Choosing Trustees and Avoiding Trust Litigation, with Beti Bergman
The Estate Planning Podcast · · Guest: Beti Bergman, Peninsula Law, A Professional Law Corporation
Episode summary
Bill Gross talks with Beti Bergman of Peninsula Law, a probate lawyer in Palos Verdes and Torrance, about choosing the right trustee and what happens when trusts end up in dispute.
Beti covers the practical problems with naming siblings as co-trustees, when a bank or a private professional fiduciary makes sense, and why any trustee should have legal counsel.
They discuss the trustee's duty to notify beneficiaries and heirs, what to do when a trustee won't share information, and how much of the trust a trustee has to produce.
They also talk about weighing the cost and emotional toll of litigation, how unpredictable witnesses can be, and why she believes in being honest with clients about their case.
Key points
- Think through practical issues before naming siblings as co-trustees.
- A private professional fiduciary can be a good option when no family member fits the role.
- Trustees should get legal advice; the job carries real duties.
- Beneficiaries can ask the trustee for information and, if needed, petition the court.
- Weigh the financial and emotional cost before going to litigation.
Questions answered in this episode
Should siblings serve as co-trustees?
Beti Bergman says to look at it with clear eyes: siblings may live far apart and have busy lives, and her general advice is not to have people serve together because it is practically difficult. Watch at 4:07
When does a private professional fiduciary make sense?
Beti says a professional fiduciary can serve when no family member is a good fit, and that banks often have minimum account sizes. Watch at 10:03
Does a trustee need a lawyer?
Beti says yes: a trustee has legal duties and should have counsel to guide them. Watch at 11:48
What if a trustee won't share information?
Beti says the first step is usually a letter asking for the information, but if push comes to shove, the only real recourse is to petition the court. Watch at 21:01
Does a trustee have to give beneficiaries the whole trust?
Beti says the trustee must produce the terms that affect that beneficiary, but in her experience carving out pieces makes people ask what is being hidden. Watch at 22:37
Is trust litigation worth it?
Beti says to weigh the cost and the emotional toll, and notes that witnesses can be unpredictable. Watch at 26:46
Transcript
Transcript generated from YouTube's automatic captions for this episode and lightly cleaned (filler words and repeated words removed, names and web addresses corrected; phone numbers and email addresses read on air are replaced with a placeholder; [unclear] marks words the captions did not capture). It may still contain transcription errors, and speaker labels are not included. Timestamps link to that point in the video, which is the authoritative record.
Editor's note: Deadlines and procedures are as described at recording and depend on the facts. Bill's comments about specific banks are his personal opinions. This is general information, not legal, tax, or financial advice; talk with your own attorney, CPA, and licensed advisors before acting.
0:02 Really important when you do an estate plan that you're not just find an attorney or lawyer, whichever word you use, to do the paperwork, but you find somebody who's really an expert in the field. Both knows the problems as they come up and deals with litigation or is familiar with them or can help you write a plan that avoids those problems. Really excited to have today a lady who's based in the South Bay, although services are all over California, but Palos Verdes and Torrance probate lawyer Beti Bergman. Beti, thanks so much for joining us again today. Oh, thank you for having me. Pleasure being here. So, you know, I know that in the course of your of your practice, in addition to writing estate plans, you see other people who come to you with problems, right? The cows got out of the barn, what do we do to get them back in? What are one or two of the most common mistakes you see people make in estate plans that you're called on to correct or asked to correct? Yeah, I mean, I you know, I think one of the things is A- a- a- a- and we kind of discussed this a little before. We naming who you're naming as trustees to really manage the estate, your trust estate, when these people cannot manage like the a principal, the usually the estate planning couple that you could call them trustors, grantors, settlors, the person creating a trust or whoever's creating the estate plan.
1:19 Who to put in place to manage the estate once they're maybe still alive but incompetent and can't do it for themselves or after they die and who's going to kind of administer everything, pay off last debts, pay off last taxes, marshal all the assets and distribute it. Who are these people that are going to be put in place to do this job? And it is a job and people need to understand that. So, you want to put people in that are responsible, one, and two, who would be willing to do it. So, it's something that maybe you want to have a conversation with the p- the that you name in those in those roles. And if you're going to name more than one person, then you got to think about whether these people can work together. And the default is if you put, let's say, two co-trustees to act, the default under the law is that they must act unanimously unless your trust says otherwise. So, if your trust says, "Okay, they can act independent of each other," then they can act independent of each other. A lot of times parents will think that their children can all get along and work together and act as co-trustees and make unanimous decisions together.
2:42 Dads down the path with a little flower basket and there's rainbows and there's unicorns flying overhead. Yeah, exactly. Right. And every parent wants to believe that of their kids and they think that they're are great and I'm sure they are. But, in reality, sometimes it's not even practical for them to work together in that way because they're not even located together. They have busy lives, different schedules, and they may not be able to, you know, get together every time to make every single decision unanimously. So, that's one thing. Practically speaking, can these people act together? Aside from practically speaking, can they get along? Because that is the most common thing as these people really do not get along and there's a lot of childhood resentments that they have against each other and those just often carries into adult life and when it's comes down to dealing with their parents' estate, these childhood resentments really rise up and create problems a lot of times. So, you really have to look at that objectively, you know, the people creating the plan. Look at that objectively and see what can really work. So, sometimes just cuz you're getting along now, those deep-seated or long-held resentments that they papered over at Christmas and Thanksgiving, once money's involved and decisions that might affect their respective children is involved, those attitudes can harden.
4:07 And I've seen I know I've seen that as a real estate agent. You must see that more regularly as an attorney in these matters. Yeah. Yeah, and it is unfortunate. So, I really would ask people to kind of look at that with clear eyes instead of rose-colored glasses to see if that's going to work. And really my general advice is not to have people work together cuz practically it's difficult. It's just difficult. Yeah. Yeah. And I also think that sometimes the person who you might think is best to handle the estate is not, meaning maybe there's three siblings and one is very successful in business and one's kind of more middle-class success and the other one is struggling financially. And you might think, well, the more successful one is the best, but he might be successful cuz he's really focused on his or her business and not as open to communicating with siblings or respecting siblings. Right? If you're a CEO all day long dealing with bankers and high-end customers, you might look down on your siblings and make the right decision but not make it the right way. So, talk about kind of the blend for somebody managing the estate as you pick your trustee, which I think is one of the most important questions. Talk about the blend between the ability to do the job, you know, patterns of success, patterns of productivity, but also the ability to communicate effectively with the whole family and how important that becomes in the ultimate success.
5:30 Yeah, that and that's very important and you raise a really good point because maybe perhaps the most competent person, like the CEO child or something like that, you know, cannot do it because if they're running a huge corporation or a business or something like that, they may not be able to have that time and that has happened where and it may not even be just the child. It could be a friend lawyer friend or something that someone names as a trustee and that person just does not have the time and when it comes down to the time to act as trustee after someone has passed away. I have seen it where this person says, "Oh, yes, I knew them but I don't have the time to do this." Cuz they're just a busy like you said, like a CEO or a lawyer or something like that and even though the person that named them thought, "Okay, this is the best person because they're the most competent person." But they may not be able to do that job when it when it comes down to it. So, that yes, that's another factor to think about and then the maybe you have this child who is the one who's struggling. They may have the most time. But they the unfortunate thing is they may not be the most competent. I mean, most savvy. Let's put it that way. The most savvy person to be handling finances, handling income taxes or making sure those things kind of get done. Whatever and they may not be the they may be the least successful for reasons and then I'm adding to those kinds of things. So, they may not be savvy enough even though they may possibly have you know, have the most time to do it.
7:09 Another thing that people do is they may pick a bank cuz they think, "Okay, I have all these children but I can't pick between amongst them about you know, who should act." And let me pick Wells Fargo or you know, I don't any bank. How could that go wrong? Yeah, so this could have right. And this is what happened is that banks one, they're not all banks have some sort of trustee department that will act as a trustee. That's one. So, you got to find a bank that's willing that even has that of department. But let's say they do. Many banks will only how handle trust estates of certain sizes, and they're usually large. They want to have handle large trust estates. And so, I've had that situation where someone has named a bank, and then they passed away, and the successor trustee is contacting that bank, and the bank says, "Oh, no, I'm not going to do it." And this is a client who actually talked to that bank during their lives, and they had a good relationship with the banker that he, you know, always worked with. And they said, "Oh, sure, we will, you know, we're happy to be named as your successor trustee." But, okay, when it came down to it, they did not want to act. And so, yeah, having a bank, you know, you really have to have a sizeable estate, but otherwise, usually they don't they don't want to be bothered with it, unfortunately.
8:34 Well, they want to give away the service, but they want to have all the assets, and they make the money on the assets. So, that's what you're saying. Which is somewhat kind of dishonest, because they're going to put your assets in underperforming funds, and that's where they make their money. So, they can't charge you, but they can only steal from you without telling you. I don't I want to disparage Wells Fargo or Chase or CitiCorp, who've paid millions of dollars for cheating their customers regularly, but the reality is they don't serve those jobs, in my experience, very effectively. Now, one of the things that I've been more and more involved with, and I recommend more often for families to consider, and I really would try to promote with attorneys, is the idea of a of a fiduciary that maybe has to be appointed to be the trustee, and they in turn hire professional, whether it be an administrator to do all the administrative work, and so they're really more of a of a board of directors role, where they look at what the person's doing, but you have a professional who does the work, and you have maybe that family member watching it, checking it, and overseeing it, or an actual professional fiduciary. In both of the cases, not uncommon where an heir will, you know, name a fiduciary to do work that they can't do or can't do as effectively. Talk a little bit about the pros and cons of using a professional administrator and or a professional, you know, separate from the legal work. And then customers think, oh, well, the attorney does all that for me. No, not necessarily. Some do, some don't or some will but charge a fee. So, talk a little bit about the administrator role that you role that you play and then what do you see for customers that might need extra service?
10:03 Yeah, so you bring up these private professional fiduciaries and those are a great option cuz not everybody has an unlimited amount of relatives or people that they could possibly name as successor trustees or to who to manage these things. And so there's a group of people called private professional fiduciaries. This is what they do as a profession. They act as in fiduciary roles, whether it's a trustee, a conservator, an administrator of an estate after someone dies after the probate of it. So, there's professional people that can take this job. Now, you know, with all professions, you do have to, you know, find a good one. There's good and bad ones. And but you know, good ones are great. If you have a contentious family, those are great options because then they're a neutral person that's coming in. They're going to just run it like a business then they're not going to deal with all the emotions of not liking one sibling over the next or any of that. They're going to be neutral. Now, of course, their fees are probably going to be Let's say if they're doing this privately, doing a trust administration, whereas a probate fees are set by statute. If you're doing a private trust administration, their fees per hour will probably be higher than a lay person's. But look, they're professionals, they can get the job done and maybe they could do it in less amount of time than a layperson who does not know how to do this. Now, whether you're layperson or professional, usually they're going you're going to hire well, if you're a layperson you really should get the advice of counsel of how to do this job.
11:48 So even if you're administrator and whatever role you find yourself in, you want to hire a competent lawyer to advise you about what to do cuz there's you know even in a private trust there's notices that need to be sent out, there's timelines to do certain things. There's if you have real property there's things to record at the assessor's office or the recorder's office and a layperson may not know all these kinds of things. So you really should get advice of counsel to make sure that you're doing the job right. A prior professional will usually use counsel and they and they have you know, so but they have their routine set up and they you know, it's kind of in their regular routine of administering things. So it's sometimes it's a little easier for them to do that because you know, this is what they do as a profession. And also I think that sometimes the states are complicated. I'm working on one where they have about $30 million worth of stocks and bonds but another $10 million worth of real estate, all kinds of other assets and you know, so now you need somebody who's going to sell some of the real estate to pay the taxes, manage the property to either keep it or turn it over or whatever. Those are complicated things and that those are disparate skills that just one person inheriting money doesn't have and to take on. You wouldn't hire that person to run the 40 bill 40 million dollar business. Why would you think that the heir or just cuz they're inheriting it can do it properly versus in this case I think the fiduciary has done a great job of going through the whole transition and after a year or two things are sold that need to be sold, taxes are paid, all the records are updated, and the business is running and then they can step in at that point and that's a much easier ask for a ex-person. So, do you Now, do you offer the service as a trust administrator for clients? I know you do the legal work, but do you do that work and bill hourly or do you only outsource that or advise the client to find on their own somebody to be the administrator or what How do you play with that set of options?
13:52 Yeah, so I don't usually act as an administrator or a trustee and I have been asked that. I don't ever write myself in as that even if I've been asked. I feel like there's a conflict. I don't like doing that. So, let's say if I was I was preparing someone's estate plan and you think, "Well, can you act as trustee?" And I'm the one drafting the papers. I don't usually do that because I just don't want to write myself in. Now, if someone else what if someone went to another estate planning attorney and then they discuss it with me to come in as a trustee, that probably could be arranged, but usually I'm doing the legal work. I'm representing the trustee or whoever gets you know put in that role and then I advise them and guide them through the administration process. So, I'm usually not acting as trustee. That's not Some lawyers do. So, I think some lawyers do that. I usually don't. I'm usually doing the legal work. One common problems that I get that come to me that I imagine some of those come to you as well are your mom and dad died, I'm one of three siblings. I know that my other sibling is the trustee, but I don't know anything about what's going on. You know, the property has not been sold. It's been a year or two. I haven't got a copy of the trust. I don't know what I'm inheriting or if I'm inheriting.
15:18 And I've come to learn actually by doing this podcast, what a great tool it is for me to learn that the trust is obligated to notify when it goes from revocable to irrevocable. All both all both beneficiaries of the trust and correct me if I'm wrong, all heirs at law, meaning if let's say a sibling a child would inherit without a trust or will, but we're winning now, they're still to be notified that there is such a trust that gives them the chance at least to contest it, right? And so Exactly. People come to me and say, "What do I do?" And to my answer is, "Well, you need to talk to an attorney to advise you of your rights and then also presses the trustee to meet their obligations. So, do you get these kind of cases and what are what are the obligations and what's the process look like when not you're representing the trustee, which the trustee is doing everything correctly, but you're representing, let's say, the beneficiary or prospective beneficiary or prospective heir, where they suspect things aren't being done right. What's that process look like? Right. And we And we do represent a lot of beneficiaries and they to pursue their rights and things like that. So we Yeah, we represent both sides and so if some beneficiary comes to us and they have been served with the notification by trustee and a copy of the trust, then you know, the clock starts ticking. So, it's very important. You got 120 days to contest this trust if you think there is a legitimate dispute. You have a good faith belief, probable cause to believe like, "Okay, this is not legitimate for any reason like, you know, things that could come up is like, okay, this looks like it got forged. Someone clearly, you know, committed some undue influence and now there's suddenly a new amendment to this trust nobody ever knew about and it gives everything to one child or a caregiver or some new friend of the a trustor things, whatever it is. So, you So, the important part is that you've got the 120 days to contest this trust.
17:18 So, it's Yeah, so it's very important for a beneficiary to, you know, again, go to a competent attorney to kind of review the trust, talk to this beneficiary about, you know, what the circumstances are, and do you think that you want to contest this trust or not. If not, then you're just kind of shepherding, you know, making sure that this trustee is providing a proper accounting, maybe disclosing any trust records that we want to see. A lot of times if I request an accounting, I'd like to see the supporting bank records just to kind of corroborate an accounting that trustee is prepare has prepared, and see if there's any transactions that are questionable. Sometimes maybe there's a huge amount of withdrawals going out to the trustee personally, whatever these kinds of things. So, you want to really one, you're entitled to an accounting if you're a beneficiary, and then what and then review that accounting to see if there's anything that you want to ask about or if there's any transactions to be questioned. So, the So, there's a whole process and you want to make sure that you are asserting your rights and within the time frame that you have to assert your rights. So that's very important. Let's have talk about the case where there's no notice and no copy of the trust. I know you and I spoke on a prior episode that I think it's your practice to always send out the full trust that's in But, there are attorneys who don't, right? They There's another opinion. I like yours. Let's get it out front. But, there are other attorneys I know who their theory is, "No, there's a minimum amount we have to tell them. Let's tell them the minimum amount and hope they don't contest in their timeline." That different theory.
18:59 And but even worse than that is the either nefarious or dishonest trustee who doesn't disclose anything, right? And so, the heir comes to me and I imagine comes to you and says, "Hey, they haven't done anything. It's been not just 60 90 days, it's been, you know, 2 years. They keep saying they're working on it." So, at that point, we need to kind of force the trustee's hand to make that initial, at a minimum, disclosure there is a trust, I would think. And then if they do the minimal, yes, there is a trust, then you have the right, I believe, and I think you said this in a prior episode, to then request a copy of it. So, talk a little bit about what's that process look like. Now, some attorneys will say, "I won't get involved in that because they don't know there's any money involved." So, we have to pay for your time up front, I would imagine, to do that, right? By the Yeah. Yeah, if you're hiring an attorney, then you're paying for that attorney's time to deal with all this. So, you do have to weigh that, you know, depending on how much you the beneficiary may be possibly getting from this trust versus how much it's going to cost to hire an attorney to chase it down for them. And sometimes, if there's not enough money, because you know, if the trustee is not providing you with that accounting or the information or a copy of the trust that you're entitled to, then you're petitioning to compel this, compel an accounting, compel a distribution, compel disclosure of records and things like that. And if the beneficiary is not going to be getting that much and it's going to cost that much to chase it down, I tend to not want to do that. I don't want to spend the money, you know, and if they're not going to be getting that much cuz you know, you don't want to pay an attorney more than what you're going to be possibly getting. But of course, it's a it's a catch-22. And so, you know, you don't you may not get anything if you don't have someone chasing it down for you. So, there's kind of a balance there to see figure out what's the most cost-effective thing to do in that situation. And sometimes you want to hope that, okay,
21:01 Communications with the other side, the trustee, just writing a letter asking it for this information that they'll produce it, but, if push comes to shove, the only recourse you really have is to petition the court. Now, you did bring up, producing a copy of the trust and whether to do it or not. And yeah, and yes, you're correct. I always like to, if I'm representing the trustee, I'm giving out the notification by trustee, I want to produce a whole copy of the trust. The code is something like you can contest it 120 days from that notification or 60 days from receiving a copy of the trust, whichever is later. So, I really want that time frame to start ticking. I don't want any questions like, "Oh, I didn't get a full copy of the trust, and therefore I have more time to contest this." And then the other thing to all I that factors into why I produce the entire trust is that, disclosure really or non-disclosure breeds mistrust. So, once there's a trustee that is not being transparent, automatically people are going to not trust what is going on. Why are you not giving me this information? Is there something that they're hiding? Even if they're not doing that is what happens in a in human nature. They will start mistrusting what is going on because of the lack of transparency. I don't see the harm in necessarily in, being as transparent as possible.
22:37 You're right, there's limitations on what you're required to give cuz you're really supposed to produce the terms of the trust that affect that particular beneficiary. And so, if you want to start carving out, you know, parts of the trust and okay, I'm going to give you these bits and pieces, the in my experience, yeah, the issue is what the what happens is that people start saying, "Why are you hiding all this other stuff?" Why are you hiding all this other stuff? So, And this is where talking to a seasoned attorney versus your ChatGPT attorney is going to get you better results. So, are you open to if somebody says, "Hey, I think I have a, you know, beneficial interest in this trust. I haven't gotten any paperwork, but I want to hire you for whatever time it takes to consult, and then to write a letter, and let's see what happens." Can they pay for Is that a couple hours worth of work? How many What are you talking about? Just to just to find out and to see what your options are at that point. Is that something that you're open to entertaining? Yeah. Yeah, and I and I, you know, And it's all, you know, the million-dollar question is always like, "Okay, how much time is going to take? How much time is it going to cost?" And every case is really different. And because attorneys like me bill by the hour, you know, you have some you can have clients or parties, whoever, that who talk a lot.
24:01 And that's going to just be more time than maybe another case where, you know, that's not happening. Or you have parties that argue more, or there's more communications. And so, it's really hard to gauge exactly how much that is going to cost. Now, I usually don't come, you know, me personally, I don't come in just to write a letter type of thing. I'm lucky to have a, you know, a very busy practice, or whatever. I mean, we kind of want to be able to do bring it to a conclusion, do the whole nine yards if that's possible. If you need someone just to write a letter kind of thing, you know, that's And then And then the person wants to stop like the client wants to stop after that kind of thing. Yeah, we don't really get in, you know, just jump into write a letter and then get out. That Yeah, we kind of want to be able to Yeah. Yeah, kind of run the whole case if it if that's necessary. And because and I want to explain it's not so much of the of money or you just, you know, attorneys just want to take cases they can bill a lot on. That's really not it. There's liability for everything that we kind of take on whether, you know, whether it's small or big or whatever. And we kind of just jump in and then jump out.
25:19 It's and then we're not handling the whole case. You know, there's liability involved for every little thing we do. So, we really want to make sure that we can do what we can for a client and not just stop short. I know one of the keys to success in any business is communication with your client, right? The setting expectations, responding to concerns, educating them ahead of times those concerns aren't blown out of proportion. Obviously I appreciate being on this podcast today and you've done a couple other episodes with me as well. So, you've been very generous with your time to try to help educate at least my platform of clients and real estate agents and such. You know, but I imagine that's got to be one of the big challenges in your profession, right? Cuz if it just came down to writing documents, that's the whole AI thing. The reason why that doesn't work is at the end of the day you need a human being who understands human beings and can give them an appropriate amount. You don't want to overwhelm people with education cuz they'll get bored or not read it, but there's certain things you have to convey. So, how do you I know it's an ongoing process. I'm sure it's something you work on regularly, but how do you try to find that fine line between, you know, wasting customers' time and boring them versus giving them important information that they take action on and will understand in order to be productive in the relationship?
26:46 Yeah, I mean everything is a cost-benefit analysis. I mean, when we take on the case I always do the cost-benefit analysis and discuss that with the client or the prospective client. You know, what's at stake here and how much it could possibly cost. And you know, there's an emotional cost, too. Like let's say if we have to do litigation, you know, easy for me, fun for me, but not but not necessarily for a client. And so they need to understand that emotional cost that's involved if they're going to get into a fight or how deep we're going to go into you know, kind of pursuing things if there's possibly contentious people out there. So you're always doing that cost-benefit analysis and you know, you don't I mean the way we work, you know, we're really we're doing what's necessary in the case. Like I think there may be a perspective out there or and I don't know what practitioners would do something like this. Like, "Oh, let's turn the case just to bill it or whatever." One, we don't have time to do that kind of thing. Like we're doing what's necessary on our cases at whatever, but we never think, "Well, this is a lucrative case. Let's turn the file or whatever." Yeah, that just never happens. I mean, we our caseload is just big enough where we don't we're getting in and doing what's necessary and go and moving on. Like we don't Yeah, I don't know. Hopefully there's not that many practitioners out there who do that, but you do hear that.
28:20 Maybe some do. You know, I know of clients who tell me they're pursuing the rest of the attorney cuz they really want to, you know, get satisfaction at getting their sibling or getting whoever the bad guy is. And you know, I always feel like, "Well, you probably watch a lot of, you know, reruns of LA Law or Suits that you know, there's this it's almost like a football game at the end. You win, you high-five, you go to the bar." Yeah. In my experience, very rarely are either party happy with the result other than they can move forward with whatever else is pouring if the focus is on the result it just there never seems to be that satisfaction people are striving for very rarely. Yeah. But if your focus is to get through this argument so we can get on with resolving this state then if the focus is there that can happen as well. So it seems to me that must come from you setting expectations that you're not going to pound your brother into the sand and win this case by litigating it you're probably going to spend more than you expect you get a little less than you expect it'll be a hollow victory at best. How do you kind of counsel customers or clients who Yeah. Want to win they don't realize that's not their business. Yeah because even when you when there is you have some losses and I would never and I litigated as well as doing a lot of estate planning so I do kind of the whole spectrum under this umbrella of probate trust estate planning. And what I'm doing a going to a to a trial or we're you know we're litigating I would I can never guarantee a win you know and I know no practitioner can. I mean you can say what the likelihood and what possibly could can go wrong what possibly can go right.
30:05 And but you can never guarantee a win and so and I've said this to many people where I can try a case in the same case in front of two different and get two different outcomes. I believe that I see that. Yeah and so you just cannot predict what happens at trial. The other thing I mean there's a lot of things within your a practitioner's control you know your evidence your every everything's lined up. What is so underestimated is what the witnesses do in court. And even the person who is bringing the lawsuit and they I think there's an underestimation of what it's like to be up on a witness stand and testify. And a lot of people think, "Okay, I get to go up there and tell my story." And that's how it works. Like the evidence has to come in through an orderly fashion through questioning. And if you don't get the right questions to bring the story out, it's not coming out. And people think they can get on the stand and they get their soapbox and they get to tell their whole story. That's just not the way it works. And they don't And you can even practice cross-examination. Like, "Okay, this is how you probably going to get crossed on these things." It's still a different thing when you're actually in the courtroom on the witness stand. And people buckle. People buckle. People forget. Like, "Oh, you know, you know, they do get deer in the headlights syndrome." And forget their own story or whatever it is. It happens a lot. And so think Yeah, so people that want to go there and really want to you know, kill their sibling and what you know, and really pound them into the sand at trial whatever, it they underestimate what that trial actually is like. And things fall apart. Things fall apart because of that. Even though everything else is it is in control.
32:09 Exhibits are there. Evidence is there. You know, you kind of have a prediction of what this judge will probably do. But witnesses go sideways like you don't believe. Yeah. Yeah, no, I appreciate that. You know, I know recently I was deposed in a in a lawsuit a divorce, very nasty divorce. You know, I have a lot of experience in court. I also have experience as a real estate agent. But I also have experience I was on debate team in high school and college where we did cross-examination. So I've been cross-examined, you know, thousands of times in high school college and then I worked for attorney for a couple years as a clerk helping him prepare for trial and preparing witnesses and doing the depositions with him. So, I'm not your normal, you know, witness. And so, the attorney, I'm sure, you know, had a whole bag of tricks and just could not crack me. I would I'm not crackable. I'm like I would I, you know, he's like, I'm like a former NBA basketball player playing a pickup game of basketball. But, I think most people have a sense that they're in control and then when they're you see them they're on the witness stand, the judge is there, everything's structured, they're limited what they say, this the cadence of the of the communication is different than they're used to. And I think you're exactly right. On the flip side, I lost a in a business I lost a whole business where somebody cheated me and I remember the attorney representing me said, "Now, she going to get there and lie about all this?" No, there's no way she's going to lie. She's this, she's that, she's she might be wrong, but there's no way she's going to just blatantly lie under oath in court in the in the face of the evidence. And of course, what did she do? She lied about everything. And I it just taught me that people will lie about anything if there's enough money involved. So, you have to kind of prepare your customer or your client, I guess, for the reality that this is not just, you know, a test of the truth, but it's also a test of character and people and people will go below that what you think, I guess. I don't you see I've seen that standard of truth go down in my career from when I was a young man until now.
34:08 It just seems like the oath doesn't mean much like it used to anymore. Is that just me? Am I just being jaded? No, it's not just you, unfortunately. And it is and it is so unfortunate because of course I've seen it, too, where people are just blatantly they will blatantly lie. You think, "How could that be? Is it me? Am I crazy here? Did he just say that?" But, they do. Okay, thank you for confirm I'm sorry. Right, but it just it drives me nuts. Yeah, and it's crazy I mean for I mean, you know, for a trial lawyer, you want you want to make sure I mean, hopefully you have something to impeach them on and show like, "Okay, this person does lie. They're not credible. What they're saying is not credible. You can't believe anything they say." But, you don't necessarily always have that. Or, they try to get around whatever you impeach them with. But, it hap- you know, it does happen. And you're right, you know, when money is involved, people change their colors. It's And it's not even the amount. I've seen it in small estates and big ones. And so, people just funny, I'll say that. That's the best way to put it when money is involved. Yeah. I don't know what it is or why that happens, but unfortunately, that does happen.
35:28 It's true across the board in business. It's not in law. I mean, I see it As a As a real estate broker, I use a phone service where I track every phone call in and out and text. And I've had occasions where not customer, but the other agent will say, "Oh, he never called." And like, "Well, that's crazy. I can just pull a report of every phone call I made to him and every text." Like, it's not It's demonstrably false to say that. Why would you say that? Like, it's too easy today to prove. I would list on my phone log. But they'll believe it. They'll say, "Oh, he never called me." How could you say I never called you? Of course, I called you. Yeah. It's like, "Am I crazy?" No, I'm not crazy. I think the world is just somehow people in their own world, they create this sense and that's why you have litigation. You know, the other thing that I see that the challenge One of the challenges you have, same with me, is that clients sometimes focus on the short term and don't realize it's a process, right? If you're going to administer an estate, it's time similar litigation that you have some setbacks. You have setbacks, but it's a long game. You have to play for the end of the game, not for just you know, along the way. So, how do you set those expectations and keep your customer or your client, you know, positive or productive and not losing hope along the way when you have, I'm sure in any trial you have some setbacks or in any administration or real estate, you have some setbacks along the way. How do you try to keep people on track or focused?
36:49 Yeah, you know, and I and my way of practicing and being and communicating with my clients is complete honesty all the way through. So, I don't sugarcoat anything. I don't think like, oh, here's a big a horrible thing that came out in discovery or whatever it may be, and but yet, don't worry about that. We're still going to win. Like, okay, that's not ever coming out of my mouth. Like, I really am and cuz that's just kind of how I operate. I'm just completely upfront, direct, honest. Here's, you know, that this could like, let's say something bad does come out, you know, that this could really kill us. I mean, this could be the end of your case if this is, you know, if we don't have if there's not a good explanation. I mean, my job is to make the arguments regardless how bad the facts are. And usually I can do it. Now, I'm not I can't think of a situation where, okay, that's it. We're done unless my client stole everything or something. But, okay, anyway, the answer to that is that, okay, right or wrong, am I am I Yeah, I'm not sugarcoating things. I'm not I'm not trying to I mean, I try to keep people focused, yeah, but you know, here's what we got. Here's what potentially could go wrong. Here's what we could do with it. Here's the arguments we're going to make, and then we're going to have to have so-and-so, you know, testify about this, that, and the other to, you know, get around that, whatever it is, but I call it as it is. I And because I think the client people need to know what they're facing. What you know, it's not like I don't I don't try to hide things from the client or anything like that. Yeah, they need to know. They got to be all in the whole way. And that's why it's sometimes not easy, you know, it's because to a client it's personal.
38:48 So this is affecting them personally. Oh, their sibling is now saying this argument about the whatever. And I understand that. So it's you know, it's difficult for them to hear things that may become out or what the other side is saying because it's personal to them whether But I can hopefully help them by seeing it objectively. This is what they're saying, but we can do this, that, and the other. But you know, I'm really up-front honest the whole way. And you know, so they're they know what they're going They're getting into what's happening along the way and what they could possibly face at trial. You know, I liked about you when we first met in that you seemed to be much more about let's just play the cards face up and we'll play them the way they come out and we'll deal with them as we have to. And I think that's you know, the better way. I think often have attorneys are so guarded and like you know, they're playing games. Well, when you sense that they're playing games and of course I'm going to have to play a game as well. Just like you mentioned the idea of sending out the trust right away. Why make them request a trust and you have to respond to the request for the trust? It's more work for you. It's work that you don't want to do. You're not really in the mailing business. You're in the emailing business. You're in the legal business. So let's just get to the brass tacks. Do you have an argument or not? And the clock is ticking now sooner not later.
40:07 So let's just get down to it. And I like that. I think that's more my approach. So I appreciate your style. And again, now that's there's different styles for everybody. And people should pick the attorney that they feel comfortable with. But, you know, I've enjoyed our conversations because you are like, you know, really straightforward, and I think that's refreshing along the way. I wish like I could always deal with the problem. If we know what it is, we can roll up our sleeves and work on it together. If we pretend like there's no problem, it's going to be a miserable day when it comes out. Oh, yeah, right. Right. And that's it's all it's Yeah, I identifying the problem is probably one of the biggest things. And a And a good practitioner can solve the problem. Yeah. So, identifying You want to use someone that can identify. That's key because sometimes some people cannot identify the problem. What exactly is the problem? And then how are we going to solve that problem? Right. How are we going to solve it? Those are two key You street smart kind of or whatever it is that's good in a good lawyer. That's key in a good lawyer. You could you could go to law school, you could learn things, you could pass the bar. You know, some people I wonder how they pass the bar, but look, academically maybe you can get through some of this stuff. But, you know, and especially because I've hired different people and so, their credentials are one thing on paper, but in addition to being intellectually smart, you want to be kind of street smart. You need to be able to talk with people, solve problems, identify the problem, solve it, whatever. And not everybody really has that, you know.
41:45 You know, unfort- unfortunately. Well, if you go back to a movie that might be before your time, but The Paper Chase was big. I went to USC. It was filmed at USC. It was about Harvard Law School. And the premise of the story was that the professor of law, very esteemed old-time professor, and there was a it was a student who had like a photographic memory, and the professor was like, "I can help you. It's not about knowing the law, it's about, you know, being able to think and understand the law and apply the law is what an attorney has to do. And so I think you're right. There are plenty of attorneys that I see, how do how this person pass? Well, no, they're good student and that's great. And also I think that's about the benefit of experience because you know, I don't want to age you. I mean, you could pass for 19 years old. So I know you've been around a while. I know you've been around. You've seen a thing or two. I think that, you know, people think they're going to run something by you cuz you're new. No, that's how I am. I tell people all the time, I didn't just fall off a cabbage truck. I've been here for a while. I've seen a lot of stuff over time. So not much surprises me anymore. I think that's the benefit of a experienced attorney like you said. Yeah. Yeah, there is a benefit to that. Because when you're young, you just don't have you haven't been around the block. You know, unfortunately, and you got you got to learn, you got to take your knocks and learn. But yeah, there's it's something to be said with people with experience cuz, you know, I've seen it all. Oh my god, I've seen I've seen so much stuff.
43:04 And I still see stuff and I'm like, you know, so that you don't believe like it whether a practitioners doing this or whether a party's doing this like, oh my gosh, how is this happening? But there it is. Well, I appreciate your time. We went a little longer than we did today cuz I you know, I always have nice conversations. I really appreciate your time so much. So if you're watching this and you have some stuff, you need some help with an attorney on anywhere in California, particularly in the South Bay, you want to meet with them in person, Beti Bergman, phone number on the screen, [phone number], [email address]. The website is peninsula.law. Peninsula.law. I'm sorry, I said that wrong. [email address] and the website is peninsula.law. There's no com there. It's.law, which is a whole another series of domains. And a lot of great information on her website. Beti, thank you so much for sharing with us today and I think educating us and I think more giving us kind of feel for what it looks like to work with an estate attorney in whatever you're planning or litigation. Thank you so much for your time today. I really appreciate it. Oh, you're very welcome. Thank you for having me. Informationally, new is estate planning weekly. We get together every week with an estate planner most commonly sometimes with vendors to learn how to be better at working with our customers supporting our customers helping them get the best estate planning litigation if necessary for various niches or standard cases as well. I'm Bill Gross at Bill Gross Probate and social media. If you're an attorney you'd like to be interviewed on this please reach out to me or if you know somebody if you have an attorney that you think could be great put their name and information in forward it on to them and let's get them on the call as well. If I can help at Bill Gross Probate and social media my name and phone number are on the bottom as always make today your best day ever. Thanks so much.
More with Beti Bergman
- Conservatorship and Probate Property Sales, with Beti Bergman (Probate Weekly, August 16, 2026)
- Understanding the Probate Process, with Attorney Beti Bergman of Peninsula Law (Probate Weekly, July 10, 2025)
More The Estate Planning Podcast episodes
- Praxis, Life, and Legacy Law, with Attorney Antoinette Bone
- Hot Litigation Topics to Consider When Creating Estate Plans, with Andrew C. Kienle
- The Estate Planning Mistake That Makes Your Living Trust Worthless, with Scott Schomer — Scott P. Schomer
Related
- A guide for successor trustees
- How long does probate take?
- Probate attorneys and podcast guests
- The Estate Planning Podcast: all episodes
- For attorneys & fiduciaries
Educational media, not legal advice. Guest views are their own. Hosted by Bill Gross, The LA Probate Expert, a licensed California real estate broker (DRE #01022275) brokered by eXp Realty of California, Inc. (DRE #01878277). Bill is not an attorney and is not a Probate Referee.