is trying to deal with people just looking for free advice. And so, an awful lot of time is spent and no revenue is generated. So, that's the issue I see out there. It's firstly having a reliable stream of incoming leads and then being able to deal with them in an efficient manner.
2:41 One of the challenges I've seen in sales throughout my career is that when you try to improve your conversion, there's a tendency to lower the standard of lead that you take in. And so, while you get a little better conversion rate or at least the number that you want to hit, you end up with business that's much harder to work with. The business that I get referred by fiduciaries or attorneys, that listing is 1/10 the work of a stranger coming through. So, talk So, I think that part of the challenge is it used to be that your past clients, your friends, your family automatically came to you cuz there was only the Yellow Pages or, you know, they only knew somebody to ask. Now, with so many options, I want to say a third or more of your past client business referral gets skimmed off by Google, Facebook ads, other people who look like they're effective and they're not. So, talk a bit about firstly, how does the practitioner who does a good job, who does good work, who has a good reputation and a following of sorts, what do they need to do to keep that kind of population percolating and coming to them for a solution rather than getting siphoned off by Google or you other legal industry equivalents.
3:54 Well, in fact, with the change I just mentioned, there is now a big opportunity for all local businesses and including estate planning, elder law, and probate attorneys as well. And the changes are that so in the old days, people would look up estate planning attorney near me. But nowadays, they're so used to getting answers about a specific issues. They might say they might get the phone out and say my dad is in hospital and I need to I've got 48 hours to sort out his estate. What do I do? Now, as I say, in the old days, the it would be just a very simple search, but it's now it's like having a personal concierge in your pocket. That's what Gemini is becoming. So, Gemini being the Google AI. And so, attorneys who can answer those questions, maybe have those as an FAQ on their site, those results will start to appear in Gemini within that Google search. So, if someone is specifically asking about protecting an estate, and obviously it is still locally based, let's not forget that. But if they have that on their site, they can start to attract that business. So, it's not just a matter of how big you are, how many reviews you've got, what's your star rating.
5:11 It's a matter of can you provide the information to Google that will then help that individual. So, there's a real there's a sea change in the way local search happens, and it's a very big opportunity for smaller attorney practices now.
5:28 You know, I see that myself. I was doing a self audit on my business and how I come up and AI. I've never really worked on search engine optimization. I've always worked on referrals. But I do know that customers get referred by an attorney and then the customer wants to check me out. So, I asked the question like who's the top probate real estate agent in Los Angeles. And was shocked that I wasn't on the list and I went across four five different large language models. And so I start digging into why and the answer is well, I have a lot of content. I have you know, podcast episodes with some of the top attorneys in LA and I have a track record that's among the top couple in Los Angeles. Agents way below me were popping up because they had websites that were more Google AI compliant with like you say questions and answers. And I said, well, I have all that here. I just don't have it in the format that is accessible to the AI in a way that makes it easy for them to find me. So, talk a bit about some of the things that you do to help an attorney who maybe has all the pieces of the puzzle in a box. They just don't have it put together properly.
6:33 Yeah, so I mean in your case, what you might want to do is take those podcast episodes and get the transcripts. I'm sure you're using NotebookLM. So, you might want to run those through NotebookLM and just pull out all of those common questions. Now, it's not quite the same as dealing with clients directly, but the same process would apply to clients. So, what they could do if they have call recordings of some of the conversations, not obviously the totally private ones, but confidential ones. But if they have conversation recordings, they can go through those and they can pull out the common questions and the common objections they might have.
7:18 Yeah. And then they can answer those on their site. Right. And if they put those in an FAQ format that Google can understand, it will start to pick to Google start to pick up that text and that copy. Now, at the same time they do need to trigger what that the Google actually takes a look at them and scans their site. I've been recently running some searches via the Google API, so literally talking directly to Google, and asking, you know, for let's say estate planning attorneys in Miami, and you'd be surprised some of these even the top ranked attorney practices, they haven't been scanned. They've Their site hasn't been visited by Google for 6 months, 9 months, 12 months.
8:07 So, it's very important that you that these practices start to trigger Google's attention, and they can do that by posting photos and updates and updating their profile, their Google Business Profile. And all will all of this will start to trigger the AI's interest in their business.
8:27 I think that the exciting thing about this is, you know, I've been a coach in real estate for a long time, and I've coached small businesses. I've always said there's two types of marketing. There's a marketing that's easy to sell, it just doesn't work. And there's a marketing that's hard to sell, but actually moves the needle. And I think what's happening with this AI, just to kind of from my perspective, is it's deemphasizing just the lipstick and the Botox and the short mini skirt and all that, and it's really saying, "Well, emphasize your reputation. We'll emphasize your knowledge, your experience, your output, but you've got to put it in this format for us to see it. And if we see it, we're going to share that cuz we want customers. Our I should say our customers want to find you, but please just make it easy for us to find you." And so, I think these changes in Google are technical. They sound very technical and off-putting, but the reality is for those attorneys who are good at what they do and are honest and have good reputations and results, this is a chance to stand up and shine. However, you've got to submit your application of your information in the right format. Is that for assessment?
9:39 Yeah, absolutely. You will have to remember that Google's goal at all times is to present their users with the best answers because otherwise they'll go elsewhere. So if you're providing Google with the best answers for its clients, in other words, its users and searchers, then it will start to use your information. So for example, let's say somebody needs to find a courthouse in their in their city. They might not know where it is or they need to visit your office before they visit the courthouse, whatever. The and Google has put them the pin for where your office is in your office block, but actually you're not on the main street there, you're on a side street you're the entrance. And you haven't put in where your car park is or whether you have car park facilities, whether you have wheelchair facilities, and of course this is very relevant for estate planning attorneys cuz often there's an elderly person involved and they might want to come along and so forth. And so all of those little tiny things you can do will help Google to present its users, its searchers with the best results because if that person is driving round and round and round trying to find the entrance and it's just plugged it straight into Google on its phone or on its Apple CarPlay on its in the car and it's taking you to the wrong location.
11:05 I'm sure we've all experienced that where you've put in the location, yeah, it's a you know, Jones and Sons attorneys and it goes there and no, it's completely the wrong place and then you're in the one-way system maybe and you can't find the car park and it and it is hard work. So you need to make it as easy as possible for Google to have the right information that it can present to that person when they're driving along, for example.
11:30 You know, I think that what I've learned about Google I mean, been very active in YouTube for the last 5 6 years. I really made I made decision then was I don't know where all the search and AI's going, but I know if I if I create good content, it's valuable to people watch it, I can always repurpose it, reuse it, reformat it. And so, one thing I learned about Google's YouTube cuz you said this on search, it's true in YouTube as well. It just tells you as a corporate but philosophy. They want the search customer to get the result experience they want and stay on Google's platform. So, for me, I know in YouTube, there's only one metric that matters. How much of a video do people watch? All the rest is vanity, subscribers, and views, and all that all that's really nice, but at the end of the day, how long is the average person stay on your video and how much cumulative is your channel create watch time? It makes happy YouTube customers. And the same with search. They're now going from search optimization to really saying, "What do people really want?" Well, people want solutions. They don't just want a bunch of web links. And so, we have to package ourselves a solution. So, let's talk about I went on your website. Well, first of all, I want to say anybody who's watching this Mark offers a free giveaway free I guess a you know, we call it lead magnet technology, but it's really a nice summary of an AI blueprint. And I actually downloaded myself and found it helpful and made a couple changes to my Google profile. So, if you're interested, I'll put it up at the end as well. But his company is silvershieldmedia.com/build is where this document's located. Feel free to go there. I'll put it up again at the end. But let's take a look at your website. And I think I would like the way that you presented the two kind of paths or main focuses in your marketing services. This is something that any attorney has to think about these two pillars. Talk a bit about them and how they fit into your system.
13:20 So, the one on the left as we look at it, the qualified consultation engine. We tend to specialize not in Google search ads as people know it, but Google local service ads. And the reason is that's pretty much guaranteed to put you in that top space. Now, there's only so many spaces for Google local service ads within a specific city or a specific area. But, it does put you at the top of the page there, and the pricing is per inquiry rather than per click. So, that's a completely different setup. Now, you can use it without having the second service, the voice AI agent. But, it's recommended to do it together. And the reason is that again, trying to pacify the Google gods, there it wants to present the best results for the people using its services, and that result will be a telephone call that's answered in a timely fashion. Timely means within 30 seconds. So, it might be that the during office hours, the call from the local service ad will go through to the receptionist or to somebody specified within the office to answer the calls. Great. Okay, works fine. But, what happens if a second call comes in at the same time?
14:40 Does that go to voicemail? Do they go to a hold system? So, that needs to be dealt with because that will start to count against the business. And when that app Excuse me, when that happens, then Google will start to rate your business lower. So, it Like I said, it wants to make sure that businesses are offering a service not just to their clients, but to Google's clients as well. So, that's why we always align it to the Instant Engage engine, which is the AI voice agent. And of course, that will answer all calls out of hours. And it's not just a press one for this, press two for that. It can really be programmed and set to qualify callers as you see fit. So, it depends on the attorney and how they like to work, but it can be programmed with all of that. And they really are quite remarkable nowadays the systems. And so, if it's somebody who qualifies, whatever qualifies means for the particular attorney, they can be booked right into a calendar automatically. If not, it can be arranged for it, let's say, a callback. Yes, we'll get one of our team to call you back tomorrow morning at 10:00. Whatever the arrangement is. So, the two working together really it's very synchronous and it helps to improve what Google does it asks you, "How do you rate the How do you rate the person who's we've sent to you?" And you have to rate it within the local service ad dashboard.
16:16 And the higher you rate it's kind of like a self-reinforcing system. Because if you answer it quickly and the person gets a fast response, then yes, that's a that's a good result for Google and then it's also a good result for the person calling. And so, it becomes a self-reinforcing thing that the more quality you get, the faster you answer it, the Google will send you those premium leads. Does that make sense?
16:44 Yes, and that's why it's important when you're user and you get this opportunity to help somebody you want to help, that you provide the review. Right? I'm a I'm older, I have various medical situations I'm getting maintained or whatever, and they all have a similar system that now leads me. I just noticed more and more even doctors that all leads kind of to some sort of a Google review or some sort of review system. And I'm always glad to help the ones that I like cuz I want to promote their business. These are becoming very important, I think, for the business, especially an estate plan which you can often be, you know, one and done or you're starting your practice or you're trying to build it's really important that customers give that good leave the breadcrumbs of good service that Google says, "Oh, they were happy. Well, we'll send them another one. Oh, we'll send them another one." As long as that happens, and so that's why it becomes so important. So,
17:32 And sorry, just to reinforce that, these reviews becoming more important, it's no point having a hundred reviews that say, "Great service." or "I love John. He was fantastic." What Google is looking for, because obviously, when we're talking about the Google Business Profile and the reviews within that, those that's prime Google space. Google knows it can read those without any issues, because it's all in the format that Google's created. And then it's looking for specific phrases. So, this is all on the blueprint if you want to pick it up. But it what you want to be asking people when they when you want to ask them to leave a review is not just how was it's like, "What did you come in with?" how do how were we able to help you? What has been the result? So, there's a story involved, and then they all start to use key phrases, not keywords, but key phrases like Medicare planning, or you know, "My mother fell down and broke her hip." or whatever it is, and dot, whatever the issue is. And so, Google can directly read those reviews. And the other important factor is to respond to those reviews. So, if you get a review on Google Business Profile, respond to it, cuz Google likes to see that, too.
18:48 Yeah. Yeah, all good advice. And again, I have to say, you know, when I first saw you, I saw you running ads in the places where I see the attorneys that I work with posting their content. So, for all I know, some of them are or one or more are your client. And I went online and went to your website and got the you know, the lead magnet, the free offer that you have for the AI Blueprint, and downloaded it, I liked it. And I think for me, you know, I don't want just interview anybody. I want somebody there's a the number of people who are in the space, but I think it's important that, you know, I'd love to get my estate planning attorneys who are doing well to do better by getting better business, not just more, but we also want to get better business. So, Mark, what does just kind of bring it to a final close here a little bit. So, an attorney who is interested in more information from you, gets together with you and has some sort of call So, what's the process look like? I mean, how much time is the attorney involved or I guess if his operations manager, is it handled at that level? What kind of investment is it variable? Is it based on the size of the of the is it customizable based on the size of the firm? What does it look like the next steps?
19:59 A lot of let me answer that from the opposite direction. A lot of marketing firms tend to say, "Well, it's 3,000 a month and we're you're set for 6 months and then whatever." And if it's SEO, then that's an even bigger because you bigger issue because you never know what's the results you're going to get. So, we've kind of turned that on its head and we charge a setup fee and then we charge a per appointment fee or per consultation fee. So, it's a pay per results kind of basis. The attorney will pay Google directly for the ads and so those for the clients that get sent by the Google LSA ads, so they pay Google directly and they pay us directly per consultation. So, that kind of removes all the risk. And the way we set that up is that we will obviously have an initial call, see what they're up to, see how they're currently handling calls. Now, the issues can be many and varied. So, let's say some of them are to do with overwhelm, some are to do with not enough calls, some of them are to do with the qualification's not happening, the attorney spending too much time dealing with people who aren't really qualified. Maybe they don't have a follow-up system. So, we en- make sure that they're the clients or the prospect is followed up in a timely fashion. There might be a series of educational emails. Then there'll be if they have an appointment, there'll be not just email reminders, but text reminders.
21:31 So, it's a complete system that will take the Google LSA inquiries that come in and then convert those to qualified appointments. And we obviously decide with together with the attorney in question what qualified means.
21:48 Are you able to share what the cost per consult is or what the variables are in pricing the price per consult? Yeah, so the cost for Google LSA ads, it's going to vary by state and by city, but let's say it's kind of a 100 is 50 to 150. That kind of amount That's what Google charges. And then we charge a fee on top of that. And what we're aiming to do is get a cost per signed client. So, in other words, not just a consultation, but a signed client.
22:21 Within a KPI, let's say 15%, 15 to 20%, something like that. So, that means if we do that consistently, the attorney's going to be making, hopefully, about a three to five ROI on the money that they spent.
22:39 So, maybe the cost per signing is 12 or 1,300 dollars and the average signing might be 3,500 or 4,000, something those kinds of round numbers?
22:49 Yeah, probably yes. Probably a bit less than that. I've actually got a calculator. So, what we do is we walk people through a calculator on the site when we talk with them. And say, "Okay, well, how much do you get per matter, per case?" Okay, we get three and a half, four and a half, five, six, whatever it is. We say, "Okay, well, how many leads? What's your normal conversion rate?" Depending on whether it's a qualified or non-qualified. And what are you used to spending on your marketing costs? Now, if you're looking to be slightly more aggressive, you might be wanting to spend slightly more as a percentage. And then we say, "Okay, well, our normal charge is X per lead on top of the Google charge, X per consultation." that then comes to a total of whatever the number is. Does that make sense? Would that work for you?" And then we put our name to it.
23:41 Right. You know, we agree on that, and they are paying on a per consultation basis. I think now is it I guess to some it's also variable, meaning times of the year they can be more spending more money to get more leads, and other times of the year they can back off if they're going to go on vacation, I guess. And so if you can get the machine running and fine-tuned, it gives you a little bit of flexibility that you wouldn't have otherwise, I would think.
24:04 Yeah, what you want to do is build up a track record with Google, so that Google is sending you those prime leads, you know? So, that again, just without wanting to repeat myself, is making sure that you answer the calls in a timely fashion, and you give the customers a good service. And then they will start to feed those good leads to you. And so you need you need Sorry, just build finish off. You need like three, four, five months to build up that track record, and then perhaps you can scale it back a bit.
24:36 Yeah, I think what you're doing is you're bringing to the market to the smaller and mid-size firms kind of marketing tools that the largest firms, the online ones, have used to build. I know Trust & Will.com, LegalZoom, they've used these kinds of tools because they were much bigger, more expensive tools. And what AI has done is made some very powerful computer available to smaller companies like you that can provide them pieces of the puzzle to attorneys to put in their business. So, that's what's I think exciting about this opportunity. Right now, a lot of the benefits are going to the largest large companies and they're jumping into this. But at the same time, those of us who can kind of bite off a piece at a time and hyper focus it with whatever business can make dramatic strides in time forward. So, Mark, I really appreciate, you know, you walking through this with us and I appreciate the AI blueprint that you had online. If you want more information, I'll put up the link for his website. In fact, I'll put up the actual website for you see it again. Silver Shield Media is the name of the company and Mark Motorshead [email address] and there's a website and then he's offering kind of free I think sample. The way I would think of it kind of go through Costco and you get the little samples of the crackers and cheese. AI written is blueprint he's created silvershieldmedia.com/bill.
25:57 Hey, how about that? I like that one. And you go in there and you put in your I think name and your email and you get a download and I found it's just a two-page read. It's pretty simple but some you know, some good points that I literally read it, sat down, and changes my profile. I and things I just hadn't thought about and I think it was very simple and easy to use. So, Mark, thank you so much for joining us today and bringing us the information regarding your program and you know, continued success in helping my clients and the industry as well.
26:26 Thank you, Bill, and all the best to you and your clients, too. Yeah, for the rest of us, this was Estate Planning Weekly. We normally talk to estate planning attorneys, administrators, litigators, but today I wanted to bring somebody who I thought is a very interesting resource to estate planning firms looking to increase their business. So, it's worth a phone call and to see if it's a good a good fit for you. For marketing program as well. But again, I there's so many different companies that do this. I thought this one was really right on point of what a trainer should be looking to do. If I can help any way at Bill Gross Profit on Social Media, I'd love to get your comments, likes, questions. If I can help in any way and as always make today your best day ever. Thanks so much.
More The Estate Planning Podcast episodes
- Becoming a Time Freedom Lawyer, with Chris Guymon
- Tax Services for Estate Planning and Wealth Preservation, with Nicole Green
- The Estate Planning Mistake That Makes Your Living Trust Worthless, with Scott Schomer — Scott P. Schomer
Related
- A guide for successor trustees
- How long does probate take?
- Probate attorneys and podcast guests
- The Estate Planning Podcast: all episodes
- For attorneys & fiduciaries
Educational media, not legal advice. Guest views are their own. Hosted by Bill Gross, The LA Probate Expert, a licensed California real estate broker (DRE #01022275) brokered by eXp Realty of California, Inc. (DRE #01878277). Bill is not an attorney and is not a Probate Referee.